Sayed Saleh Qazwini

Sayed Saleh Qazwini
 
Age:
Location: Michigan
Nationality: United States
For User Saleh

Public QnA

I just have a couple of questions regarding ghusl janabah and prayers.

1. If someone went for a shower with the intention of performing ghusl janabah but they did not do the full niyat (ghusl janabah wajib qurbatan il-allah allahu akbar) would their ghusl be valid? Would their prayers after also be valid?

2. If someone, after washing, with soap and shampoo, their head and body in the shower, intends to do ghusl janabah would they still have to wash their full body with water or just niyat and leave the shower since they have already washed their whole body and water has gone everywhere?

1- They don’t have to say the niya, they can make the niya in their heart. They need to know what they are doing and who they are doing it for. That is sufficient.

2- They have to perform the full ghusl correctly after the niya. The washing before the niya does not count towards the ghusl.

There are some fish and chips shops in west, and the only serve fish (both halal ones and non halal). The fish are fried in oil, are we allowed to eat the halal fish with scaled even if it is cooked in same oil as fish that has no scale (like calamari)? Does contamination rule apply here, even if the fish are not najis but harram to eat? I’ve heard that Ayatollah Sistani has said as long you eat the halal fish doesn’t matter if it gets fried or cooked in same place as a non halal fish?

It is okay to eat it.

How can we distinguish between truth and falsehood, in a world full of information? There is many fake information out there. How can we know if something is true or not in all aspects of life? Political, family affairs, Islamic History.. Etc

Know the truth and then follow the people of the truth.

My advice is to always double check what people are saying, especially if it’s regarding a controversial topic. See what the other viewpoints are and don’t accept what you hear immediately.

The western toilet is designed so that it flushes once in a continuous flow after a person uses it. This ensures that any excrement is washed away. However from a fiqhi perspective it is known that for urine a object must be washed twice with a break(water stops flowing) in between washing. If one flushes a toilet which only leaves one continous flow is the water after the flushing considered najis?

If it is connected with a main line of water, and washes away all of the najasa, where you don’t see anything it should be considered pure. However, usually there may be some najasa on the side of the toilet that does not get flushed away.

In a world which we we are living in so different from the world which our Prophet and Ahlulbayt lived, there is so much of sin around and a lot of competition and difficulty to earn money in a halal way. Hw can we remember Allah constantly? Whenever I stand to pray, the worldy things getting in my mind. While reading Quran always my future bothers me that how to become rich to survive in this era. Please suggest me how to live a good religious life in this kind of world where people respect you on the basis of your richness and so much nudity on internet and so much of entertainment shows on tv? How can I be always attached to Allah because at the end we will return to him.

Being a practicing Muslim means you have to fulfill your obligations. Pray your prayers on time, try to contemplate about God every once in a while, remember the afterlife. If you do this, you will always have God in your heart despite the many distractions. As for halal wealth, you should know that having less wealth and it is halal is better than having more wealth which is haraam. At the end of the day, God will not leave you hungry. He created you and He will send you your sustenance.

There are many narrations that refer to weeping out of fear of Allah swt. Can you please tell me how can one get to that state? Because I can understand weeping out of guilt of committing a sin, love for the Almighty, being hopeful in only Him, being thankful of His blessings & mercy, and when he rewards you in some way or removes a difficulty from you. But I can not understand how to weep out of fear. In fact, I have never acted out of fear of Allah swt but only out of pleasing Him and out of not disappointing Him.

When you want to not disappoint God you are acting out of fear. We have narrations that say a believer should be between hope and fear always. Hope on the mercy of God and fear from the punishment.

I wanted to ask how reliable is the book Sulaym bin Qais Hilali and its narrator Aban bin Abi Ayyash? In a YouTube video someone Non Shia referred to Sheik Saduq that Aban is a ضعیف narrator? Also can you give me more traditions on Bibi’s Shahadah other than Kitab e Sulaym?

Some scholars have questioned the reliability of sulayms book. However, even if that is weak, we have many corroborated narrations from Sunni sources which prove that there was an attack on the house of Lady Fatima.

Is my fast still valid if I purposefully don’t do any prayers? And is it the same rule for both Ramadan and qada prayers?

Fasting is an obligation and praying is an obligation. Both are required. Your fasting is accepted, however, prayer is the pillar of your faith. You have to make the intention to make up the missed prayers.

During Ramadan a sin is multiplied just as a reward is multiplied in reward.

I was in an online haram relationship with a girl. We did not commit any form of zina however 2 months in I learnt about the consequences of haram relationships that Allah could possibly not bless the marriage if that goes through. I wanted to know if I do go ahead and break things up with her would that be the best choice? Although she may be very sad/heartbroken

If you have not committed zina, and you see that she is fit for you. Why don’t you make it halal? If you see there is no compatibility you can end it.

My husband and I we haven’t consummated our marriage yet due to a medical condition on my end (vaginismus). In our marriage contract it states he can’t take a second wife or do muttah without my consent which he knows I won’t give.
Am I wrong to deny him a second wife/muttah if I can’t fulfill this duty due to medical issues?

Did he know you have this problem before the marriage, or did he find out after you two got married? If he knew, then it would not be wrong for you to keep that condition if both of you agreed to it. However if he did not know, that condition is not valid, and he can even end the marriage. If this is a marriage where he cannot have penetrative sex, he does not have to abide by that condition that was made.

I encourage you to seek treatment as best as you can so you can save your marriage and have a more healthy marriage.

My husband’s cousin has passed away. I feel very upset because over the last few years my husband and him weren’t in touch very much.

His cousin had many issues, some of which include drinking alcohol, being verbally abusive towards my mother in law and many more issues. My husband went to see him when my father in law was dying and his cousin wasn’t interested in coming to meet my husband’s father before he died.

So over the years my husband hasn’t made much of an effort but recently he met him and also since he got taken sick we visited him a few times.

But my husband and I still feel guilty for not having done more during his lifetime – is there anything we can do to make up for this so we don’t fall into the sin of not silatur rahm.

You can pray for his maghfira, ask Allah to forgive him and have mercy on him.

I hear a lot of our Shia scholars talk about the return of Imam Mahdi but nobody ever talks about how Prophet Jesus is coming with him. Most of the time I hear that we are awaiting the return of Imam Mahdi and hardly any mention of Prophet Jesus return. Why is that the case ?

Our narrations say that Jesus will return after the Imam and be his supporter.

I have had a few encounters where I feel like I might be giving evil eye to people which apparently I don’t want to and feel bad about it. I’ve tried to ignore it many times thinking it’s just a coincidence but it seems not to be so
If you could recommend any duas/a’maal how to get rid of this, I’ll be grateful.

Recite Surat Nas and falaq, say Mashallah when you see something nice, and read dua Makarim Akhlaq

There are some Caucasian Sufi rituals where they walk/run in circles while doing Dhikr Allah. (Not to be confused with Turkish Sufi rituals where they spin in circles). Would the first example be haram? I understand that the ritual of going in circles isn’t something explicitly sanctioned by the Prophet or Imams, but at the same time they are doing Dhikr Allah. I have a similar questions regarding some of the Latm rituals that some Shias practice. They fall under the category of Mourning Imam Hussein. Why can’t the Caucasian Sufi rituals fall under Dhikr Allah?

If it is done as a legislated act of worship it becomes Bida. If a person just wants to spin in circles and remember God it would be okay, if it is not a part of the faith.

Why is a lot of the Quran Allah(swt) is comforting the prophet(SAW). I thought the Quran was a guidance and mercy. The prophet(SAW) found comfort in prayer and reading Quran and I know Quran is true but I don’t get comforted when I read or when I pray.

The Quran is comforting the prophet because people harassed him and abused him and despised him for no reason. The Quran is a mercy and guidance. The Quran shows mercy to all, not only to the prophet. God invites everyone to His mercy. God forgives everyone’s sins if they are sincere. Spirituality is not a switch that one can turn off and on. You have to turn away from distractions and anything that sways you away from the remembrance of God, so you will begin to enjoy the connection with God.

1) Is it haram to make jokes that are dark humour?
2) Is it permissible to listen to dark humour and laugh for example from a video on the internet?
3) Is listening to swear words impermissible if it has no effect on you or is it makruh?

1) Listening to jokes is halal. If those jokes become harmful to you or someone else then they become haraam.
2) A believer should abstain from listening to something that may impact them in a bad way.
3) We should not encourage indecent behavior.

I started salat Ayat before the qada time but finished after, would I have to repeat the prayer? Also would I have to repeat the prayer if it were a regular prayer?

No we long as you started and there was still time you are fine.

I have seen cannabis sativa (hemp) seed oil as an ingredient in a number of wellness products like hair wax, pomade, soap etc.

Are we allowed to use such products?

If you are not eating or consuming it and it is not intoxicating it would be okay

Forgetfulness and memory issues lies in my family.
Please tell me a way to avoid it because I have started feeling I am forgetting a lot these days and it is hindering my studies as well. I am reciting ayatul kursi after every namaz, reading memory du’a after every namaz .
What can I do restore my brain to full potential? My cognitive functions are also compromised

Recite this dua:

سبحان من لا يعتدي على أهل مملكته، سبحان من لا يأخذ أهل الأرض بألوان العذاب، سبحان الرؤف الرحيم، اللهم اجعل لي في قلبي نورا وبصرا وفهما وعلما إنك على كل شئ قدير)

I wanted to ask wherever the time when we get married & who we marry is pre-destined and written? Or can this be changed with the power of Dua?
Having tried several different avenues of looking for a spouse over the space of a few years, I am now thinking whether marriage is something that is even ‘written’ for me.

It is known by God but it is up to you to change your destiny

For neurodivergent people/people with mental illnesses, is it haram for them to wish for death even when they can’t help it?
This includes people with mental illnesses like depression, anxiety, and other personality disorders. Not necessarily those who are considered "insane"

If it’s not in their control it’s not haraam

In Surah Naml, why did Prophet Solomon(AS) want to wage war against the Queen of Sheba if her and her people didn’t become Muslim? I thought there was no compulsion in religion and for us is our deeds and they have their deeds?

Solomon was a prophet and a king. He could have taken over her empire through his political power. At the end of the day, he didn’t force her to become Muslim, when she saw his power and that it is from God she chose to believe.

A political power can conquer another power, however it cannot force the conversion, that needs to be through conviction and that is what happened with Solomon and RasulAllah

I ran through some family problems last year that ended with my father divorcing my mother and disowning me. I am still unmarried and wanted to know if I need his permission for marriage if he disowned me? And if the answer is yes, doing so will place a pressure on me, since he lives in another country, I haven’t seen him in 7 years and I haven’t talked to him for the whole year.
So is there another solution?

Yes if you have not been married before you need your fathers permission. You have to apologize to him and talk to him. Permission can be given on the phone, it doesn’t have to be in person.

I have a question that comes to my mind often. We see the names of Allah projected in to our daily lives through Allah’s creation and Allah loves all his creation. What about Shaytan? Does Allah love him?

Allah created Satan, and was merciful to him. However Satan even though still receives the general mercy of God because he is alive, he is not liked by God because of his evil nature and his oppression. He will not receive the specific mercy of God in heaven

I eat bubblegum frequently. I recently found out that Trident gum has 2% sugar alcohol.
So should we eat it or not?
Is it halal?

That should be halal

Is it permissible to slowly pay off kaffarah (over a few years) or do I need to save up and pay it all at once?

You can pay it over a long period of time.

According to Ayatullah Sadiq Shirazi, is it permissible to eat at a restaurant that serves halal food but also sells alcohol?

If you are sure the meat is halal and not mixed with the alcohol you can eat.

I am a recent convert who is under Taqiyya from my family, and for diwali, a festival, my family bows towards idols and makes prayers. Is it permissible for me to bow in front of idols with no intention of believing in idols or polytheism so that my family is not suspicious of me? Is it enough that I in my heart I know that the only God is Allah SWT and he has no partners?

Not bow to idols. Bowing is a sign of worship. You have to not do that.

I initially liked a non Muslim boy through non halal means and I since then have repented and continue to do so, as ashamed as I am to admit it, we would consume alcohol and commit zina

I for the almost the last year have been repenting and trying to ask for forgiveness however I am stuck with some dilemma

The boy and I wish to get married and he has researched Islam on his own and wishes to convert. Would our marriage be valid if we repent for our earlier mistakes of zina and alcohol? Would it have an effect on future children? Is this marriage permissible?

Yes the marriage would be valid. If a person was married and committed adultery with another person, they would not be able to marry the person they committed adultery with. However if they were not married and committed zina then they can get married. You have to continue doing istighfar and he needs to do istighfar as well.

I figure it all depends on your intention. But I have heard from people that even if you intend to learn yoga for health, the longer you live in the subculture the more likely to either engage in the weird sexual aspects of it and even bits and pieces of the Hindu religion it derives from.

So I’m just wondering generally about how we approach other traditions with some valuable tools like meditation and yoga. Should we avoid it just in case, or as long as the intention is pure it’s always fine?

It is not haraam to meditate and exercise. If a person starts practicing and believing in something other than Islam than it becomes haraam. However I don’t see yoga as a Hindu thing. It’s become common practice in many cultures. Of course the rules of hijab would have to be practiced.

For me the matter is clear and I would like to name my son after a name of the Ahlulbayt.

My father, however, would be happy if I named him after him. I don’t know if my father’s name is a good name that Allah swt would be pleased with.

My father’s name is Raef when I read the definition of this name my heart really goes out because he lives this name.

You can give him two names. Pleasing your father has a lot of reward.

I have a cousin brother who was going through a lot of financial crisis, was unemployed and had a family to look after. By the grace of Allah I was in a position to help him so I did. He asked for some help every few days and I was able to help him. He got a job now but still every month asks for some monetary help by giving some reason every time. And now I doubt he’s making up those stories. Also I saw some instances which made me believe the money he asks for is based on lies. Now what should I do if he asks for money again? It’s not right in my opinion to keep supporting him if he’s lying.

It’s good to give him but if you feel he is taking advantage of you, you don’t have to. You should not end the relationship with him. You can also give him something minimal if you feel that he doesn’t need anymore.

I have a problem with my Sunni friends who apparently think it is bidah to celebrate the Prophets birthday. Do you have any specific verses from the Quran or Sunni hadiths that proves otherwise? And how do I explain it to them without being judged by them

The prophet celebrated his birthday by fasting on mondays
The Quran celebrates the birth of the prophets Jesus, Yahya, and Ismail by speaking of their birth. The fact that the Quran is talking about it means it is an important event. If God discusses it and talks about it why can’t we? When we talk about the birth of the prophet we are celebrating his birth.

My question is can women pray in hoodie?
If that hoodie cover the head arms and neck and it is very lose does not show any body curves .

Yes if the hair does not show and neck

1) Is it permissible to do tayammum from a turbah and if we do so is our salah not valid?

2) Does the turbah have to be big enough for both of our palms to touch? Or just a part of our hands?

1) Yes it is permissible and the prayer is valid.

2) Part of the hands is enough

Before doing ghusl, I will put soap on my body, and then I will make niyyah to wash my body while the lather is still on. The soap doesn’t make a barrier to water, and I step under the shower and let the water wash off the soap.

Do I need to wash the soap off before I make niyyah for ghusl, or can I do niyyah for ghusl and then wash the soap off?

No you are doing it correctly. You can do the niya and then wash the soap off

1) Allah with his infinite knowledge choose Muhammad (saw) as messenger. Based on His infinite knowledge, He knew he would use his free will in the best way to make efforts but now I wonder that even if there is no explanation for us, for Allah there is since he created us with free will. So why do some use their free will better and become great people close to Allah while some dont? It can’t be possible that Allah made some free will more inclined to do something. So how could it be explained? Would I be able to get an answer in the hereafter?

2) In the world of particles for example, with everyone having a free will, what is the thing that made some acknowledge our Lord faster than others?

3) Does this mean Allah created us different ?

1) Everyone has equal free will. No one had more freewill than others. Everyone is judged by Allah, and Allah knows what’s in the hearts.

2) People are different, some accept the truth some don’t. Just like we see in this life.

3) We are all created with different potentials, but we all have the capacity to accept the truth or reject it.

As-salam-u-alaykum,
I have some questions regarding buloogh and responsibilities.

My maraja Sayed Sistani and he has said, regarding puberty for males, that it is shown in 4 ways: Completion of 15 years, ejaculation, pubic hair and hair on the face.

1) If one of the signs (ejaculation, pubic hair and hair on the face) before 15 years occurs, does that mean that someone is buloogh or is it at 15 years and over if one of the signs occur?

2) If someone, let’s say they are 18, 19 or 20, has ejaculated before 15 years of age but they have forgotten if it was at age 11, 12 or 13 should they count their qaza obligations (prayer and fast) from age 15 onwards?

3) If someone does not know they are buloogh and that fasts are obligatory on them do they have pay kaffarah alongside qaza fasts or just do the qaza fast? I have read a Q&A from Sayed Mohammad Al-Musawi on the website Al-Islam that you don’t have to pay kaffarah if you didn’t know, is this true?

4) Does someone that didn’t know they had to pay kaffarah if they delayed their qaza fasts to the next Ramadan have to pay kaffarah for the multiple years that they have delayed it?

M5) hen making up qaza fasts, that are being done out of ignorance of becoming buloogh and missing out on that year, does the person have to do the consecutive 30 days? Or can they do 1 day fasting and the next day not and then the day after fasting? I have read a Q&A on the website Islamqa that they do not need to be done consecutively, is this true?

1) Yes you become Baligh as soon as one is the signs show, even if it is before 15.

2) They have to count from the age signs of puberty showed. Not 15, but rather 11 or 12, the time they are sure they were baligh. They have to make up those prayers and fasting.

3) If you are not aware there is no kafara.
4) Yes if the fasting was missed intentionally and knowingly they have to pay kafara. The kafara can be paid whenever. Even many years later. The day that was missed must be made up too.

5) They can make up the fast whenever. It does not need to be done consecutively.

My question is for a friend of mine who is saying that we can’t be sure to curse in qunoot, I have seen the Hadith of Imam Jafar Al Sadiq (as) doing so but he said that we can’t just follow what the Imams (as) did so is it allowed to curse in qunoot?

Cursing the enemies of God is a dua. It is asking Allah to remove His mercy from the evil Individuals. If this is done with the intention of a dua then it is allowed.

I’ve just recently found out that when we’re washing our arms from the elbow, we’re supposed to wipe all the way down to the finger tips. I’ve only been washing from the elbow to the wrist. My hands were still wet with wudu water however due to using them to wipe my arms. Does this mean my wudu has been invalid for all this time and do I have to make up all my salah again?

Yes you need to make up the wudhu and the prayers.

I want to ask that when we say that Allah is everywhere and he is non physical so we all believe this with our sense and proofs

1. But when he is everywhere so does he touches things?

2. If he is everywhere so is it that everything is in him? Obviously he is not hollow or leaves some space.

3. If we believe that he is everywhere so how de we define them because when he is everywhere and non physical so nothing can touch him or neither he touches anything so it that everything is in him but he is not empty,

4.If he is with things than how?

5. And if he is apart from them than how?

Material is a creation of God. Your imagination can only imagine that which it knows and sees. God created all material and therefore cannot be trapped within something He created. He does not have a physical body and does not resemble anything. His power and authority has encompasses everything. He is aware of everything. He is everywhere the same way light is everywhere. The light is not confined to a place, it just lights everything.

There is a sermon in nahjul balagha related to the death of Prophet where Imam said "After you the nabuwat came to an end, The orders of God are completed and no more divine message will come" so a scholar has raised a question on Imamat through this line?

But we believe this that Hazrat Jibraeel used to come after the Prophet to Hazrat Fatima and other Imam so please guide in this regard

The prophethood did come to an end. The job of the imam
Is not to receive divine message but to interpret the message of the prophet and the Quran. There is no issue against Imamate with this.

Yes angels comes to lady fatima doesn’t mean the revelation of the Quran is still coming down. The angels used to speak to maryam too, and she is not a prophet.

Does the wife have to ask her husband for permission when she goes out somewhere and what about the other way round?

She needs to inform him and receive his consent if her going out with take away from his rights, or if she is going somewhere that he has not agreed to initially.

He does not need his wife’s consent.

I want to ask if it is permissible to ejaculate by seeing wife’s pics/video, when one is away from wife?
Is it the same as masturbation, if the individual does not touch his genitals?

It is halal to see a picture or photo of your wife. It is haraam to masturbate to those pictures or any pictures. If one ejaculates without touching themselves, there is no problem.

Is Living with in laws an islamic concept? Did Imam Ali live with his mother after marriage? If a couple separates from their parents after marriage, it is said they broke the family, and as if committed a sin by leaving parents on their own in old age. How does Islam view this?

No it is not an Islamic concept. Imam Ali lived on his own. Respecting parents is an Islamic duty.

Can you please educate me on nikah e Mutah responsibilities?
Is husband supposed to take care of wife financially?

No, husband is not responsible to take care of the wife financially in muta. His responsibilities are what they agree upon in the marriage contract. If that was a stipulation then it becomes obligatory.

Is it permissible to use beard brushes that are made from boar bristles? If it makes the beard najis, will splashing a bit of water on the face make the najis place tahir?

If the brush is wet then the face becomes najis. You would have to wash the face.

I’ve read that if you’re salah is not accepted nothing else you do get accepted. For instance, if you build a mosque but your salah is not accepted then your good deed building the mosque is also not accepted. So what I’m wondering is, how do we know our salah is accepted? Is not focusing during prayer something that leads to the prayer not being accepted?

That is for someone who does not pray. If someone prayed and they are having trouble concentrating, their prayer is still accepted.

I have a question about a Hadith in Bihar Al anwar. It’s a Hadith I’ve heard many Shias mention but I’m personally questioning the accuracy of this Hadith. It makes no sense to me. It’s about imam Ali divorcing Aisha from the prophet in the battle of the camel. Is it really saheeh? I’ve heard differently about this Hadith so I wanted to ask you about it

There is no need to divorce the prophet from Aisha since the prophet had passed away. Divorce is something that ends the marriage and death does exactly that.

I have a question about Imam Mahdi. I read that every Imam has to be buried by another Imam and that when the 12th Imam dies apparently Imam Hussein will come back to bury him. My question is, how will Imam Mahdi’s death happen and how will the burial be? Will we be able to witness Imam Hussein as burying him?

We don’t have many details of the events. What some narrations say is that the Imam will be killed and Imam Hussayn will wash his body and bury him. Some narrations suggest he will be killed. If we are alive at the time perhaps we will see.

I regularly get asked from the youth, is all music haram, what type of music can I listen to and the same with instruments ?
If you can please explain more about this topic I’ll be really great full, I’ve done some research but get different kind of answers.
I don’t like to say some kind of music is halal to the youth because I feel they tend to take advantage of it.

This issue has different opinions based on marji you follow.
Sayed Sistani says classical and soft music are allowed. Those that are used in inappropriate atmospheres are forbidden.

If after intercourse, some time passes and by the time one gets in the shower, a bit of sperm is on his organ but it’s dry and qalil water gets on it, does it make it pure?

If qalel water gets on it, you need to pour it several times to make sure the Sperm is removed

Someone stole and they were on the news. This person is Muslim. Would sharing this news be gheebat?

It’s better not to do so. Unless doing so bad some sort of benefit.

What is the ruling on drinks that are cbd based but have no THC in them which is the component that is the drug. A company states it is impossible to get high on their beverage as it does not contain any thc at all but the drink just relaxes one’s body with no change in mind

If it is not intoxicating and non alcoholic it is fine to drink

I recently had my puberty break and now have to choose a Marja, I want to do taqlid of Ayatollah Sistani, please guide how should I go about it.
Since its my first time choosing a marja, do I still have to investigate about whether Ayt Sistani is the most learnt or not
If yes, then how am I suppose to do it?
And do I have to compare him with all the other Marjas out there, and which points should I focus on reach to the conclusion of who is more learnt
Once this is done and I am ready to do his taqlid,
Do I have to inform him on him website/email or do I have to take like an oath of declaration?
Can I follow him even if I have no khums to pay?

You just make the intention to follow him. No need to do anything else. For Islamic laws refer to sistani.org

Is it okay for a women to offer prayers in a public place, where she is being watched by non-mahram men?

If she is wearing proper hijab yes.

I was on internet and I saw this claim : ‘god cannot be worthy of worship if he created billions despite knowing they’d burn to Hell for eternity.

His main point is that he is creating us knowing billions will go to Hell.

How to awnser this?

Everyone makes their own decisions in life, otherwise it would be unjust for God to create us and force us to go to heaven or hell.

Gods knowledge does not impact the decision we make. Imagine yourself on a hill watching a car driving and it is going to hit another person on the other side. You can yell and tell the driver to slow down and the driver does not. You know there will be an accident but you are not responsible for it. This is the same, Gods knowledge of things does not mean He is forcing them. He has knowledge because He is not trapped in time and knowledge is His essence.

I often share religous videos on my social media and many people see them. My intenion is to share the video with other belivers who may find it beneficial or bring peace to them. However, I still feel like I’m indirectly giving an impression of a highly pious person which I don’t want to give and it gives me guilt. Are my intentions correct and can I continue to share them or should I stop all together until I feel my intention is 100% pure?

Your intentions are correct. It’s better than giving an impression of a non-religious person which many people are doing. Do it with the intention of spreading knowledge and guiding people including yourself. If everyone was afraid of what others think then there would be no one doing anything good.

Can you please tell me what will happen after Imam’s zuhoor like we move into that Era there were war happens like old age (using swords and horses). Or there will technical world?
I’m an engineering student. Does my studies not benefits the Imam?

Inshallah you can benefit the imam. No we will not go back to old age. The new modern era will be a life of happiness and bliss.

My query is, am I allowed to be present in the delivery room when my wifeis giving birth?

Yes she is your wife.

توفي والدي وقد اخبرنا قبل وفاته بانه مديون لشخص واحد فقط، ولقد قمنا بسداد دينه. ولكنني لا ادري ان كان هنالك دين اخر قد نسيه، كما انني لا اعرف بمدى حلية الاموال التي كان يتعامل بها ولا ادري ان كانت هنالك حقوق شرعية في رقبته.
اود ان ادفع بالنيابة عنه لاريحه. سواء اموال او مواد عينية. هل من الجائز ان تكون النية هي( ابراء ما في ذمة ابي وان لم يكن هنالك شيء في ذمته فصدقة باسمه تعالى في ميزان حسنات ابي)؟

نعم يجوز و هذا عمل جيد وان شاء الله يكون في ميزان حسناتكم والوالد رحمه الله

In the past the company Fedex company was about to go broke, and the CEO played blackjack in order to sustain his company and now Fedex company is very successful.

If one works there, is their money halal? Like even if the origin of the business included haram money?

Gambling or playing Fam fling cards is haraam. Maybe he made money but many lose. The money is also not pure.

The salary is pure

So we know that in Islam, Allah grants the most pious of his servants with karamat, the extraordinary powers or miracles they can perform in this world. I was wondering if you could show me some of the ahadith on this? Specifically the ones that state that anyone, even non prophets/imams, can be granted those powers.

غاية التقرب - رسول الله (صلى الله عليه وآله): قال الله عز وجل: ما تقرب إلي عبد بشئ أحب إلي مما افترضت عليه، وإنه ليتقرب إلي بالنافلة حتى أحبه، فإذا أحببته كنت سمعه الذي يسمع به، وبصره الذي يبصر به، ولسانه الذي ينطق به، ويده التي يبطش بها، إن دعاني أجبته، وإن سألني أعطيته (6).

What are the limitations of following the mujtahid?

A mujtahid cannot be followed in matters of ideology. The mujtahid must be qualified and perhaps the most knowledgeable. He must be a man and does not sin and do things wrong.

Do I have to put the letter that I wrote to imam madhi in a special box or leave it bare with no protection cover? Can i throw it to the river without putting protection cover on it? I like writing  in a piece of paper so can i throw it like that ?

And also can I keep the letters with me instead of throwing them in the river. If I keep the letters with me , will Imam Mahdi read them ?

And what are the benefits of writing letter to Imam Mahdi? and also what are the benefits of throwing it in the river ? Will it reach to our Imam faster?

You can put it in a box or just put the letter without a box. We have narrations that the Imams encourage people to write them letters. This is to strengthen the ties and relationship with the Imam. Even if you do not write an Ariza, the Imam knows what is in your heart because God informs him.

There’s this one boy in my university who has a crush on me, and he looks at me, so is it waajib for me to wear a mask(hide my face) and to hide my hands?

If him looking at you is causing fitna yes you should do so. (Fitna meaning) Is it making you fall in haraam? If not then it is not mandatory.

I’ve been wondering how it is that the Prophet and Imams are above people and got such privileges. Isn’t it that everyone should be equal? And isn’t it that a rank in the eyes of Allah should be earned and not just given. It seems a little unfair to put someone above the rest just cause you MADE them infallible. You MADE them perfect. They didn’t become it, since that is literally impossible. Also if there was a test before which showed they WERE actually better. How is it that we’re going through another test? Wasn’t that one enough to show who goes to heaven and hell? Besides how did they know what their lord asked from them? Since there were no Prophets or Imams in the previous test. Also if there was another test it really ain’t fair that we don’t remember or know about it. Since the reason we have to go through this one consciously, is so that we know where we end up is because of our own choices in life.

Everyone is equal in the eyes of Allah, means that everyone has an equal opportunity to reach God and attain his satisfaction. Everyone is tested by God, the prophets are tested and the normal people are tested.

In fact the test of the prophets and Imams are more severe and more difficult than the test of normal people.

The reason they were chosen as Prophets and Imams is because God knows through His knowledge (which is not limited by time) that these prophets and Imams are the greatest and most obedient of Gods creation. We are limited by time and place so we know who the victor of a test is after the test results come out. Allah created time and place so Allah knows who the victor is even before the test.

The reason the Prophet and Imams are greater is because of the knowledge they have. They have been given the knowledge by God because they accepted the knowledge. We all have access to signs of God and knowledge but we look past these signs most of the time. The prophets and Imams have knowledge, however they are also tested based on their knowledge, that is why their tests are more severe.

God tested the souls in a previous realm, and tests is again to show us and prove to us on the day of Judgement our own actions. Although He knows who goes to heaven or hell, our actions will be displayed in front of us so no one questions the Justice of God.
Just because we don’t remember the test doesn’t mean we were not tested. We forget a lot of things in this life, it doesn’t mean that didn’t happen. Also, the test in the previous realm was a simple test not something as extensive as in this life.

It is said in the ahkam book that a mosque must have a certain distance from each other to be prayed salat jummah. This applies only to shias mosques or even if sunnis build a mosque close to a shia mosque, it will not permissible to pray salat jummah there?

This applies to Shia mosque where the prayer is prayed in the correct fashion.

1) If I was late to join jamaat salah for Jumu’a would it be the same rules that apply to any jamaat salah?

2) And also would it be different for Eid salah?

1) If you missed the juma prayer, you would have to do zuhr prayer.

2) Eid salat as well, however eid is recommended so it is okay to enter half way. Juma prayer takes the place of zuhr and therefore must be done correctly.

Entering into any other prayer, a person would have to follow along the imam while counting where they are in the prayer.

I am very curious about people and sin. I try my best to not sin. Stay away from major sins that are easy to access in western cultur where I live. Many Muslims I have met much older than me have been the worst not only lifestyle with zina and drugs but also violence arrogant and unfair behavior towards everybody. They reach a age where the youth has fade away and now the repent and become religious.

What is the status different between those ppl and those who even in their youth behaved, treated people good, prayed etc. It seems unfair that the other part “enjoyed” this Dunya and used all those “good” years on doing exactly what they want when they wanted and then they repent and come to Jannah, while others “struggle” the whole life to be good human beings and good Muslims. I have heard people being happy about their experience – this saddens me. I have always tried my best to be on the right side. Always feared for punishing and now the people that have sinned all life can just get away with it. Please don’t misunderstand I am just confused. Because I really make effort, and when I watch people laugh at their dirt past and be proud they are righteous now. It saddens me.

Of course living a lifestyle while refraining from sin is much healthier and better for a person. First of all no one knows if their repentance is fully accepted. It is only accepted if a person is sincere.
Second, living a sinful lifestyle becomes addictive. It becomes very hard to get out of it and change your life. This is like someone doing drugs which damage the body, then going into rehab. It is obviously must healthier to not go drugs from the beginning.

The third point is that no one knows when they will die. Perhaps they die while they are sinning and this will be their end. So it is much better to refrain from sin because sins destroy our life and afterlife.

I am also making up for 18 years of praying, I read them short after watching sheikh Mohammad al-hilli YouTube where he describes the wajib acts duas. I’m now in doubt if my prayer were fard on me from age 9 or when my menses started?

What is your advice for salat up Layl or just witr, should I start them or first pray all my qadha?

If you follow sayed Sistani, you count from 9 hijri.

You can pray the midnight prayer or recommended prayers and make up the missed prayers at the same time. Pray your missed prayers after midnight then do the shaf’ and witr on their own.

My building’s water comes from a direct connection to the bore well (ground water) and overhead water tankers are all over 500 litres through which all taps in the house get water. I have crossed checked, there are 4 overhead tanks and each of them has a capacity of 1000 litres (i.e. 4000 litres in total).

Is my tap water considered Kurr? Please explain to clear my doubt.

It is Kur however it is not Jaree (running water). Hence ayatollah Sistani says that a person must wash 2 times and not just once as one does in the running water

A cat had defecated in one corner of the living room of my house.
I had asked the house help to clean it and make it paak but I am not sure about his method of making it paak cause he is Sunni and I don’t even know if he made the cloth paak after cleaning the area where defecation was done.

This was a while ago and the house has been cleaned multiple times ever since. Also, the house help cleans the floor of the entire house with the same cloth.

I am now afraid that the floor of the entire house might be najis. Please let me know what the right course of action is now as I am scared of even praying inside this house as I am afraid the floor is najis.

If the house cleaner is Muslim, then you can consider it pure and they cleaned it. The law of purity should apply

My question is regarding the 40th aayat of Surah Tawba. I was talking to a Sunni brother online and we were discussing about the caliphs. He said that the first caliph’s martaba can be proved from the Qur’an and he put forth the 40th aayat of Surah Tawba as an example. I would like to know whether it is true that the aayats true meaning is in praise of the first caliph or not. Please clarify.

That is the verse of the cave.
No this verse shows God is supporting the prophet. Not necessary enough to prove that he deserves the caliphate.

I would like to know if there are any particular positions or amaal that are not permissible while a couple tries to conceive.

As long as they are married it is halal to have a relationship and conceive a child. Everything is halal unless it is clearly stated that it is haraam.

Is it permissible to take ADHD medication like Ritalin?

If it is prescribed by a doctor yes

If my older son (4 years) hits his younger brother (1 years) and I cause him fear telling him he hurt his brother is that fine? Is there a better way that can be taught from the lives of the Ahlul Bayt when teaching a young child to be kind to others?

That is fine. You have to discipline him with out harming him.

For the first 2 years of me praying as a Shia I used to raise my index finger in tashahhud until I found shias and shia scholars saying this isn’t something shias do and it may invalidate salah. Do I have to make up 2 years worth of salah that I did because I used to raise my index finger? I was praying everything the Shia way but this was my only unintentional mistake

No you do not need to make up the prayers.

One of my Sunni friend asked me whether Angles used to descend on your Imams (A.S) too after the Prophet (PBUH) left or not?

If yes then how can we differentiate this from the belief of Qadiyani who don’t believe on "Khatm e Nabowat"? i.e what is difference?

Furthermore, if your answer is yes then, what is meant by Imam Ali’s (A.S) Khutba #232 in which He (A.S) says that O Prophet (PBUH) your death wasn’t like any other Prophet, as it discontinued the connection with News from Skies etc?

Revelation stopped as the Quran was complete however angels can speak to someone who is not a prophet. The angels spoke to Maryam, she was not a prophet and it was not a revelation.

We have hadith that angels spoke to the Imams.

Is acting haram? Is it allowed to take part in university courses where knowledge is taught through acting?

If nothing inappropriate is being fine yes.

Is one’s will a part of their essence or attribute? Or is both?

No a persons will is separate from their essence. The will changes based on desires and moods.

Why Eid Al adha is 4 days while Eid Al fitr is only 3.

As for eid, also because God has ordered so. Perhaps it’s because the pilgrims are in the hajj and that gives them more time to do the slaughtering and rites of hajj.

For many months, I’ve had continuous bad dreams about my father relating to his health and wellbeing. I’m not sure if this is just my brain or something else. How should I deal with these dreams? Do they have meanings?

Recite Ayatul Kursi before you sleep

In a marriage if the husband cheats, will he be punished? Can the wife demand a divorce from him? Also is it fair for men to want more than one woman, even though wife does everything, he choose to remarry or lust over other women, is that a sin or male nature? In that case, how to handle that situation as a wife. Because I can’t help feeling used and deeply insulted if that was me. I feel every man wants more than one woman and desire women to a point it destroy their marriage. I have been told if woman cheat she should be killed if a man does is it fair enough because we are different and men tend to crave it more than women.

If the husband has an illegitimate relationship he will be punished. However if it is done in the halal way, it is halal. She can demand a divorce if she had out a condition earlier.

Is watching videos of people dying or of gore haram, makruh or mubah?

It’s not haraam however if it will affect you in a bad way then it can become haraam

I wanted to ask if for example, I had an dish that was contaminated because someone placed non halal meat on it, I washed it three times and I had gained certainty for a while that it had become Tahir. What does Sayed Zanjani say about purifying dishes that are contaminated by the Non Halal meat? Is his fatwa based on Wajib Ihtiyat? But later I got doubts whether I had washed that dish completely after gaining certainty before. What should I do in this case?

You consider it pure

What should I read to learn the responsibilities of a husband and wife? Like some rules and regulations that will help I and my wife better partners.

This book
https://www.al-islam.org/principles-marriage-family-ethics-ibrahim-amini/part-1-duties-women

I want to know why zinah is haram. What impact does it have on society that makes it haram? I need to know so I can defend it in-front of my non Muslim friends.

Zina is haraam because it is entering into a relationship without an agreement which guarantees the rights of both individuals.

A lady can get pregnant, who will guarantee her rights and the rights of her child? In a marriage the rights are declared and known. Marriage provides responsibilities and rights and duties. Zina doesn’t do any of that. It is just fulfilling a pleasure and then moving on. It means there is no commitment to the relationship.

If a person wants to discard old quran or a surah of quran, can he do so my using whiter or black out or scratch out the verses so it’s no longer "visible" and then discard it like regular paper?

I know about the method of throwing Qur’an into clean river but is the quran still a quran if you cross out all the verses? Or is it haram to use white out on the quran to erase the verses?

Yes you can scratch it out or put whiteout. However even after doing so, one should not throw it in the trash and discard it in a way which would not seem to be showing disrespect to the Quran.

When a man marries a woman who already has daughter or son, is the step father responsible for the maintenance of the child and is this his responsibility or is the responsibility still on the biological father of the child?

The responsibility is on the biological father. If he went into the marriage having made an agreement with his wife that he will take care, then he must abide by that agreement.

Can one do ghusl at the end of their shower? Or would one must dry themselves up first and then do ghusl?

Yes you can do ghusl at the end of the shower and there is no need to dry yourself.

If for whatever reason I am not content with the way i did my wiping of the feet or head, whether it be because I have doubt that I did it correctly or some other reason.

Can I repeat the process of the wiping? Must it be done once? Or should you restart the wudu from the beginning if the sequence is important?

If you are not certain you wiped correctly you can wipe it again to make sure you are certain. Once you are certain you should not do it more.

Is it haram to say "jesus Christ" as exclamation of surprise or annoyance. For example: "jesus Christ man, leave me alone"?

Jesus Christ means Jesus the messiah. We believe that he was the messiah. There is no problem with saying just that. However if it is said to imply in anyway that he is God or the son of God then it would be haraam.

What’s the greatest amaal I can do for a dead person according to hadiths? Or top 3 things that are the most beneficial to a dead person? Maybe something you can do daily.

Recite Quran and gift it to their soul.
Give charity on their behalf
Do good deeds in general in their name.

I’ve been wearing the abaya for a little over a year. I do realize it’s importance but at the same time it’s so hard to be the only hijabi in my city. I feel so lonely and I have no other form of support from friends or family in terms of wearing the abaya. I also fear that one might try to hurt me because my hijab resembles those of Muslim countries (like Saudi Arabia).
I was wondering if it is possible for me to wear baggy jeans while maintaining hijab. I plan on keeping my clothes loose and not flashy.

Hijab just means you need to wear modest clothes where your body is not revealed. You can decide what you want to wear and you are your own judge. I would recommend a skirt or long dress and below it pants. That way it is loose and body would not be revealed.

1) Is it allowed to rinse the mouth while fasting because of thirst if the water doesn’t go inside the throat?

2) If someone brushes his teeth, not because of thirst but because of smell and he accidentally swallows the water will he have to keep a qaza for that fast?

1) Yes it is allowed

2) No

If a person intentionally misses a fast with the intention of paying it’s kaffara and pays it as well, will he be sinned?

Yes

1) Why are there so many contradictions in the hadees? I’ve noticed some hadees say something while the other hadees contradicts it, so how would we know which hadees is true?

2) How are we supposed to understand religion when everyone has different opinion? How should we know who’s opinion to follow?

1) Contradictions happen for many reasons.
A- Sometimes people lie and make up things in the name of prophet

B- Sometimes mistakes can be made which bring up a contradictory message.
C- Sometimes the understanding of a hadeeth is contradictory. One example the prophet saying who ever I am his mowla Ali is his mowla. Shia understand mowla as leader while Sunnis understand mowla as friend.

2) That’s why Allah gave you the power of intellect and reason. You have to comprehend, not just follow blindly.

If someone killed his nafs, can he regain it?

The nafs doesn’t die. It just transforms. It can be a nafs that is after evil, it can change to nafs that is after God and afterlife. It requires training.

Is it okay to create websites for certain businesses like vineyards, winery, cannabis or gambling?

If no, is it permissible to create websites for businesses that are indirectly related such as restaurants that also serve alcohol, or a business that wants to teach people how to play a certain gambling game?

If making the website is promoting the haraam it is haraam.

A restaurant is okay but not something that is directly aiding and supporting haraam acts.

Does the husband still have authority over the wife if he is not fully providing for her financially? Does she still have to be obedient to him?

He loses his rights if he is not giving her rights. However, this should be through counseling and judgement would be passed. She shouldn’t take matters into her own hands.

Do I need to ask permission from my boss if I pray in a break room before work begins?

No unless you know they do not allow, you cannot pray in a place that you do not have permission to pray but if you don’t think they wouldn’t allow you you don’t have to ask.

There is part of a hadith by Imam Ali that says "وأعلى المنكوحات النساء وهو مبال في مبال، ومثال لمثال، وإنما يراد أحسن ما في المرأة لأقبح ما فيها.
وأعلى المركوبات الخيل وهن قواتل…"
What is the interpretation of the first part because of course I don’t want to understand it as belittling, as Imam Ali is the one who said it, if its authentic, and of course thats not the case?

In this hadith the Imam is talking about the best things in this dunya. He points out 7.
As for the منكوح he means that which is penetrated and he refers to the female reproductive organ with the male reproductive organ مبال لمبال - as opposed to penetrating anything else.

I don’t know how authentic this hadith is, but it is in no way showing disrespect to women. The Imam has many wise sayings and he clarifies and discusses a variety of topics.

I wanted to ask what are the logical reasons behind why bank interests are permissible? I’ve seen a lot of scholars say that it’s haram but also many who say it’s halal. I’d appreciate if you could shed some light on this inshaAllah

Their are several “loopholes” which make it halal.

One is one they refer to as Inqath mal al kafir- this works when the financial institution is a non-Muslim one.

If they are offering you money, you are allowed to take it, not with the intention of loan. Then later they ask you to pay it back, with some fees you do so in order to save your house. But the initial taking of the money was not with the intention of a loan, even though technically it is a loan.

Another is to consider the interest as fees given to the bank, they did paperwork, etc for your needs to be met. That extra you are giving is to pay for those fees.

Another would be to not consider it a loan, you are buying a house, the money goes directly from the bank to the house owner. So technically you are agreeing to purchase the house from the bank at a more expensive price.

1) If someone says Wallah for something and they forget are you obligated to remind them.

2) Do they get sins if they forget? And if I remind them with that then they will not get sins

1) You are not obliged to remind them. It’s on them to remember.

2) Yes if they do not go through with an oath it is haraam. You can remind them if you like.

However if they were not serious when they said Wallah, they will not be held accountable for it.

Is it permissible to kill someone who is a confirmed rapist? Also what is the punishment for someone who sexually assaults someone without raping them?

No it is not permissible. It is up to the court or those in power to issue the punishment sentence.
The judge decides what the punishment is.

During prayer for Dhuhr, Asr, Maghrib, isha’a and fajr we recite Surah fatiha and any other surah that we chose at a whisper or moderate tone depending on the time of prayer, I was wondering if any other sections of the prayer for example qunoot and tashahhud needs to be recited in a whisper or moderate voice?

You have the option of reciting those in whisper or loud.

I have to choose a Marja, I want to do taqlid of Ayatollah Sistani, please guide how should I go about it.

Since its my first time choosing a marja, do I still have to investigate about whether Ayt Sistani is the most learnt or not? If yes, then how am I suppose to do it?
And do I have to compare him with all the other Marjas out there, and which points should I focus on reach to the conclusion of who is more learnt

Once this is done and I am ready to do his taqlid,
Do I have to inform him on him website/email or do I have to take like an oath of declaration?
Can I follow him even if I have no khums to pay?

You don’t need to do anything. You just follow his rulings and if there is an issue that comes up you refer to his opinions. You can find his opinions on the website Sistani.org

If several experts tell you sayed Sistani is the most knowledgeable, you can take their word. Today sayed Sistani is the most followed marji, therefore you can follow the suggestion of the experts and follow him. If you choose to do your own research you can.

I was wondering why cousin marriage is allowed when it can cause some type of sickness for the children?

This is the ruling of Allah. It doesn’t always cause sickness.

Can I perform Amal Umme Dawood, even after Zohrain Namaz, if I get home after work and it’s maghrib namaz time?

They are meant to be done during the day. If you couldn’t do it during the day you can do it after. Since it is a recommended act, we can be more lenient with the timing.

I have chosen someone to marry. I am still studying. We have known eachother and each others families and I’m happy to go forward and be married but before doing so I want to make sure I know everything I should know about marriage such as my rights. Where is the best place I can get this information from as I want to make sure I really know everything and am well equipped for this life commitment. I also wanted to ask you about doing a marriage long distance? Also my mum is happy with the family and with who I’ve chosen but she is hesitant just because of the fact I am young and he is not financially stable yet which I know are not islamically noteworthy factors but I have a difficult time explaining that to her. I’d rather be married sooner than later, but often I don’t know how confident I am that I am ready in the sense that I know if I know enough yet.

This lecture states the rights of the husband and the wife in a marriage.

https://youtu.be/bU0wNBpafqw

Marriage is a sacred relationship according to Islam, my advice is for you to always put God first when making any decision. If you do that you will find happiness in this life and in the next.

Long distance marriages have many challenges. It’s best to be together because that is the purpose of marriage. If financial stability is an issue now, that will go away as long as you both work hard and remain patient.

If it is common practice for women in my culture to put on henna for weddings or other occasions even where non mahram can see them, is it permissible for me to put it on if it’s considered normal?

No, culture does not override the laws of God. If the henna will be regarded as makeup and attract negative attention it can be considered haraam and should be covered in front of non-mahram men. If it is not regarded as seductive then it would be okay.

May I ask whether or not Hazrat Abu Talib and Hazrat Khadija were part of the Ahlulbayt?

There is a specific meaning for Ahlulbayt, that is the 5 ahlul kisa. The general meaning of Ahlulbayt is family of the Prophet and that includes them. However generally speaking when we say Ahlulbayt we mean the infallible masoomeen

1) What are the rights of a wife?

2) What can a woman do if her husband stops/refuses to give her nafaqah?

3) What can a woman do if her husband refuses to give her mahr?

4) How does Islam protect/enforce the rights of the wife when the husband refuses to give them and also refuses to give permission for divorce?

1) The rights of the wife are
A- Nafaqa- which covers the expenses of clothing, living place, and food
B- The right of intimacy - at least 1 every 4 months, or based on the need of the wife.
C- The right of sharing a bed at least one out of every 4 nights the husband has to share the bed with his wife.
D- Be treated fairly.

2) If the husband does not give nafaqa she can inform family members to counsel him, if that doesn’t work she can inform the Muslim jurist who would admonish him, if that doesn’t work, the jurist can carry out a divorce.

The above answer works for the 3rd and 4th question.

Husband doesn’t want to work and shows his agression and violence in front of kids by the name of depression

That is haraam. He has to work, he can’t show aggression and violence to family. He needs to seek therapy.

According to Sistani, is there a ruling that men are not allowed to wear tight clothes just like women are not allowed to wear tight clothes?

If those tight clothing are provocative and could attract negative attention they become haraam.

I have a question regarding the hijab. Is my mother allowed to force my sister to wear a hijab in Islam?

If she can force her and has authority over her she should. However your sister should not wear the hijab because of force, she should understand it and know it’s significance.

Why did abu Hanifa and Imam Malik create their own madhabs when Imam Sadiq taught them even if it was only a short while? Did Imam Sadiq practice taqiyyah with them? Were they not influenced by Imam Sadiq, and therefore if they were his students how were they able to go so astray from the teachings of the Imam

The madhabs of these individuals were propped up by the governments who wanted to oppose the Imams. They had different opinions, which was normal at the time but the governments raised them to bring down the influence of Imam Sadiq and the Imams of Ahlulbayt

I just wanted to ask, if a piece of clothing becomes najis through ayn ul najasa, and then it is placed into the washing machine, then placed on a drying rack, is the drying rack considered najis too? I rewashed the clothes in the washing machine on a rinse cycle, which according to the manual rinses the clothes 3 times, with an intermediate spin setting. would that suffice to purify the clothes and in the case if wringing were required?

The washing machine, if it is connected to running water should purify it. As long as you rinse it, which the washing machine does, it becomes tahir

Do women have to lower their gaze when watching male scholars give lectures? What exactly is lowering the gaze limited to?

If looking at a man will cause some sort of fitna (test for them) yes they have to lower their gaze

Me and my partner live far apart from each other and it is not possible at the moment to see each other and satisfy our physical needs. So we have conversations that include intimate and arousing talk to make up for that. However, after talking for a while it may lead to one of us having an orgasm from the speech and being aroused for so long

Would it be permissible to continue such conversations knowing it will cause an orgasm from the prolonged arousal? Or with the intention to orgasm through this way (not touching oneself)

As long as the person you are talking is halal upon you there is no problem with having that conversation and no problem with arousal without touching oneself.

Would it be wrong to place a condition that the person one wants to marry must be free of their addiction to pornography and masturbation for a certain amount of time before they get married? Or would it be makruh to place a condition when a marriage could potentially help? However the fear is that these addictions will continue into the marriage

Yes you can place those conditions. If someone has an addiction problem they need to address them before going in the marriage. However, marriage would also be a way to confront those issues.

Question regarding joking in a group that is based on Islamic discussions most of the time. I would like to clarify this,

1) If the jokes are directed between the non-mahram in the group, would that be a problem?

2) If the jokes are general jokes but the sisters can be heard laughing and making jokes back, would that be problematic?

3) If this occurs in a group chat setting where only two of the non-mahram are joking with each other, is this appropriate?

4) Is two mahrama complimenting each other in this group of non-mahram permissible?

1) If they are directing the jokes at each other it is not a group anymore. It is haraam to joke with the opposite gender, especially a joke that can be interpreted as flirting. As the atmosphere is appropriate it would be allowed. If it turns inappropriate it would not be allowed.

Is there any Dua form the Ahlul Bayt which we can read for the success and well being of our wife?
I know there’s duas for example in Sahifa Sajjadiyah for our parents and children, but I don’t know of anything for my wife.

I don’t know of a dua that specific. As you mentioned there is a dua for family in Sahifa Sajadiya.
You can recite this verse in Qunut (Furqan 74)

وَ الَّذِينَ يَقُولُونَ رَبَّنا هَبْ لَنا مِنْ أَزْواجِنا وَ ذُرِّيَّاتِنا قُرَّةَ أَعْيُنٍ وَ اجْعَلْنا لِلْمُتَّقِينَ إِماماً

We have a responsibility of a cat on us. We can’t abandon him and he gets so uncomfortable when he’s on heat (for mating). Is it permissible to get him neutered? I’ve tried resisting to his yelling and howling but it gets worse. He starts peeing in the house and that’s even more troublesome

It is allowed if the harm of not neutering is greater

I am pregant of 8.5 months. I am really worried and concern about my baby’s good future. I am worried about he or she will face the difficult of wealth in his or her life. Please suggest me good amaal for my new born baby’s good future

Recite Surat Yaseen everyday, Aytul Kursi 4 times, Inshallah Allah will protect you and your baby.

I had a question regarding sustenance. Is it haram to consume the food of a person who is known to have obtained money in a haram manner? As in, lying to the government to get more money? And is it haram to live in a house in which lying had to take place to obtain governmental benefits?

No, as long as a portion of the sustenance they make is halal, you can consume and benefit from that halal portion.

My question is in regards to how can one perform all their actions sincerely for Allah, with full Ikhlaas.
It feels very difficult. We humans are social beings and would like to be accepted in the society we live in and so sometimes we do actions saying it is for Allah but we cannot deny that we also want the people around us to be pleased with us. I don’t know if I am wrong but sometimes it feels like it is in our nature to want people to be pleased with us? Or is that the waswasa of shaytan?

So for example I go to university and make the intention that I want to gain Knowledge to gain closeness to Allah by serving the Imam of my time (a.s), and so I would want to perform and get the best grades but if I don’t do so well then I feel ashamed infront of the people around me and start thinking about what they will think about me (doesn’t that show that I was doing it for people?).
In the same way we participate in recitations during the programmes held in mosque and we get pleased when people acknowledge and praise us.
Isn’t that the complete opposite of Ikhlaas for then our deed is not solely for the pleasure of Allah.
What steps can one take to ensure that their deeds are solely performed for Allah and only Him and not care whatsoever about people’s opinions.
And is there a way to test and know if we are sincere in our actions?

It is normal to worry and be concerned about what people think. The most important thing is that your intention remains for Allah. Whatever you do in life which is good, let it be for Allah. The hadith says the reward is all through the intentions. You know your intentions are for God if you are not sinning or prioritize what people think over God.

I’m not sure what the ruling is if the moon is sighted in the country

It depends on the marji you follow. Some maraji like sayed Sistani, and Khamanie say the crescent needs to be sighted in your area. Others like Khoie say as long as you share the night with a city that witnessed the crescent, you can go with what they sighted.

How can a book which is najis due to blood and then sweat spreading the blood around the book be made tahir?
Because i cannot wash the book or wipe it with water?

If you cannot wash the book you can laminate it or cover it so the najasa does not spread.

I suffer from urinary incontinence (lack of voluntary control over urination or defecation). My urinary pipe leaks one or two droplets unknowingly in intervals of time, I come to know when see it or feel wetness so I don’t stay pure because of it.
1. The question is how do I perform my prayers?
2. Before this trouble I was good in prayer and in my religious life and I used to restrain my soul from sins. After this disease my religious life is getting ruined and still I am avoiding sins, but I am enough. I have sinned again and again. So please guide me.
3. I have decided to become a scholar, but how can I do that without purity and prayer?

1) If you are urinating on your self 24 hours non-stop you can do wudhu and pray and disregard what happens. However if you have a few minutes of time between each urine, you have to do wudhu and pray as soon as you can without any mustahab.

2) You have to pray and stay connected with God. Even if you don’t have wudhu you can recite Quran without touching the words, you can recite dua, you can listen to the Quran being recited.

3) You don’t need to always be in the state of purity to study religion.

I advise you to see a doctor who can give you medication to treat this issue.

“”Help me in their upbringing,
their education, and my devotion toward them,
give me among them from Thyself male children,
make that a good for me,
and make them a help for me
in that which I ask from Thee!””

This is an excerpt from Sahifa Sajjadiya, His supplication for his children.

I was just reading this with the translation, and I came upon this part. I want to ask, why is it mentioned specifically that a male child be born, rather then a female. Why is any gender mentioned for that matter? Is it not sufficient to say that a pious child be given from Allah be it a girl or a boy.

The Imam is not stating that one gender is better than the other. You can ask God whatever you want in the dua. He says amongst my children grant me males. He is not asking for only males and not asking to not have girls.

Although there are numerous narrations that if a person has daughters and raises them properly, those daughters will be the reason the parents go to paradise. The prophet was a father of daughters. However, typically a father needs a son to help him with the physical labor and the duties of running the family. So the Imam is saying the dua that many people have in mind. It is in no way against women.

Is it permissible to wear clothing of your choice (revealing or tight clothing) in a female only party or event?

If it does not cause fitna yes it is ok.

I want to ask that sayed’s nikah with non syed is halal or haram? Kindly highlight this topic with some authentic points from Islamic history.

This is a fatwa from Sayed Sistani. Someone is asking him about marriage with non-sayed from sayed. He said if their is not other reason to block the marriage and the person who is proposing is a good person but not sayed, and blocking the marriage means they get older without getting married, it is haraam.

السؤال: هناك كثير من الشباب العوام يشتكون من ظاهرة عدم قبول السادة بتزويج بناتهم من غير السادة، حيث يتقدّم بعض الشباب لطلب يد الفتاة العلوية لكن أهل الفتاة يرفضون الموافقة لمجرّد كون المتقدّم عامياً (ليس سيداً)، فما هو ردّ سماحتكم؟
الجواب: إذا كانوا يمنعون من زواج بناتهم من غير السادة من دون مبرّر شرعي حتّى يكبرن ويفوتهن الزواج فهذا حرام بلا إشكال، وفي الحديث الشريف: (إذا جاءكم مَن ترضون دينه وخلقه فزوجوّه إن لا تفعلوا تكن فتنة في الأرض وفساد كبير).

1) What is the definition of ‘home’ for example when I visit my parents house (that is beyond 28miles) would I pray Qasr? Or can I consider my parents house also ‘home’?

2) In addition the local Imambargah I attend is also 28 miles away however I attend regularly. Would I pray Qasr here too?

3) Further to this can I consider my grandma’s house as another ‘home’ I visit frequently over the weekend. I would say at least once a month? Would my niyyat of considering this a second home be valid?

1) If you still consider your parents house as your house you pray full. If you don’t consider yourself living there in the future then it’s not yours and you have to break the fast.

2) If you go to the Imambargah regularly you pray full.

3) If you truly consider it a home that you sleep/live in yes

I wanted to ask that what is the difference between contemplation and a interpretation of a holy Quran verse

Contemplation is just sitting and thinking about the words, the signs of God.

Interpretation is giving a meaning to what is said. This can be accurate and it can be wrong and forbidden. The interpretation of the Quran must be from the prophet and imams.

I have asked one of my Non Muslim widow friend for mutah. And I asked her to recite qalamah and become muslim. So for that she agreed. Do I need to check on her intention of converting. Or if she recites qalamah infront of me is enough?

It should be enough. Unless you know she didn’t mean it.

Is Bingo haram? There’s a game called bingo clash and I usually play it, I do not use any of my own money but I do win money when I win a game and can use that money to play more rewards and money, is that considered gambling? As it’s non of my own money.

Are you paying to play? If yes it is most likely haraam.

1) I wanted to ask you; Is Allah the name of God Almighty? Or is it a word that means God Almighty?

2) Is it the meaning of the word Allah which means God that is His name or is it the letters alif lam lam ha that is his name?

1) Allah is one of the names of God and it literally means God- which applies only to God. It is a name that no one else can name because it is the description and the name of God at the same time.

2) اله is God; ال before it is a title for the only God
So it is الله

If one on the night of 15 Shaban asks for getting rid of his prolonged sins; then is it correct? Or we cannot ask for getting rid of sins as a prayer?

You can ask for anything as long as it’s not something haraam. There is no problem with asking Allah to forgive you for all your sins, as long as you don’t go back to those sins.

Can fitra be used to buy clothes for poor and his family?

It is meant to be for food. You can give the person money and don’t ask what they do, but if you want to buy an item you have to give food.

Scholars say that people evolve spiritually when they’re in Jannah. Does that mean the rewards people get in Jannah are not fixed? Or to rephrase, do the level of rewards in Jannah stay the same eternally?

For example, Mulla Sadra says:

As far as the Right-Side People are concerned, they are the people of the journey and actions. They are the pious people. They are of different grades according to their deeds. So they have grades of the rewards according to the grades of Paradises: For each of them grades according to their deeds. [Quran S:46 V:19]

Sadra, Mulla. Life after Death (Mulla Sadra) (p. 17). Kindle Edition.

Does this grade of reward stay the same eternally?

Heaven is made in a way where who ever is in it will feel content with whatever level they have. So they would not feel the need to elevate to a higher level.

We have proof from some verses that the believers whose family also entered paradise but at a lower level, will be able to have their family raised to their level to be with them. This is an indicator that perhaps people can elevate in levels of paradise.

Since early age, have heard Ulema describing instance of how H. Ali a.s was named Hayder by his Honoured Mother.

1. Imam Ali was alone in the house and a snake came. Once his mother came back, she saw snake ripped into pieces. She uttered Hayya Darra which was then routinely called Haydar.
2. Arabs had custom to check legitimacy of a child through snake and same snake was allowed to sniff H. Ali so he ripped into 2 pieces and that custom was stopped.

Both of above instances are read under the pretext how he was named hayder

1. Done above narrations have any relevance?
2. How is it possible that H. Abu Talib a.s allow such thing to happen in his house?
3. What if Snake found the child illegitimate and swallow, do their parents allow this to happen in their presence?
4. What is the Real meaning of name Haydar?

This is the hadith you mentioned and it’s source.

عن أنس، عن عمر بن الخطاب: أن علياً "عليه السلام" رأى حية تقصده وهو في المهد، وقد شدت (وشدت) يداه في حال صغره.

فحول نفسه، وأخرج يده، فأخذ بيمينه عنقها، وغمزها غمزة[1]، حتى أدخل أصابعه فيها، و أمسكها حتى ماتت.

فلما رأت ذلك أمه نادت واستغاثت، فاجتمع الحشم، ثم قالت: كأنك حيدرة [حيدرة] اللبوة، إذا غضبت، من قبل أذى أولادها

مدينة المعاجز ج2 ص35 ومناقب آل أبي طالب ج2 ص287 و 288 و (ط المكتبة الحيدرية) ج2 ص120 وبحار الأنوار ج41 ص274 والإمام علي بن أبي طالب "عليه السلام" للهمداني ص611.

Haydara means a fierce lion

Just because the hadith is mentioned doesn’t really mean it is authentic. However, we know that Imam Ali was brave from a young age, and just as Allah chose certain prophets to show signs of greatness from a young age, that could very much be the case with Imam Ali.

The part of Arabs had a custom to check legitimate birth of child, I have never heard of.

I am confused about the time for Fajr prayer. Is the prayer valid till the darkness STARTS to disapper or once the sun completely comes out means the dark sky becomes clear? Means if I see a blue light outside, it it valid till that time or till the time when it is totally white?

Once the sun rises fajr time is over. You can check the exact time of sunrise everyday

I have some questions to ask if you could please guide.
1. While standing for prayers, is it necessary that the toes should touch each other or there should be gap between them? Which is the correct one?
2. In Salat ul Layl, is it pronounced as "Al-Afwa" or "Al-Afuu"? Is there any difference in their meanings?
3. Lastly, while reciting surahs during prayers, is it necessary that I pronounce words containing ح، ع، ق just as they do during recitation or I can recite normally? Means, do I need to pronounce from my throat necessarily?

1- You have to stand normally as you usually do. Don’t try too hard to put them together or spread them apart. The feet must not be more than 4 fingers apart from one another. Some people spread their feet apart too much.

2- al-Afuu- there is no difference. It goes back to Arabic grammar. If you are continuing and not taking a pause you can say al-Afwa al-Afwa

If you are stopping after each one you say al-Afuu

3- You have to try to recite it in the correct you to the best of your capabilities. Listen to how it is recited and recite like that. If you couldn’t then it’s ok.

İ have a confusion regarding whether one should let his/her knees touch the ground first while going into Sujood or the hands as İ have read multiple sources which say both are correct. But İ wanted to ask which one is better according to our sect or which one is more authentic.

Both are correct, however it is mustahab for a man to put hands first then knees.

1) I saw your lecture and it inspired me to recite Dua Abu Hamza, but I don’t know how I can prepare for my death?

2) How can I make sure I don’t get the squeeze of the earth and I die with complete faith (not letting Satan trick me into disbelief in Allah at last second)?

You should always ask Allah to protect you. Make sure you fulfill obligations and stay away from sins.

If all 8 doors to paradise are open for you, does that mean you will be in the highest level of paradise if you pick the best door to enter from?

I don’t need to offer Salah Al layl because I fasted 8 days in Rajab which gives the benefit of the all 8 doors open to Paradise? Can I guarantee that if I have fasted for 8 days?

1) Yes

2) No it’s always good to pray salaat al Layl and do good deeds because just as a door opens it can close due to actions and sins.

My father had a talk with me recently asking why we don’t have kids yet. I told him I don’t want to yet. He said that I am not allowed to do such and that I should be having kids at the first chance possible. That I am committing Gunah Kabeera (major sin) by taking away my wife’s ‘right’ to be a mother. He says that if God wants his Shias to have children and I’m not helping that goal of His then I am coming in His way and that he’ll punish me by taking away our ability to conceive.

From my understand and research- from a shariah standpoint I am allowed to plan when I want to have children and if at all. I am under no compulsion to do so even though I understand how highly recommend it is to have a progeny/offspring.

Please guide me, I’d really appreciate it.

You can choose to have children with your wife when you are both ready. Your father cannot force this upon you.

1) I was told that Allah tested us before coming to this dunia, is this real and if yes would you explain it a little bit to me if it doesn’t bother you.
2) Do only us Shiaa muslims go to heaven? Do Christians, Jews or Atheists who do good deeds and help others go to hell knowing that Allah is the most merciful?

Yes we have verses in the Quran and traditions which state that the souls were tested.
See Sura Araf verse 172

Allah chooses who goes to heaven. The important thing is we do what is expected of us and leave the judgement up to God.

Is it permissible to listen to Manqabats which describe happy occasions and are meant for happy days, on days which are the martyrdom dates of the Imams(a)?

You can always listen to manqabat

I recently was at a mind enhancing session and my doctor who is a Sufi, asked me to practice one exercise to enhance my consciousness called Muraqqaba. As a Shia Muslim, is it permissible for me to indulge in such a practice with the intention that it is a mental health enhancing exercise rather than a Sufi exercise?

But is it allowed for us to draw from other traditions? Basically this exercise consists of observing each sense mentally and then all the senses together and then observe who is the observe and finally observe the observer.

It depends on what you are doing in the exercise. If it is just thinking and contemplating and going over your life there is nothing wrong with that. From the way you are explaining it, it doesn’t seem wrong. You can sit at home and have mental observations in your room.

It depends on what other traditions are. If they are contrary to our beliefs no. If it is telling you to have observations there is nothing wrong with that as long as you are fulfilling your religious duties and not doing something wrong.

Our backpacks that we get at work has a leather material on the ‘handle’. I contacted the company and ask whether the leather was real or not, and they said the leather was real.

Now when I went back to the message I sent, I realised the link I sent them was for another bag and not exactly the same one we have at work. However it’s from the same product line called so the leather details look identical.

Now since the answer they gave me was for that other bag, can I consider this one as pure even if there’s a very high probability that the two bags are made of the same materials (since they come from the same product line and look similar)? The aql says it would be najis because I heard that when it comes to the fiqh, aql is not always the source when it comes to laws regarding tahara/najasah

The original ruling for any item is that it is pure unless you know knowledge/certainty that it is najis.

If you believe that it is najis based on what they said you should treat it as so. If you think there was a mistake or they are speaking about something else, you can consider it pure.

I used to have a car with najis leather, and sometimes my friend would ride the car with me when it was raining so their jackets would touch the leather and become najis.

Now I have a new car that is not najis, if my friends come and sit in my new car with their same jackets, do I have to consider the seats as najis (since the jackets are mutanajjis)? Or can I consider their jackets tahir as there might be a small possibility that they have washed them? Or is it obligatory upon me to ask them and make sure they wash their jackets?

First of all leather in cars may not be najis. You have to know for sure that it is from a najis or animal that is slaughter in a non halal way to consider it najis. If you do not know that you consider it pure.

If you know for sure that it is najis, then their jacket has also become najis.

If it is najis then it will make a second item it touches najis if it is moist. If there is reason to believe that the jacket has been washed… which is most likely the case, or it got rained on and purified; you can consider it pure.

What happened to Cain after he killed Abel according to Islam?

He died soon after

1) Is it Haram to recite nafilah prayers aloud?

2) Does it break the fast if we fall asleep with the zyn, a nicotine pouch, in our lip and wake up after fajr with it there?

3) Am I sinful if I let a dog lick me or pet it then purify myself before prayer?

4) Is dog hair impure or just wet dog hair? I read that sistani says all of the dog is najis but does that mean it’s najis only when it’s wet or even if the dog is dry?

1) It’s not haraam to recite nafila loud,

2) No it does not break the fast if you fell asleep with it, but once you realize you have to take it out.

3) You are not sinful if a dog licks you but you become najis and can’t pray with najasa.

4) Dog is najis, if it’s wet and it touches you you become najis.

I want to ask, is ziarat ashura and waritha something I should recite every day? I was not sure if they were just if I went to visit Karbala. Also, what are recommended things to say after prayer besides tasbih Fatima (a.s.)?

You can recite the shorter one ziyarat warith. It is not obligatory. If you couldn’t do it you don’t have to. It’s good to send salaams to the prophet and the 12 imams everyday. It can be a short salaam or the long ziyara. After tasbeeh zahra there are daily supplications after each prayer. You can find them on duas.org

It is also recommended to recite Aytul Kursi after each prayer 2:255

I also want to ask, does washing my privates while in the shower break my wudu?

No it does not, unless you do something which invalidates the wudhu

1) I want to ask, how do I give khums? Am I obligated if I don’t own a business?

2) Could I pay it when I do my taxes, so that I’d be able to tell how much I made in the year from where I’ve worked? And to see how much I spent, I’d have to go back through my transaction history and see how much I spent compared to how much I’ve made, yes? Do cash transactions count if they were so small that I can’t remember them? And when I’ve calculated who do I give it to? Is it like zakat where there are organizations?

1) Khums is not whether you own a business or not. It is paid on the extra surplus each year. Say you make 50 thousand and you spend 40 thousand. The ten thousand is the extra surplus. You would have to pay 1/5 of that, which is 2 thousand. You have to also pick a date to give Khums. You refer to that date every year when you make calculations.

2) If you will do your taxes soon you can do your Khums
Calculation after that.

You don’t need to look at all transactions. Just see what you own after the expenses are taken out.
Then give 1/5th of that which is left. When you are ready I can direct you to organizations that take the Khums.

Also according to sayed Sistani if you have a house mortgage you can deduct it from the Khums. (However it’s not that simple, there is a specific calculation)

I wanted to know that what should one recite in the 3rd & 4th rakat of prayer when praying with jamat & if sometimes furadah.

Also what should I recite In 1st & 2nd rakah of Zohr & Asr prayer.

First and second Raka are Fatiha and a Sura

Third and fourth Raka is the 4 tasbeeh
سبحان الله والحمد لله ولا اله الا الله والله اكبر

We have small child, he is very mischievous & he is behaving badly with everyone day by day. Kindly Suggest some dua or else to get relief from this

Saheefa sajadiya dua for children

Where does an individual stand if they believe someone to be right for them but her father believes someone else is right for her and psychologically pressurises her marriage to his chosen person?

You marry the one you want. Marriage is a life choice you make not your father.

How to gain concentration towards Allah to get success?

By increasing Marifa

In Surah Yousuf, it’s written that 11 stars and sun and the moon will do sajda infront of Prophet Yousuf. Why did Allah do this because we all do sajda to one and only Allah. What is the reason behind this sajda and the main thing is that the sun was our prophet Yaqub, why did he do sajda?

It is a metaphor to show the greatness of Yusuf and the greatness of his father, mother and brothers as well.

1) My question is about luck, is it true that our luck is written on our hands and forehead . I’ve heard many people saying that having small forehead means no money, is it true or everything is based on hardwork and determination?

2) As I am a student and planning for higher studies which is very difficult, people say ‘if you plan before the time comes it won’t work’ . So is true that I should stop planning and wait or plan the things on right time?

1) No that is not true. God decides how a persons life is, and their own work and determination. Size of forehead does not matter at all.

2) No it’s good to plan, but always rely on Allah. Things may not go as you planned, but planning is good.

I have suffered from a chronic illness which at the moment has no cure and is only getting worse. I wouldn’t be able to get married and have to support myself financially. I am planning on buying a house to put in rent and get an income from it. However while saving for it hajj would become wajib on me. Would I have to do Hajj first and then come back and save for my house?
(side note due to my health condition performing hajj would be very difficult for me)

No, hajj is only Wajib once you are fully capable. Having a home and income stability comes before hajj. It’s not just money that defines stability.

Can you please explain the process of choosing a ayatollah. (for kids)

I suggest following Sayed Sistani. His rules are very accessible and he is followed by the majority of the Shia. I say this because his website is in English and the rulings are easy to find. If the children come to the understanding that another scholar is more knowledgeable they can follow the other scholar.

Monins living in western countries pay 40% tax from their earnings. Does this exonerate them from Khumas obligations or not. If not, don’t you think asking for 20% more from a person who has already paid 40% of his earnings an injustice to him?

No, it does not exonerate them from tax and giving to a government is different from giving to the imam and Islamic cause. The 20 % is only for the surplus. If a person does not have any surplus they don’t have to pay anything.

In salah after surah fatiha we say Alhamdolillah and sunnis say ameen. Why the difference and what did the Prophet used to say? Alhamdolillah or ameen?

They consider the Fatiha as a dua, that is why they say Amin.
We have hadith which says say Alhamdulila after Fatiha.

Also, saying Amin is speaking in prayer and if it not done with intention of dua it can be considered as speaking in prayer which can invalidate the prayer.

Is it permissible to travel for Ziyarat e.g to Najaf and Kerbala during ramadhan for less then 10 days in each place? E.g. 1 week in Najaf and 1 week in Kerbala (from the UK). And if it is permissible, would we have to miss the fasts and repay later on or can we fast whilst over there?

Yes it is permissible to travel any halal travel and stay for less than ten days. You cannot fast if you are staying less than ten days. You would just have to make up the fast after Ramadan. No need to pay anything since you are excused for breaking the fast due to travel.

I have a question that I hope can be answered in order to strengthen my Iman. With how much confidence can we say that the Quran we read today is the Authentic Quran that was present in the time of the Prophet? I have heard that in the time of the Prophet dthumas, kasras, and fathas weren’t even in the Quran when it was revealed. I’m also aware that mainstream sunni Islam was spread through war, just as Christianity. Wouldn’t have rulers changed the holy texts to favor them and their actions like they did with sahih Bukhari. I’ve also heard that Imam Ali attempted to compile the Quran in correct order but was denied and to this date shias and sunnis compile the Quran in the same way. This information hinders my faith on the authenticity of the Quran.

We are sure that the Quran we have today is the same one that was revealed upon the prophet because the Quran was memorized during the time of prophet. Many Muslims had memorized the Quran including Imam Ali. It was passed on where thousands of Muslims memorized it, including the Imams of the Ahlulbayt.

The chances of the Quran being changed are very weak because the Quran was and is recited everyday by Muslims. Furthermore the Quran was written during and after the prophet. Yes the dialectical markings were added later but it was orally transmitted and memorized, the markings were added to help non- Arabs recite the Quran.

If there would have been a change to the Quran people would have noticed.

Do we have any narrations on Rasoolallah (saww) fighting in battles himself? I had always believed that the prophet SAWA would be at the front of the lines fighting or atleast in the middle of the battlefield fighting. However recently someone told me that while he (sawa) was present at the battles, he never actually fought in them or that he stayed in the back. I have trouble believing this as I’ve heard a hadith from Imam Ali as when Imam Hassan AS charged the enemy at Jamaal after Muhammad ibn Hanafiyya couldnt, where he said something along the lines of “that is because Muhammad is my son, and Hassan AS is the son of Rasoolallah SAWA” (paraphrasing I dont remember the exact hadith). Based on this I always assumed Rasoolallah SAWA was amongst the fiercest warriors but now I’m confused a little and would love clarification. I suppose theres multiple questions here so to simplify:

1. Was Rasoolallah SAWA in the front, middle or back of the battlefield?
2. Did Rasoolallah SAWA fight in the battles himself, or was he only there to command and instruct the army?
3. If Rasoolallah SAWA did fight, did he kill anyone?
4. If Rasoolallah SAWA wasnt actively fighting, did he atleast wield weapons to defend himself? (I feel like this last question is silly but someone said he never wielded a weapon)

Yes the prophet did participate in the battles and he would fight. He did not hide in the back, this was used to cover up the others who were hiding in the back. He did carry weapons to defend himself as well.

There is an opinion that says he did not personally kill anyone. He would fight without killing. This is perhaps due to his mercy.

When I was younger for years I would pray but I would recite all of my prayers in my head without moving my lips and making noise. I know this is not correct but does this mean I have to repeat al of these prayers? I never knew.

No if you did not know then it is okay.

A man falsely accused a woman of having lawful intercourse through mutah but was lying. He was wondering if this constitutes as qazaf one of the 7 major sins of accusing a chaste woman. He has obviously repented for this and told that it was a lie but wants to know if the sin was just lying or if it was this major sin of accusing a chaste woman. He was confused because technically the accusation wasn’t a sin but he knows that the lying was. Is this a major sin mentioned by the prophet?

Since she was in a temporary marriage it is not qazf, however it is a lie and lying is forbidden. Qazf, is accusing someone of committing a sin which is adultery or an illegitimate relationship

A man used to commit the crime of masturbation and when doing so would insert fingers/objects into his prostate for stimulation. He stopped this gross and big sin since but wants to know the extent of it. Is it the same sin as masturbation, or does it entail homosexuality and sodomy and are ther punishments for this? Also out of curiosity does watching homosexual imagery mean you committed homosexuality? How do you repent for these acts are there punishments (hudd etc)?

These are all considered sins, it falls under the category masturbation.

Looking at haraam whether it is men or women is also forbidden.

Repent by not going back to it.

‎السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُMy question is regarding Aqeedah/Aqaid. What is Aqeedah and why is it important. There are so many sects within Islam. Everyone believes in Allah (SWT) and RasoolUllah (S.A.W), everyone acknowledges that prayer, zakaat, hajj, fasting etc is obligatory.

So why is it important to know the importance of Aqeedah and research that it is correct if as a muslim are fulfilling your day to day obligations and Allah will judge you based on your actions.

Aqeeda is important because it is what you believe in. Your actions are a reflection of what you believe in. It composes the belief in God, Prophet, Day of Judgment. Etc. these are the foundations of faith and hence aqeeda is important.

I had a question regarding Mutah and unlawful relationship.

Parents from both sides will not agree to marriage due to cultural reasons which has led two people into a unlawful relationship, sinning and they are not virgins.

Therefore, they want to do Mutah to make their relationship halal but will not be able to get their parent’s permission just yet.

They will really appreciate any advice given regarding how to approach the situation and specifically on whether Mutah is possible without consent from parents.

According to sayed Sistani they cannot do a temporary marriage without the permission of the girls father. If she is independent and does not rely on her father in all cases and makes wise decisions in life that can be an exception. However when it comes to marriage you should try to seek your parents blessings as it is a major decision in life. If she does Muta with another guy without her parents permission this can potentially ruin her reputation. If her parents excuse is not justified she can have someone talk to them. Or she should do the permanent marriage and not the temporary, that way it is a solid relationship and chances of abuse would be less.

Can you suggest English books on the biographies of the Holy Prophet (s) and the Imams (a)?

The ones I’ve read so far are more “survey histories,” focusing on, for example Karbala, in the case of Imam Hussain (a) and contain lots of commentary on their personality (without much in the way of what happened through their lifetimes and how they handled their affairs). They are full of praise and low on content.

I am looking for actual histories, with the story of their lives. Events and their handling of the events. Their motivations and explanations. Their conversations with friend and foe alike etc. with references, of course. Like a modern biography written on, say, Napoleon or Churchill or even Steve Jobs.

Are there such books available in English? And in physical printed versions? I prefer reading physical, paper books. But I’ll take PDFs, if there isn’t another option.

There is a book which I enjoyed reading. It is written by a non-Muslim however well written.
The author is Lesley Hazelton. She had a book about the prophet, I believe the title is The First Muslim
And a second one which I enjoyed more was After the Prophet.

Al-Islam.org has some good books

Is watching polo match is halal?

I don’t see a problem with it.

1. Please can you provide us with authentic hadith about the oppression done to Bibi Fatimah (a.s) i.e fadak snatched away, being slapped (not sure if it’s true) being hit by the door. If possible can we please have authentic Shia hadith and Sunni hadith as well if available.

2.) Please also provide who her Oppressors were and were the oppressors close Companions of the Holy Prophet?

3.) In what other instances/ situations have these oppressors broken the Islamic law

4.) Were these oppressors there during the death of the Holy ProphetP and did they have any participation?

Many scholars have written full books about this or given full lectures.

https://youtu.be/V2CmU_0Jafo
https://youtu.be/GWuAsFJWqvk
https://youtu.be/GWuAsFJWqvk

Is it permissible to name children after angels?

Giving them names like Jibreel, Mikaeel, Malik and Rizwan?

Yes

1) Can we do muttah for the girl whose father and grandfather both died and she’s a virgin and she is not married?

2) If the girl has done muttah with other but not told her father and taken permission, does this means she has done Zina?

3) If she has done muta without her fathers or grandfathers permission, and the muttah time has ended and she wants to do muttah with other so does she have to take permission from her father or grandfather every time?

1) Her father and paternal grandfather are her Wali amr. If they are dead she can make her own decisions. However it is recommended for her to seek advice from other family members.

2) If she has done muta without her fathers permission, she would have done something wrong but it is not considered zina.

3) Yes she does

Recently I’ve noticed a change in attitude from a close friend of mine. He has become very bitter and hateful towards almost everyone. He does not say Salaam to anyone anymore, he’s very paranoid and distrustful of his brothers, and he just speaks about how he is angry at everyone including our Shia brothers. Is it better to leave him for now? Or to help him? I feel I should also note that before this shift in attitude he was very kind and happy and always joked and smiled.

Maybe he is going through personal issues. Give him his space but also let him know that you are available for him if he needs help

What is the meaning of Ulul Amr??

I am confused whether it refers to ahlulbayt Or not ?
Because the complete verse is telling something else

أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا أَطِيعُوا اللهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّ‌سُولَ وَأُولِي الْأَمْرِ‌ مِنكُمْ ۖ
""O you who have faith! Obey Allah and obey the Apostle and those vested with authority among you.""

Till here it is understood but the second part puts condituons

فَإِن تَنَازَعْتُمْ فِي شَيْءٍ فَرُ‌دُّوهُ إِلَى اللهِ وَالرَّ‌سُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ تُؤْمِنُونَ بِاللهِ وَالْيَوْمِ الْآخِرِ‌ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ خَيْرٌ‌ وَأَحْسَنُ تَأْوِيلً

""And if you dispute concerning anything, refer it to Allah and the Apostle, if you have faith in Allah and the Last Day. That is better and more favourable in outcome""

What does this means?? "If you dispute…Refer it to Allah and the apostle" ?

This indirectly means that the ulul amr can make mistakes and if we dispute regarding anything we should refer back to Allah and his apostle.

This means that if you are not sure who the Ulul amr are- refer to God and the prophet. Ulul amr means those who have authority- this is referring to those who God has given authority. Some understand it to mean any person of authority, however that is wrong, because that would mean God is ordering us to follow oppressors and people who are misguided. It means those appointed by Allah.

How does one pray Salatul Laylatul while laying down? Is there a certain technique for it or can one do it however he likes like pray with his finger?

You just point or use your eyes

People ask for the hadith which states that Prophet Muhammad swt. used to raise kittens and the favourite kitten was named moeza. Please tell me if that’s true and from where can I get that hadees?

I don’t think we have that hadith in our books.

We have hadith which state the the cat in the house is a blessing ( Baraka) and also that it is pure and one can do wudhu from a bowl it drank from, as opposed to other animals. There is a hadith which says it is from the people of the house, meaning it is pure.

My question relates to the oldest son of Imam Ja’far (عليه السلام). What is his stance in our books and how is he viewed? Is he in any sense responsible for the sect that exists today and is named after him? Also, I’m aware he died before his father, but what exactly was his cause of death?

Ismail the son of Imam Sadiq is praised and considered to be a devout believer. He is not to be blamed for the sect that emerged because it emerged after his death and he had nothing to do with it. The cause of his death is not really mentioned.

I have read a hadith that scholars are the best in the eyes of God in the time of occultation because without them we would have gone astray.

How can I become a scholar even though actually going to Iran to study is impossible for me. My family is dependant on me financially so I cant do that but I have got brothers and sisters that I can guide.

Does this suffice to earn me the status of a scholar in Gods eyes?

I understand becoming a real scholar is one that genuinely needs you to earn qualifications but what can I as a regular person do to achieve the same rewards?

You can take courses online. Many howzas offer online courses. You have to always seek knowledge, wherever you may be, the more knowledge you have the closer you will be to God.

How can we remove animosty and grudges from our heart even when the person we hate will continue to hurt us in the future.

I just don’t want to lose my good deeds due to resentment.

You are allowed to disassociate from people who are hurting you or will hurt you. If they are against your faith, you don’t have to love them.

Sayed Sistani says one should not disobey the laws of the land but he also says that you can use cracked apps of someone else has cracked them.

He also says that we can’t sell pirated material but we can make personal use of them.

I am very confused, is pirating movies and software permissible for someone living in the west?

We only intend to use them for personal use and we are not the ones to steal them, we just download from websites

You can use it but don’t sell it. If using it is considered breaking the law and it can get you in trouble than don’t use it either.

How active is Allah in our lives and world?

For example, is Allah the one who raises the prices of fuel and causes floods and droughts?

I understand that humans cause corruption but doesn’t Allah have full authority and nothing happens except that he allows it?

I want to know so I can be more God conscious and realize Gods presence in every situation

Allah is involved in our lives however the bad things that happen are a cause of other people. Allah has laws in this universe and He does not intervene every time someone does something bad. However Allah will reward and compensate the believers for everything they do and punish the non-believers for the bad they do. This life is a test. God is aware and watching but if He keeps intervening it won’t be a test.

I am young man but I truly regret not worshipping Allah from the beginning of my youth.

I understand I have lost an unimaginable amount of goodness in this world and the next because of this, at times I say to myself that I wish i could have restarted my life from the beginning just so i could worship Allah earlier.

Is there a way that I can redeem myself?

Yes you can by repenting and making up the prayers. It takes time but you need to be determined to do so.

What are the consequences of sinning?

I read a hadith where Imam Ali said that bad things that happen, like falling over on your face is a consequence of sins.
(paraphrasing to the best of my rememberance).

Does this mean that sins have immediate consequences in this world?

For example a thief steals and ultimately is robbed himself?

Yes, sins have consequences. Some that we notice, others that we don’t notice. However that hadith you mentioned is in fact a reality. The reason is to have us fear sins, so we may return to Allah.

A man told imam Ali i missed praying at night, imam Ali told him it’s because of something you must have done during the day.

Sometimes it’s dua not being answered. Sometimes it is getting hurt.

Can you please give a practical and guaranteed method by which one can get the absolute Pinnacle, top of the top place and rank in heaven.

I know the regular humans cannot reach the rank of Imams and Prophets but what can we do to reach the absolute highest position possible for us regular humans?

Is it to memorize entire Quran? Because all levels of Jannah are like verses in Quran?

Follow the life of the prophet and the Ahlulbayt. Try to emulate them. One part of it is Quran but there are many other parts.

What should someone do has wronged someone who is a stranger and cant find them anymore?

What should we do to be forgiven and not lose our good deeds to the person we wronged in qiyamah?

Do we pay sadaqah on their path?

Yes you can do good deeds on their behalf and ask Allah to forgive you and them.

If a person recites Ayatul Kursi after every namaz will that person go straight to heaven when they die or will he be held in barzakh until qiyamah?

It all depends on the intentions and other actions of a person.

My mother has family who hate her and only want money from her, this is not a assumption but rather something that is a fact.

Does my mum still have to keep relationships with them like calling once a year and doing her part in not severing ties of kinship or can my mum cut them off?

We can’t give them anymore money because they were stealing from us.

Since they are family it is haraam to cut off with them. If they are being disrespectful they will deal with the consequences of their actions. On the day of judgement God will ask you what you did. Helping out family is also a way to receive mercy. If you are able to help out, do it for God not for them. If you can’t help out then that is another issue.

My friends when non Muslims ask questions and suggest somethings, all they say is it’s haram in Islam and no other. And I feel like this always makes them away from Islam or scared from the religion, is saying haram for every of the haram things permissible, or can one say it in any other way?

If something is haraam it’s haraam. We should not be ashamed of our religion nor should we always try to appease others.

1) Is hadith unwan al basri authentic? If not, is it takeable and if so why?

2) If I were to narrate this hadith and If I do should I say the imam said or should I say the hadith says

1) It is mursal, meaning the chain is cut off. However generally speaking the content is accepted because it does not contradict other narrations.

2) Say it is narrated from the imam

I just wanted to know what Islam teaches us as to how to deal with toxic family members who deliberately hurt you with their words

You have to maintain ties with them, however you are not required to spend so much time with them.

I wanted to ask, at which year did the event of israa and miraj took place. Like I want to know in relation to the following events:
1. الدعوة الخاصة للاهل
2. الدعوة العامة
3. Birth of lady Fatima.

Did the event take place after or before each of the three events. Because based on some sources, they mention a year which comes after the birth of lady Fatima, but we have narrations which state that lady Fatima was formed from the food which the prophet ate in that event. Also, some source state that it was before الدعوة العامة but then we have narrations which depict the reaction of the non believers to that event.

There are multiple narrations. Some scholars say that it could have been several times and not just one incident.
Lady Fatima was born 5 years after bitha, and the narrations say she was conceived after that incident.

However other narrations suggest it was after year 5.
To say it was several times works according to both narrations.

I had a question regarding termination of pregnancy (abortion). I am in a relationship with a recently reverted. We are not married however are doing mutah. We had intercourse and she somehow fell pregnant after the condom ripped and she took the emergency contraception pill. We do not live together and are not financially stable enough to provide for a baby. We are still immature and don’t think we can provide enough or be good enough role models for a child, especially at such a young age. I was wondering what are the rulings on this?

Since the marriage was lawful and you are both consenting adults, you both made the decision to sleep with one another. It is haraam to terminate a pregnancy.

Both of you or who ever made the decision to terminate it should seek forgiveness from Allah.

Can you tell me methods that will increase my chances of allah responding to my duas?
Like is going the shrines of ahlulbayt (as) and asking them for to do the dua on my behlaf will that help?

Listen to this lecture I have a few days ago.
https://youtu.be/vriVhlI10zc

Yes one of the methods is going to places that Allah likes to be asked. Like a masjid or at the shrines of the prophet and imams.

Can I recite qadha of namaze wehshat e qabr if I was inform late about somebody’s death?

You should pay sadaqa on their behalf if it’s late.

I want to know that if I’m sharing my happines with good intentions but people thought that I am sharing it to feel them down. So have I commited any sin because they thought I am wrong but my intentions are pure?

No, it goes back to your intentions. However you have to try to not hurt the feelings of others.

My question is that my father in law and my sister and brother inlaw’s son are mehram for me or nonmehram?

Your father in law is mahram

Your brother in law and his son are not mahram.

Unless you are the aunt of the son then he would be mahram upon you

My father has hardly ever prayed more than a total of 2 months in his 75 year life span, and I’m sure my mom who prays every day has missed some prayers that she is yet to make up, my two older brothers don’t pray either.

Tthe question revolves around the death of my parents, when their time comes, I’m under the understanding that it is obligatory upon the eldest son to make up the prayers of the parents (my dad is sunni and my mom is shia, im personally shia but my oldest brother follows sunni ideology when he does pray), either by doing them himself or by hiring someone to make them up, but assuming both my brothers think that this is a far fetched idea, would I be able to shoulder that responsibility (paying for their prayers to be made up) and if I perform hajj for my father, or for my mother, or for both, does it still count towards me as well or does each hajj need to be performed on separate occasions in order that it reaches them?

Also a final question, which are the best acts of sadaqa jareyeh that can be done for parents and family members?

Yes you can pray on behalf of your parents even though you are not the oldest. You can hire someone to pray as well if you choose to do so.

For a Wajib hajj, you can only perform it on behalf of one person. Also in order for you to perform the hajj you need to have performed the hajj on behalf of yourself in a previous year. You can give money to someone to do the niyaba as well.

There are many acts of sadaqa, one can recite Quran, give charity, do righteous deeds and pray for parents. These are all good.

What should one do when encountering an Atheist ;should we answer hisher questions and how?

You should make sure you are empowered with knowledge before engaging with an atheist.

I have a question that may sound ignorant, I would like to start off by saying that my intentions are to learn and educate myself.

I’ve heard some Shias say that Imam Mahdi (as) can see us all. This then did not sit right with me because we are giving Imam Mahdi (AS) God like features. Allah SWT hears us and sees us. We are a population of billions and SubhanAllah He is able to hear, see and fulfill all of our duaas in matters of seconds if not even less , this of course is something a human cannot do. I understand that Imam Mahdi AS is an infallible human and can do things an ordinary human can not do, but is it as far as having such a powerful control that Allah SWT has? Is it true that Imam Mahdi can see us at all times like Allah SWT can? Or is it a myth or is there more to the situation than what I have heard?

Yes there is nothing wrong with believing that as long as we believe God gave him that knowledge. His knowledge is not independent of Allah, it is from Allah.

There are several verses in the Quran that allude to this meaning.

وَ رَسُولاً إِلى‏ بَنِي إِسْرائِيلَ أَنِّي قَدْ جِئْتُكُمْ بِآيَةٍ مِنْ رَبِّكُمْ أَنِّي أَخْلُقُ لَكُمْ مِنَ الطِّينِ كَهَيْئَةِ الطَّيْرِ فَأَنْفُخُ فِيهِ فَيَكُونُ طَيْراً بِإِذْنِ اللَّهِ وَ أُبْرِئُ الْأَكْمَهَ وَ الْأَبْرَصَ وَ أُحْيِ الْمَوْتى‏ بِإِذْنِ اللَّهِ وَ أُنَبِّئُكُمْ بِما تَأْكُلُونَ وَ ما تَدَّخِرُونَ فِي بُيُوتِكُمْ إِنَّ فِي ذلِكَ لَآيَةً لَكُمْ إِنْ كُنْتُمْ مُؤْمِنِينَ
Al-Imran 45 Jesus tells people I can tell you what you hide in your homes, raise the dead, cure the sick all by the permission of Allah.

If this is allowed for Jesus, it is definitely allowed for Imam Mahdi who is a savior for all mankind.

وَ قُلِ اعْمَلُوا فَسَيَرَى اللَّهُ عَمَلَكُمْ وَ رَسُولُهُ وَ الْمُؤْمِنُونَ وَ سَتُرَدُّونَ إِلى‏ عالِمِ الْغَيْبِ وَ الشَّهادَةِ فَيُنَبِّئُكُمْ بِما كُنْتُمْ تَعْمَلُونَ
Towba 105

This verse says do good deeds, God will see it, his prophet, and the believers.

The tafsir of believers are the imams of the Ahlulbayt.

So not only does the imam see our actions but the soul of the prophet according to the Quran.

If one of the names of Allah is "The Creator", does it mean we pre-exist in Allah’s thoughts? Will we ever stop existing? And does this make us eternal?

God is the creator, and we were created. That means there was a time we did not exist. We can’t be eternal if we did not exist at one point. If we remain it is because God has kept us. Independently we are nothing.

The case concerns a daughter who recently got married. She lives in Europe and her husband resides in Iraq. Her husband wants them to live in Iraq but her parents disapprove. What is the ruling here, does the daughter have to follow her parents decision or what is she ought to do? In what way can she convince them?

When she got married what was the agreement? If it was agreed upon that they live in Iraq from the beginning she has to go to Iraq with her husband. If the agreement that they live somewhere else, then they can stay. However generally speaking a wife should follow her husband.

Most of my duas do get accepted sooner or later but there is this one specific dua related to my marrige that I have been making since years now and it’s just not being accepted. I know there might be a right time but I just feel to get settled in my life but no matter what I do this dua is not being accepted.

You are still young and that dua will be answered too Inshallah. Sometimes it’s not the dua but it’s us that need to change. You have to look at things from all angles and try to find a solution. Inshallah you will get married and that dua will be answered as well.

When reciting Ziyarat al Ashura, is it necessary to pray a 2 unit prayer along with it? Or is this just something mustahhab?

It is not necessary. However the 2 Raka is recommended.

If someone who is not a public figure has shared something on their social media account which is vieweable by the general public (e.g. setting a facebook post to be public), is it considered backbiting if the post is reshared, taken screenshots of it or simply shown to other people to bring into attention the misdeeds of the person in the post without adding any false statements to it or misrepresenting the post?

If the post is viewable by the public, it means this person is doing whatever they are doing publicly, so they don’t care if it is shared.

However if it was private, or it is being shared by someone and other things are added which were not in the post, it would be backbiting.

A year ago, i was diagnosed with having migraines most likely due to hormonal changes.

I am prescribed 2 types of medication. One is longer acting and is taken daily to decrease the amount of headaches I have overall. The other medication is a very quick acting medication that is taken at the first signs of a "breakthrough" migraine. If I wait too long after the first signs, the medication becomes almost useless.

As for migraines during fasting, in this last year when I have fasted and these migraines have come on, I have powered through them all the way to Iftar, which I usually open with some tea, medication, and a date until I am able to eat.

My question is, I know that fasting when you are sick is impermissible. and I know that these migraines are a type of illness, but what I need to know is, how do I determine if I should break my fast due to the migraine or not?

I am in no way looking for a way out of offering my fasts as even though not fasting is permissible under certain circumstances, the Quran rightly says.."and that you fast is better for you if you know", so clearly the best outcome is to complete as many days of fasting as possible, in sha Allah.

You have to break your fast when you are sick and the pain becomes unbearable. If you know you will have pain or a doctor recommends you don’t fast you would be excused from fasting. However if the pain is bearable, you should try to fast and if it becomes too difficult You can break your fast. If you break the fast you would have to give the fidya, which is 3/4 if a kilo of food to the poor for each day (that is if you were not able to make it up within one year).

My advice is to practice the fast before the month of Ramadan. As in train your body to fast in rajab and Sha’baan. You have to try to wake up for suhur, have your tea or coffeee and maybe even take the pill. I know people who had this problem and they treat it this way by eating at suhur and starting the fast before the first day of Ramadan.

In India there is a trend to recite qawwalis one night before the marriage. People usually clap and also use a ‘tabla’ or dhol along with qawwali recitation. Is it allowed to use such ‘dhol’ since the sound it makes pleases the ears and makes the crowd to start clapping?

If it is an instrument that is used in haraam music, it is forbidden to use.

Should qunut be done on the 2nd and 4th rakaa of salah? Or just the 2nd? And what specific duas do you recommend?

It is recommended to do anytime. But typically it is fine after the second Raka

1) Is the act of meditation an acceptable concept in Islam?

2) Is there anyway to meditate in accordance to the sunnah

1) Yes it is recommended

2) Yes, think about God. Go over your sins and hold yourself accountable.

Why is it considered sad that Imam Hussain did not get a kafan?

Because he was buried without a kafan. Even in death he was oppressed.

1) I am from Europe and I will travel to Toronto, Canada this summer for a period of 12 weeks for an internship. Will Toronto become like my residence during this period ?

2) For exemple, if during these 12 weeks, I travel to Montreal during a week end and then come back to Toronto, without knowing if I will stay in Toronto another 10 days without making another trip, should I pray full or qasr ?

Also, as cities in north America are very big, I am considered to be a traveler when I go beyond 22km from my housing, even though I am still in Toronto? If not, how how am I supposed to calculate that ?

1) If you are not staying for ten days straight you pray Qasr. You start counting from the end of the city.

2) Then you pray Qasr, you have 30 days to make up your mind.

Why do we have to worship God ?
Of course, it is natural to be thankful for everything He did for us. But fact is that we did not choose to come into being, so why are we threatened with hell if we do not pray for exemple ? Why did Allah destroyed so many cities which refused devotion ?

In short, what is the philosophy being the obligation of worship?

Worshipping God is for our own good. We benefit when we worship God. Even if we did not choose to be here, our intellect tells us to protect ourselves and remove any harm that may come our way. When we worship we are protecting self in this life and in the afterlife. We are putting our soul in a state of comfort by fulfilling our duties to our Creator.

Is it possible for a man to give the mahr of his temporary wife out in charity, as per her instruction of course, instead of giving it to her directly?

If she approves of that there is no problem. She should not feel pressured to allow.

Is fermentation procedure things are halal or haram?

Not everything that is fermented becomes haraam.

I heard that the earlier source of the tafseer of “al kawthar” being about Fatima al Zahra was Fakhr al Din al Razi (Sunni) but do we have earlier shia sources, ahadith, tafseer that show that it is shia interpretation?

Scholars of tafsir mention a hadith from Ibn Abbas- in which he says one of the pagans used to call the prophet Abtar - then the Quran says your enemies are abtar.

Fakhr al-Razi says it is the progeny of the prophet. Other scholars have understood it differently.

However just the hadith of Ibn Abbas is clear to understand that the reference is to lady Fatima.

The fact that a Sunni is narrating a hadith in praise of Lady Fatima makes it greater in proof. We prove the Imama and greatness of Ahlulbayt from their books. There is no issue with that. This is admission from them, so it can be accepted.

Do you have sources that indicate that the Sayida Zainab was in fact buried in Syria? Which sources point to her burial in Egypt and which point to Syria?

Sayed Mohammad Kadhim Qazwini has a book (Fatima from the cradle to the grave) he addresses this issue thoroughly and gives both opinions. I believe the book was translated into English as well. You can find the PDF in Arabic online.

I want to ask about this issue: believing that if something bad happened to someone it’s because of their previous or recent sins, is this way of thinking aligned with Shia Islam, it feels like it’s a painful way of thinking but I’m not sure if Allah would punish us in this world directly after a sin. Do we have any ahadith in our books on this topic?

Yes we have several verses in the Quran and hadith from the Imams that say the suffering we see in this world is a consequence of our own actions. Sins do have impacts on our lives, our spirits and our physical being is impacted by the way we live our lives.

Quran 2:225
Quran 2:225
Quran 30:41

Those who don’t follow Ahlul Bayt (as) what will happen to them on the day of judgement? Will they still be considered to have lived their lives as Muslim?

Yes they are still Muslim, it depends on whether they ignored the Ahlulbayt on knowledge or ignorance. God will judge them.

Both of my parents have fallen into great sins and I’m very worried. My mom has seeked help of a magician to send jinn to her enemy even though I told her that it’s haram and takes one out of Islam and my father does not pray and many other sins have been committed by both of them. My questions are:

1- Are my parents both still Muslims? Especially my mom since she sought the help of a magician and even my dad who doesn’t pray

2- if I ask Allah (SWT) in my dua show them both guidance, then will that have any effect on them? Will Allah guide them if their child prays for them?

Yes they are Muslim as long as they say the Shahada.
Yes you can ask Allah to guide them, you should also continue to enjoin the good and forbid the evil.

Can we ask Allah (SWT) not to test us when making dua?

Everyone is tested. Test can be a good thing, because that’s how you gain paradise and elevate in ranks. You should ask Allah not to test you with a test that you would fail in.

Is it permissible to become a real estate agent or start your own real estate brokerage if we don’t deal with any mortgage or riba and only assist in the signing process?

Yes there is no problem with that.

I know that taking a riba-based loan with the intention of not paying the interest for situations where we are forced is permitted but does the same apply if one wishes to start his own business in the west (with the intention of benefiting his family & others) and cannot do so without taking a riba-based loan keeping in mind that he can easily live his entire life working a job instead?

Yes

In shia islam we believe a girl needs to wear hijab at 9 year old because she becomes baaligh. However I think its more logical that she becomes baaligh when her menstruation starts, because there are ahadith that says this. Does this mean she becomes baaligh once her menstruation starts? Also most of the time a 9 year old has the body of child, changes happen usually around 12/13, so if becoming baaligh is when your body starts to change its more logical to me.

This is a disputed issue amongst scholars. Although the majority of the scholars say a girl becomes mukalaf at age 9, there are some scholars like Shaykh Ishaq Fayadh and Sayed Taqi Modaressi and some others who say she becomes mukalaf at 13.

I need historical references/books of those companions of the Holy Prophet especially after his demise with regard to Imam Ali (as) Caliphate.
For instance, I learnt that Anas ibn Maliq had no good ending, for not being a witness to Imam Ali in respect of Imamate vis Imam Ali’s (as) curse on him.

Read this book

https://www.al-islam.org/tags/companions

For as long as i could remember i’ve had the problem of not being able to lower my gaze online and searching up and indulging haram content. I’ve tried many things, reached out to friends, to keep myself accountable read hadiths on the matter, tried to increase my dhikr in Allah. When I do the sin, I seek tawbeh and try not to do it again. I’ve even blocked the content on my phone but i still find ways around so I ask you. What is the best thing to do in this situation to remove this sin from my life?

You have to repent to Allah.
Keep yourself occupied. Don’t treat the act lightly. Make consequences for yourself each time you sin, for example fasting for 3 days. That way you would think twice before committing anything.
Don’t sit alone.
Ask Allah for guidance and help.

Is the Hadith regarding conception on the start, middle and end of the month as well as it’s consequences authentic?

Yes there are some days that should be avoided and some days recommended.

I’m very much into traditional menswear, but it uses a lot of silk.

Can we wear silk blended with other fibres like cotton, linen and wool?

If it is blended you can wear it

I am a creative person and have a decent collection of art books, but a few of them contain art works are have nudity, especially that of women.
Should I get rid of these books?

Looking at the body of a female with lust is haraam.

Would you advice doing mutah before a permanent marriage?

It depends on the circumstances of the relationship. Some cultures accept it others don’t . This is a personal decision you have to make.

I know that generally we are not supposed to share sins with others but are we allowed to do it in a way that can help others. For example, if I struggle with an addiction can I share the ways I overcame that issue. I feel that sharing personal stories and experiences can really be beneficial in helping others.

Yes that is allowed as long as it is not encouraging others to commit the same sin. If someone looks up to you and you tell them you used to commit a particular sin, this person will see that it is okay for him to commit that sin and repent later. You should always make it seem as if someone committed this sin and not yourself.

Should we believe in stones and stars?

I have a ring with a moh e najaf stone in it, can I wear it and what beleif should I have? and can it be worn in the left hand?

It is recommended to wear a ring in the right hand as it is the sign of the Shia. It is not haraam to wear it in the left hand.
The ring by itself does not have any power. It is only God who has power.

Sometimes on a sajdagah, a layer is formed due to repitition of prostration and it darkens. is namaz valid on such sajdagahs?

Yes generally it is okay. If you feel that this layer is too thick and you are not doing sujud on the soil anymore but on that layer you should clean it or change it

Is it permissible to pray in clothes that are torn or with holes? Also how big should the tear/hole be in order to invalidate the prayer of at all holes invalidates prayer.

Holes in clothes do not invalidate the prayer. If you’re a man you just need to cover your private parts. A female should cover her body with the exception of face and hands. She can wear something above ripped clothes.

Is it permissible to use mushrooms as a psychedelic?
If it’s not, can you tell me why? As it’s not harmful for the body and is even considered a possible treatment for mental health issues (because of the substance psylocybin).

If it is an intoxicant, it is haraam to use. If it just relaxes a person without taking away the ability to make sound decisions it would be okay.

If it is used as a medication it would be okay regardless. However for recreational reasons, it would be haraam if it takes away the intellect.

Do I have to remove sunscreen from my face before making Wudhu? I have seen a video showing that water alone doesn’t remove sunscreen from the face, so does this count as a barrier which would make wudhu invalid?

If there is a thick layer of oil on your face which is water resistant you would have to remove it before doing wudhu. If you believe the water reaches the face you are okay.

What if we're living in a household where we have to open our fasts according to the Sunni iftar times, 10mins earlier that is. Will it be considered as breaking the fast? If yes, then what to do in this situation?
I would like to mention that my mum belongs to the Shia fiqqa and so do I, unlike my dad who's from the Sunni fiqqa. And it's because of him that I can't carry on my fast till our actual time. I because of my dad's restrictions, have to open my fast with him as soon as the Azaan is said. Although I am an adult myself but I can't defy him and go against what he says. I want tp know if my fast is considered incomplete if I do this. And how can I correct this? I've been fasting this way for more than 10 years now, and do I do qaza roza ? Or do I give Kafara?

You have to continue the fast for another 15 minutes. You need to tell your father you are doing precaution.

1) I wanted to know is saying 'al hamdulilahi rabil aalameen' after surah fatiha mustahab on in jumah salah? Or could i say it while i am praying individually aswell?

2) Also when saying kadhalik allahu rabi after surah tawheed, is it better to say it once or three times?

1) Yes it’s always mustahab.

2) One time is enough

Scenario:
A person has set his yearly khums date for the last 10 days of Shahr ramadan of every year(from many years ago when he began paying khums) and he plans to go to hajj this coming year. He uses his income from this year to pay for his hajj trip as a lawful expense and pays it in full to his hajj group provider in rajab of this year (about 2 months before his khums date). He then pays his khums on his remaining income leftover for the year in shahr ramadan as he does every year.

Question:
Since hajj is a few months later in thil hijjah, is he liable to pay khums on the full expense of hajj as he will have paid for an expense that he was unable to use before his khums date? Obviously the group requests the full payment in advance of the trip to cover the expenses of the trip including visas, accommodation, preparations so my understanding is that khums is not liable on the hajj expense but I want to check with you as a qualified and respected scholar.

What he did is correct. He is not liable to pay Khums for the amount that he paid towards the hajj. Since the year before he has paid for the Khums, and his money towards the hajj was from money that Khums had been paid on. The hajj is valid and there is no issue. Khums is due on whatever is extra. The money he paid towards hajj was not with him and couldn’t have possibly been with him since he had to pay for the hajj expenses a couple of months before the hajj.

The question is if anyone has done what the people of hazrat Lut(a.s) did? Even had penetration and sodomy but now he is repenting before Allah, what if I apologize? Torment and punishment for him in the Hereafter (even he has repented), can he marry a woman? And if he gave up all his sins and tried to performall the obligations(wajibat), can he become a scholar if he wants to or not?

Yes if a person repents sincerely Allah will forgive. The best thing is to not talk about it and and bring it up and repent of that act. If a person repents, they can change their life.

My wife says that she divorced me by saying that saying “we are done” and that we have not spoken since then. It's been 2 months. I have been actively trying to reconcile.

She says that she does not need to ask for khula because according to her, I did not take care of her or do my responsibilities as a husband. She said that she does not need an Imam because she believes she has solid grounds to do so.

Is this valid? I know there is a method prescribed by Allah. What is the correct method?

This is not the correct method of divorce. She is still your wife.

Divorce is the hands of the husband, unless he gives her power of attorney to perform the divorce, or a jurist conducts the divorce if the husband is not fulfilling his duties. However the jurist must reach out to the husband before conducting the divorce.

From what you say it seems your wife has not done any of those and therefore the divorce is not valid.

I was wondering why Allah swt gave Pharaoh so many chances and why did Allah swt want him to believe? Is there a reason why he gave Pharaoh so many chances

Because Allah wanted a chance to test him and to show him mercy for some of the good he did. There is a hadith that says pharaoh used to feed people because he thought he was God. He kept feeding less and less, until the punishment came to him when he stopped feeding people.

When a person is getting closer to Allah swt will the shaytan come with thoughts? To get you away from Allah swt. I’ve been getting closer to my lord and the shaytan is always around trying to give me thoughts

Yes that’s when shaytan works the hardest to distract you. You have to be stronger and choose God over Satan.

Are there any narrations discussing the effects on an individual staying home for extended periods of time, as we have been during the lockdowns? Are there any advices on relieving these effects?

Muslims are encouraged to socialize and spend time with one another. Staying alone, eating alone and sleeping alone is makrooh. However for the cause of quarantining and preserving your life and the lives of others, there is no problem.

I was talking with my mother, and she was telling me about people who believe in Mother Nature etc…

So I was then thinking, and thoughts passed by, like “Mother Nature is my creator and I came from nature etc…”

But I still acknowledge Allah (swt) and have faith in Him, but these thoughts passed by, and they weren’t just thoughts, it’s as if they came from the heart, so did I commit Kufr/Shirk?

If not, can you give me a definition so that I know what it is please?

No that is not shirk. Shirk is associating a partner with God and believing in that. Just having thoughts is okay.

If during prayer, one thinks “I’m better than X” does it invalidate his prayer?

Or is showing off the prayer itself what invalidates it?

Prayer is valid, but when losing concentration in prayer, one loses the benefit of prayer.

If one stays in the shower for like 30mins or more, just standing under water and thinking and doing nothing, is it haram?

Wasting water is haraam. If that is regarded as wasting water it would be problematic.

I wanted to ask you, what Amal would you recommend? I’m in a situation where I want to do something but I may regret it later, and I want Allah (SWT) to do what’s best for me.

What would you recommend?

You can do the prayer of istikhara. That is making a decision to do something then praying 2 rakas and after the prayer ask Allah sincerely to give you what is best.

You can also make the decision of what you want to do after the 2 Raka prayer.

1) If one used to wash the left hand before the right hand, should he redo all of his prayers?

2) Can one wash the left hand before the right hand in a normal Wudhu, or should one always start with the right hand?

Yes washing the left before the right voids the wudhu he would have to make it up. If the wudhu is void the prayer will be void as well.

Can 2 non mahrams be in a car together alone without a third person?

If they’re driving on a road where there are other cars too, so they are surrounded by other people in other vehicles too, is it permissible?

If the atmosphere is one that would encourage them to fall in haraam no.

One was in his last rakaat, and a gas was about to come out, but it goes back in. So it goes out and in again.

And then there was a bit of odor.

Does it invalidate the prayer?

If there was odor yes.

Are these lies, truly lies?

Like if I was talking to someone, and I say:

“Yeah when this happened I was like: Ya Abbas what’s wrong with you”

But in reality when it had happened I hadn’t said “Ya Abbas”.

Does it count as a lie?

Do I go to the person and tell him that this was a lie?

If it is misleading and causes harm you should tell him it was a lie. If it is just an example then it is okay

If one was moving his eyes around and they land on a woman’s chest, this person then looks again to see if what he saw the first time was haram or not, does the second look count as a sin? Even if he’s intention was to verify what he saw, and it was without lust?

A person must not look at something would ignite his lust. He is to decide if that is a wrong look or not.

If one was saying what happened with him, and it includes saying something bad someone did does it count as ghiba?

For example, someone was telling me:

“I said this, and then he got angry and proceeded to take off the windows”

Does it count as Ghiba if one is saying what happened with him?

A description of events is not necessarily gheeba unless it’s something that happened in private and that person would not want to be exposed.

If involuntarily someone ejaculates without any touching but after having some natural sexual excitement, will it be considered masturbation and is it a sin?

No if it’s involuntary it is not a sin, however the person needs to do ghusl

I learned about Shiism from a young age and I was never taught about the Quran and Ahlul Bayt. I was only 16 years old and my house hold was Sunni so when I told my family they started yelling at me. I got uncomfortable and ever since that experience i’ve changed. I became insecure, lonely, sad and isolated. I would put on a fake personality in front of my friends and family. It is so severe to the point where I lost my friends because I wouldn’t want to talk and I would become isolated. I obviously finished high school, college but I’m so isolated that I just stay in my room most of the day. I love Allah and Ahlulbayt. The problem is that I was never able to practice what they taught, in fact, I don’t know what those practices are. I know what the Quran is. I was never given guidance when I figured out the truth of the Ahlulbayt. All I was given was negativity which discouraged me and put me in a state of isolation that drove me away from societal obligations.

You should introduce yourself to the Ahlulbayt and to the followers of the Ahlulbayt. If you are able to interact with fellow Shia, I would recommend you do that. Believers are encouraged to be together.

Can any human being who submits his will to Allah and the AhlulBayt by strictly going through trials and tribulations receive a miracle from Allah (SWT) which would make he or she infallible? If not, please explain where the Prophets and Imams say that they alone canonly be infallible? If I saw Prophet Muhammad during that time I would be in love with everything about him and I would ask how can I be infallible like him. Wouldn’t he tell me how to receive Allahs grace the way he did?

We cannot be infallible because we were not chosen by Allah. This is a position only for those chosen by Allah. You can be sinless if you choose to live that life. Infallibility is not only not committing sin, it’s being chosen by Allah.

Hadhrat Amina (AS) said that when the prophet Muhammad (SAW) was first born light shone from his face and filled the whole world. I have a couple of questions .

1) Since their was light shining from his face, did that allow people to see his face parts (mouth, eyes, ears etc) or were they not able because the light was so strong?

2) Was he able to see his own face? Or would he see light?

Yes they were able to see his face and he could see his face

Should I be reading the Quran in my head or reading it out loud? Whenever I read something out loud my parents tell me to “read in my head” I’m confused

You can read it but with a soft voice. It doesn’t have to be one or the other, either in the head or loud.

Do you have any information on how to begin a path of the spiritual wayfarer while alone in the west? I had found some texts written by Allamah Tabatabai but this seemed to be in regards to people with high level scholars at their disposal.

I recommend refraining from sins. If a person is indeed able to fully control all desires and block out Satan, they will reach high levels of spirituality. In addition to that, I would recommend doing some recommended acts in addition to the obligations. For example fasting when possible, doing the duas after each prayer.

Finally, I recommend seeking knowledge. The more Marifa we have of our religion, God, Quran, Prophet and Imams, our worship will carry more meaning and value.

I just wanted to ask, why did the Holy Prophet leave his will to the last minute to write it down? Ie when he asked for the pen and paper? Isn’t there a Hadith from the Holy Prophet or Imam Ali AS which says to sleep with you will under your pillow incase you die? The Holy Prophet knew when he was going to be martyred so why didn’t he write his will beforehand like straight after Ghadeer for example? Also, in sunni Hadith we hear that after everyone argued about the pen and paper the Holy prophet told them all to leave. Is that supported by Shia Hadith that that is what happened? And if so, doesn’t it raise the question why did the Holy prophet just let it go? If his will had been written then wouldn’t the ummah have been in less disarray now?

The Prophet had already told people what to do on the day of Ghadeer. His real will was with Imam Ali. This letter was for those people to hear from the Prophet. However they accused him of hallucinating and therefore he kicked them out. He did not continue because they had already questioned his mind and he wanted to show that his last interaction with them was kicking them out. The test for the Sahaba was not only the last minute. It was always. That was just one instance of it. The prophet is a messenger he had to make sure the message has reached everyone and his role is to remind people. So obviously on his deathbed he wanted to remind them. Even if he knew they will not accept, as a messenger he has a duty to deliver the message. That’s like saying a teacher knows the students will fail so he should not teach them. The fact that they disobeyed causes disunity not the prophet. Writing it down in their presence would have made it impossible for them to change the meaning or wording of the prophet. Imam Ali was not in that group or even if he was, they began to quarrel in the presence of RasulAllah, they wouldn’t have cared for Imam Ali being present or not. Imam Ali is the subject of the will. The prophet wanted those who he knows would cause fitna to listen to the will. If Imam ali tells them this is the will of the prophet and this is what he wanted they would reject him just as they did. There were other companions but they were overpowered by Umar. Abdulla Ibn abbas says he was present and he witnessed how the prophet was not allowed to write his will, hence he calls it a calamity. It can also mean that the prophet was reiterating what he had already said. In an oral culture things were not written down, even the Quran was initially just memorized and transferred orally, however the prophet had told them about Imam Ali on the day of Ghadeer and on the Thursday calamity, because his message was so important he asked for it to be written down? What should strengthen the Sunni belief is that the Sahaba did not let the prophet say what he wanted to say, whatever it may be they were in the wrong for not allowing him to speak his mind and accuse him of being delirious. As for appointing a successor, he clearly appointed imam ali on the day of Ghadeer. Whether he says it on his death bed or not is not an issue, he just wanted to reinforce what he had already told them. The prophets job is a reminder. انما انت مذكر

I was reading a book were it was mentioned the Gibrael had come to the Prophet (ص) saying that Allah has forgiven his “past and future laps” and I’ve seen similar hadiths which speak in the same manner. I was wondering why such things are said when our Prophet (ص) is never sins nor does he make mistakes

This is not jibrail, this is a verse in the Quran

لِيَغْفِرَ لَكَ اللَّهُ ما تَقَدَّمَ مِنْ ذَنْبِكَ وَ ما تَأَخَّرَ وَ يُتِمَّ نِعْمَتَهُ عَلَيْكَ وَ يَهْدِيَكَ صِراطاً مُسْتَقِيماً

Second verse of Surat al Fat’h

However the Ahlulbayt interpret this verse differently from the Sunni view. We believe the Prophets are infallible and inerrant.

The sins that are forgiven are the sins that were in the eyes of people. The people of Mecca viewed the prophet as a wrongdoer, magician, and other things. So after the conquest of Mecca when people joined Islam, that view that they had of the Prophet was removed.

1) What is your opinion on Basairud Darajaat? When it comes to reliability of the book itself

2) What your view is on the book Dalail Al Imamah?

3) What is the reliability of the book Mishkat Ul Anwar?

1) It is generally considered one of the reliable books.

2) it is a respected book. However our scholars analyze each hadith individually

3) We can’t give a blanket statement saying everything is right or everything is wrong. We measure what is said and judge based on that.

When it comes to the Imams (ع) and Prophet (ص) , do they not sin because they don’t want to or they don’t sin because they can’t?

They choose not to sin because they have knowledge and know the consequences of sinning.

How much is it permissible for a religious speaker to copy-paste a lecture from a senior scholar on the Majalis of Imam Hussain a.s? There are young speakers in our community who are straight away copy pasting lectures from senior Alims Word to Word. Is it permissible to sit on the mimbar memorizing a lecture from youtube and then delivering it?

Yes it is permissible. When the senior scholar delivers a lecture they are doing it to guide people and so others learn

1) Are men superior to women?

2) And if they are not why is it obligatory on a women to obey her husband and do everything he says within the boundaries of shariya?

1) In the eyes of God men and women are equal. However in terms of running a family there must be a balance and system of power so the family functions properly. Just as a government cannot have two presidents, a family cannot have two heads. The husband has specific duties and the wife has specific duties.

2) She controls matters of the house and the husband controls matters outside the house. This system creates a balance of power and a system that the marriage functions properly.

As for God, men and women are equal. Both have equal and same chance at attaining Gods satisfaction and entering into paradise.

If there’s a whole surah in Quran on women, why isn’t there a surah for men too?
And if Allah doesn’t have a gender why is he referred to "He" in the Quran?

1) The rulings in the Quran are generally for men and women unless specifically pointed out. Since there are some laws pertaining to women only there is a sura in the name of women.

2) God is referred to as He in the Quran not because God has a gender but because of the Arabic language which has a natural masculine gender. Some languages like French and Arabic have nouns as naturally masculine. English doesn’t have that natural masculine because it has It- as opposed to He. Whereas the Quran used the word هو which means He for gender or It for an object that is gender less (as it is used for God)

Is it permissible to lie in jest( when the other person knows we are lying and it is obvious that it’s a joke) ? for e.g someone asks "where does the sun rise from?" and we say "west" as sarcasm

Yes as long as it’s known that it is a joke or sarcastic

Is it permissible to discuss sexual matters with friends of the same gender if it doesn’t lead to sexual excitement?

Yes as long as the talk is appropriate.

Is it correct to say that girls who have reached the age of nine years are responsible for their actions and should be blamed for their sins? for e.g if a girl of nine years steals should be be held guilty for that? Because I’ve seen many girls of nine who are still not mature. Also if a boy of nine commits a sin he is not guilty but if a girl of nine years commits sin she is guilty and will be punished, so is this fair ? I know the age nine is the minimum age limit for puberty but if a girl is not mature at that age will she still be accountable?

Whether it is a boy or girl they are held responsible if they steal.

Puberty isn’t for common sense things. Puberty just means salaat and other obligations become Wajib.

A girl and boy have to both be praying by the time they are 7. According to the majority view it becomes Wajib for girls at 9 and boys when they go through puberty. They have to do it to the best of their ability.

1) Is using profanity simply as an exclamation a sin too, even if we don’t mean it?

2) Is it haraam to listen to profanity? What if it’s not causing moral corruption, would it still be haraam?

1) It goes against Islamic morals. Would you use it in front of a respected person? Most likely the answer is no. God wants you to be at your best behavior at all times.

2) One should abstain from profanity.

1) Is calling someone else god just for fun would be considered shirk even tho we don’t mean it? For e.g sometimes people say "I worship him" or addressing myths like "Zeus the god of sky"

2) Are all non Muslims committing shirk since they don’t believe in Allah? Will they be punished for that?

1) One should definitely avoid that kind of talk even if it is jokingly.

Sayings about what other people believe like the belief in Zeus is a different issue. You are saying what they are believing in not what you are believing.

2) Shirk is associating a partner with God. That means believing in other Gods. Anyone who fits in that category is a mushrik.

Why is there the system of kaffara when all our sins can be forgiven by repenting anyways?

To discipline the person not to commit the sin again. To make it more difficult to sin

However not all sins have Kafara. There are some, most notably is the breaking of the fast in Ramadan.

God can forgive the sins however one of the conditions for forgiving is sincerity. A person who is sincere will quickly take care of the kaffara.

The majority of the sins don’t have kafara. A person just does repentance with sincerity and God forgives.

We have many hadiths attributed to the Imams and the prophets and its such a blessing many have reached us today. I have a question about the narrator’s who attribute it to them. I know there is a book that confirms if there reliable or not. But how do we know if those are the exact words of the Imam for example in Al Kafi. Some sanads have 7, 8, or even 9 narrator’s. The words of the Imam had to go through many narrator’s to then be combiled in our books. How do we know if some narrator’s forgot something or understood it differently, or even some spelled words have different harakat and have a totally different meaning. How could they be the exact words attributed to the Imam.

Scholars of hadith in the field of rijal study several points to determine whether a hadith is authentic or not. First and foremost is the truthfulness of a narrator. The faith and truthfulness determines the reliability.

Scholars of hadith say that as long the narrator is reliable, it is okay if there is some variance in the wording. Scholars acknowledge that some of the narrators have recorded narrations in meaning not in wording, and as long as the narrator is deemed reliable the hadith is accepted.

How do I apply the knowledge that I have into practice

It takes patience, time and determination. When you know the value of something you will dedicate more effort for it.

I would like to ask about the prayers offered for ziyarat, such as for Ziyarat e Ashura. Can we say the same prayer for all the Ziyarats? For example, can we say the same prayer for the Ziyarat e Ashura, and Ziyarat e Warisa?

Yes you can.

Which is the best Quranic Tafseer Book?

There are several good ones. Al-amthal is good by Shaikh Nasir makarim and al-Mizan by Tabatabaie

In regards to Allah swt’s relationship with logic, do necessary truths like a=a, or God = God, exist in gods essence, or are they outside of Gods essence. The reason I ask is because I once heard that in high levels of irfaan that God=Logic. If the answer is no then does god have to follow logic making him limited? If yes then doesent this make god composed because he would be composed of different necessary truths.

We believe in Absolute truths that exist. Right is right and wrong is wrong. These concepts are not superficial and a creation in our minds.

These absolute truths do not limit God but rather make God complete since without these truths there would be oppression and God is not oppressive. Without them God would be ignorant and that is not the case with God. God would be unjust if He expects us to live with certain truths and He does not implement them.

The Quran says كتب على نفسه الرحمة

God made mercy incumbent upon Himself, since without it God wouldn’t be complete.

My question is that we sin and then repent, and if that sin is repeated after repentance. Then how to do toba again?

Do towba again, feel the guilt and plan on not doing it anymore. That attitude is much better than not feeling shame and continuing the wrong.

Recently, I came across a Facebook comment in which an idol worshipper (hindu) was telling a Muslim of how Muslims being hypocrites hates idol worshippers and at the same time worship a black block (ka’bah).
How do we explain that we actually don’t worship kabah?

The Kaba is the direction that we pray, we don’t worship the Kaba. It’s different with idol worshippers who worshipped and pray to the idols. Furthermore, the idols were something that people made up. They have no holiness other than people saying this is holy. The Kaba is the first masjid of worship and it’s a place designated by God.

How to create sincerity in worship and how to avoid hypocrisy?

Focus on prayer. Know that God is constantly watching. Know who you are worshipping, have your heart present during the worship.

Is the brother of Imam Ali (as), Jafar, called At-Tayyar and Abbas having wings means they had wings like how Angels were portrayed? Do we have narrations about it?
And is it wrong to draw them with wings?

When Jafars hands were cut off in the battle of Mu’ta, the prophet said Jafar will have wings in paradise so they called him Tayar.

Imams of Ahlulbayt said the same thing about Abbas because his hands were cut off while defending Imam Hussayn.

No it’s not wrong to draw a heavenly image of them in wings.

1) Is turning the Ring facing upward part of the Qunoot or any Rewards in it?

2) Can We say Bismallah In the Qunoot, or recite a Complete surah?

3) The Qunoot is not Wajib Correct?

4) Can the Qunoot be Said in a different language.

1) It is not haraam to turn the ring during the qunoot however it is not proven to be from one of the mustahab acts of Qunut or prayer. It can be done with the intention of raja’ almatloobiya, meaning you hope for it to be accepted.

2) Yes you can say bismillah, or recite anything however the purpose of Qunut is to ask God. If a sura or aya consists of dua that is better to recite.

3) The qunoot is not Wajib.

4) It can be said in a different language. However it is best to say a few words of Arabic first like reciting salawat then ask Allah in a different language to gain the thawab of the qunoot.

In which verses Allah has said about Hazrat Ali (a.s) giving zakaat in the state of Rukuh. And also the Shan e Nazool of Surah Kausar with reference or tafseer.

You can find your answers in these lectures

https://youtu.be/h5duIZcTvvg
https://youtu.be/9N3e7Fhv2fU
https://youtu.be/9N3e7Fhv2fU
https://youtu.be/1SbhCF8eIYY

When Hazrat Hurr changed his side to imam Hussain’s side, did EVERY sin he had done (even the unforgivable ones) were forgiven on the day of Ashura?

Yes when God forgives, He forgives all of the sins.

is the person who is doing black magic is still Muslim? And the one who is bearing it, what can he do?

It’s a sin to do it. However if they say Shahada they are Muslim.

The one who is bearing it should not believe in it. It’s haraam to believe in something other than God influencing your life. They should just do dua

Often times in the school cafeteria we would order cheese pizza, to stay halal, and next to it would the pepperoni (separated), and the cafeteria lady uses the same gloves to handle the cheese pizza as she uses to handle the pepperoni pizza, would eating the cheese pizza be consider halal even after knowing this?

In order to consider it najis you have to have certainty that it came in contact with a najis object, either the glove or the pepperoni or anything else.

How to instill the love of Holy Quran in children?
What to do if they are unwilling to learn Quran?

Have them listen to the Quran. When in the car, in the house, before they sleep. Give them reward for reciting the Quran.

I want to ask is it okay to comapre your deen with other mazahib to get more calrifications about Islam?

Yes there is no problem as long as you are taking your information from a scholar. You don’t want to do something that may end up confusing or misleading you.

I want to ask is there any hadith in Sunnis book in which it is written that Imam Mehdi عج was born and he will not born in future.

Yes there are some Sunni scholars that have documented that Imam Mahdi was born.

https://www.alrasd.net/arabic/islamicheritagee/1485

This link has a list of the scholars and what they have said.

Is it good to thank Allah for an unanswered dua, in the trust that he will answer it? To act as if it has already been given

One should always thank Allah, because whether it is answered or not God knows what’s best for us.

Since I moved I havent felt as spiritually healthy.
Do we accept the belief that some rooms/places have better "energies" while others dont?
And if so, what can one do to increase the energy in a room besides praying in it?

I don’t know about rooms but I do know there are places that are better to pray in, like a mosque or a place of worship.

As for in the home you can pick a room, remove the distractions in it like pictures. Turn off the television and any sound that my disturb your prayer. Pets should also not be in the room. The room should be clean. Some narrations say a filthy room angels don’t enter in, a room house with dogs and music as well.

If I am currently living at my parents house and my husband divorces me 1 time, then does my iddat have to be spent at my husbands house or at my parents house?

Legally it must be at his house. However if it is anywhere else it does not invalidate the divorce.

Some hair brushes/hair dryers contain bristles from animals. If I use it would I be able to pray or do wudhu with it?

The hair by itself from an animal is pure unless the animal is najis like a dog or pig. Using a brush is okay. The problem is with wearing the leather of an animal not slaughtered in the halal way. Otherwise just using a brush is okay as it is not worn during salaat.

I just wanted to enquire just as how the descendants the prophet and Imams are syeds, there are pashtun clans who’ve migrated from Afghanistan to Pakistan named Yusufzai and hashimkhel who are the descendants of prophet Yusuf. Does this make them Syeds as well?

Sayeds need to have a family tree to prove that they are sayed. Without a family tree it’s difficult to prove.

Most likely those people are not descendants of prophet Yusuf. If they are they need to have a family tree to prove it. They are not Sayeds either.

Recently I have found myself repeating Shahadat again and again with the thought that what if due to some thought I had became a kafir although I have absolutely no doubt in Allah being the only God and in his oneness and and the Prophethood of Prophet Muhammad and the Wilayat of Imam Ali but still time to time I feel the need to repeat Shahadat even if any thought hadn’t crossed my mind

It’s good to repeat the Shahada. We repeat it in prayer. However you should ignore these thoughts.

What is the status of torment after death ‘azab’ of suicide? Is it sin according to Ayat and Hadeeth? If yes, why is is a sin while no one willingly does this act but he does so when there is no option left behind for him or when he is mentally sick?

It is a sin to commit suicide. Islam will not say it’s halal because that would encourage many people to commit suicide. We believe that Allah is fair and will judge people with equality. If they are truly sick, and are not making proper decisions, Allah will only hold them accountable for what they know.

Is it haram to play simulation games where they depict cartoons/anime/not real as dressed provocatively or those games that depict sex (as anime only)?

One should not look at anything inappropriate

On what grounds can a wife refuse to have sex with her husband.

1)Can she refuse on the pretext of being tired or having headache?

2) Can she refuse for ‘not in the mood’?

1) If she has a health condition yes she can refuse. The husband should also respect that excuse just as he would like his health excuse to be accepted.

2) No

In the state of ehram for Umra, if one has used a sanitizer, is it ok?

If we had used one which has scent and realised later, what has to be done?

1) If it has scent it may invalidate the rule of not applying scent during Ihram. You have to use one that does not have a scent.

2) The kafara for using scent on purpose is slaughtering a sheep. Based on obligatory precaution according to sayed Sistani

My children want to read Harry Potter series. As the story revolves around magic and sorcery is it allowed to read them?

Reading them is okay as long as they do not believe in the magic.

Please share the name of authentic maqtal book which one can read.

https://www.al-islam.org/maqtal-al-husayn-sayyid-abd-al-razzaq-al-muqarram

1. How many times should one wash the urinary outlet with qalil water and with Kurr water to make it paak.

2. Is it sufficient to just pour water on the urinary outlet and to areas where the najasat has spread to make it paak, or does one have to use their hand to wipe while washing the najasat? Is it different if it’s kurr water or not

1) 2 times, it’s better 3 times for qaleel water

2) If the one is attached to kur, one spray is sufficient.
There is no need to use hands to wipe unless the najasat is visible

I want to ask about the tension problem. I over think too much about any problem and that makes me go psycho. What to do and what dua may you recommend to overcome tension?

I recommend reciting some of the duas in Saheefa Sajadiya.

Can I invest in banking stocks?
i have this question because banks take interest which is wrong.

Yes you can. Investing in the bank itself is not forbidden. Even taking a loan from a non/Muslim bank is allowed.

What characteristics would make a latmiya haraam to listen to?

If you feel that it makes you turn away from the spirit of remembrance of Imam Hussayn you should avoid it. The purpose of Latmiya is not for entertainment but to be inspired and to lament the martyrdom of Imam Hussayn.

What is the other meaning of the verse اضربوهن (Surah Nisa:34). There was a website shared to me a while ago where the author said the this verse has multiple meanings. Some has taken this meaning as beating and but there is another meaning to this verse. Can you explain the other meaning ?

The other meaning is Strike from them, meaning show your objection just as workers go on a strike. Another meaning is walk away, ضرب في الارض means travel in the land.

A husband is supposed to treat his wife with respect, care and love. However based on the meaning of hitting, those who choose that meaning say that it must be gentle where it is not intended to cause hurt or pain but it is intended to send a message. This is also only for the wife that is being disobedient and not providing the right of the man.

If the man does not provide the right of the lady, she can object to the jurist who will discipline and reprimand the husband.

I have bought a Fermented Korean red chilli paste whose ingredients mention that it contains alcohol to preserve freshness, but the amount of alcohol isn’t mentioned. Am I allowed to use this product for cooking?

It seems this is allowed as the alcohol is a byproduct of the fermentation. According to our scholars if it is a very small percentage and it is not meant for intoxication it is allowed to be used. If it’s a preservative and it is very little there is no problem.

One friend of mine is constantly arguing with me that asking for help from Mola Ali (as) is shirk. He keeps quoting Quran that in it Allah has constantly said that ask me and I’ll help you than why do Shias ask Ali as for help. How can I answer him from Quran as only needs answer from Quran.

My advice to you is to prove to him asking Prophet Muhammad is okay. Once you do that then move on to Imam Ali. Use this verse Nisa 64

وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَا مِن رَّسُولٍ إِلَّا لِيُطَاعَ بِإِذْنِ اللَّهِ ۚ وَلَوْ أَنَّهُمْ إِذ ظَّلَمُوا أَنفُسَهُمْ جَاءُوكَ فَاسْتَغْفَرُوا اللَّهَ وَاسْتَغْفَرَ لَهُمُ الرَّسُولُ لَوَجَدُوا اللَّهَ تَوَّابًا رَّحِيمًا (64)

Also, the fact that Allah tells us to pray in the Maqam of Ibrahim

Is Umrah more recommended or Ziyarat Of Karbala if I have the budget to go?

Both are recommended. In doing Umra, you visit RasulAllah which is the greatest ziyara

I’ve seen a scenario in my community where the man of the house doesn’t work but helps his wife with maintaing the house, taking kids to school, buying groceries etc.

My question is:
Has the man fulfilled his duty according to Islam, as a father and husband? (unable to work due to lack of qualifications and education)

If his wife is happy and he has an agreement with his wife that is okay.

I have some money saved up from student finance.
I have 3 questions:

1) Do I have to pay Khums from that money? (not currently working)

2) If a start working part-time or full time, do I have to pay Khums and add in the student finance saving as well as part of the savings?

3) Can I go on hajj with this student finance? Note: this money is a loan and has to be paid back to the government in the future.

1) If you have extra money left over after one year or on the day your Khums date passes you have to pay Khums on it. If it’s apart of the expenses then you spend it on the expenses. Khums is just on the surplus, that includes student financing money. My advice is that if it is surplus return it to the institution that gave you the money.

2) If you start working yes you pay for all that is extra

3) If you are in debt you can’t go to hajj according to Sayed Sistani

What will be a portion of zakat if one is running a livestock business? Minimum livestock for the eligibility of Zakat? If applicable then in what proportion?

Refer to this for more explanation

https://www.sistani.org/english/book/48/2285/

What are some ways someone can remember to say Bismillah before eating if they constantly forget?

Write it down on a note where your food is.

I think i’m a hypocrite and I don’t want to be one but it’s hard. I feel like I have a stone heart. Is there a way to help?

A hypocrite is someone who deep inside does not believe in faith and just shows to others that they believe.

If that’s the case you need to see why you don’t believe.

If you have a long thick beard (fist length), how do you wipe your face for wudhu? Would you wipe upto the cheek line or wipe the entire beard? (The sticks out from the chin)

You wipe all of it. However just the outer layer of the beard needs to be washed.

1) Could you please help me with the difference between rabbul alameen and maula e kainat?
2) Also, why do we call Imam Ali (as) ‘Maula e Kainat’. It will be of great help if you could educate me with some authentic hadith.

The difference between God and Imam Ali is that God is God and Imam Ali is the slave and servant of God. One is the worshipped the other is the worshipper.

Imam Ali is called that because he is the leader after the prophet. He is the leader of all.

1) What Is the definition of "wali" of a child?

2) What are his responsibilities

3) Why is mother not a wali of child?

1) Wali is the religious guardian.

2) They care for the well-being of the child. For a girl the father also oversees her marriage.

3) She can for the first few years if a child’s life.

And I was going through some hadeeths and I read Hameed Bin Muslim narrating that ‘ I counted 1900 Arrows, 12 spears, 5 axe and 3 Swords in the body of Hussain ع’ yet I believe that whatever he saw was right but is there any book reference for it

Check this

https://www.al-islam.org/revolution-imam-al-husayn-shaykh-muhammad-mahdi-shams-ad-din-al-amili/rites-remembrance-al-husayn#ii-public-rites-remembrance-al-husayn

I read this on social media ‘salaam upon that lady who’s cheeks colour kept changing from Shaam to Karbala and Karbala to shaam’. People tend to post this salaam regading bibi Sakina س – I would like to know if it is part of the ziyarat or not?

No it’s not from an actual ziyara.

I feel I have lost peace in my heart and mind – I have started reciting Quran and tahajjud but things are not getting better. I feel suffocated & frustrated. Is there any Amaal that can change impossible situations to possible? Why does it happen?

I recommend salaat alayl. Wake up just to pray to God. If you do that you will rebuild the spirituality.

There are several reasons:

1- We have shortcomings with God.
2- We are not asking correctly
3- We are asking for the wrong thing.
4- Our dua is accepted, just not at the time we want.

Is ghinna (music) worse than zinnah?

No.

Who was khalid bin waleed and who gave him the title sword of Allah?

Khalid Ibn alWaleed was a man who waged wars against the Prophet, then he converted to Islam.

He was named sword of Allah by Abu Bakr. In the Shia opinion, he carried out crimes and killed Muslims like Malik Ibn Nuwayra.

May I please request where I can find details on clothing requirement for women performing namaz. I’d particularly like to know if the top should be knee length and should the headscarf cover the entire chest or just till the lower neck?

If you are praying in your house and there is no stranger man, your body just has to be covered with the exception of your face and hands. The top can be above your knees, and the hijab can just be only up to the neck, as long as the shirt is covering your body.

If you are in public then the garment must be loose and not revealing and preferably up to the knees.

İ wanted to ask if İ can pray with long nails or not? İf it is permissible, do İ need to clean my nails before doing wudhu or my prayers will not be correct with long nails?

You can pray with long nails. It is important to keep clean always regardless of prayer or not.

I want to ask that if a person is not completely a male (have insufficient genitals) and cannot suffice his wife’s needs in future but he wants to marry because of the initial relationship with his future wife then what is the rule for him in this case?

He would have to let his future wife know before getting married. He can also seek medication which may increase testosterone levels.

I teach at one of the madrassah. Many of my kids have been asking about Yazid’s death. How he died? I know he died 3 years after the tragedy of Karbala but there is no mention how he died. Can you please share some light on this?

No one really knows exactly how he died. There are different opinions. Some say hunting accident, others he died drunk in his sleep

A male in heaven could be granted many houris, besides one primary wife. Though in Jannah, a woman would only desire one male companion. Though for a woman that was unmarried in this life, and granted Jannah she becomes married to a male companion. What is the name of this kind of creature? I know it’s not a "houri" or "male houri", as that is primarily female.

Probably al-Wildan al Mukhaladoon

I have mental health issues. I often feel tired, exhausted and unmotivated due to these conditions. These are very difficult for me. Especially since it’s hard for myself to be clean, I find it hard to do salah too, because it is very physical to me.

Sometimes I get the chance to do a few prayers in one or two days, but only out of the whole month. Though, how could I tell the difference of me being unable to do salah due to my medical/mental health conditions and the product of laziness? I feel that what I can’t do would be excused, and what I could do will not be excused. Though how could I tell if what I have is excusable or not?

While other obligations can be excused at times, there is no valid excuse to miss prayer. If you can’t pray standing you can sit, if you can’t sit you lay down.

Prayer is the most important obligation we have as Muslims and should never be missed.

I wanted to know that what was age of Imam Ali (as) when he married Hazrat Fatima (sa) and how much age difference was there between them when they married?

Imam Ali was about 25 years old. Lady Fatima was around 10 years old The marriage of Imam Ali and Lady Fatima took place in the second year after Hijra

1) On social media platforms, like Youtube, FB, IG, people upload short videos or Islamic posts, if some people of other sects comment like shia kafir and bad things about us, what should we do? should we stay quite or we can say something unlawful to them coz its hard to control after seeing some negative comments on our shia community..

If they say bad about us, will we be rewarded for it in akhira?

If you believe that you can change their mind then you can talk to them
politely by showing them the manners of Ahlulbayt. If you think they will not listen to you then it’s best to ignore them.

If they attacked you personally yes God will reward you for your patience.

Me and my husband went to meet one of our friend. He was studying astrology so he asked our date of birth then he said few thing about our past and future and said few things to change in lifestyle. After coming back from there, we followed for few days and we start feeling some difficulties.
Yesterday I come to know that it’s a sin In Islam. Earlier I didn’t know. Please tell me what should we do for forgiveness from Allah.

Repent to Allah and don’t believe that any of that has an impact on your life.

Is consumption of Duck halal?
If it so, are the conditions of slaughter similar to that of slaughtering meat & chicken?

Yes it’s halal and conditions are similar to chicken

I would like to know the logic or philosophy behind beard in islam

We don’t always know the exact reason behind each rule. Allah knows best. However perhaps it is to differentiate the looks between men and women and keep the men looking masculine.

Can I perform salatul ghufayla when I’m performing maghrib and Isha together after the time for maghrib has passed?

Yes.

I want to also ask, I am a convert and marrying cousins is not culturally acceptable. Am I required to treat my female cousins as non mahram?

You have to treat them as non-mahram, means you have to practice laws of hijab with them.

When I do ghusl, can it be part of a regular shower with soap and all if I make intention before or does it have to be after since I have to clean the semen and urine from my body first?

You can do ghusl while showering regularly with soap. However you just not forget the order of the ghusl. You have to remove any najasa while you are washing that part of the body.

This Ramadan was my first one and I broke the fast some days without valid excuse, only because fasting was very difficult this first time. I don’t remember how many days I broke the fast during the month.

1) Is it expiation required since it was my first Ramadan?

2) What do I do for expiation?

3) Do the poor have to be Muslims or can it be any?

4) Is it allowed to mix kafara? Like, if I fast two consecutive months and then only pay 500, or fast 4 months and pay 400. Or do I have to do completely one or the other?

1) Yes expiation is required since you are a Muslim and laws of Islam apply.

2) Try to estimate how many days you missed. You have to make up the days you missed and feed 60 poor people for each day missed on purpose without an excuse.

3) For the kafara most likely they have to be Muslim.

4) You can’t mix kafaras, but you can pay to feed people in poor countries where it is fairly cheaper.

1) The 4 extra nafilah rak’at that we may pray before dhur on Friday if we aren’t attending jummah, I’ve read that those are prayed before noon. Does that mean before the time of noon or before dhur calls? And does each 2 rak’at for nafilah prayers need separate intentioncor can we make the intention for all 8 or 12 etc when we start?

2) Do nafilah prayers have to be in Arabic? I know the obligatory prayers must be in Arabic. Are we also allowed to say supplication during qunoot in English even during the obligatory prayers? I found a translation of Al-Sahif Al-Sajjadiyya by Imam Ali Zayn al-Abidin (a.s.) and was wondering if it was permissible to use the English translation for my qunoot and dua?

3) Also, is it permissible to hold my phone for qunoot if I cannot remember a supplication I want to say?

4) Is it permissible for us to say a Dua during qunoot that requires sajdah? Are we allowed to prostrate or do we not prostrate or do we not say a Dua that requires prostration?

1) Before noon time. You can make intention for all at once or for each one.

2) No. The Quranic verses must be recited in Arabic. The Dua can be done in English.

3) Yes it’s permissible to hold your phone.

4) No

I converted to Islam as a sunni Muslim. Am I required to retake my shahada after realizing the truth about Imam Ali (A.S.)?

You just believe in the Ahlulbayt and follow their teachings.

I washed my prayer mat and it fell on the ground where my dad throw away petals and water after he is done using it for idol worshiping. I assume the mat was bit wet.
My question is should I use it as it is or would I have to purify it ?

If you don’t see anything najis you can consider it pure. The idol itself is not najis unless there is najasa on it

Why are tattoos permissible after there are so many Ahadith present that tattoos are haram?

Those narrations are understood to imply that it is makrooh (disliked) since there are narrations that allow it. So when we have a narration that allows and another that speak bad of it, we understand that it is makrooh.

Is there any book that can guide me on the rights of a wife?

https://www.al-islam.org/new-perspective-women-islam-fatma-saleh-sayyid-moustafa-al-qazwini

What are the guidelines for fasting and namaz time for people living at poles where day and night hours are extended beyond 20 hours. Can you please give your point of view on how to determine times of sehar and after and 5 prayers.

Different scholars have different views on this issue.

Sahar time is seconds before Fajr.

Fajr is the horizontal light that emerges out of the darkness. Before that is a vertical light which is called the False Fajr.

Zuhr is when the shadow of the sun disappears when you have a stick. Sometimes it may not totally disappear depending on where you are, however it is the moment it reaches its lowest and starts growing after.

Asr is about 4 minutes after Zuhr time. The first 4 minutes are dedicated for Zuhr only.

Maghrib is when the redness in the eastern horizon disappears.

Ishaa is about 3 minutes after maghrib. The first 3 minutes are exclusively for maghrib.

Ishaa prayer becomes Qazaa with midnight, which is the point between sunrise and sunset.

The midnight according to sayed Sistani is between fajr and sunset

While sayed Khoie says it is between sunrise and sunset

I have got two queries
1. If Imamat were to be part of belief (Usool e Deen) then why Allah
did not ask us explicitly to believe in Imamat as He has number of times asked us in Quran to believe in Allah, Rasool, Maad, Angles and the Books. We do not find Imamat any where in Quran mentioned alongwith the list of other Usool e Deen. We deduce it separately by
connecting bits and pieces from various ayats disregarding the context
and mostly rely on the Hadees to build the concept.

2. If Allah’s design was to have 12 successive Imams (from Aale
Rasool) after the last prophet to lead the Ummah then it means if
things had gone as per Allah’s initial design this world  would have
ended (Qiyamat) somewhere around 350 Hijra, maximum 100 years after the birth of Akhir uz Zamman, because its illogical to assume that
each Imam or the last one would have lived a life spreading over
thousands of years where other human beings and even the prophets
lived normal span of life, and if now this world is continuing to survive, its because we the humans because of our Irada o Ikhtiar did
not let the Imamat prevail.

1) Scholars divide the Usul al Din into 2 categories. There is one category that Islam relies upon, that is Towhid, Prophethood and belief in Judgement day. The other 2 beliefs (Adela, and Imamate) are Usul al Din of the Shia. It means a person with complete faith beliefs in those, however not believing in the latter two does not make someone not a Muslim.

However we have many hadith from the Imams of the Ahlulbayt that discuss the importance of the position of Imamate. The Imam is the one who guides to Allah.

Zurara narrates from Imam al Baqir that Islam was built upon 5
عَنْ زُرَارَةَ ، عَنْ الإمام محمد بن علي الباقر ( عليه السلام ) أنهُ قَالَ : " بُنِيَ الْإِسْلَامُ عَلَى خَمْسَةِ أَشْيَاءَ : عَلَى الصَّلَاةِ ، وَ الزَّكَاةِ ، وَ الْحَجِّ ، وَ الصَّوْمِ ، وَ الْوَلَايَةِ " .
قَالَ زُرَارَةُ فَقُلْتُ : وَ أَيُّ شَيْءٍ مِنْ ذَلِكَ أَفْضَلُ ؟
فَقَالَ : " الْوَلَايَةُ أَفْضَلُ ، لِأَنَّهَا مِفْتَاحُهُنَّ ، وَ الْوَالِي هُوَ الدَّلِيلُ عَلَيْهِنَّ

ما نودي بشيئ كما نودي بالولاية

The Imam says Islam was built upon 5, salaat, zakaat, hajj, sawm, and Wilaya. Then the Imam says the wilaya is the most important because the Imam guides people to all of the other acts of worship.

Furthermore the faith was complete on the day of Ghadeer after the appointment of Imam Ali.

2) We don’t really know that the world would have ended. Perhaps the Imams would have lived longer lives like Noah. Things happen for a reason, however the fact that life continues should not justify the disobedience of God.

How can you guide a brother to continue to live with his senior parents after his marriage? He seems to be having a problem with everything they do after his marriage.

He has to be patient with his parents. The Quran keeps instructing believers to care for and respect parents. Even if it’s difficult he must be patient with his parents.

Please guide me any Dua to make me habitual to continue prayers & spiritual religious excercise. I do prayers with depth of my heart but suddenly that process breaks usually without any reason & had long gap then

You have to focus on consistency and try to understand your faith more. Know the purpose behind worship and try to do the duas after each prayer.

1) Is sushi without alcoholic halal?

2) Sushi is having raw fish in it

1) If sushi does not have alcohol in it or anything else that is haraam it is permissible to consume.

2) It’s not haraam. Unless it causes harm to a person and that has not been proven.

I committed a big sin by purposely looking at a hijabis photos without her hijab on someone’s phone. I know this is a big sin and I repented, however I was wondering if I violated her rights (haqq Al nas) and must compensate by asking for forgiveness or something or is this between me and Allah?

No you should just repent and not repeat that. Also, you do not need to tell her.

My question is that what is the ruling for a non-virgin person who has not even been married yet, is it right to marry with him?

Yes it is.

At what age must I stop breastfeeding my healthy child. Am I allowed to go beyond 2 years of age. Can you point me to some Hadith or explanation as to why it is recommended to stop at two years?

There is no age where it becomes haraam to breastfeed the child, however it is recommended to stop at 2 years. If a child goes on further than 2 years it is allowed.
The verse in Quran says mothers suckle for 2 years

Is it permissible to send lanat on the killers of Imam Husayn (AS) during qunut, or is it not allowed during prayer?

Any dua is allowed during Qunut.

Can salaah be prayed on sand?

Yes.

Why Abdullah ibn Abbas was not in karbala, despite that he was a follower of Imam Ali and trusted by Imam Ali in Battle of Siffeen?
Was he a rightous companion?

Many of Bani Hashim did not attend karbala. They had their own excuses, some tried to tell Imam Hussayn not to go. Ibn Abbas is accepted as a righteous companion.

Is it a coincidence that out of all of Allah’s creations the greatest of them(the Ahlulbayt) happened to be in our universe
Like the ones Imam Al Sadiq mentions here

from Imam Sadiq (A):
"Perhaps you think God has not created a humanity other than you. No! I swear to God that He has created thousands upon thousands of mankinds and you are the last among them."
"Like this world there are 70,000 other planets with each of their peoples believing they are alone in the universe."
"I cannot say that there are human beings in other worlds, but I can say that there are living beings, whom we cannot see because of the great distance between us."
-Bihar al Anwar, vol 14, p 79

Everything is planned by God nothing is a coincidence. God chose for us to be in this realm

What do you say about reading Hadith Al Kisa? From what I heard is that the Hadith we read at majlis is very weak. If so then should we read it?

The actual event of Kisa is agreed upon by all Muslims, as it is narrated through Sunni chains as well. The wording of the hadith that we recite now may be questioned (not saying it's weak), however since the context is agreed upon we read it and there is no problem with it.

Many duas have not so strong narration. Many of the sermons of Imam Ali. However our scholars say that we are certain these are from the Infallible Imams for various reasons and therefore they are accepted.

Why did Allah let the Ka’bah be destroyed on several occasions shouldn’t he have protected it like he did against ashabal fil?

Perhaps the reason why Ashab al-Fil were destroyed was because they had a personal problem with the Kaba, while in the other cases Kaba was destroyed was an accident and not a purposeful intent to destroy the Kaba itself.

Someone I know only comes to me when they need something from me. If they don’t need my help then I am forgotten. How should I feel about this?

I will continue helping but I can’t help but feel sad that this is the case and I am without a doubt being used

Help them for the sake of Allah to the best of your capabilities

My question is regarding the “yellow shoes” and the rīwayats about it and it’s benefits such as increasing the rizq, etc. Are these Hadiths authentic or to be taken literally and are they walaei? (Most of the riwayat about it are at volume 6 of Usul Al Kafi)

I have seen some scholars wear yellow shoes in the Hawza.

We know for a fact that colors do have an impact on our moods and the energy we give off. Perhaps the Imam is trying to tell the companion to not wear black and instead wear yellow because it is a bright color which would improve the mood. I believe that if we can implement some if these orders, it wouldn’t hurt to do so.

Is there any evidence in Islam somehow from the derivation of Quran, Hadith, Aql, ijma that makes offensive jihad (i.e: Waging wars, participation in wars, doing wars) with others in ghayba since Iran is doing it I wanted to know if there is. Since I heard we should only stay in home and hide and only to defend ourselves.

Yes some scholars have allowed preemptive attack if it will save the Muslims or the oppressed. Sayed Khoie, Sayed Khomenie have allowed it. Even Sayed Sistani allowed the fighting of ISIS in Iraq.

If one’s parents are non-muslim, for eg Buddhists, can one do something for eg dig a well, and have the thawab given to the non-muslim parents? Will this act help them in any way? Or is it better to do it for Muslims instead (eg friends)

If they are monotheists and believe in God, then a person can ask God to forgive his parents. If they are idol worshippers no.

How does one stop procrastinating and watching excessive amount of TV shows?

Keep yourself occupied with something else that is good.

I have few questions:
1) When the Dajjal LA comes will there be a thing known as Dajjal LA system or will it be just Dajjal LA and his large followers?
2) Is it true that Mecca and Medina will be the only place safe from dajjal LA and that they can’t enter either of them? If this is true then what about his followers, will they be allowed to enter Mecca or Medina?
3) Is it haram to refuse COVID vaccine even if whole family states that you must get it?

1) Their are several theories about the Dajjal. Some say it is a person others say it is a system. Either way we have to focus on building our faith so that we can protect ourselves and our faith from the Dajjal.

2) The Dajjal system will make its way in Mecca and Madina as well. There won’t be a location that is secure from the Dajjal.

3) If refusing the covid vaccine will cause harm and anger to your parents then yes it becomes haraam to not take it. Furthermore it is the wise thing to do as the grand scholars are asking people to take it.

I work in the office and I do online business as well and in break or between my office work, I check my online business is that okay? And do I have to use my own internet for my business

As long as you are not interfering with your office work it is okay.

I had a questions regarding the timeline/history of religion. I have been told and upon very brief research that Islam is the youngest major religion in the world. I am a firm believe and have been all my life. Apparently Judaism was establish hundreds of years prior, as well as Christianity. I was watching a lecture and I’m pretty sure I heard that prophet Abraham pbuh was one of the monotheists. Is there any justification on what people were believing prior to prophet Muhammad pbuh and the Quran? The life of the prophets prior to Muhammad pbuh, like Musa and Abraham. Was it not mainly monotheists prior to Muhammad pbuh. Also, Judaism and Islam are extremely similar (80%), why is it that Islam was established centuries after.

Islam is regarded as a message that completed Judaism and Christianity. That is why it comes last. It is the final update.

All of the prophets who were sent by God had the same message, since the source was one.

Islam is a continuation of Judaism and Christianity because it builds upon what was already taught by the previous prophets. The Previous prophets told their people that there will be a prophet who will come at the end of times and he will complete the faith, referring to RasulAllah. This is why several tribes of Jews and Christians settled Arabia to anticipate the new prophet. When he came many accepted him and many rejected out of arrogance.

My question pertains to the nature of the Islamic Calender and why we use the lunar calender to decide when Shahr Ramadan begins. 

In the Holy Quran Allah swt states in multiple ayats to use the Sun and Moon to calculate the years and months (Surah Yunus verse 5 for example being one of the obvious ones). Why then do we as muslim just rely on the moon? Why not utilise both celestial beings for calculation, does Allah swt not state "The sun and the moon are (bound) by a (fixed) calculation." (5:55).

Even in Surah Kahf verse 25, "300 years [add] 9" can be see as 300 solar years and/or 309 lunar years as 300 solar years is equivalent to 309 lunar years. 

Furthermore, many of the Islamic months correspond to seasons (such a Rabi being Spring or Jumada signifying low water levels), why then would a month be called spring if it moves around the year and doesnt always correspond to spring and why would a month be called Jumada which comes right after Rabi’ al thani if it doesnt correspond to the low rainfall levels which come right after the end of spring in the middle east? 

In additon, in Surah Baqarah verse 185 which is actually talking about Ramadan, Allah swt states "Allah wants ease and not hardship for you so that you may complete the number of days required". How does a shifting ramadan which forces some people in the northern hemisphere to fast sometimes 18+ hour days account for this ayat? How is it fair some fast 12 hours and some fast 18 hours? How is it fair and merciful that in some poor countries such as Iraq and Pakistan many of those who fast end up dying of thirst because the shifting ramadan ends up in the middle of summer. Also how can someone who lives in a Scandinavian country in which several months in the year have 24 hour daylight fast? 

It only makes sense that shahr Ramadan as well as all the islamic months are fixed and dont shift. When using a lunisolar calender this is the case, every 32 months an additional month is added which aligns the months back to their seasons. This is similar to how the west adds an additional day every 4 years to February.  By doing this, shahr Ramadan aligns closely to the autumn equinox (around september) this rectifies all the issues stated above as all countries have similar length days (12 hours of daylight approximately), even the northern most cities in the world. This also makes more sense as around this time middle eastern countries start to cool down and days aren’t as hot.

There are so many more proofs even from hadiths and the quran relating to the battles of badr and yarmouk and the weather conditions on those days and how if we use the lunar calender they dont correspond but if we use the lunisolar calender they do correspond. 

We follow the way the Prophet told us to. Our scholars are not making this up on their own. All Muslim scholars agree that the Islamic calendar is a Lunar calendar.

There is a famous hadith of the Prophet- Fast when you sight the hilal and break the fast when you sight the hilal.

وعن سعد ، عن العباس بن موسى ، عن يونس بن عبدالرحمن ، عن أبي أيوب ابراهيم بن عثمان الخراز ، عن أبي عبدالله ( عليه السلام ) قال : قلت له : كم يجزي في رؤية الهلال ؟ فقال : إنّ شهر رمضان فريضة من فرائض الله فلا تؤدوا بالتظنّي ، وليس رؤية الهلال أن يقوم عدة فيقول واحد : قد رأيته ، ويقول الآخرون : لم نره ، إذا رآه واحد رآه مائة ، وإذا رآه مائة رآه ألف ، ولا يجزي في رؤية الهلال إذا لم يكن في السماء علة أقل من شهادة خمسين ، وإذا كانت في السماء علة قبلت شهادة رجلين يدخلان ويخرجان من مصر .
[ 13440 ] 11 ـ وبإسناده عن علي بن مهزيار ، عن محمد بن أبي عمير ، عن أبي أيوب (1) وحماد (2) ، عن محمد بن مسلم ، عن أبي جعفر ( عليه السلام ) قال : إذا رأيتم الهلال فصوموا ، وإذا رأيتموه فأفطروا ، وليس بالرأي ولا

The Quran states that the months are 12

إِنَّ عِدَّةَ الشُّهُورِ عِنْدَ اللَّهِ اثْنا عَشَرَ شَهْراً فِي كِتابِ اللَّهِ يَوْمَ خَلَقَ السَّماواتِ وَ الْأَرْضَ مِنْها أَرْبَعَةٌ حُرُمٌ ذلِكَ الدِّينُ الْقَيِّمُ فَلا تَظْلِمُوا فِيهِنَّ أَنْفُسَكُمْ وَ قاتِلُوا الْمُشْرِكِينَ كَافَّةً كَما يُقاتِلُونَكُمْ كَافَّةً وَ اعْلَمُوا أَنَّ اللَّهَ مَعَ الْمُتَّقِينَ

Yunus 5
هُوَ الَّذِي جَعَلَ الشَّمْسَ ضِياءً وَ الْقَمَرَ نُوراً وَ قَدَّرَهُ مَنازِلَ لِتَعْلَمُوا عَدَدَ السِّنِينَ وَ الْحِسابَ ما خَلَقَ اللَّهُ ذلِكَ إِلاَّ بِالْحَقِّ يُفَصِّلُ الْآياتِ لِقَوْمٍ يَعْلَمُونَ

He is the One who has made the sun a glow, and the moon a light, and determined for it stages, so that you may learn the number of the years, and the calculation (of time). Allah has not created all this but for a rightful purpose. He elaborates the signs for a people who understand.

Allah does talk about the sun however the Quran also talks about the moon. The verse says it’s through the moon you can calculate time.

The Earth revolves around the sun and it takes one full year. It’s easier to keep track of the months using the moon rather than the sun because that’s a much longer circle.

So it is actually more difficult to rely on the sun alone. Furthermore even the solar calendar has leap years and some months are 29 days others are 30 or 31

We have an easy system where a month is either 29 or 30 days.

As for the solar calendar making it difficult to fast, scholars say if someone is in extreme difficulty they can break their fast, they can also travel. People have been fasting for 1400 years, it hasn’t been that big of a probleM.

Can a Masum (as) offer Salah before a ghayr e masum?
All I wanna know about this is because I’m a Sunni converted to Shia and as far as I have learned a Masum can’t offer prayers before a ghayr e Masum. But I was kinda astonished because my Shia friend said that Imam Ali (as) offered namaz before Second Caliph

Kindly Clarify this issue

Sometimes the Imams would have to practice Taqiya, in order to preserve the order and preserve their life. Imam Ali would go to the masjid and pray behind the others sometimes for those reasons.

Did Imam Ali (as) forgive Zubair in Battle of Jamal when he(Zubair) turned back when Imam Ali (as) reminded him the Hadith of Rasool (saww) during battle of Uhad that(Zubair you will draw your sword against Ali);and sentenced his murderer the Hell.

Imam Ali was saddened that Zubair was killed. However Zubair did not truly repent. He just left the battlefield. If he had repented he would have joined the side of Imam Ali.

I just had two questions I wanted to ask you
1) If a woman who is a virgin wants a Muta’ah relationship but she doesn’t have any contact with her father at all, does the man need to get permission from her uncles or her brother? Or can she decide it for herself? Also is it necessary to go to a sheikh for Muta’ah?

2) Is protesting considered haraam? Example for black lives matter, and can you give me hadeeths or quranic verses for why or why not, please.

1) A virgin needs her father's permission or her grandfather (father's father). Those are the two that can give permission for marriage.

It is not necessary to go to a shaikh for the marriage contract, it can be done by the man and woman.

2) Protesting is not haraam. It can even be obligatory at times as enjoining the good and forbidding the evil is an obligatory act upon all Muslims.

I’m single parent. I’m looking after my daughter myself no support from my ex husband about my daughter. I’m also trying to save some money with the intention for my daughter’s future requirements. Please tell me according to Agha Khamenei if money is saved for my daughter’s requirements will it be khums free? Or I’ll have to pay khums on that?

If you give it to her Khums does not apply until she is a baligh. If you decide to keep it, You don’t need to pay the Khums if the difference is a few days from the Khums date. You cannot save it for years.

Here is the ruling from Sayed Khamenei

Q 882: Does khums apply to the money saved gradually intending to buy a house or other life necessities?
A: If, according to the financial status of the person, buying their life necessities depends on saving annual earnings and they decide to spend these savings to purchase such things within several days, then such savings are not subject to khums.

If my stone ring is big on my right ring finger, can I wear it on my index finger? I heard its makrouh. if its markouh, may i know why?

It is permissible to wear it on the index finger.

There is a hadith which Imam Sadiq says it’s makrooh to wear the ring in the pointer finger and the middle finger because it was the action of the people of Lott. Meaning it’s the acts of homosexuals.

Another hadith says don’t leave the ring finger without a ring.

فقد روي عن الصادق (عليه السلام) قال: قال رسول الله (صلى الله عليه وآله): أنهى أمتي عن التختم في السبابة والوسطى.

وروي عن النبي (صلى الله عليه وآله) أنه قال: يا علي لا تختم في السبابة والوسطى فإنه كان يتختم قوم لوط فيهما، ولا تعر الخنصر.

ومعنى لا تعر الخنصر : يعني لا تترك الخنصر عارياً بدون خاتم، يعني أمر محبب عند أهل البيت (عليهم السلام) التختم بالخنصر.

المصدر: وسائل الشيعة (آل البيت) - الحر العاملي - ج ٥ - الصفحة ٩٧

When Allah guided me, he showed me everything that was in my ذمة and alhamdulillah i am on the journey of taking them out of my ذمة. However, I am constantly scared and worrying so much that there is something else in my ذمة that I dont know of?

As long as you try your best to clear your conscious you should be okay. This is why it’s important to do istighfar everyday and ask Allah to forgive you for everything.

Can I have some advice as I am starting school soon, and I want to make this year a year full of all in that which pleases Allah, even if what im dealing with isn’t religious in school. So how do you make the most out of this school year? Also, our school has a masjid but our breaks are quite short and I’m not sure if we’re gonna have access to the masjid due to covid. What can i do therefore? Do I pray at home?

Seeking knowledge in itself is a form
Of worship. My advice is to focus, be dedicated in what you do and Inshallah the blessings will come from God.

As for prayer, try to be in the state of wudhu so when it is prayer time you can pray quickly. If it is at the masjid that’s good, otherwise try to pray in an empty classroom or some corner in the school.

I try to become very content with what I have, just like Hazrat Fatima (as) was but sometimes, I want something, but I don’t need it. I feel like I should be content with what i have. My question is, I know islam is a religion of love, but is it wrong to want something? Is it wrong to want something that you don’t need? As long as you are far from loving this dunya?

It is not wrong to want things. You just have to control what you want, try to be moderate in what you have and not waste too much. Too much attachment to this dunya brings us away from God, however that doesn’t mean we can’t be comfortable and enjoy the worldly blessings. One thing I do is if I buy something new, I give away something else. For example if you buy a shirt, give away an older shirt. That will make you always do something good.

Is it permissible to wish a happy birthday to a non mahram?

If it doesn’t cause fitna between them there is no problem

Which Dhikr or Dua / or what can I in General do If I have a hard heart that is sick and dark ?

لا اله الا انت سبحانك اني كنت من الظالمين

What amal or work we should do so that we can have no love for this worldly life and can focus on life after death. How to control on our nafs from loving this worldly desires

Follow the ways of Imam Ali and the Imams of Ahlulbayt.

Are there any highly mustahhab a‘mals one can do if one wants to do ziyarah?

Recite ziyarat Ashura everyday, Inshallah you will have the opportunity to visit in person.

Is it for a male to beautify himself, like making of eyebrows?

Keeping your self clean and maintaining yourself is okay. It’s haraam for a man to make himself look like women.

Some Muslims use a symbol of eye to get protection against evil eyes, is it allowed (jaaiz in Islam)?

The blue evil eye has no Islamic significance. It’s okay to have it as long as you don’t believe that it will change your life. It is God only that has an impact on your life. You can seek protection from God through dua.

1) Which ayat forbid us to eat food from non muslim?
2) What about veg food
3) They told us we could not eat wet food from kafirs as they are najis Is this reason is valid?
4) We can also eat the food offered by Chritisians and yahudi etc ehle kitab

1) Surah Anaam: 21 - The slaughtering must be from a Muslim and the name of God must be mentioned over the slaughter

2) That is okay from non Muslims. Just the meat must be slaughtered correctly by Muslims.

3) If they are idol worshippers they are considered najis, and if they touch the food while it is wet then it becomes najis as well. However if you did not see them touch the food or if they touched it with a spoon then you can consider it pure.

4) If it’s non-meat food yes you can. For meat it must be halal and from a Muslim.

is it permissable to use bbq grills that non halal meat has been cooked on?Is there a particular way to purify it, like leaving it in the sun for a few hours, or is the only way to purify it to wash and scrub all the stuck and charred material away?

You have to purify it. Wash it with water. You don’t need to remove all of the old charcoal. As long as you spray it with water. If you have reason to believe that the charcoal is najis you should remove it.

In al Kafi vol 1, page 83 we have a hadith of the Prophet (s) stating that prophets don’t leave dirhams or wealth in inheritance, but only knowledge.
As we know, it is a hadith used by Abu Bakr against Fatimah Zahra (as). Therefore I would like to know, what did the Prophet (s) really meant by stating that? What about the stick of Musa (as) and other objects belonging to previous prophets that are in possession of the Imams (as) one after the others, is it not material inheritance for example?

This hadith is not talking about materialistic belongings as the Quran is clear that they do leave behind material inheritance. This hadith is talking about the prophets not focusing on wealth but rather focusing on educating others.

I have been told by scholars that the washing machine cycle turns najis clothes into pure ones. However, can I add detergent into the cycle, or would this alter the pure water into mixed water, therefore not purifying the clothes?

Even if you use detergent, the process of washing machines is that first they wash with the detergent then they rinse away the detergent and the last few cycles are only water. In the last cycles the clothes and the full inside of the washing machine gets purified.

Can a man recite a surah of the Quran as a mahr for his wife in temporary or permanent marriage ?

If a man teaches a lady the Quran or a sura in the Quran that can be counted as Mahr. The Mahr has to have a monetary value according to the Urf, (the common understanding of people). If the thawab of a sura has monetary value it is accepted. If it doesn’t then he has to give her another dowry of an average Mahr

Does the stepfather (second husband of the mother) have any wilayah over the marriage issue of his stepdaughter? When the real father is alive but lives far away ?

No. Her real father and her fathers' father have wilaya only.

What are the obligatory duties of a lady towards her husband, kids and inlaws?

The duties of the wife towards her husband are
1- The right to intimacy
2- Not leaving the house without his permission (unless there is a legitimate excuse)
3- Not bringing anyone in the house without his permission
4- Not taking anything out of the house without his permission.

She does not have a duty to the in laws.

As for the kids, she has to care for them until they are 2. She is also the first teacher. She also is not responsible for feeding the kids, it is the husbands responsibility.

Also if she chooses to use birth control, she has the right to do so.

1) In the will of Imam e Hussain to Lady Zainab on the day of Ashura, the Imam instructed his sister not to tear her dress, do not scratch her face and do not lament. My question is we followers of Shia school of thought do Azadari, Tatbir and other rituals however Imam stopped his sister from doing this kind of mourning. Also, we have heard in Majaalis that after releasing of captives in Shaam, lady Zainab asked for a house where they wanted to mourn and conduct majaalis for her martyrs.

Please throw some light on this. In which context Imam stopped his sister and does this implement on us also?

2) Can you give me any reference or any hadith that tells if any Imam who did morning and lamentation in the remembrance of Imam e Hussain?

1) Scholars say that Imam Hussayn told his sister that because he did not want her to lament at the moment of his martyrdom. He wanted Sayeda Zainab to show strength so the enemies would not deem the Ahlulbayt as weak and humiliate them.

However after Ashura, there is no problem with mourning. We have many traditions that encourage people mourn Imam Hussayn.

2) All of the Imams did. We have several hadith that the Prophet lamented in sunni books.
Ahmad Ibn Hanbal narrates the hadith of Um Salamah.

As for the Imams, we have multiple hadith of Imam Sadiq, Imam Rida with Dibil al-Khuzai.

https://www.al-islam.org/revolution-imam-al-husayn-shaykh-muhammad-mahdi-shams-ad-din-al-amili/rites-remembrance-al-husayn#ii-public-rites-remembrance-al-husayn

This book is a good source

1) I live in hostel, and I’m really not good in making friends. Girls here are only concerned with gossips and i feel bad sometimes that I cannot somewhere fit in these people!
It’s getting so difficult for me to live alone, being no one’s priority!

2) Moreover is there anybook or anything that helps regarding living with people from knowledge of Ahlul bayt’s life

1) You have to try to find good friends that leave a positive impression on you. Even if it’s one friend that is better than many bad friends.

2) Secrets of Divine Love By A. Helwa

Is it permissible to become a real estate agent or start your own real estate brokerage if we don’t deal with any mortgage or riba and only assist in the signing process?

Yes there is no problem with that.

When Imam Mehdi arrives and establishes his government then will he resort to a more Capitalist or Socialist Islamic economy? I know Islamic Economics cannot be defined as either Capitalism or Socialism but I’m asking what will it be more aimed towards.

The Imam will resort to an Islamic system of governance, which is neither capitalism nor socialism. The Imam will end the world of poverty, while people will have abundance access to resources. The hadith states that people will not be interested in money as the Imam will reveal resources on earth which will make everyone live comfortably. This has not happened with capitalism, socialism, communism or any other system out there.

Resturant depot, a local wholesale food store in US, sells halal meat in bulk which is imported from Australia or New Zealand. The meat is labeled as “Halal” but there is no mention of “Zabiha”.
Almost all local restaurants buy meat from Restaurant Depot.
Is it permissible to use the meat where it is labeled “Halal” but without “Zabiha” label?

If you can be rest assured that it is coming from a Muslim source and the Muslim source gives the certificate that it is halal you can eat from it. The general rule is that as long as a Muslim informs you it is halal you can take their word. If you have reason to believe that they are untruthful then you should be careful.

Please tell me about the authenticity of belief of evil eye in our religion. And how to combat it like any dua or charity?
In subcontinent we call it “nazar” and remove it by chillies/egg/water. I am quite sure this way would not be islamic. Please guide me

Yes the evil eye does exist. The Prophet used to protect Imam Hassan and Imam Hussayn by reciting Surah Falaq and Naas. Chili and eggs don’t protect from evil eye, God protects through dua and Quran and sadaqa. Ayatul Kursi is good.

is it the son’s responsibility (even if he’s not the eldest) to live with his elderly parents? Or can he just help them financially in old age?

The son, whether oldest or youngest doesn’t matter, must fulfill the needs of the parents and be there for them. He does not need to live with them, however he needs to make sure the needs are met.

I performed a wajib ghusl and noticed after I was done I still had some makeup on my face even though I washed my face before ghusl. Do I need to repeat it?

If the makeup was thick enough to block the water from reaching your face, yes you need to make up the ghusl.

I am learning the Quran and my recitation is getting better. Sometimes, in family or friends gatherings with non-mahrams, they ask me to recite a surah or two for them. Is that okay to do as I am a woman?

Yes as long as you don’t make it sound like you are singing

If I prayed salah in the past without interest/with haste, do I have to pray it again?

If you prayed correctly you do not have to make it up.

I have some friends who are Sunni and we used to hang out sometimes so when their prayer times come, they stop the car near a masjid and get inside to pray their namaz like maghrib prayer. So I also pray in their masjid according to their maghrib time. Is it ok if i pray maghrib namaz with their maghrib time?

Our scholars say it is precaution to wait until the redness in the East has disappeared. That is about 15 minutes after sunset. If you see that it has disappeared then you can pray at that time.

Do you know what determines the religion that you are born?

There are many factors, however we believe that God tests the souls before they are born. The souls that show Iman end up being people with Iman.

This goes back to the topic of predestination or freewill. As Shias we believe that we were neither predestined nor do we have total free will.

There are some narrations referred to as حديث الطينة , the narrations of the soil which indicate that because God knew what kind of decisions we would make in the future (since Gods knowledge is not limited by time), He placed us in the category that we belong. That means if God knew I would be a Muslim he made me a Muslim. If he knew someone who reject it then He made this person far from it.

Before the creation took place the souls existed and each soul showed its own potential, some souls were pure others were not.

I don’t know if an English source on this, there are Arabic sources that discuss it under the topic of حديث الطينة

Is it correct to say that we worship Allah through Ahlebayt (A)?

They guide us to worship Allah. We should think of God and they are the servants of God.

A lot of IT consultants in US provide jobs by making out fake experience resumes. Like they will make my resume with 6-7 year of experience while I have none. They will market with that resume and also give interview on my behalf (acting as me). Once they clear the interview, will do the job from there. If I am stuck on any task the consultants will provide me with support. So my question is that will getting a job like this be right? Will the money be halal?

Lying is always forbidden and highly discouraged as it can mislead a company to hire the wrong individual.

However the income would be considered halal if the company did hire and one was performing the job correctly.

I am suffering from a migraine from last 4-5 year and I had done my medication too, but there does not seems any progress in my health, now it seems like it is uncurable for me? Is there something that I can recite and get cured of this pain?

It is narrated from Imam Baqir that you should wipe your hand on your head and say the above dua 7 times.

أعوذُ بالله الَّذي سَكَنَ لَهُ مافي البَرِّ وَ البَحْرِ وَ ما في السَّماواتِ وَ الارْضِ وَ هوَ السَّميعُ العَليمُ.

If someone used talk to na mahrams in university and work and that talk involved laughing and teasing each other. It was not a romatic talk but casual talking and joking. Now that person is ashamed and wants to repent. What should he do so that God accepts his repentance?

Say astaghfurallah and not do it again. Repentance is about feeling guilt and not doing the same act again

As a young Muslim in the west, I need advice as to how to lower my gaze from sexual temptations without monastizing myself- and more importantly, to learn how to secure a healthy marital relationship in the future.

Self accountability is the best way to control actions.

Many people who have no control of their desires do so because they don’t regard what they are doing as wrong and they don’t keep track of the sins. If a person begins to hold themselves accountable things would be very different.

Furthermore, remembrance of Allah during times of desire is also important. It will bring you away from the sins.

How to achieve Qalb e Saleem? How to begin this journey

By seeking knowledge about faith, meditation through salaat al-Layl, and forgiving others

Is there a Salah to pray for the infallible imams?
If yes how do I pray the Salah?

After ziyara of the Imams you can pray a 2 Raka prayer and gifting the reward to them.

My son likes to wear short pants while jogging، exercise etc…His pants are an inch above the knees. So is this allowed?

Yes it’s allowed.

1) I would like to know about rings and pendants which have Ayaats engraved on them, like we have rings which have Ayat engraved on the stone and there are some pendants which have Ayat ul Kursi etc. Does one have to be in Wudu for these to wear? Can I wear them even when I don’t have wudu? I am clean but without wudu?

2)Also, I would like to ask about stones. I’ve read that I am capricorn and my stone is Garnet (یاقوت) but to be honest, I do not believe that stones have any effect on our lives. But what is the best stone to wear? I have read Hadith about Aqeeq.

3) Is Hadeed a good stone to wear?

1) If you are not in wudhu you should not touch the Quranic verses. If it is hidden in the ring or in a place that you cannot touch easily it is okay to wear.

2) We have some hadith that says stones do have an impact the best of which is probably Aqeeq.

3) Hadeed is also good.

Was there ever a conversation between Imam Mohamed al Baqir as and Imam Hussain or Abu Dadhal at Karbala? Did Imam Mohamed al Baqir ever say anything to Yazid?

I have not seen that as he was a child and the Imam during that time was his father. Out of respect for his father he does not say anything.

Is our opinion about Zayd ibn Imam al Sajjad positive? Also what is his story?

Yes he is praised by Imam Sadiq. He revolted against the Umayyads and he was killed. Imam Sadiq says if he was successful he would have stayed with the Ahlulbayt and he was not calling people to follow him as opposed to the Ahlulbayt.

When wiping the head in wudhu, if a person accidentally wipes too far and one or more of his fingertips touch his forehead and thus the water of his fingertips mixes with the water of his forehead, does this make the wudhu invalid and in turn does he have to start his wudhu again or is it permissible to continue and wipe his feet?

That does not invalidate the wudhu. The face has already been washed and a part of the head just needs to be wiped. There is no issue with that.

Is it obligatory to turn off the water or leave the shower cubicle and come back in after washing my body before ghusl?

You don’t need to step aside and go back in. You make the intention and begin washing your head even if it’s wet.

My question is, am I able to move out in the pursuit of obtaining mental peace for me and my wife knowing that my mother would be upset eventually? Would me moving out displease Allah as an act of disobedience to parents?

You can move out. You have to just make sure your mom is pleased with you by visiting her and staying connected with her even if you are not living with her.

I decided to read ziyarat e ashura for 40 days so my wish can be fulfilled, right after 5 days the wish came true. I kept reading ziyarat e ashura to keep up the 40 days. However, yesterday i missed reading it, do you think i need to do 40 days all over again or can i give sadqa and finish it altogether?

If you did not say Wallah you will read it for 40 days you do not need to continue the reading as it is not Wajib. It was just a promise you made and it’s ok to break it as long as not bringing the name of God. It is recommended to complete the 40, even if you missed a day you can continue until you reach 40. Or you can read it twice in one day to catch up.

سؤالي هو في سورة الحشر لماذا بدأت بالفعل سبح وهو بصيغة الماضي (هل معناه ان التسبيح حدث وانتهى زمنه) ؟
بينما جاءالفعل (يسبح)بصيغة المضارع في آخر سورة الحشر فما هو الاختلاف بينهما؟

الجواب المفصل في هذا الرابط

https://www.islam4u.com/ar/shobahat/الفرق-بين-سبح-لله-،-ويسبح-لله

Sayyed, when one purifies something najis with qalil water, they say the seperated water is najis.

How do I purify something with qalil water? It’s an endless cycle no?

For example after one urinates, if he pours twice qalil water, the place touched by urine is pure, but the seperated water that comes off is najis, and then one has to wash all of area that are touched with this water.

Or for example if a place where one sits is najis, and he pours qalil water on it, same thing, the seperated water is najis too, so how do we use qalil water, when the seperated water is always going to be najis?

Should I just pour twice/once and forget about the seperated water?

You would have to suction the najis water, or remove it with a towel. It can be squeezed out, suctioned out with a machine or absorbed into a cloth. Then the next time you pour Qalil water it becomes pure

I wanted to ask you, I know how to prove The Prophet (PBUH) was sinless, but how do I proof he doesn’t forget, and he doesn’t do mistakes like we do, how do I prove his ultimate perfection?

We have two proofs.

1) One is through hadith, which there are several from the imams of Ahlulbayt.

2) There is also a logical argument which is if the prophet forgets then he would forget the Quran or other things. It would not make sense for God who is perfect to send someone who either sins or forgets and makes mistakes. If a teacher forgets and makes mistakes several times the students will also make mistakes.

Imam Amir-ul-Mu’mineen Ali [a] said

If a person calls another Sinner, Indecent, Kafir, Munafiq, or Donkey, he must be given thirty nine lashes.

Greater sins Vol 1, part 3, page 252; Mustadrakul Wasael.

Is this Hadith Sahih?

If one can’t remember how many times he called someone these terms how many lashes should he take?

The lashes are not up to people to decide. Whether this hadith is sahih or not, this applies to the Islamic jurist. It does not apply to normal people. Even if someone knows they said something like that, they should not try to apply this hadith to their lives. They can just say istighfar and not do it again.

I know this maybe a dumb question, but in this verse (19:26), it says:

"So eat and drink and refresh your eye; and if you meet any mortal, say: ‘Verily I have vowed a fast to the Beneficent (God), so never shall I speak today with any human being’.

I read the tafsir, and it said that, Prophet Jesus (PBUH) spoke and defended her chastity. But if she’s doing a silence fast, why does this verse say that if she meets a mortal she’ll say that she’s fasting. I know that Prophet Jesus (PBUH) talked and Lady Mariam (PBUH) didn’t but my question is why this verse says so.

She signaled to them that she is fasting through hand gestures. This was a common fast that was done before Islam. Zakariya also did it after God informed him he will have a child.

If someone gets jealous from something for like 1sec then he does istighfar, but this person didn’t act on his jealousy too. Like he didn’t do anything, but it happened between himself.

Does it count as a sin if you don’t act on it?

No it not a sin unless someone acts upon it.

I wanted to ask you, if you could give me advice or teach me how to untie knots in the heart, and how to purify the heart from everything.

Do istighfar as much as you can. Pray salaat alayl.

Something I’ve been contemplating a lot recently under the circumstances is riba and student loans. I am very passionate about economics and going to university

Riba is forbidden however there are ways to make the transactions by avoiding the haraam riba. There are ways to make it halal.

A) If you are taking a loan from the bank because you don’t have money for education or to buy a house there is no problem if it’s not from a Muslim owned bank.

You can consider the money you take as a gift given to you and the interest you pay is the transaction fee.

B) Or you can consider the money you take yours as it is given to you by a non-Muslim. Then in order to keep the house or whatever you are getting with the money you have to pay the mortgage.

C) You can also consider the money you are receiving as money going directly to the house. If you buy a house they don’t give you the money. They give it to the house seller. Then you just make payments to the bank as if you are a renter.Then you just make payments to the bank as if you are a renter.

I have just started trying to recite ziyarat ashura regularly, but I find its to long, and my reading in arabic isn’t great so it takes me a long time to get through the whole ziyaret. It especially takes long to recite the laan and salams 100 times each. I was wondering is there an easier/quicker way to recite the ziyarat at the start, when trying to learn it?

There is a shorter ziyarat. You can read that one and you can find it in the books of dua. It’s called Ziyara Ashura the shorter version. Also you do not have to recite all 100 salaams and La3n if you didn’t have time. Do what you can

I have read a few narrations/descriptions of how the Prophet (sawa) and the Imams of Ahlul Bayt (as) used to wear their hair. In some narrations I would see that their hair would be long, either up to the ends of their ear lobes or to their shoulders, and in some they would have a shaven head. I’m not sure as to which one is accurate, perhaps they could have done both during their lifetimes.

I want to follow the Sunnah as best as possible, so I ask what would be the recommended/mustahab length for hair for a male? My hair now goes past my ears and I would be willing to cut it if there’s a chance it will bring me closer to Allah SWT.

In the past it was the norm to grow hair longer. The prophet and Imams did also have that however they maintained it clean and tidy. When they perform the hajj they would shave it all off as it is Wajib for first timers and highly recommended for pilgrims after the first time.

There are certain things that were performed in the past because they were socially acceptable for men. Today they may give off a different impression. For example the long hair or the eye kohl which men used to practice. Today this may be regarded as imitating women. If that is the case then it becomes haraam and unacceptable. If the intention is purely to follow the Sunna of the prophet and there is no attempt to look like or imitate individuals whose values are against Islam then it is okay.

I need serious advice on what happens when you overdue it with ethical training. Here’s is an exerpt from Imam Khomeini’s book that explains what happened to me

If the young people do not treat themselves considerately and kindly, and if they do not meet the needs of (their) nature through lawful ways, they will be subject to a great danger, which cannot be compensated. The danger is that when one is too severe with his self and pulls the reins too hard, they will break off, and then the will gets out of control, and the accumulated natural needs and the sharp fires of desire, under unlimited pressure of austerity, burn out the whole kingdom.
If a sālik’s reins break off God forbid! Or an ascetic person becomes unable to control himself, he will fall so deep in a precipice that he can never see the face of rescue, nor can he ever return to the road of happiness and righteousness.

Wth istighfar and seeking nearness to God everything can be compensated. You just have to keep trying and not give up.

1) Today in the era of social media is it right for a female to do online majalis or any noha etc despite male scolars are present?

2) Is it right for a male to listen a female religious scolar if she is posting online videos ?

1) Yes women should also educate people as there is no problem with that.

2) Men can listen if the talk is appropriate and she is not changing her voice.