Maulana Sheikh Mohammed Al-Hilli

Maulana Sheikh Mohammed Al-Hilli
 
Age:
Location: London
Nationality: United Kingdom

Public QnA

I am a student in Germany, I recently got a part time internship opportunity in another state. I will be traveling frequently as my university and classes are in one state and my job in another and they are 400-300 km apart. As I will be working part time I will be 3-7 days there and then back to my home for where I am currently living, for the next 6 months. I have a student hostel in both the states. My question is what will be the ruling for my namaz and other faraiz and wajibaat when I will be traveling to the other state for work. Do I have to pray qasr namaz whenever I am in the new city and I would also like to know the rulings on my Fasts in Ramadan.

Please watch this

https://youtu.be/NpBnm0s2tLA

If you have any questions let us know

If you have hadith which are giving the same general message, are they considered متواتر معنوي mutawwatur ma’nawi? Can something which is mutawwatir ma’nawi be considered a Hujjah even if the hadiths are all weak? So Sunnis have a lot of hadith that tak about Imam Ali being a guide/leader but many are considered weak by their standards. Can they still be used as a Hujjah against them if they are muttawattir ma’nawi and why.

Yes indeed if the hadiths are saying the same thing this is one way of attaining confidence in the idea or concept or ruling discussed as being reliable by meaning

My husband passed away, so are my husbands sons from his previous marriage still mahram for me after his death?

They remain your mahrams

1) Does one have to pray zuhr if they missed some of the first Khutba of Jummah ?

2) Should one also pray zuhr for precautionary measures if the khutba is in a different language they don’t understand?

1) No if they missed khutba they can pray juma

2) It is not necessary

Is it permissible to recite Dua al Faraj in the Qunoot of Farz Namaz?

Yes it is permissible

Im wondering if going on hajj is wajib on me.
My situation is as follows:

I am married & mother of 2 children (5 & 3 years old) and I work full time. Alhamdulillah my salary is really good and I was wondering if hajj is wajib on me. The only problem is that my children are quite young and leaving them for a week or longer will be difficult for me. I’m not sure how this is seen islamically…

If there is a way in which someone reliable can look after your children then hajj is wajib and you should do it

However if you don’t have anyone or it causes you unbearable hardship if you go to hajj then you should wait until the opportunity arises to go without this difficulty

Does Islam have any explanation for the phenomenon of Deja vu? It’s the feeling that one has lived a certain moment before or remembers details about a moment that hasn’t happened yet. For example, if someone is walking down the street then thinks to themselves “I remember this, a cat is going to come around that corner any second now” and then a cat actually comes around the corner. Is this just some random brain trick or has this ever been explained before by the prophet or ahlul bayt? I’ve never heard of it ever discussed but I’m curious

I am not aware of it being discussed as a phenomenon for lay people. Yes for the friends of God they’re told of things by permission of Allah

If I come across an individual who doesn’t identify as their birth gender or any gender (so they ask to be referred to as they/them) what is the proper way to go about this? Do I still refer to them as he or she or do I call them based off of what they want? And how would I maintain the best mannerisms while navigating this?

Do what is best in protecting yourself from harm. If by calling them by they/them is supporting their claim then it should not be done. But if it’s a norm in society and not deemed support for this behaviour then it’s ok

If i am making up prayers on behalf of my deceased parent, or even on behalf of my own self, can i do this while sitting down?

No this is not allowed and it must be done as normal

If the wife is asking for a divorce and the husband will not divorce her can she apply for a khulaa divorce ?
If it’s a khulaa divorce, can the husband ask for a higher amount other than her mahr for her to pay ?

What if he’s emotionally and psychologically mistreating her and he won’t divorce her to the extent that she’s mentally ill , can the sharia divorce her instead ?

1) Yes she can ask for a divorce. Yes the husband can ask for more. A condition for khula is that she hates the husband

2) Yes she can ask the Marjie or his representative to conduct an investigation and issue a divorce

What should one do if they overpaid Khums?
Can they deduct that amount from their next year Khums calculation?

No. They should contact the office of the marajie and seek permission first

I recently saw on a social media platform, someone cursing Saddam Hussein, should I forbid it as taqqiyah?

I’ve read a hadith that says one who doesn’t perform taqiyyah and says something which leads to the murder of someone else will have his part of blood on The Day Of Judgement.

There is no need to forbid it

When discussing the supposed crucifixion of Nabi Isa (a) I’ve always heard the narrative that someone was made to resemble him and that person died on the cross, not Jesus. Recently I came across a video online that made me curious to see if this theory the person was stating was a valid Shia one as well, so I went onto Al-Islam.org and found an interview with Shaykh Muhammad jawad Cherri about his views on the interpretation of this event. Below I will leave the link to the page. To summarize briefly there’s another theory that doesn’t involve the divine miracle of changing a disciples appearance and having them die on the cross in jesus’ stead, rather the Jews did put Jesus on the cross but he didn’t die as a result and he was still alive when they buried him. Basically saying the Jews made a mistake proclaiming him dead. The interview explains the details much better than I could. I’ve also seen both interpretations of Quran chapter 4, verse 157. One translated verse says the verse says “ but another was made to resemble him” and the other doesn’t, I cannot read Arabic so go strictly based off of translation of the Quran. When I asked someone who speaks it fluently they said that it doesn’t include the part that says “but another was made to resemble him.” If that is the case then why do the majority of scholars accept that specific narrative? From hadith or other verses in the Quran?

Link to article : https://www.al-islam.org/inquiries-about-islam-shaykh-muhammad-jawad-chirri/where-islam-and-christianity-agree-and-differ

There is strong Hadith that stands alongside the Quran to highlight that isa (a) was not crucified and someone resembling him was. The theory you mentioned is a theory and it’s not substantiated

I have a question in regards to the birth of Bibi Fatima. Narrated by al-Mufaddal Ibn Amr on the authority of Imam Sadiq (as) in vol.1 of Al-Bihar by Al-Majlisi. It stated that 4 noble women helped with the birth of Bibi Fatima. These 4 being Mother Eve, Asiya Bint Muzahim, Kulthum, Musa’s sister and Maryam Bint Imran.

My question is following; is this narration authentic and is the book authentic? And secondly, how is it possible that the dead came back in living human forms to help with the birth?

Each narration is studied by its merit and chain of narrations.

It is possible for those who have died to come back according to some ulema, as we believe in Rajah (the return), and the Quran affirms that ppl who died did come back, such as Prophet Uzair, or those with Musa (a), or the animals slaughtered by Ibrahim (a).

Is it allowed to eat the meat from Ahmadis (those who believe that Mirza Ghulam Ahmad is a prophet) or is meat slaughtered by them considered haram?

No. You should not eat meat slaughtered by them

I have seen a few videos from Christian’s saying that Christmas trees and other traditions are from pagan origins and pagan practices, in recent years a lot of Muslims have been getting Christmas trees and shaping them to be moon shaped and displaying them during Ramadan, eid etc. Is this practice okay to do?

No, this shouldn’t take place

Are women allowed to wear mascara in public?

If it’s worn to draw attention then it’s not allowed

Can a virgin shia female do mutah without her parents permission as long as there is no consummation?

According to Ayatollah Sistani, and based on obligatory precaution, that is not permissible, and the permission of the father is required

My Question is in regards to Surah Yusuf ayat 31 of the Holy Quran. In the later part where Allah (SWT) says "and when they saw him, they greatly admired him and cut their hands and said, " Perfect is Allah! This is not a man; this is none but a noble angel"". My Question is did the women literally say perfect is Allah? As far as I am aware Allah SWT’s name was not known by people back then and the women were polytheists so they may have praised their own deities ( though I may be wrong). I would appreciate if you can explain this.

Many nations believed in one God but that he has sent these idols or that the idols have to worshipped instead.

1) In the house my mother has bought things like giraffes, made out of wood and other materials, is it permissible to have them or should one remove them?

2) Is it permissible for a small statue of a woman too?

1) Yes it’s permissible

2) If they’re full covered yes

In regards to a mother weaning her child at the 2 year mark, is it the child’s Islamic birthday or the birthday on the gregorian calendar?


The Islamic Hirji calendar

What is the responsibility and rights for a younger brother to his elder sister and brother?

What is the responsibility and rights for a elder brother to his younger siblings?

The responsibility of enjoining good relations with respect and harmony and support and help whenever is possible

Can we give haq e Imam of khums for the construction of a very old masjid?

You would need permission of your Marjie

I wanted to ask if we discuss the wrong things done by famous politicians and maulanas which have turned towards politics and how they have deceived other people and discuss these matter with people who dont know about it. Is it counted as gheebat? And if yes what are we supposed to do in situations like these because these are influential people and they have a lot of power in their hands. So how do we expose them and make more people aware about their deeds?

Please watch this to learn what is gheeba

https://youtu.be/eGrzdhJ5eHk

have recently come across an obviously false allegation that Shias have invented surahs in an alternative Quran regarding wilayat. Would you know the origin of these stories?


It’s the work of the enemies of Islam

I have to do laundry with my Non Muslim mother but I have a feeling her clothes would have urine on them. My question is if i wash my clothes with hers after they come out are my clothes considered najjis because the washing machine only washes things once. I dont know what to do.

No it should be ok as the washing machine goes through a number of cycles and it would make the clothes Tahir

Can you wish happy birthday to blood relatives on the martyrdom of lady Fatima (as),who are not Shia but are Muslims? If i do not send a message to wish them it will result into a family issue. As it has in the past due to Arbaeen being on a family members birthday,I did not wish them, it has lead to a big issue. What should one do?

This should be avoided, but if really necessary can be done but without taking part in any celebrations etc on the day of shadahat

Can I give my Khums money to my mother for her to go on ziyarah? She is a single mother who makes a little above minimum wage where we live. She also has a shoulder injury which is preventing her from working full time and she is receiving disability money from the government.

No. You would need permission of your marjie in doing so. Please contact his office where you live and ask them if you can do that

I am looking into beginning hawza studies next year in either Najaf or Qom but I am not sure which city I should go to, both are great so it makes the choice hard.

In your opinion which city would be best and why?

If you could also list pros and cons of both that would be much appreciated.

Each has pros and cons.
In Najaf you need to know Arabic.
In Qum you will spend some time learning farsi.
In Najaf you will be next to shrine of Imam Ali (a).
In Qum you can study more subjects as the hawza has not gone through too much difficulty over the years like Najaf.

Let’s say I want 10 kids. Is it enough to have tawwakul on Allah or do I have to be financially stable?

Tawakkul is key but planning is also important

I have just moved to the UK from a Muslim country where swimming was segregated and I knew that I am swimming for my health, well-being and connection with Allah. (Regular Swimmer & Competitive Swimming) – Swimming all my life.

I have spoken to many people (Shia Muslims) about this and they say “If it for your well-being then it should be permissible in my unique circumstance” or go at off peak times (highly unpredictable)

The only solution was the weekend swim with the community but I need consistency as, I am recovering from a back injury. Where swimming has helped me immensely. By keeping me mentally, physically & spiritually awake.
Reducing my laziness and keeping me aware that my body’s health is my minds health too.

I’ve tried the gym and can not stick to it. But yet again it’s mixed. So is the fatwa similar to swimming?

What should I do? I do not wish to lose my connection with Allah. For it is too precious.

If you can state that without swimming you will face unbearable hardship or difficulty, then you can go provided you ensure that you don’t have any haram looks or thoughts and it’s best to do so when it’s quiet without people.

Is it allowed to listen to slow music for relaxation and for deep sleep?

If it’s music not usually played in areas of haram and vice then it’s ok

I am a revert to islam and live with my parents which are both atheists and against Islam. I live in France where hijab isnt allowed at school or work. I am not wearing hijab but I am wearing modest clothing. I asked my parents if I could wear hijab and they refused, saying that if I do so they would kick me out of the house. I am financially depending on them. My parent’s biggest wish, is for me to finish my education at the university so I have 3 years left to study in France and then I will be financially independent and free to move to a Muslim country and wear hijab.
It means that during these 3 years left, I won’t be able to wear hijab. According to my situation, am I committing sin by not wearing the hijab ?
Because if I start wearing it now, the consequences will be so bad for me, kicked out of the house, no education, and no more good relationship with my parents.
What should I do ?

If you fear for your life and your well-being then you can practice what is known as Taqqiyya (dissimulation). Hence in this instance you can’t hide your faith and not wear hijab. But you should wear hijab anywhere you can as much as possible where it doesn’t involve any harm to you

For years I have been stuck in bad circle. I make many ideas and plans but don’t have courage and knowledge to achieve them. I’m wasting mig life. I.. really need to seek knowledge(Islam). Where should I start? What topic and from where. I somehow get extremely lazy when I have chores. This effects me and my mother and sibling. Other than work I can’t bother to do anything. Bad habits from childhood I was mentally abused for years. Idk if there’s a link. But I wish to change it and need help. I don’t want Allah to be angry at me for wasting my life he has given me. Is there any hadiths from Ahlul Bayt AS on how to manage lifestyle/lazy ness? If I don’t change now I’ll die like this. I don’t want to be an fiasco anymore.

Please watch this lecture on laziness with tips:

https://youtu.be/Sl0gDr5Af_4

Are collagen products halal? Are we allowed to consume collagen powder, or tablets etc if it’s derived from animals that have not been islamically slaughtered?
What about marine collagen etc? And can you use collagen based products like face and body creams?

If they’ve gone through chemical transformation then it’s halal
You need to investigate that and be convinced yourself

I have a few questions regarding chemical changes in products for both skincare and consumption.

1) In skincare products like lotion, if the ingredients are derived from najis sources like pork and cow and certain fish, do the ingredients remain najis or have they been chemically altered? Meaning can I leave them on my skin during salah? Also, if it does go through a chemical change how were you able to know? What proof did you get that convinced you?

2) Same question for gelatin from any source, can you eat it?

3) Does mascara and halal wudhu friendly nail polish create a barrier for wudhu? Must they be removed? As well as tinted moisturizer or foundation? As well as the mascara and nail polish for wudhu, do you accept it as valid and why?

You need to investigate chemical change and be convinced yourself. For lotions there is no need to do this as they’re tahir and can be used.

Please watch these videos:

https://youtu.be/ruyCQQP_l7U
https://youtu.be/oWLw2GcmcHI

I have a close, Muslim cousin who does not perform salah, and does not fast during the holy month of Ramadan. In secret, he does not accept the verdicts of the scholar, but prefers to follow his intellect. He is not concerned with whether his wealth is brought through halal means. He suspects the Qur’an is distorted, and questions a lot of the Prophet’s actions, and believes that the Islam that ISIS came with is the same as the one the holy prophet brought. However, openly, if you would meet him, he would seem like any average Muslim, and seem very agreeable to Islamic discourse. He says God-willing, and prays to Allah in times of need, praises Allah in good times, and respects the Imams and Ahul-bayt, and he cares about his reputation.

I am very perplexed about this matter. I have no hope of guiding him, as he often lets you hear what you like to hear, but at the same time, he is a cousin of mine, and I know how much Allah puts emphasis on kinship. Please guide me to that which is best, may Allah reward you.

Your role is to keep enjoining the good and forbidding the evil. Advice him and try to answer his questions. You mustn’t approve of his un Islamic practice. Don’t cut relations completely but if you feel he is influencing you then don’t spend too much time with him

Is wearing a tawiz (such as a locket or an armband) permissible, and are symbols such as the hamsa allowed since people associate them with the occult and shirk?

Wearing tawiz is not shirk if you don’t believe that it will help you independently of Allah (swt).

I don’t know what Hamsa is

I’ve heard your talk about praying while driving. You said we need to bow the neck showing sign of rukuk and sujud. My question is, is it need to bend down the neck while reciting the tasbih for ruku and sujud or we can just bow down and lift the head back while reciting the tasbih? Is it permitted for us to look left right while praying during driving?

Bending should be slight and yes dikr recited during that
Looking right and left should not happen

Is illuminati, freemasons and dajjal the same thing?

No. Each has its own definition

I came across the above in Al Kafi, volume 6 and I wondered how we go about interpreting it in an Islamic sense. I ask this question purely academically; coming from an Indo-Pak background earrings have always been discouraged and in the west the argument of it being a ‘feminine’ quality (which wouldn’t hold up in 2022) but the above hadith goes on to say this is a recommended act and that, beyond piercings, the Imams apparently had earrings, too.

1. These narrations are weak
2. Today some marajie consider earrings usage is mainly by females and so males should not be wearing them
3. Some consider times have changed and circumstances different (eg marriage of 9 year olds was normally at time of Prophet)

I have a question regarding something unusual that has been happening to me. One week ago, I flew overseas to Iraq and did Ziyara in Najaf, Karbala, and Sayedna Shareefa. I noticed that ever since I came back to Michigan, I keep having bad dreams every day that disturb me. Even if I take a small afternoon nap I wake up from a bad dream. Should I be concerned or should I just wait it out? Normally I would never ask this type of question. I could care less for dream interpretations. I wish people cared about the interpretation of Quranic ayat the way the care of the interpretation of their dreams. But I just can’t help but feel it’s a strange coincidence that ever since I came back from Ziyara all I have is bad dreams.

May Allah accept your ziyarah
Please ignore the dreams and don’t worry about this
It’s maybe Shaitan trying to impact you and place doubt in you
Ziyarah only brings goodness and thawab inshallah

Seek refuge in Allah before sleep through istiadha, be in wudhu, do tasbeeh of fatima before sleep, recite Quran and dikr and Insha’Allah these dreams will stop

Do we need to pray 2 rakaat namaaz for every masumeens ziyarat we recite or it’s recommended for only specific ziyarats?

Can we pray one set of 2 rakaat namaaz for one or more ziyarat by combining their niyat: Eg: Ziyarate Waritha, Ashura and Ziyarate Imam Zamana?

It’s not wajib and actually recommended
So you can pray what you wish

When we are in a car and we touch the leather with a wet hand is it needed to check to find out somehow if the leather was najjis or is it considered tahir? if a product is made out of something like wool, or the hair of an animal is it haram? And if we dont know if its made from animal products should we check? Or is that unnecessary?

Everything is tahir unless we know for sure otherwise. So unless you know base it on tahara

When outside the house (eg work or school), is it better to pray as early as possible (& quickly) or later at home but in peace ?
Do ease/difficulty in factors like finding a place to pray/social norms etc influence this decision?

This is assuming there is no fear of prayer being Qadha later.

Timing of salah is key. It should not be delayed

Couple of years ago, I was accompanying my mother in her hospital room and I found a power bank there. Not caring, I took it since during our stay of a couple of days, no one came to ask for it.

I don’t remember very well now and I’m also not sure if I knew the ruling at that time or not but in a recent discussion I realised that I should have made an effort to find it’s owner.

I did feel burdened for taking the power bank at that time therefore after some time I stopped using it and since then it’s there in the store room.

What should I do now? What is the best course of action?

If you can’t find the owner, give sadaqa for its value (current value as what you would get if you sell it now) and you can continue to use it

In a matter where you and your spouse are constantly arguing and you feel the negativity of being around them, should you consider divorce, if you’ve tried all you could for the past few months to solve this and you’re fixed on divorce?

You should try mediation and seeking help from professionals such as trained scholars

We used to pray in a certain direction at home for 2 years. then checked Googles Qibla Finder, and it turned out to be wrong.

From your recent video, I learnt that when the time for namaz has passed and then one realises they prayed in the wrong direction, they dont have to re do the namaz.

Just want to confirm that applies in our situation too.

Yes in this instance you don’t need to redo the salah

I want to know how accurate is the hadith of rasool Allah (saww) that the residents of hell will be women predominantly.
I am of the impression that both men and women are equal in front of Allah and whoever is a sinner will be answerable to their deeds regardless of gender.
Both men and women commit sins, then why is it that Prophet of Allah mentioned in the hadith that there will be more women than men in hell.
Who is the narrator of this hadith? I wonder it would be someone who hates women and pushed his own agenda rather then conveying what the prophet (saww) wanted to say.

Such narrations are not authentic or reliable
If any Hadith contradicts the Quran we reject it
There is no ayeh that points to what these narrations are saying

Someone gifted me stone with sharaf e shams engraved on it. I got it fixed in a ring. Can I wear that ring all the time. I often remove it before going to washroom but sometimes I forget. What is ruling about it?

Yes it’s fine to wear it all the time

I have a condition whereby it takes me a lot of time to pass urine to where I can reach to a point that I am confident nothing will come out while I am praying. This takes a minimum of around 45 minutes up to two hours, with the average being an hour and ten minutes.

Because of this I have stopped praying my Fajr on time as it is too difficult to wake up an hour before prayer to use the washroom and even Zuhr/Asr because I can’t get that much time off my work schedule. As a result most of the times nowadays these prayers become qadha because even when I return home I spend upto 2 hours in the washroom, at which point it is nearly time for magrhib….
What is my obligation is in this case? Do I spend a normal amount of time cleaning myself and pray knowing that drops of urine might or will be released, or do I spend the extra amount of time to ensure that during my prayer I will be clean?…

You may also have OCD. Please see a therapist. There is nothing with that as well

In your case you should ignore the time and pray. Salah must never be missed. There is no excuse. So please ignore the time and the feeling of urine dropping and perform your prayers

Are there practical ways to foster a love of Allah in children (beyond telling them to look around and identifying the blessings around them)? My child is 4 years old.

1. Tell them stories of Ahlulbayt and how Allah has chosen them
2. Tell them stories from Quran
3. Keep emphasising that Allah loves them
4. Practice worship of God in front of them and enjoy it, show it’s very positive

I would like to ask that when I was about 8 or 9 years (when I became baligh) I did not realize that I was doing some mistakes in my namaaz , until later I came to know that I was making mistakes, and immediately I rectified those mistakes . e.g, I used to recite tashahud and salaam together in 2nd raka of 3 and 4 raka namaz, but I rectified immediately when I came to know my mistake. Now I don’t remember how many days I prayed like that? What should I do?

If you didn’t know before then you should be ok and there’s nothing you need to do

I wanted to ask how Husband and wife should pray together at home.

1) As it is just two people what is the procedure regarding praying Salah together. Will there be Iqamah, Azaan, will the Husband lead the prayer in Jammah style and how should they be positioned.

2) If it is just the husband and wife, does the wife do Iqama or the Husband?

3) When the Imam is leading the prayer, do the people reading behind the imam recite Surah Fatiha and another Surah as well, or do they stand quietly and just listen to the Imam?

1) Yes the husband leads and the wife is behind him. She should be doing sajda to the point of where his knees are in sujood. Iqama etc is as normal,

2) She can do iqama no problem

3) They should not recite fateha and other surah as in jamaat prayers only the imam does this

I have a hard time to draw a line between being nice to people and being too nice to a point where people think they can allow step on me. This happened many years now. But I feel bad when I get angry at people. Where is the limit, how to show people limit? I make fun and laugh with colleagues and some of them think they can talk down on me. When I get serious they either make me feel stupid emotionalyl or argue with me. I considered even not smile or be nice to anybody anymore but that is against what I have learned and my nature. I like helping people, being honest and be social person.

Remember when you help others and be kind your reward is with Allah (swt). However you need to be kind but firm. Please read self help books and maybe some TEd talks on this as there is nothing wrong on enhancing our communication skills in this way. You need to ensure you draw boundaries and ppl know that. The issue is sometimes we’re afraid of what ppl think of us and hence we don’t stand up for what is right. That can be done in a nice way but communicated

Once imam Sadiq (a) went to his house with someone but didn’t offer for him to come inside. When asked why he said I’m not ready for the person to come inside, but he said it kindly and gently

I wanted to start a meditation YouTube channel. Where it has these calm music but it has no beats jut to calm the nerve. Will be permissible for me to do so?

If it’s music that is not normally played or used in areas of vice then it’s permissible

Can a husband and wife use donor sperm to fertilize the wife’s egg and implant it in her?

Can a husband and wife use a donor egg from another woman, fertilize it with the husbands sperm and implant it into the wife?

It’s not permissible, according to Ayatollah Sistani, for sperm of the non husband to be used

Regarding second part, yes but if it involves the exposing of the woman’s body in front of a non Mahrem it’s not permissible unless there is very pressing need to have a child since otherwise it causes unbearable hardship or distress, eg mental health issues

I was doing some independent research on Islamic laws recently and came across what is permitted for muttah (temporary marriage) for men vs. women. Why is it that men are permitted to have a muttah with “People of the Book”/Christian and Jewish women? The laws did specify that they cannot permanently marry them, but why allow a temporary marriage with them when it cannot become a permanent one? Isn’t muttah working towards a permanent marriage. Why is this option then not allowed for ladies? I am curious as to why the law exists and what the purpose for such a temporary union that cannot progress further would be.

Temporary marriage does not need to lead to permanent. They are different. The opinion regarding allowing only temporary marriage with Ahlul Kitab and not permanent is by some marajie, such as Ayatollah Sistani. It is based on the understanding of the Hadith literature that distinguishes the temporary from the permanent.
Re females, it is unanimously agreed by Muslim scholars according to the Quran that they cannot Mary a non Muslim. We may think it’s because the male may influence his wife but Allah knows best

I have heard the sword of Imam Ali a.s is in a museum in Istanbul, turkey, is that true?

They claim that but we believe it’s with Imam Mehdi (a)

In salah sometimes I intend to recite the letter س but it sounds like ص and sometimes I recite the letter ص and it sounds like س.
Is my Salah valid?

If you’re trying your best and it’s not intended then there is nothing to worry about

Sunni Muslims often believe that black magic can be deadly, break relationships, get someone possessed by jinn, and other powerful effects but Is it true that Shia Muslims do not believe in black magic being powerful rather we believe it’s just a dulustional and has nothing to do with the physical world? As in it cannot harm us significantly like ending relationships or making someone severely ill.

It can but it’s very limited and often exaggerated

Can we recite the Subh/Fajr Qadha namaaz of the Day or of any other day Qadha namaaz , after Zohr Prayer before Asr OR after maghrib before Isha? i.e between Zohr and Asr or between Maghrib and Isha

Yes you can

Am I required to pay khums, according to His Eminence, on money that was wired directly into my bank account as a gift?

Yes

To tell someone near you something during salah, can one say during qunut, "Ya Allah tell him/her xyz", loudly so that they are able to hear you?

No such practice should not take place as it affects the form of salah
Salah is connection between you and Allah only

The Sunnis have a belief of pre-destination of our spouses before we were born like some 50,000 years before we were born. Kind of like the concept of a soulmate who is only meant for us and we are meant for them.

What’s the Shia belief regarding this? Are our spouses based on personal choices or did Allah (swt) make us and our spouse for each other before we were born?

No we don’t have this belief generally speaking, although some may tend towards this, but it’s not a widespread accepted opt by our scholars

1) A husband starts a business and after some years the wife joins the business. After many years of continuty the husband died. The wife continues the same business and after some years the son joins in. The existing family now after 20 years of death of the husband consists of his wife son and 2 married daughters
How does the inheritance work.

2) Does the wife have the right to distribute the property as per her own wish ?

As per Islamic law, after death of husband all inheritors are entitled to a certain percentage. If they give that up and gave it all to the wife she becomes the owner of it all.

1) Are dreams after fajr prayer concidered as unauthentic and troubled even tough there is one of the Masomeen (as) included in?

2) Are dreams in general reliable and how to recognise if they are troubled dreams or dreams from Allah swt.

Please watch this lecture

https://youtu.be/JGz04Ckvuzw

A friend committed a lot of zina but repented and is on the straight path. However, he is about to get married but has not told his future spouse. Should he disclose it? What if I am asked about his past by his future in laws, should I disclose this knowing that it will end the marriage?

It should only be disclosed if it directly or indirectly affects his future and his marriage with that person. Sins are supposed to be protected from people but in marriage if someone has done something that affects his future he should be honest and tell his wife about it. If it doesn’t affect the future then it’s his decision to tell or not. For eg has the Zina affected the way he will approach the physical relationship with his wife?

Is it permissible to engage in Greek Orthadox Easter greetings with relatives, with the intention of Silat al-Raham instead of believing it it? The greeting is Χριστός Ανέστη / Christ has risen

Instead you should say happy Easter and not a statement that we Muslims don’t agree with

In one of your lectures, you quoted a beautiful hadith that stated that when Shia of Ali hear virtues of Imam Ali being listed and they feel serene and calm, that’s breeze from Jannah.
Could you please provide the reference for this?

It’s not a Hadith but a possibility mentioned by some scholars

Why is it that a wife cannot refuse for sexual relations with her husband and has to go to him even if she’s on a camels back, while a husband can refuse sexual relations for four months straight?

Allah has created males and females differently with different needs. He knows best. No one is better than the other. The 4 months thing is the minimum. A husband should respond to his wife’s needs for sure and not wait for 4 months. These rights are bare minimum and a marriage may not survive.

Maybe the husband needs to be encouraged by the wife by use of clothing, make up, perfume etc

I want to ask about I am married. My wife has some psychological issues and I cannot go near to her because of this. How can I control my sexual desire because it is a little bit difficult to control and cannot do anything with wife for the time being. What does shariah says here for my case?

There is no way other than halal method for you to fulfil your needs. Marriage is the only way. Either help your wife or discuss with her possible other marriage

The only way is through marriage, temporary or permanent, with someone else

I recently have remortgaged my house of approximately £100,000. The loan was to repair my house and go to Hajj. At the time, I had £25,000 left (over one year) before I went for Hajj.

Do I have to pay Khums on the £25,000 (£5000 is 1/5th) as my mortgage loan is over £100,000?

Secondly, do I pay Khums on any of the leftover remortgaged money?

Please read this carefully as it explain how to calculate the khums based on the new ruling

https://www.world-federation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Khums_Guide.pdf

Since you have a degree in pharmacy, I wanted to ask you is refined Glycerine and Glycerol tahir? Almost all our edible and non edible products available in shops use Glycerine and Glycerol which could be from Animal or plant sources.

Yes they’re both Tahir

I am a lady that is willing to get married. I know I am ready for it as well as mentally as physically but the problem i have got is that the country where I live there is a huge lack of shia people/community in here. Thereby I asked and talked to my own parents many times about my interest to get married buy both of them don’t show any support and are not willing to search nor are they showing initiative. They have also a really small network or only have family friends which dont have children. I have no idea what to do

1. You need to sign up to trusted online religious match making forums

2. You need to search in your country for events for Shi’a matrimony. There are quite a few

3. You need to ask every friend you have to go through their phone book and maybe suggest a potential spouse

4. Do these a’maal and Duas as follows:

https://youtu.be/oU3vfdLzL08

I have a question about praying with boots on in the following scenario.

I hike and camp regularly in rural areas and nature parks. As you know in the UK it can be very wet and boggy. I often find myself in muddy fields or woodlands when I need to pray dhuhr and asr. Is it possible to pray with my hiking boots even if they are pak in these areas? Or must I pray and get my feet muddy?

If possible use a shoes where you can at least have your toes touching the ground in sujood
If that is not possible or difficult due to where you are, then it is ok to wear shoes in salah due to your circumstances

I live on my own in the UK and there is no one who can travel with me as amahram Since I travel a little what would be the ruling on this? What can I do in the situation?

Unless you fear for yourself from falling into haram, there is no need for a Mahrem

There is a Hadith going around where it likens selling the soil of Karbala is like selling the flesh of imsm Hussain(as) I believe the Hadith is in the book kamal ziyarat(I’m not sure on the page number of it) I was wondering what the authenticity of this Hadith is ?

Does this mean we’re not allowed to purchase or sell turbah ?

Selling the actual soil of Imam Hussain’s grave should be avoided.
Turba of Karbala is fine to be sold

1) My question is regarding difference in methology of prayer by a male and a female regarding which I came across a little difference in opinion on research.
What are the main differences between the manner of praying Salah for a male and a female, if there are any. (Specifically regarding the elbows touching the ground during sujood.)

2) Is it permissible to read Surahs from a book or phone screen for an obligatory prayer?
I recently read the importance of reciting Surah Al-Fajr in Salah and I have Alhamdolillah almost memorized it but still fear missing a few words here there.
Would appreciate your clarification on this.

The differences between male and female salah is not on wajib matters but recommended issues, so if the male for example does it the female way it’s not haram

Yes you can use a phone or book to read surah in wajib salah, but be sure not to be distracted with anything else during salah

I go to university far from my home to where I must pray with the intention of qasr. When Ramadan begins, will I be able to fast if I am considered a traveler?

I think you have misunderstood rules of travelling
Please read this booklet

https://imam-us.org/islamic-laws-of-fasting

Usually for university you have to pray full if you’re staying there

I am in a mutah marriage and I regularly visit my husband. He lives more than 28 miles away so I am considered a traveler and the rules of qasr and fasting apply to me. However I consider this to be my home as it his own flat, I visit regularly and I will be living here once permanently married. As this is the case are my fasts valid for me to keep and does it matter if I am here for less than 10 days even though I consider this to be my home?

This is the ruling of Ayatollah Sistani

Long-term stay (LTS) (watan al-itikhadhi): A place where a person plans to stay long-term for work, school, summer or spring vacations, or similar purposes, even if they do not own property or a home there. Except for the first month of stay during which time the person must perform both full and shortened prayers and fast the month of Ramadan and make up those fasts based on obligatory precaution if one of the following criteria related to their stay in that place applies:

o Remain there for six hours during every trip, in twenty-two days every month, for four years
o Remain there for eight hours during every trip, in twenty days every month, for four years.
o Remain there for twelve hours during every trip, in fifteen days every month, for five years.
o Remain there for twelve hours during every trip, in twenty-two days every month, for three years.
o Remain there for twenty-four hours during every trip, in seven to eight days every month, for four years.
o Remain there for twenty-four hours during every trip, in fifteen days every month, for three years.
o Remain there for twenty-four hours during every trip, in twenty-two to thirty days every month, for one and a half years.

I have heard of a Hadith whereby the washing of the wife’s feet by the husband on the wedding night and spraying the water around the wife’s new home brings baraka for the couple and their marriage. Will there be an issue if one does this day two weeks later for example after the honeymoon? As I am going on holiday straight after the nikkah and am not able to do this until after we’re back and in my husbands home. So will it still be valid if we do this after the honeymoon?

There is no issue in doing this later

I have a son and don’t wish to have another child however my husband is forcing me to have a second child.. Do I have a right to refuse?

Yes you have the right. Having children is a mutual decision and cannot be forced

Just wondering, who is classified as your "elder" in hadith? Someone above a specific age? Or would someone who is 4-5 years older than you also fall under the category of your "elder" speaking in terms of hadith

Those known in society as elderly, ie as urf they are considered that category

Is it permissible to get premission from guardians for a girl who is virgin? I know it is neccessary but if the father doesn’t allow to girl in any condition to marry a person to who she wants. The reason of denial is just that he does not belongs to syed family otherwise he is good by character and have love of Ahl ul Bait a.s in heart and follow all teaching of religion.
On the other hand, the family is forcing the girl to marry the person who is not good by character, does not even follow any act of shariah at all. Girl didn’t agree for that marriage.
What can she can do?

1. Forcing the girl is haram and the marriage is void
2. If father refuses to allow her to marry based on matters that are not usually acceptable then he loses his authority. Please consult a scholar to establish this

My mother who is non-muslim has contact with a psychic. She helps her find things that are missing and she can explain quite strange things. She gives detailed explanations of our whereabouts, and where we would find the missing ipad and dog that ran away.

What is the islamic explanation for this?

This is possible as some people have this ability
But in Islamic law such practice is not allowed and should be avoided

Do we accept those hadiths and do we have similar hadiths that tells men to marry young or virgins?

Yes we have such hadith but it comes out of general recommendations

The Prophet himself married non virgins and some were not young

I have a question about the permissibility of CBD oil. CBD oil is not like cannabis and it comes in different forms.

What about for non-medical purposes, if someone used broad and isolate cbd oil which have no trace of thc, would that not make it halal since thc is the intoxicant factor and therefore why cannabis is haram. As the intoxicant factor is removed would that not mean that it would be halal for non-medical purposes like being used as a supplement to improve general wellbeing even though it is not necessary at all?

Yes CBD oil for medical purposes is allowed

If non THC cbd oil is not addictive or harmful then yes can be used for general well-being

If someone hits a non muslim in their childhood, while playing or normal fights and arguments that take place between children, do they have to pay a diyeh to the mon muslim or ask him for forgiveness or pay any rad e mazalim?

Yes it’s best to ask for forgiveness and pay rad madhalim if they can’t access them

I saw in one of your videos that if a dark layer forms on your turbah after a while, then it is not permissible to pray on it.
1. I didn’t know about this ruling so does this mean my previous prayers are invalid?
2. I cleaned it underwater with my hands but the layer still remains. Is this ok or does this mean that I need to scrape it harder using some tools?

1. That is fine and you don’t need to repeat
2. You need to remove the layer or use a new turba

What happens if someone doesn’t perform ghusl e haiz and thinks its not important because they don’t do namaz anyway,so what’s a point

They remain impure and unable to perform the acts of worship such as entering a mosque, prayers or tawaf. If they do these things without ghusl, it’s invalid

I have a question regarding the Islamic ruling on getting IV and IM Medications while fasting. Is it allowed or does it break your fast?

It’s allowed

Ruling 1555. Injections and intravenous drips do not invalidate a fast even if the former is an energy injection and the latter a glucose-saline drip. Similarly, a spray that is used for asthma does not invalidate a fast provided that the medicine only enters the lungs. Applying medicine [such as drops] to the eyes and ears does not invalidate a fast either, even if its taste reaches the throat. Likewise, if medicine is applied in the nose, it does not invalidate a fast as long as it does not reach the throat.

https://www.sistani.org/english/book/48/2263/

I’m aware intoxicants are haram, but overall some intoxicants are MUCH less dangerous for our health than non-intoxicant therapies. To give an example, weed against med pills.

Weed gets you high, but it comes from a natural plant that can help your health. Medicines do not get you high, but they are dangerous for our body.

This being said, can someone prefer consuming drugs that intoxicate you instead of common medicines that can harm us in the long term?

Such comparisons don’t work in Islamic law
Consuming Cannabis is not permissible

I had a question regarding mental health. I wanted to ask you if it’s good to seek help from other than Allah. As in, therapists and things of that nature on mental health. Or is it better to focus on Allah SWT and not seek help from His creatures.

Yes it’s absolutely fine, since we see doctors and go to hospitals etc so there is no problem in seeking mental health support . Ofcourse at the same time we believe all cure is from Allah and we rely on Him always but He wants us to use means

My question is about placenta encapsulation. It has become very common for women to encapsulate their placentas after birth and taking the placenta pills to gain its health benefits. Is this halal?

This is usually not permissible unless the person gets permission directly from their marjie or representative due to dire need or unbearable difficulty

I have invested in stock market last year and I did Khums and this year date is arrive of khums so do I need to perform khums? Even though I am not selling this stocks for next 5 to 10 years.
Please explain me

If you’ve paid khums last year you don’t need to pay this up to the amount you’re left with from last year

So for example, if the stock was $1000 and you did khums on it last year, if this year it’s value is $2000 and you sell it then you pay khums for difference

If you don’t sell it you can hold off the khums and pay as soon as you sell it

I have a question regarding a name I have come across which holds good Quranic meaning and want to name my baby girl this but want to make sure that this is a legitimate name to keep.

The name is Ayana

The name is not in the Quran
There doesn’t seem to be any problems with using it however

Ofcourse the Ahlulbayt have recommended names given to the family of the Prophet or for eg righteous family of prophets to be used

If husband stop his wife to do Sile Rahmi with her family. Does she have to listen to her husband?

Silat Al Rahim is wajib and the husband must not stop his wife from this. She is allowed to leave the house without his permission for this purpose if it’s to visit family

My husband and I are on the verge of separation.
Please can I have some duas to make marriage better

Recite Quran 25:74 many times a day

Watch this video and recite these Duas as well

https://youtu.be/CZKMX9LK4YQ

I was wondering if you could please tell me some duas that help with adhd? I am taking medicine for it but still it’s really hard to focus or remember anything. I always forget what I’m doing when I do salat and schoolwork is very hard

This video helps with memory

https://youtu.be/N3kSVVfP0Hk

Should I leave my husband or start to think that might happen if he says he believes in islam very little?
I am worried it will end up being none

You should address why he is saying this. It maybe due to anger, frustration or lack of knowledge. What are his doubts. Don’t give up that easily. Maybe this is Allah’s message to you and a chance to gain reward. It certainly is a test for you. Get him to see a scholar to answer his question. Be patient and keep asking Allah for his guidance for your husband.

Get him to be in good circles
Maybe take him ziyarah or Umrah/hajj
Or perhaps keep encouraging mosque attendance
Or watch Islamic lectures together

1. If someone works at fruits farm, is he allowed to eat those fruits on job site without permission of owner? Or he must seek permission for eating those fruits?

2. For example If owner of the strawberry farm himself personally offers him to eat the strawberry, but he refuses owner’s offer saying I don’t like to eat strawberry, but later on he eats one strawberry. Does he still need to seek permission or tell him about strawberry he ate, Or does he consider his offer as he granted the permission of eating?

If he is not the owner and does not have direct permission he should not eat. In the second instance, he needs to ask the owner if it’s ok to eat sometimes otherwise just because he was offered and he eats later is not sufficient without permission

I used to be Muslim but left Islam for a while. During the time that I left Islam, I used to believe in God but I didn’t believe his name was Allah and I didn’t believe He sent the Quran. I just used to believe in a universal God but not that his name is Allah.

Since then I decided to come back to Islam but now i’m having confusion if Allah is a different God to the universal God that i used to believe in because the characreristics are all the same. He is unseen, He is the creator of everything etc. Or if it’s the same God and just that His name is Allah. I’m not sure if i’m believing in Allah correctly. Can you help me understand if I’m believing correctly?

Is it the meaning of the word Allah which means God that is His name or is it the letters alif lam lam ha that is his name?

Whether you believe in Allah or God, He is the same. As long as you believe in the Powerful Being who is Creator of everything and He has not been created, that is the main thing

Allah means The God ال الاه

I work at a marketing agency where we deal with international clients. We have a new client from the US that owns a Cannabis company. Since I am a graphic designer, I’ve been asked to draw banners related to the product. Is that haram?

Yes it will be not permissible since you’re promoting a haram product

When a divorce is taking place, if the husband in question doesn’t get along or doesn’t like one of the witnesses who was present at the time the divorce was read, is that divorce valid?

Also, once a husband has given instruction to read or give the divorce, can he later retract it after the divorce has been read, and then seek for the divorce to be a khula divorce instead?

Only if they can prove that the witness is not just. They have to make a case with a religious authority

If the divorce has taken place, he cannot retract it if it’s khuli, but if it’s the revocable one then yes within the idda 3 cycles he can go back to his wife

I recently found out that I’m required to pay Khums on my earnings, but didn’t know about this in the past. I’ve been working and earning for about 4 years now. Should I try and calculate the khums I owe for all 4 years I missed or can I ask for forgiveness for not knowing and pay the khums starting from this year moving forward? I would really appreciate the guidance, I’m not sure I am able to calculate all my expenses from 4 years back but can try if necessary.

You should try to calculate khums from 4 years ago and for each year. Try to estimate. That is the right thing to do.

Here is a booklet that helps you

https://fiqh.world-federation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Khums_Guide_Web.pdf

I understand that Zihar is unlawful, and it is something to the effect of calling your wife like your mother in an attempt to divorce her. And this is a little TMI and embarassing, but sometimes I call my wife "Mom/momma/mommy" playfully, both her and I enjoy it. But I was wondering, have I accidentally been doing zihar on her?

Your intention is not dihar, so just these names don’t impact your marriage and so it should be fine

Is it permissible for a woman to play sports where there is no physical contaact such as badminton with a man while being in proper hijab?

There is no problem if they can safeguard themselves from falling into haram (ie gazes etc)

May I request you to please explain, How is our beloved Holy prophet Muhammad s.a.w.s Superior to all previous prophets in all terms?

Kind request is to provide answer in the light of Quranic Verses and not Hadiths Nor Hadith e qudsi.

One ayeh is this

Holy Quran 33:7
------------------
وَإِذْ أَخَذْنَا مِنَ النَّبِيِّينَ مِيثَاقَهُمْ وَمِنكَ وَمِن نُّوحٍ وَإِبْرَاهِيمَ وَمُوسَىٰ وَعِيسَى ابْنِ مَرْيَمَ ۖ وَأَخَذْنَا مِنْهُم مِّيثَاقًا غَلِيظًا

[Recall] when We took a pledge from the prophets, and from you and from Noah and Abraham and Moses and Jesus son of Mary, and We took from them a solemn pledge,

Allah says He took the pledge from the holy Prophet of Islam first

Holy Quran 21:107
------------------
وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَاكَ إِلَّا رَحْمَةً لِّلْعَالَمِينَ

We did not send you but as a mercy to all the nations.

No other Prophet has been described as such in the Quran

Holy Quran 33:56
------------------
إِنَّ اللَّهَ وَمَلَائِكَتَهُ يُصَلُّونَ عَلَى النَّبِيِّ ۚ يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا صَلُّوا عَلَيْهِ وَسَلِّمُوا تَسْلِيمًا

Indeed Allah and His angels bless the Prophet; O you who have faith! Invoke blessings on him and invoke Peace upon him in a worthy manner.

Only Prophet Mohammad (s) from all the Prophets receives this salawat

In surah Al-Ma’idah ayat 96, it explains that it is lawful for us to eat seafood, so why we can’t eat fish without scales and other sea creatures like clams, lobsters? Would you mind give me the strong narration about this?

When my sunni friends know about shia not eating lobster, clams, they are wondering because what they know is Al quran allows us to eat all creatures that lives in the sea

moreover, I read a narration that said that we can eat all sea creatures even the carcasses meanwhile in shia it is forbidden to eat the animals that are dead in the sea, why is it contradictory?

Because we have so many narrations that quantify what the Quran says. We cannot abandon Hadith. Many Hadith say fish must have scales. You can find this in Alkafi, wasail alshia etc

I would like to ask if there is a specific way of Positioning of legs while sitting in Tashahud or in between the Sujood in namaaz ?

Is it Wajib to position legs in a particular way ?

what if one does otherwise? eg. keeping left ankle on top of right or just sitting on both the legs or just sits down and legs aside?

What is wajib is to sit on both legs. Yes there is a mustahab way but the method you described on placing one leg on another is ok

What if the food was bought with Khums free money? as I understand if I buy non-food commodities like clothes with Khums free money then I don’t need to remove Khums even after a year if it’s unused?

Yes correct

1) I’ve recently read some authentic ahadith as well as views of classical scholars such as al-Kulayni, Allama Majlisi that state Rasullulah (SAW) had 4 daughters and not 1. What are the views of the modern scholars and maraja3 on this? If he did have 4 daughters, how do we reconcile with them being married to Kuffar?

2) Why does Allah (swt) use the plural word of daughters in the verse instructing the Prophet (saw)? I understand the same was used in the verse of Mubahila but here daughters is specific rather than women?

1) This is a matter of disagreement

Ayatollah Jafar Amili who has written one of the biggest biographies of the Prophet (over 40 volumes) concluded that the prophet had one daughter only. I agree with this and evidence points to this, such as praise of sayida and no praise of other 3 for eg

2) It’s because of his adopted daughters. They were daughters of the sister of Khadija Hala.

But doesn’t Allah mention in the Quran not to call adopted sons as their own sons i.e in the case of Zaid bin Harith?

He says don’t call them as such:
Zainab bint Muhammad if they’re adopted
But they can be called sons and daughters but not in name linked to their adopted father

If you are praying qasr prayers in jama’ah, do you end your prayer as soon as two rakats are over or do you wait until the Imam finishes the the rest of the rakaats

Yes you end it when you finish

Is there something like halal nail polish?

Or a way you can apply nail polish and ghusl and wudhoo works if the nail polish does not touch the sides of the of the nail, just the middle

I heard from a good source that there is a brand called 786 which is water permeable and hence will be ok for wudhu and ghusl

I have daughter and has been sick for some time and asking duas for her health recovery

This video has some Duas

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=DfThTZBwrUM

Also perform this Salah:

https://islamiced.org/video/important-prayer-for-fulfilment-of-wishes-hajaat/

I have always been troubled by my existence with homosexual desires. This a challenge I cannot bear some days and is truly one of the difficult tests bestowed upon anyone. Only the pain and suffering of Ahlulbayt makes me realise that I am just a mere human with problems that are not too difficult in comparison to theirs.

I have hated my existence in this world and therefore I have come up with a theory to satisfy myself of my existence in this Dunya and the reason why I have homosexual desires. I believe homosexual desires exist because they prove the existence of Allah. Our desires are unexplained by the theory of evolution. According to the theory of evolution, homosexual desires would have diminished over mankind’s existence due to survival of the fittest. Our homosexual desires show that Allah is the creator and can test anyone with the way He wishes. Therefore, it gives me great satisfaction in knowing that I have a reason to exist to prove creationism. It satisfies me in knowing that I don’t have a cursed and undesirable existence. Am I wrong to think this way? Otherwise why would Allah create these feelings if they are so undesirable.

It’s a test like any other tendency or addiction or excessive desire, eg men who wish to fornicate

We are human who must have self control and not fall into temptations whenever we have desires and act upon them. That would be wrong.

I heard that we shias believe that Prophet Ibrahim father was not name Azar but his name was Tarakh. Why does the Quran say Azar name instead of Tarakh if Tarakh is the actual father?

The term father in the Quran is used for anyone who takes care and looks after someone, and for uncles as well

In relations to my question about Khums and student loans, I was wondering what I actually need to pay Khums on as I’ve heard varying replies to this question.

As a hypothetical example, say I had

£500 at the start Jan 2021 then a year later in Jan 2022 I had £3000 with £1,500 being from a student loan.

What would I be required to pay Khums on if at all, as I have been told different answers.

Please read this booklet carefully as it answers your questions

https://fiqh.world-federation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/02/Khums_Guide_Web.pdf

I just got married.

None of my husband’s family know about me.

This situation I am in gives me a lot of depression but I want to wait for him as we agreed and because I trust & love him. How can I help myself in times of sadness?

You should trust God and think positively. You should occupy yourself with activities that are righteous and help others. You should plan and build for your future correctly and not worry if things go wrong, as many things don’t go perfectly in this world

Our flight is shortly before iftaar. Are we still permitted to fast on this day? We land the following day at 9am after transiting. Hence are we able to fast on the day of travel and the following day of arrival?

If you leave your place of permanent residence after Duhr then you can keep your fast. So in this example yes if you live in a UK city and departing from that city after Duhr then you must keep fast

However on reaching Dar, if you intend to stay there 10 days or more or it’s your hometown etc then if you reach before Duhr you can fast that day

My brother has failed his medical licensing test. Without this exam he won’t be able to practice Medecine and he has worked very hard all his life to be a doctor and now despite studying a lot he regularly fails his exam.

Can you please tell us a dua to recite or an Amaal to do that can help him clear this life and death exam please

This salah is recommended from Imam Sadiq (a)

https://youtu.be/alDZrXTvP80

Also check other a’maal in our videos on YouTube page Noor Islamic Education

I am concerned regarding the use of haram substances medicines for medical purposes like in cough syrups we have alcohol, in some capsules the companies use animal gelatine. My question is what is the view of Islam on consumption of these medicines?

Regarding gelatine, if you do the research and find that it goes through complete transformation in the manufacturing process then it’s ok to consume

This is the answer of Ayatollah Sistani re alcohol in medicines

It is permissible to consume if the amount is very minute, e.g. 2%
If the amount of alcohol is more than 2%, then one may dilute the medication with water, so that the amount of alcohol becomes very minute, e.g. 2% or less and then consume it.

My children ask me to recite surahs from the Quran whilst they are falling asleep in bed next to me, is it ok to recite to them whilst laying in bed without head covering? Or should I sit up and wear head covering before reciting? And must I have wudhu to recite even if its reading from memory and not touching any text?

Head covering for Quran recitation is not obligatory. If it’s memorisation and not touching the words then wudhu is not necessary

My question is regarding Mixed Gyms. There are mixed gyms here, in 2017 I sent a question to the Office of His Eminence, Ayatullah Sistani about being able to attend a mixed gym if I can be sure to not look at the opposite gender with a lustful look. The reply I got was that this is not allowed. Now, my question is that what should I do in this case, I really can control myself in that particular environment and as far as gym music is concerned, for the entirety of my workout I listen to majalis of Imam Hussain to learn while im working out. I understand that the fatwa of a Marj’a is be all and end all, but what is your advice in this case if I really want to go.

If you can stay away from haram
Looks or gazes and protect your faith, then other marajie allow this and you can follow them in this regard, but you have to be very careful about this and practice taqwa all the time

I have a very particular question about Me’raaj. Particularly, a verse in Surah Najm (verse 18) states that "He certainly saw of his Lord’s greatest sign"

Now my question is that regarding the Ayatil Kubra in this verse, I have heard two narrations – One states that Imam Amirul Mu’mineen says that I am the greatest sign of Allah and the Second states that Sayyeda Fatima alayhasalam is the greatest sign of Allah. So who did the Prophet (PBUH&HF) see at the highest point of his Me’raaj journey?

Everything he saw was some of Allah’s great signs. The whole meraj was a great sign. Hence although what you mentioned can be accepted from narrations, it’s not confined to one or two things only but a number of things, and Allah knows best

Holy Quran 53:18
------------------
لَقَدْ رَأَىٰ مِنْ آيَاتِ رَبِّهِ الْكُبْرَىٰ

Certainly he saw some of the greatest signs of his Lord.

The ‘min’ in the verse means some , and points to a number of signs

I live in a western country, is it permissible to practice as a tax lawyer?

There shouldn’t be any problems as long as no deception or lying is practiced

Duas

What’s the source for O Jabir, the first thing God created was the light of your Prophet, then He created from it all good.

Bihar Alanwar vol 15 p. 24

Do we have any hadith saying that men and women are equal in religion or in the eyes of God?

Holy Quran 49:13
------------------
يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ إِنَّا خَلَقْنَاكُم مِّن ذَكَرٍ وَأُنثَىٰ وَجَعَلْنَاكُمْ شُعُوبًا وَقَبَائِلَ لِتَعَارَفُوا ۚ إِنَّ أَكْرَمَكُمْ عِندَ اللَّهِ أَتْقَاكُمْ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ عَلِيمٌ خَبِيرٌ

O mankind! Indeed, We created you from a male and a female, and made you nations and tribes that you may identify yourselves with one another. Indeed the noblest of you in the sight of Allah is the most Godwary among you. Indeed Allah is all-knowing, all-aware.

Holy Quran 16:97
------------------
مَنْ عَمِلَ صَالِحًا مِّن ذَكَرٍ أَوْ أُنثَىٰ وَهُوَ مُؤْمِنٌ فَلَنُحْيِيَنَّهُ حَيَاةً طَيِّبَةً ۖ وَلَنَجْزِيَنَّهُمْ أَجْرَهُم بِأَحْسَنِ مَا كَانُوا يَعْمَلُونَ

Whoever acts righteously, [whether] male or female, should he be faithful, We shall revive him with a good life and pay them their reward by the best of what they used to do.

Is it okay to work for a national airline of a country that is known to be enemies of Ahlubayt and their followers?

If the country is actively against the School of Ahlulbayt and by working in the airline you’re supporting that objective then you shouldn’t work there. This maybe difficult to show on this day and age however

Is there any way to find out if Allah has taken away HIS blessings away from me?

No. Allah will always give blessings. He gives blessings even to non believers of tyrants. This is the blessing of life for example and breathing etc

Is it permissible, if ones wife wants/permits her husband to give her bruises willingly, for the husband to do so for the mutual pleasure of the two as long as the bruises do not lead to considerable damage to her health.

If it’s not serious harm and does not involve putting anyone in difficulty then it’s permissible if under consent

1) Pedophilia has become a huge issue around the world. It is when grown men have sexual attractions to very young girls. Like a 40 year old man being attracted to a 9 year old girl. It is shamed all over the world. I would like to know what Islam has to say about this, since it doesn’t have any age restriction and that girls are allowed to be married off at 9

2) Aren’t 9 year olds too young to make a good decision on who to marry etc? Aren’t they too young to be handling a house/birthing children? Why is this allowed?

At this time, and due to change of society laws and other considerations, marrying a 9 year old would not be permissible

1) Is there any limit to how long a temporary marriage can be?

2) To fulfill her sexual desires can she do a short mutah a few times a year to to satisfy herself?
If no; why? Wasn’t mutah created for the purpose of satisfying ones needs?

3) Can the girl say no to the man if she doesn’t want to consummate?

4) Does she have to ask permission before leaving the house etc?

5) If a child is born, who gets to keep it?

6) Can a woman have a temporary marriage with a Christian/Jew?

1) Yes temporary marriage can be for any fixed period of time,

2) Yes a girl can marry to fulfill her sexual desires

3) Yes the wife can place the condition that there is no consumation

4) No she doesn’t need permission if she is not living with him

5) For a child, it stays with the mother for two years then it’s the husband who has it

6) A Muslim lady cannot marry a non Muslim under any circumstances

I have lived in England for about 6 years. I had couple of Bank accounts and was using credit cards as well.

While coming, I didn’t return the money used from credit cards and overdrafts used from Banks. What can be done in this case?

Also I was using mobile phone and laptop on installment and brought those things with me and never paid the remaining amount.
Please explain what should be done now?

You need to pay the amount as Rad Al-Madhalim

Please watch this video to find out more

https://youtu.be/42et1gpoW2U

I wanted to ask a few questions regarding umrah e mufridah;

1) Covering the ears isnt allowed, but is that only for men? (Like not in terms of hijab for women, but covering the ears to answer a phone call during ihram?) So do we pay kaffara on that?

2) Does the kaffara have to only be a sheep (or a goat is fine)?

3) I went for umrah during covid, so we had to wear face masks.
i) I tried to keep the mask as low as i could, and it covered my lower chin (which was still part of the face)
ii) And my mum, covered her chin area
So do we have to give kaffara?

4) I accidently looked into the mirror a few times, (there were too many mirrors in the hotel) and i accidently saw my reflection on my phone during ihram, so is there a kaffara on that?

5) Do the 25 things become haram after I wore my ihram or after I did my ihram niyat (so anything after masjid e shajarah)?

1. Yes it’s only for men
2. It depends what was violated
3. No as masks are obligatory
4. No kaffara as it was accidental
5. After you do niyya and say the talbiyah do the things become haram

1) I wanted to ask after performing ghusl for umrah e mufradah (before wearing your ihram), if a hair or two fall out, do you have to give kaffara? Or do you have to pay kaffara for hairfall after wearing ihram?

2) For umrah e mufradah, do you also have to wear ihram for tawaf un nisaa and tawaf un nisaa namaz?

1) There is no need to do anything. Since hair falls naturally and not done deliberately

2) You don’t need to be in ihram after taqseer so you can do tawaf al-Nisa without ihram clothes

I am a university student who recieves money from student finance. I’ve always wanted to go for hajj and I’ve finally managed to save up for it but am I allowed to perform my wajib hajj with this money? (Although It is a loan, I only have to pay it back when I earn a certain amount, so does that make it valid?

Yes you can do hajj with what you mentioned

I have been going through depression and anxiety due to my past sins. I get dreams about the things I have done and it depresses me because all those things are now haunting me. I have repented to Allah and I am trying to walk on Sirat e Mustaqeem but these dreams and thoughts are ruining my efforts. Can you please suggest me a way to get rid of these anxious and depressive thoughts?

1. Seek therapy such as CBT
2. Know it’s Shaitan who is trying to affect you
3. Don’t lose hope from mercy of Allah
4. Recite these Duas

https://youtu.be/jBHfQUwDwLE

https://youtu.be/CZKMX9LK4YQ

During Ramadhan, is it permissible to travel for leisure such as a hike or to visit friends when this will involve breaking fast due to distance and perhaps staying overnight? The trip is non essential and not work

It is permissible but makruh (not advised)

I wanted to know if lanolin cream is halal if taken into the mouth? This is used by mothers for their own care when nursing children to heal their damaged skin. But I wanted to know that if this goes into the babys mouth will it be considered haram? I read that it is created from the hair of the sheep and wanted to know of that source of extraction is valid or not.

If it causes harm it will be haram. If it goes in small amounts and not intended for ingestion and doesn’t cause harm to baby then it’s ok

As per the UK medical law, if any doctor is practicing and they are visiting patient wards, it is necessary for them to be bare below elbows (they need to fold their sleeves upto elbow) however when they exit the ward to other areas they can roll their sleeves down. I wanted to know if in this situation is it allowed for a women who is a doctor to work? Can she work and roll her sleeves up when in ward and roll them down when she comes out of ward?

If this is the law and there is absolutely no way out, and by not doing it, it places unbearable hardship on them (eg losing job), then it’s ok but should be done only as minimum as possible

Is it ok to recite the third shahada about Ali in tashhahud, not as a part of prayer in itself, but with the intention of additional dhikr (the same way we do with adhan for example)? To conform with the hadith stating that we should mention Ali after having mentioned the Prophet.

According to Ayatollah Sistani this is not permissible

I am a revert and I still live with my non-muslim parents a grand part of the year. They are neither ahlul kitab.
For this reason, it is really difficult for me to respect the law of tahara especially when it comes to food, and it really saddens (and sometimes angers) my dad when I do not want to eat with them (he doesn’t know why but he is figuring it out).
I wanted to know, am I allowed to eat with them for the sake of maintaining family ties even if I know the food or the ustensil used to prepare it has been touched by their wet hands ?

Yes based on secondary considerations it’s ok for you to eat with them

When doing wudhu, after washing my face I forgot which side of the hand to wash first. I thought it was the left side, and began pouring water on my left hand. After a few seconds I realized the right arm should be first. So I then followed the correct procedure and completed my wudhu. Is my wudhu invalid because I mistakenly began washing my left hand first?

In such a case you should start your wudhu again by washing the face

I’m a Shia and I generally respect every other Muslim but sometimes I feel extreme anger at them for their beliefs (especially for Salafis) and I lose my temper and then they accuse me of "taqqiyah". I know this is wrong as they are Muslims too and have rights over me like any Muslim but sometimes I cannot control my anger. What can I do to avoid this?

Put yourself in the shoes of the Holy Prophet or Imams who had to deal with much worse

Be grateful for the blessing of Wilayah and pray for them.

Look at each of them as potentials who maybe guided

The Quran says don’t worry about others but protect yourself

Holy Quran 5:105
------------------
يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا عَلَيْكُمْ أَنفُسَكُمْ ۖ لَا يَضُرُّكُم مَّن ضَلَّ إِذَا اهْتَدَيْتُمْ ۚ إِلَى اللَّهِ مَرْجِعُكُمْ جَمِيعًا فَيُنَبِّئُكُم بِمَا كُنتُمْ تَعْمَلُونَ

O you who have faith! Take care of your own souls. He who strays cannot hurt you if you are guided. To Allah will be the return of you all, whereat He will inform you concerning what you used to do.

I’d like to give small amount of charity everyday but it’s not possible to always donate small amounts online so I set aside the money and then send it one day. is this okay even if the money is not going directly to the needy everyday.

Yes it’s fine but the money you put aside is not considered charity until it reaches the poor or the needy

When I used to be sunni, we had adhkar of the morning, evening and before sleeping. Is there anything like that in shiism?

Yes ofcourse

Here is a good source

https://www.duas.org/mobile/morning-evening-duas.html

I was wondering if there were any ahadith emphasizing the importance of a exercise and incorporating an active lifestyle.

Yes there are a few
For eg: a believer is strong is better than a believer who is weak

I have a question regarding the prayer times.
We know that we can combine prayers and Sura 17, verse 78 says this:
"Establish Prayer from the declining of the sun to the darkness of the night; and hold fast to the recitation of the Qur’an at dawn" (3 times: Fajr, Dhuhr + Asr, Maghrib + Isha)
In Sura 11 verse 114, Allah says:
"And establish the Prayer at the two ends of the day and in the first hours of the night."
What I have heard is that the two ends of the day are Fajr and Maghrib, the first hours of the night is Isha. So adding them all up, it would be Fajr, Dhuhr, Maghrib and Isha.
Would this interpretation be correct? Doesn’t this mean that we’d have to pray Isha at its time without combining it with Maghrib?

No it’s not correct. The Quran is explained by Hadith of Ahlulbayt. In Hadith the current way of prayer is clearly established. We cannot interpret legal verses by ourselves since we need Gods representatives to explain to us

I was wondering if you know any English books about Allah swt and Tawhid. I would love to learn about it.

This is good

https://www.al-islam.org/god-and-his-attributes-sayyid-mujtaba-musavi-lari

I was wondering how a person can really concentrate on Allah swt in salah? Like what should we think about in our minds. For me my mind wonders off but then I try to get it back to Allah swt. What is the solution to this?

These are two books I recommend you read to get this done properly

101 Ways to Concentrate in Prayer https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/190811021X/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_glt_i_W86S0H73CYSPASMEZZ8N

https://www.al-islam.org/adab-salat-disciplines-prayer-second-revised-edition-sayyid-ruhullah-musawi-khomeini

I was wondering if my wudhu would be invalid because I have cats and I do wudhu with my normal clothes that could have some cat hair on it but i have different clothes that I wear when I pray so I don’t have any hair on that. So my question is would my wudu be invalid because I could have cat hair on my normal clothes when I perform ablution?

Clothes with cat hair do does not invalidate wudhu

How do we perform salat al Layl while sitting? Does it suffice in being in direction of qibla and reciting without movement, or should one bow and prostrate too if he’s sitting.

Is it true we can pray salatul al layl as we’re driving too for example?

Whilst sitting you can bend for ruku and go down in sajda
If u don’t want to then yes head movements for ruku and sujud suffice

Yes it can be done whilst driving since qibla is not wajib for recommended prayers

What is the argument against the idea that we are just playing out Gods plan for our life thus we don’t really have true free will? If whatever we do is decided by God anyway, how are our choices important?

Simple way is this: if all was predetermined this life is useless, since God is Just and why would he then place some in hell and others in paradise if they had no free will? They can say it’s not us who did wrong for eg

In the west, we have to deal with people who belong to the LGB2Q…(etc).. community. My question is: if I have a lesbian woman as a classmate where we have to do class activities that require touching and exercising together, is this ok and halal considering her interest in women.

Another question, should I observe hijab in front if a transgendered woman?

Yes you should observe hijab and try to avoid any activities that you described

1) Is it allowed to love or have affection and attraction towards a person (opposite gender) someone wants to marry (marrying that person is the intention), but that other person doesnt know that he/she loves him/her?

2) Also, if it’s allowed, is it also allowed to ask Allah to make us get married to that specific person?

3) Another Sheikh was talking about this same topic and told that love happens naturally and it’s not something a human can feel or falls on his own. Firstly, is this true? and secondly, if it’s natural, does Allah himself put this love in the heart or is it just a human instinct?

1) Love is not the same as lust. Love exists in the heart and difficult to remove.

2) Hence as long as no lust exists, one can pray to Allah to bring the two together in marriage yes

3) I’m not sure I agree. Yes Allah places it in hearts but people can fall in love themselves

I have a disease which make me very skinny so I am really underweight and I have met a few doctors who told me that fasting is not good for me. Is it okay if I do not fast?

If fasting is harmful for you then it’s haram to fast

1) What is the penalty of not giving khums for a year or missing it?

2) If I didn’t give khums previous year and giving it in the next or current year, would the khums of previous year be considered "expenses" and deducted from your profit as part of the current year or would I have to give 1/5th khums on the previous year khums as well as for the current year?

3) If i am living in USA, do I have to give khums in USA to the merja representative or would be ok to give khums to a representative in different country?

1) Just do istighfar for missing khums

2) Go back and calculate khums on the date you were supposed to. Then for next year after that, take this calculation into consideration

3) You can pay khums to anyone anywhere who has proper ijaza from your marjie

1) Is it permitted to have body sculptures or artworks hung up at home?

2) Is it permissible for both full and half bodies?

1) It’s permissible

2) Yes

My question is related to rights of family when it comes to religious activities. For example, if my wife tells me to not go for international travel to avoid the chances of covid, but I want to travel to Karbala. Now what should I follow? She is right in a way as it is a risk these days and I I will risk my own life and her life possibly.
What is more important here?

Like many decisions in life, you have to look for advantages and disadvantages
In this case you need to make a decision ideally based on consultation. But if you can’t agree, you don’t have to listen to your wife and you can travel

Why is the blood money for women half than that of men? Some people use this as an excuse to justify that the worth of a women is half the worth of a man. Is this true?

This is not correct and we must not spread this. The blood money for both is the same

In Islam it’s recommended to visit the graves. I don’t live in a Muslim country but here in the west. Can I visit any cemetery like a Christian or I have to find a Muslim cemetery in the west

If it’s a visit just to see graves and remember death there is no problem. But praying and reciting Quran for the dead should only be in a Muslim cemetery or section

I have a question regarding Khums on savings for building my first home.

I saved up and bought a plot of land where I plan to construct my house after a few years.
My question is that what is the ruling on paying Khums on that plot of land and the amount being saved up for construction of my first home.

According to Ayatollah Sistani, if where you live it is expected or a societal norm for you to buy a house then the savings for a house (which is based on your status or income appropriate) is excluded from Khums

I was wonder if it would be permissible to invest in index funds/etfs. An index is basically a big basket of many stocks combined together into this one unit. Big ETFS that you may have heard of would be like The Dow Jones, S&P 500, etc.

But the problem is, these etfs may include one or two companies that produce their income based off of Haram items, like for example an alcohol company, even though majority of your gains may be coming from other stocks within the index, would the profit from even one Haram business make the buying of the index impermissible?

If the investment involves any company or product that is haram, eg alcohol, then it’s not allowed.

I wanted to know about the origins of istikhara and whether it has any basis in the Quran please?

Everyone document I’ve read simply goes into the different types of istikharas. I’m aware of the different types, I just would like to know its origin and if it has any basis in the Quran?

See this

https://www.al-islam.org/istikhara-seeking-best-allah-swt-muhammad-baqir-haideri

We have been advised all our lives that obeying our parents is the ultimate responsibility of children. Please advise what are its limitations and how far does it apply to? As it does not make sense for children who are baligh, who is married and his decisions affect his own family (wife) where many of the opinions come from cultural values and are affecting our family life. Is the man able to take decisions for himself and his family even if his parents do not agree with it? What are its limitations?

Well he should not make decisions that hurt his parents. It doesn’t mean however that he has to agree with them or do whatever they say but rather respectfully disagree trying not to hurt them if possible

Is it permissible to build a GoFundMe in order to buy books for research and study?

If the objective is made clear for the donors then there is no problem

Wanted your view on the following with regards to birth & reproduction system of the Holy Imams (as):

1. Al Majlisi reports (& probably others) that Imams are not carried in the wombs but only in the thighs & given birth from the thigh.
Is this true?

2. As reported, Imams (as) go in to sajdah/prostration right after birth.
Is this true as well?

3. Finally, do Ahlulbayt (as) reproduce via eyes, tears/fuild from the eyes?

All the above in my opinion is in sharp contrast with the functioning of a human body.
If any of the above are true – can we conclude that they (as) are not completely ’human’ in terms of biology.

1. This is not established
2. Yes we have evidence pointing to this
3. No I have not seen this

1- After marriage when I visit my parents place, I have to consider it as my hometown?
2- What if I visit my birth place town.

Yes both places are considered home town

Just wanted to know if we can give hadiya of recited quran for our dear ones who are alive? Or those s who are very sick? Kindly advice

Yes that is fine

My question is, is a woman supposed to wear the head scarf, ie hijab, in front of a blind man?

She does not need to wear hijab if he is completely blind, although Lady Fatima (a) did so in front of a blind man and hence it’s best

I need some clarification. If I have qadha fajr namaz, can I pray it right before my Dhur/Asr namaz or Maghrib/Ishaa namaz? I heard that I can’t make it up right before the time of another wajib Salaat.

You should do it after the wajib

I have a question around taking on debt from a bank for a mortgage. I see on the sistani site it says its permissible as long as its "not with the intention of a loan". What does this mean? When you take out a mortgage the intention is always for housing. I dont think anyone takes out a loan to pay back more money

Change the intention to something else like a grant for example

An elderly member in our family just passed away. She suffered from a mental illness (psychotic behaviours) and thus she had not prayed or fasted for many years. Do her children have to ensure her prayers and fasts are paid for?

The executor of the will or oldest son or daughter is responsible and yes must seek to get someone to do the salah or do it themselves

I have some questions regarding black magic. When I was a sunni, there was belief that magic can harm people to an extent that can even kill them. Please advice.

Evil eye can happen but not cause death as such.
It’s important not to blame black magic on unfortunate things that happen to us as part of trials of life.

https://youtu.be/Bl9-n-_GaSM

I’m on a ambition to study more about God’s essence and the Attributes of God, is there any books or lectures that you can recommend me?

This book is good

https://www.al-islam.org/god-and-his-attributes-sayyid-mujtaba-musavi-lari

With due respect i wanted to ask – if it is okay to choose a spouse according to my wish (as I am a girl).

Yes that’s is entirely fine
Keep praying and don’t give up
If you find someone then take the first step first. Lady Khadija (a) did

If a woman (never married before) marries a man who was married before (divorcee), who does he go into jannah with?

He will have the choice

At the time of marriage my family members informed my husband about my decision to work after the completion of my degree. He had no Objections at that time. But now he is refusing to allow me to work, even though I fulfill all my marital duties. He says that he takes that permission back and won’t allow me to work.
Is it permissible for me work without his consent?

Was this a condition of the marriage? If it’s agreed upon then it’s a condition
To resolve this you need to gain the permission of your marjie or their representatives where you live

I have a question regarding property advisory.
Recently I bought a plot on installment basis for my cousin. Plot down payment was 135000. I was in contact with marketing agency, they told me on my regarding they will take 90 thousands as down-payment and the remaining amount is my commission, they did that discount for my commission purposes otherwise the normal down-payment is 135000.

My question is do I have to let my cousin know about this. If I tell him may he demand some amount from my commission. If I do not telling him, then what will be rule for this in Islam. Is it halal or haram?

If this is your business and you buy and sell property, and your cousin if one of your normal customers, and it’s expected that you make a profit from a sale and this is known by people (ie not hidden) then you don’t need to tell him. Otherwise you must tell him as it will be deception.

If Allah SWT is infinite, then how/where does the universe exist?

It exist in a finite space as a creation of the infinite Lord

I wanted to ask regarding accounting/accountancy/finance jobs are any type of jobs related to these haram?
Or any roles related to these I should avoid

If they support companies or organisations that deal with haram and aids their work, then you need to contact the office of your marjie to get permission. For example if you do accounting for an alcohol company or a betting company etc. Most scholars would say this is haram

Allah created Earth so it can be a temporary home for us. However he has also created other planets such as Saturn and Mars. What are the purpose of these?

See these verses. It’s all for human beings to benefit. We may not know how

Holy Quran 14:32
------------------
اللَّهُ الَّذِي خَلَقَ السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضَ وَأَنزَلَ مِنَ السَّمَاءِ مَاءً فَأَخْرَجَ بِهِ مِنَ الثَّمَرَاتِ رِزْقًا لَّكُمْ ۖ وَسَخَّرَ لَكُمُ الْفُلْكَ لِتَجْرِيَ فِي الْبَحْرِ بِأَمْرِهِ ۖ وَسَخَّرَ لَكُمُ الْأَنْهَارَ

It is Allah who created the heavens and the earth, and He sends down water from the sky and with it He brings forth crops for your sustenance. And He disposed the ships for you[r benefit] so that they may sail at sea by His command, and He disposed the rivers for you.

Holy Quran 14:33
------------------
وَسَخَّرَ لَكُمُ الشَّمْسَ وَالْقَمَرَ دَائِبَيْنِ ۖ وَسَخَّرَ لَكُمُ اللَّيْلَ وَالنَّهَارَ

He disposed the sun and the moon for you, constant [in their courses], and He disposed the night and the day,

Holy Quran 14:34
------------------
وَآتَاكُم مِّن كُلِّ مَا سَأَلْتُمُوهُ ۚ وَإِن تَعُدُّوا نِعْمَتَ اللَّهِ لَا تُحْصُوهَا ۗ إِنَّ الْإِنسَانَ لَظَلُومٌ كَفَّارٌ

and He gave you all that you had asked Him. If you enumerate Allah’s blessings, you will not be able to count them. Indeed man is most unfair and ungrateful!

how can I do tawassul? What kind of words should I say? And do I have to pray rakats before doing tawassul?

You can recite Du’a tawassul

Link is here:
https://www.duas.org/tawassul.htm

Based on hadiths quoted by Masoomeen (as), chess is considered haram and strictly prohibited, whereas some of the mujtahideens have considered playing it halal as long as there is no galmbling or money betting involved.
I’m a follower of Ayatullah Fayaz. Could you please help me with this query?

According to Ayatollah Fayyadh, it’s not permissible even without gambling or money

http://shiaonlinelibrary.com/الكتب/804_منهاج-الصالحين-الشيخ-محمد-إسحاق-الفياض-ج-٢/الصفحة_108

Is astral projection halal?

1. Islam establishes that soul exists. It travels to other existence after death.
2. In some rare cases yes the soul can be separated from body in this world but this is very rare and with permission of God

But this idea as such of astral is not within Islamic teachings

My question is related to gunah e kabira like being in na-mehram relationship, lying, etc. Especially when the person knew they were doing gunnah but couldn’t restrain, had fear in heart but were somewhat trapped.

If a person has the fear that disclosing their sins for punishment will lead to discomfort, and they seek direct forgiveness from Allah Almighty with a pure heart, and restrain from any gunah, is it acceptable?

Or should the person get punished for act of zina, in order for their tauba to be accepted by Allah Almighty?

No you should not disclose the sin but ask sincerely from Allah for repentance

I wanted to know if it is allowed in Islam for women to work in an environment surrounded by namehram and make a career alongside looking after their family if her husband permits?

As long as Islamic hijab is practiced and modesty maintained then there is no problem

Are we allowed to download the piano app on our phones to practice maqamaat (in tuning), or to play simple tunes like twinkle twinkle, happy birthday etc.?

Yes no problem, since piano is used for music that is not played in areas of haram

If a woman has done aqd but then decided to divorce before consummating the marriage will she still need the permission of the father when she decides to marry again?

If she is still a virgin then yes. She needs father’s permission

Can I work in a restaurant where they serve haram chicken, pork, sausage etc? And can I eat the vegetarian food from there while washing all the utensils

Washing utensils in which alcohol has been presented from is not permissible. Otherwise it’s fine.
Yes vegetarian food can be consumed (if it doesn’t contain other haram ingredients)

The Euro million lottery and national lottery in uk have a portion given away to charities. Which help the community in many projects such as education, health, sports and community projects etc.

1. If I buy the lottery with intention of my money helping towards those projects and not winning. Is it halal to buy the lottery?

– If i win anything, what is the ruiling on the money. Can I use it as permissible halal?
– Is it halal to use as loan for investment? And give away the amount I won to charity after?
– Halal to give away to anyone else in family?

2. I give away the said lottery to someone else before the winning numbers i.e. i buy the lottery and do not care of the winnings or not but only bought to contribute my money that I paid to buy the lottery to the charity causes of lottery and then gave the lottery ticket as gift to someone else (i.e someone in family) before any winnings known. And specify that I do not want or intend on any rights of any winnings no matter how big. Is it permissible for the other person to accept a lottery ticket as gift?

Will the winnings if any from the lottery be halal for the person I gave it to in this case?

What if they gift me anything or use that money to buy me something is that halal for me.

3. Please clarify in which cases of the action of buying a lottery or raffle is deemed permissible and in which cases the winnings of a lottery or raffle is deemed ok to accept.

4. Are raffles considered ok if the motivation to buy the ticket was to win something? why are raffles genrally considered. ok?

Please see answers here

https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01240/

I heard that Imam Mehdi meets with high rank Ayatollahs who are very high in piety and guides them and etc. Does this have any basis supported by Authentic Hadith or Quran?

No this is not established
It’s a possibility just like the Imam meeting any other person

I’m a Sunni who is thinking about converting to a Shia but I’m very confused on 1 particular matter which is not the faith itself but with the clerics. I have several Shia friends and some of them follow Iranian clerics such as Ayatollah Khamaini and Makerem Shirazi while the others follow Ayatollah Sadiq Shirazi. Both of them tell me to convert to their side because the other side aren’t true Shia and have extreme beliefs and they fight eachother over their scholars. The Iranian clerical Shia friends tell me the other side is funded by western governments while the followers of Ayatollah Sadiq Shirazi say that the other side is too soft and does "Taqqiyah". They constantly confuse me and curse the other sides scholars. I’m so confused I’m thinking of not turning Shia anymore because both sides seem so ignorant to me. What can I do in this situation to further my knowledge and decide which side to follow in taqlid?

My advice is to follow Ayatollah Sistani who is considered to be the most knowledgeable Shi’a jurist by many. Regarding what you said, it’s claims by followers who are emotional and biased. It’s best to contact the actual offices rather than rely on what people say

I wanted to ask you, if sometimes we’re talking to non mahrams, like for example at the grocery store or drive-through or at the cashier, and let’s say the non mahram is talking and as she’s talking she smiles and I smile back, is it haram?

If the smile is not malicious or comes with lust or desire and doesn’t not lead to haram then it’s ok

There’s a brother, who was asking me a question about Shirk, and if it’s forgiven or not, and I gave him the example of Pharaoh, and told him, that he’s a mushrik.

And that he won’t be forgiven, because he knew Allah (SWT) and still decided to deny him and not submit.

So he asked this, and I don’t know how to answer:

Do you mean that those who die a mushrik knowing all well in their hearts that Allah exists (because they want to seem different and are arrogant) are the ones that are unforgiven?

And that those who die a mushrik simply because they were overwhelmed by all these religions and did not know what to believe could be forgiven?

So basically, even dying a mushrik depends on why you died a mushrik? and is not an instant death sentence?

Quran says if you die a mushrik Allah will not forgive you.
So the state at time of death is important

If someone sees a woman’s face, and looks away, and within his own self, he says, MashAllah she’s beautiful.

Is it a sin?

The key thing is looking away
Admiring beauty without bad thoughts or lustful intentions may not be haram

If one is in a vehicle travelling (bus/train/plane) Should you pray right away when the time for prayer has been established, or wait til after you get off before praying. This is in the case one is certain there is enough time to pray the prayer after getting of the vehicle, (prayer will not become qaza.) There are usually many obstacles praying when in a confined space, such as having to pray whilst seated, very tight places to make wudu, and not beeing able to concentrate properly etc. But I know that the best reward and effect of ones prayer is at the very begining of the prayer, so I want to know the better option, even if both waiting and praying right away is permissble.

If you know that after reaching there will be enough time to pray properly then you should wait and pray somewhere that you can fulfil all the conditions of salah (eg standing)

Is touching old woman permissible if she needs a hand?

It depends if she has reached in-marriyable age and it is something that is necessary (no alternatives)

I want to cosmetically fix my teeth I.e. straighten them/whiten/file. I just wanted to ask is it halal to pay this off via finance that involves interest. Also is filing the teeth to remove cracks ok?

Yes it’s fine to do this.
In terms of loan, your intention should be that you’re not paying interest but gifting them the extra money

Is it permissibile to deliver non-halal food to non-Muslims as part of my job? What about pork and alcohol?

What about delivering fish without scales or seafood/ shellfish to non-muslims and sunni muslims?

1) It’s not permissible to deliver alcohol or pork products. Other than this non halal meat can be delivered to non Muslims

2) Yes that is fine

My sister has a son and she breastfeeds him. It’s been a few days since her son doesn’t eat well and keeps asking for breastmilk. Now that his daily nutrition almost only depends on my sister’s milk, she’s afraid that if she fasts it might affect his nutrition. Is it permissible for her to, for example, to fast every other day and eat well on other days so that she can be sure her son can have the right nutrition?

If fasting is harmful for her or her baby she can break the fast

In a temporary marriage who has more right over the wife: the husband or the father?
Furthermore, if the husband wants his wife to visit him can the father prevent his daughter from going to her husband or can she disobey her father if her husband wants to see her?

It’s the husband, since the father gave permission for the marriage .

Do you know what the ruling is for Sayed Sistani in regards to signing up for a record company if someone was capable of being an artist in that record rather than listen? In other words, they would record the anasheed but is there ishkaal on it?
Would it be haram to sign up for this?

If it’s recording halal anasheed there is no problem.

I am a revert to Islam, for more than half a year now.
I’m unsure what I need to know of the economical duties.

Is there any other economic obligations? And how do I fulfill those duties.

What you need to know about is khums

https://www.al-islam.org/khums-islamic-tax-sayyid-muhammad-rizvi

I have a microsized business developing websites and have been applying for covid based grants. One alcohol making company has a grant for California based small businesses offering 25 people $10,000 grants. Is it permissible to go after this grant and receive funds from this type of company? Would the funds be halal?

If the company is solely for sale of alcohol then it’s funds are illegitimate and hence receiving from them is not permissible

My mother wakes up my brother (baligh) for fajr everyday. She tries to wake him in a calm way however he doesn’t wake up and it ends up that my mother is just forcing him to wake up every morning. It comes to a point where she is nagging him and it seems like he is beginning to hate the prayer itself as she comes into his room multiple times to wake him up and they sometimes begin to argue etc. Please can you advise whether it is correct to keep nagging in this way as I fear it is causing more harm than good.

It should be done in a nice way. Conversation must take place during the day on importance of Salah. There are tips on how to help our children pray. Please see my video on Noor Islamic education YouTube channel

Imam Ali P.B.U.H. says "Doubt extinguishes the light of heart". I think that Shaytaan’s most powerful weapon for a believer is doubt. And needless to say I am entangled in it. I need someone’s help. I would really appreciate it if you could help me. The topic of doubts is purity. In Quran Allah says "We do not burden a soul more than it can bear" but at this point I am feeling I can’t bear it any longer.

Having too much doubts should be ignored. Allah doesn’t not want to burden you. In Tahara (purity) don’t listen to whispering of Satan and ignore the doubt

You may also benefit from therapy related to OCD or get CBT therapy

I need to make sure that I have a correct Islamic will.
I have a wife and only daughters and my will states that in the event of my death or of my wife then all of our belongings will transfer to one of us and after us will be split equally amongst the daughters.

Both our parents have waived their rights to any inheritance.

Please kindly advise if this will is possible.

From what you described it’s only valid islamically if the daughters consent now to all inheritance being revived by you or your wife if one of you dies. They should do this by writing or verbally if they’re mature

Can you please help me with ways to focus more on deen and detach myself from wordly pleasures. Most of time I feel lonely and to avoid that feeling I engage myself talking with people but then I feel guilty and attachment really hurts

1. Increase knowledge by signing up to Islamic courses which are reputable.
2. Visit cemeteries and remember death.
3. Do self accountability every day.
4. Busy yourself with halal activities and don’t be bored.
5. Recite Quran and Du’a but reflect
6. Do a good deed project by helping others
7. Join Islamic organisation and get good friends

I have a family member who has been suffering with mental health for a long time, and has not prayed in years. We have tried to advise him but he does not listen. But in Ramadhan, he always fasts with us. Will he be rewarded for his fasts, despite not fulfilling his obligatory prayers?

Allah knows best. Yes there will be reward Insha’Allah.

It’s noted Imam Ali A.S & Fatima Zahra A.S had 5 Children together but did they have a Daughter named Sukayna?
I’m asking based off these 3 sources referring to Her as their Daughter

Mustadrak Safeenatul Bihar by al-Namazi volume 5 page 90

Wasa’il al-Shia by Hurr al-Aamili volume 14 page 168

and Bihar al anwar volume 45 page 104

I would love to know your opinion on this. There is also a shrine for Her in Damascus so she obviously existed & was the daughter of Imam Ali A.S the question is who was her mother

Yes he did have a daughter by name of sukayna but not from Lady Fatima (a)

1) According to Ayt. Sistani ruling on Muta (ruling 2439). The girl can stipulate no sexual intercourse. However, she cannot say the mutah cannot fulfil some sexual pleasure.

What exactly is defined as ‘sexual pleasure’ and what are its limits?

2) Can this ruling be explained? ie. Would the be muta be valid if there is no sexual pleasure derived from it?

3) If the couple originally stipulate no sexual intercourse but later on they both consent to it.

A). Do they need to draft a new contract?

B). Can they amend the existing contract?

C). If so, would the fathers permission be required to amend the contract (if the girl is a virgin)

1) The term sexual pleasures is self explanatory.

2) Yes the muta is valid if there is no sexual pleasures.

3 A) They can, but not needed

B) Yes they can if they both agree

C) Yes it should be sought if that was a condition of the marriage in the first place

What to do when you are feeling spiritually low and you start skipping prayers because you are not getting any benefit from prayers and procastinate tasks?

Visit the cemetery and spend one hour inside an empty grave if possible

Read about paradise

Be with positive and good people who remind you of Allah

Is it normal for men to wax their arms/legs, underarms, pubic area, chest or any other part of their body?
Any religious rulings or recommendations regarding to this?

What about indulging in facials and shaping eyebrows, manicures, pedicures.

It is usually ok except if it’s done deliberately to create fitnah or draw attention to ones self from opposite gender.

Can a human who is pious can perform miracles by the permission of Allah or only prophets and Imams will do it?

They can have what is known as karamat (blessings). Miracles are only for Prophets.

After a divorce, the child stays with the mom and mom’s family, can mom’s family change child’s name to child’s maternal grandfather?

No this is not allowed.

Is it permissible to eat Vegetarian Food at at restaurant that also serves pork.

Yes it’s permissible as long as there is no contamination.

I heard many things about prophet Yousef kids. Some say he had a daughter and son while some say 2 sons. Did Prophet Yousef have a daughter and son or just the 2 sons

It is a matter disputed in Islamic history.

I had a conversation with my father about mutah, and he gave me general permission to do so if I achieve certain conditions, primarily, am in a state of financial independence.

I don’t have anyone in my life, I sort of just asked before anyone did to see if the option was available to me.

Ultimately, does that still work? Or must I seek permission when I meet a specific man?

A general permission is fine

Is it permissible to lick my lips whilst fasting?

If there is anything on the lips that is external, for eg lip balm, then it’s nor permissible

However if there isn’t anything on lips then yes it’s ok

Eating Tuna Fish meat (whether available in packed tins or as a whole in fish markets) is Halal or Haram or Makrooh. Please Confirm.

Tuna is halal to eat

I would like to ask a question regarding use of Israeli products by us Shia Muslims. We live in the west where most of the household products are from Israeli owners like Tesco, M&S, Nestle etc. So what we are saying we can not go to any supermarket or buy products which belongs to Israeli owner? I am sure you will agree not every Jew is bad nor every Muslim is good. I’ll appreciate if you could provide guidance.

It needs to be clear that these companies give a lot of their revenues to Israel. I don’t think that’s the case. They may give some or small %

1) When one does a recommended ghusul for eg ghusul for Eid, laylatul qadr etc, does one still do wudhu for prayer?

2) Will the following ghusul cover wudhu:
Ghusul Janabah
Ghusul Haydh
Ghusul laylatul qadr
Ghusul Eid.
Is this correct? So other type of ghusul like after touching a dead body is excluded?

3) Can one take a total bath (for no reason), and make it as intention as a ghusul, and dont have to do wudhu for prayers?

1) Some established recommended Ghusls cover wudhu yes, like Eid and Laylatul Qadr but not all.

2) Wajib ghusl covers wudhu
So ghusl mayyit covers wudhu

3) No

A person made a vow that he will fast for a week if he passed his exam and passed his exam. If he didnt fast the 1 week vow immediately after or within the year, must he pay fidyah on these ‘vow fasts’?

No they can fast when they can and no fidya is payable.
However it shouldn’t be delayed too long except for a valid reason

Can one do qadha of regular prayers while one is a traveller who has to shorten his prayers?

Yes they can

Is there a difference in benefit/reward if one prefers to read the Holy Quran using a cell phone as opposed to a physical book copy.

It should be the same, and Allah knows best.

Do you have an answer about why Imam Ali(as) didn’t did not return the land of Fadak to the heirs of Fatima(as) when he became caliph?

Yes. He said I will not forcefully take that which was forcefully taken. Allah will be judge on Qiyama. Plus he couldn’t just use his power because people will say just because it's Khalid’s he took it not because Fadak belonged to Fatima (a)

Can we perform salah al layl in congregation?

That is not part of the sunnah of the Prophet (s) and so we are not allowed to do it in congregation

Do women need to do ghusl after a smear test (cervical screening)?

No.

Is it allowed for a Shia convert who practices Taqiyyah within her family to attend Shia Islamic centers and events without their knowledge provided that she is safe?

Yes it’s allowed.

I wanted to ask you, if you could help me come to know more about Imam Mahdi (A.S).

If you could give me a link or anything else, which could help me read more about him and his companions, and how to prepare myself.

This is a very good page that have many books to help

https://www.al-islam.org/person/imam-al-mahdi

What should one think about during prayer? Can I for example during one of my prayers only be thankfull to Allah, and think about my love for him, and in the next prayer maybe concenrate on my sins, and regret those during the whole prayer, and alternate in such a way? Or should there be something specific to have in mind whilst praying?

Yes what you mentioned is fine

Please read Imam Khomeini’s secrets of prayers book for more

My question is related to acquiring God given wisdom. Prophet Muhammad (s) said: “The person who devotes himself sincerely to God for forty days, streams of wisdom will flow from his heart to his tongue.” [Al-Suyuti, al-Durr al-Manthur, vol.2, p. 237].

1- How does one devote himself to God entirely? Are there any requirements? I feel as though keeping away from sin, and fulfilling ones obligatory requirments isn’t enough. I feel like there is something missing.
2- How to accuire sincirety in prayers? (prescense of heart) There are some prayers where I seem to have strong connection to Allah, and the next prayer all of a sudden I dont.
3- I have heard that if you are not able to cry during salatul layl, you should atleast pretend to cry, is this true?

1. Displaying sincerity
Definitely doing the wajib and staying away from haraam is necessary. Studying Islam sincerely and gaining knowledge
Serving others
2. Read Imam Khomeini’s book secrets of prayers
3. No

If ones parents are divorced and father says not to invite mother to ones home, do I have to obey him?

If it is his home, then yes you should have his permission

I understand we are not permitted to donate organs or our body for research after death.

One view is that in the absence of cadavers medical science will not progress and there will be more humans dead due to non availability of organs

Simultaneously we are allowed to receive organs from other donors after their death this appears unjust

Your views to understand this matter in the right perspective will be useful for youth

Yes this is current opinion of Ayatollah Sistani
Until the opinion changes, there are many non Muslims donating organs and Muslims are a minority in the West in any case

While giving ghusl to the Marhuma, there was a lot of blood coming out from the mouth. As we are taught in Fiqh rules, we have to flush out as much as we can to eliminate najasat. However, due to the current situations is it okay to leave the blood inside the mouth?

If you fear that there might cause an infection or it’s dangerous to those performing ghusl, then it’s ok to leave it. Perhaps place cotton inside the mouth to avoid the shroud becoming najis

Does swallowing sweat intentionally or unintentionally invalidate a fast? And lets say I pass near a restaurant and the dust from the barbecue stove flies over and I inhale it does that invalidate my fast?

1) Swallowing sweat intentionally invalidates the fast
2) The dust from barbecue, if it’s thick dust and you do so intentionally it invalidates fast, otherwise it’s ok

What are the rulings for the vaccine in light of recent tweet by sayed Khamenei? Is it ok to get it? As far as I know Pfizer and Moderna is available, not the China one

The statement by his eminence is mainly for people living in Iran.

Other scholars like Ayatollah Sistani have recommended the vaccine taken if benefits are greater than the harm

Some people told me that Imam al-Hussayn (as) was not « really » killed in kerbala, but God saved him exactly as he saved Jesus a.s from the cross, and he replaced him with an ennemy. Is that right ? The guy who told me this gave me a nussayri hadith. I want to know if we have this kind of version in imamiyyah school.

No such belief is held by our scholars. Those spreading this are exaggerating and are wrong

Is it permissible for men to wear perfume in public even if theres a chance it will attract the opposite gender. Is there any hadiths that address this for men specifically?

Yes it’s permissible and no problem

I've revently came across disrepectful image blaming the scholars for they way of wearing the turban. As you can see, they cites many ahadiths stating that a turban with tabiqhiyyah is the turban of Iblees (la) etc. So I would like to know why the majority of our 'ulemas wear the turban in this way? Even if these narrations were to be proven weak by their isnad, is it not better to act upon them by precaution ? Or is there another answer.

Yes they are weak, and for centuries the ulema have worn the turban like now. The ulema are very careful and would not have acted this way if there was a shubha (an issue or suspicion)

1) Is it permissible to see istikhara frequently for small tasks to know the will of Allah SWT?

2) Can an istikhara come out good for a task which is not allowed by Sharia? Or a task which is haraam?

1) Please watch this lecture to find detailed answers

https://youtu.be/cuMGgaiIZMo

I don’t advise istikhara for small tasks, only for those you’re really not sure about after using reason as well as consultation.

2) We cannot use istikhara for haram acts. It’s not valid

There is a mareez, for whom diagnosis hasn't helped yet in identifying the actual source of the disease, hence the existing treatments have not been helpful, (for almost 8-10 years now).

1) Given the situation, can we consider the patient with an incurable disease and give khaak e shifa as medicinal treatment. If yes, then how much quantity is allowed in a single dosage

2) How frequently it is permissible to intake.

1) Yes a very small amount mixed with water. http://duas.org/kshifa.htm

2) Only for shifa purposes whenever one wants

I wanted to know the Shia viewpoint on the order/compilation of the Quran.
I know that Uthman compiled the Quran and I have heard growing up that Imam Ali AS also compiled a Quran which uthman rejected. So does this mean the Quran that we read today has been compiled incorrectly I.e uthman compiled the Quran in a different order to that compiled by Imam Ali AS?
Another opinion I’ve heard is that the compilation by Imam Ali AS and Uthman was the same, the only difference was that Imam Ali’s Quran was annotated in that each verse was explained in terms of context and direction. Is this true?

Also if uthman did compile the Quran incorrectly then what of the promise of Allah in the Quran where He promises to protect the Quran? Because if you have a book that has the order messed up then it’s been tampered with and hence not ‘protected’?

Please read this chapter of Ayatollah Khoei’s book:

https://www.al-islam.org/al-bayan-fi-tafsir-al-quran-prolegomena-quran-ayatullah-sayyid-abulqasim-al-khui/8-collection-quran

I am a female. If I want to recite a verse when there is non mahram around for dawah/educational purposes, should I say It in arabic and English as this is recommended? Or just in english as I am a female?

I know we can't pray loud in front on non mahram, hence my question.

You can recite as long as voice is not made intentionally to draw attention or in a way to appeal to men. But it is better to exercise caution in any case and be careful

I am scared about the harsh punishments in islam. They are carried out to people who sin so I pray you help me gain back some ease.

Its especially in relation to homosexuals. I have homosexual family and other aquaintances. They aren't evil people SO I say hate the sin, not the sinner. But if this was an Islamic state, what would happen to them?

I understand your concerns
Firstly such sins must be first verified in an Islamic state. Meaning just because someone is homosexual doesn’t mean they get punished.
They must either confess on 4 different occasions or 4 different people witness them in the act.

Islamic criminal law is mainly a deterrent. Yes homosexuality is like other major sins, like adultary.

In non Islamic government no punishment must ever be inflicted

We treat people as human beings. We all make mistakes and err. We need help sometimes

Can husband stay at home instead of working? If the wife earns enough to sustain them?



Yes it’s permissible

1) When I urinate drops of urine/water which I use to wash urine are scattered and some drops may touch my body, whenever I notice it I try to wash it but there may be cases where I can't feel the drops coming. Will they still make me impure? If yes then how can I avoid it?

2) When I wash my private parts after urinating splashes of water comes back to me(water when hits the toilet seat bounces back to me). Since the "Splashback" touches my upper parts of legs it is not possible for me to see whether the urine is there or not. I know that the toilet seat is najis but is the water bouncing back is najis too? How can I avoid it?

3) My question is that I do istibra but sometimes even after doing that drops come out does that make me impure or ruin my Wudu?

1) If you don’t see the urine or najasah and you don’t know it’s there then there is nothing to worry about. It’s best to check every time just in case

2) Yes if the water for sure is splashing from a najis area, you must wash wherever the water splashes

Avoid the water splash, or clean the toilet seat

3) If you see urine clean it. It doesn’t not affect your wudhu provided area being washed or wiped in wudhu is Tahir

I had a question about halal/breathable nail polish. There are brands that say water can go through nail polish therefore we can do wudhu whilst wearing the nail polish. Is this allowed? And how would we test it to be sure the water goes through?

Yes I’m aware of these brands. After some research, eg Inglot, it’s hard to be sure. Some say it’s breathable and other tests say no. Some ladies have told me it depends how many coats of it you apply. The final decision is up to you. If you’re satisfied through research that it is you can use it and do wudhu. Precaution is best way however

What’s the ruling on turbah being in one place during salat? I have small children and ofcourse they pick up the turbah while I’m reading salat. Is it okay to pickup in my hand while not in sujood?

Yes it’s fine to hold it in your hands

Are we allowed to have pets in Islam eg cats, rabbits etc. And is it true that Angels do not enter a house which has pets ie cats?

Yes you’re allowed
There are narrations that point to angels not entering house if there is a dog

I'm having some difficulties with my husband that followes Khameini and Sistani.

I have been raised not to eat any seafood that doesn't have fins and scale. and as a result I've never eaten shrimp and prawn. The country I live in doesn't have a separate word for the 2 animal and they're both called Prawns which might be the reason why. My husband however eats both and it makes me upset when he does. I know many scholars say its makruh which to me is enough reason to stay away from it. I don't like that my husband eats it which I've made clear to him but he says its halal

Eating shrimp and prawns is halal and there is no issue with that

I understand you might not be comfortable but we are governed by God’s laws not our desires or thoughts.

Yes we should only eat fish that has scales except those that have been specified like shrimp.
https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01251/
See first question

Would like to know the extent of knowledge of our Holy Imams(as) regarding ilm-e-gayb/ knowledge of the unseen/ knowledge about past and future and so on.

Full answers in this documentary that I was part of

https://youtu.be/Lhu0Ec3JKRI

How do I dispose cds, pendrives with Islamic Content?

It is best to recycle if possible.
If not it can be destroyed as normal

Is it halal to consume multivitamins, which contain gelatine, but it has not been specified if that gelatine is derived from plant source or animal source or made synthetically?

Yes it’s permissible

I wonder how can we strengthen our relation with him and get ready for the reappearance? is there any books you recommend for starters?

Main thing is to do the obligations and to stay away from forbidden acts. To prepare for his reappearance by doing community work and Serving others, and establishing organisations and institutions to spread Islam and Shiasm as well as humanitarian work.

These two books are good


https://www.al-islam.org/shiite-encyclopedia/last-luminary


https://www.al-islam.org/al-imam-al-mahdi-just-leader-humanity-ibrahim-amini

Is study music haraam?

It is only permissible if it is to be used for halal purposes. For eg certain types of music are permissible. Ayatollah Sistani states that any music that is suitable for gatherings of vice and evil is haram. Hence any music not usually played on those gatherings becomes permissible.

I dont why I am not growing spiritually. I am praying Salat five times I recite Holy quran and supplications and I also seek religious knowledge but still it feels like that I haven't moved forward. I dont why I am not getting peace. I am anxious 24/7. Most of the time I am annoyed and its feels like everything is falling apart

We have to try our best. Leave the rest to Allah. Change your routines. Do things differently. Maybe volunteer to help the needy. Set yourself targets which are achievable. Don’t over stress yourself. Sometimes you might need therapy. Sometimes the right crowd or support from friends. This world is full of hardship and difficulties. Don’t let it put you off.

I don't remember quite yet but since the past 3 years I been committing a sin that is very bad. I want to get rid of this act but I am failing despite that I am committed to my prayers and still seek repentance. I don't want to do it but something is pushing me so hardd to committ this sin and I want to stop myself but I am failing now its feeling like I am faraway from Allah swt and holy prophet and Ahlulbayt (a.s). What should I do now? How should I control myself to not to commit this? The sin that I am committing is masturbation and watching pornography.

Firstly it’s very good that you feel you have wronged and you want to stop.

Allah is all merciful. He will forgive you. You must believe this. But this act is damaging you badly. It’s worse than poison. Your future will be very negatively affected because of it.

Please watch this clip I did. Also another clip on pornography. You need to do what is recommended. Practice it and reward yourself with halal if you don’t do the haram. You must busy yourself as boredom makes you think of haram. Ultimately maybe marry temporary or permanent to save yourself and your religion. But don’t give up as Shaitan wants you to give up

https://youtu.be/y8pypvuw2u8
https://youtu.be/4ErJBv70VHU

Could you kindly advice an amal that can be performed at the time of distress? And any specific amal to perform after fajar prayers or before fajar prayers that can maintain the peace and good energies and make you overthink less?

You can do this salah:


https://youtu.be/alDZrXTvP80


My question is related to the rulings in islam about marriage. Since "arranged marriage" is a norm in asian households, its usually the parents who choose a suitor for their children amidst this how is one supposed to judge a persons(possible spouse) akhlaq and living in diverse world. If you come across someone who you want to approach for marriage, we are blocked by some discriminatory rules.

1. Is it permissible for a shia sayed female to marry a non sayed or non shia muslim(keeping in mind that the discrimination between sayeds and non sayeds is very evident in the asian culture.) 

2. What are the rulings for inter sect marriages, why is it not encouraged.

3. What are the Islamic rights of a daughter who's father doesn't give her permission to marry out of sect.

1. Yes it’s permissible

2. It might create many problems in the future eg naming of children, ziyarah, matam etc

3. She needs to discuss this with a scholar because it may be depending on a number of issues

My another question is what rules, morals, behaviour and discipline Shia scholars follow because as per as I have noticed they all behave same in their morals,discipline and behaviour.
And if even I want to follow the behaviour and discipline of Shia scholars what should I do?

It is those of the Prophet and Ahlulbayt (a).

One good book to find out is this:

https://www.al-islam.org/ahlul-bayt-ethical-role-models-sayyid-mahdi-sadr

What state of mind or emotion a man should be always in according to Quran or hadees of ahle bait( as) because we cannot always be happy, sad or angry. So have Quran or our imams have said something about this? What emotion or state of mind we always try to be in?

According to Hadith of Ahlulbayt (a), a believe is sad in their hearts but always smiling. The reason is the yearning towards God and the desire to always do better but in terms of how we deal with people, it should always be pleasant and as much as possible hopeful and helpful to others.

Is it permissible to draw portraits of animals

Yes it is allowed as long as it’s no sculptured

1) As per Sayyid Sistani's rulings, are there certain instruments I am not aloud to learn to play, even if I use them only to practice non-amusement gathering styles of music? More specifically the piano, acoustic guitar, or violin?

2) Do his rulings show we should generally stay away from learning to play music (even if it may be considered a halal form) i.e. is there unavoidable spiritual risk in the act? I ask because I've never read a positive hadith regarding music, so the "ONLY amusement gathering music is haram" rulings seems quite liberal.


542. It is permissible for adults as well as children to learn the art of halal music in music schools or other places as long as their visits to such places do not have any negative effect on their proper upbringing.

https://www.al-islam.org/a-code-of-practice-for-muslims-in-the-west-ayatullah-sistani/music-singing-dancing

567. Question: Musical instruments are of different kinds. Sometimes they are used in musical gatherings and sometimes for soothing the soul. Is it then permissible to buy these instruments, manufacture them, deal in them, or play them to soothe the soul or listen to the ir sounds when someone else is playing them?

Answer: It is not permissible to deal in the instruments of haram entertainment: neither selling nor buying, just as it is not permissible to manufacture them and accept remuneration for making them.

“An instrument of haram entertainment” means that its physical shape—that gives its value and eventually the purpose for acquiring it— is not suitable except for use in haram entertainment.

Sayyid Sistani's new ruling shows that one only has to pay khums when his cumulative year on year income matches the amount left in his loan account. Supposing someone has multiple loan accounts, is this ruling refering to the total when all the values of the loan accounts are combined? Or simply when the smallest loan account value is reached by cumulative income?

It’s total loan
But ofcourse depending on some conditions which are stipulated in this document

https://www.world-federation.org/sites/default/files/Khums_Guide.pdf

I have some questions regarding obedience to ones parents.

1. Is obedience to ones parents unconditional if they are commanding something halal?

2. Say ones parents have such high expectations that it is realistically unreasonable for one to fulfill these expectations, yet they are disappointed and angry at their child for not fulfilling them (even if it may have been in his theoretical capacity to meet them). Has a sin been committed in this case?

3. Is it permissible to disobey ones parents in secret, if it has no chance of humiliating or displeasing them?

4. If ones parents command one to marry someone, is it obligatory to obey them or does the child have the right to say no? Conversely, if one has been ordered not to marry someone, is it obligatory to heed to this command?

5. As a man, is it still obligatory to heed their advice even if it may make them upset?

Please find answers to first three questions here in this answer by office if his eminence:

http://ijtihadnet.com/childrens-obligation-toward-their-parents-according-to-ayatollah-sistani/

Re 4, no it’s obligatory. Re not marrying someone it depends if it’s a girl or a boy, and the reasons for parents not allowing the marriage

5. Try as much as you can to make them understand. Do not disrespect them. But sometimes they will not accept and that’s the nature of human beings

Is it permissible to play cooking games on the phone if pork is included as an ingredient for some recipes?

It should be avoided

When is the Awal-waqt for Asr and Isha? Is the Awal-waqt and Waqt-Fadheela the same for both of them?

According to Ayatollah Sistani, for Asr is about 1.5hours after Duhr (for countries in Middle East) and for Isha its 45min after maghrib

But praying Duhr and asr together and maghrib and isha together is fine as well

1) We are planning to buy a house in UK as we have saved money for deposit but I wanted to know, is mortgage allowed if interest is attached with it?

2) If I don't buy a mortgage house to live in. can I buy for investment under interest mortgage.

1) Yes it is allowed

2) https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01256/

In lock down I was free so I was spending more time in praying and making dua and tasbeeh nawafil and now I hv joined work so I don't get much time. I feel something is missing.I'm not satisfied just praying 4 rakat namaz. What act should I do other than namaz while working? To get closer to Allah. And if I dont pray nawafil, tasbeeh and if I dont make long dua then is it a sin? Will I be questioned for this?

Do dikr whenever u can. Such as the 4 tasbihs. Recite salawat. No if you don’t do it, it’s not a sin. Do what you can. Allah will help you

I'm from India and almost in every company there are disbelievers so it's tough to make prayers on time. I get only 1 hour break and masjid is far and in the company it's not possible to pray? So what shall I do?

You’re not allowed to miss prayers. If you can’t pray on time then make sure you pray it before qadha. There is no excuse for missing prayers deliberately and it becoming qadha

My question is if a man lives in the UK and he has a female cat as a pet at home. I am worried that the cat will give birth to many children and it will cause difficulty in the household. In this situation, is it allowed to sterilise the cat so that it is not able to give birth?

Yes it is permissible.

My question is; if a man lives in the UK and he has a female cat as a pet at home. I am worried that the cat will give birth to many children and it will cause difficulty in the household. In this situation, is it allowed to sterilise the cat so that it is not able to give birth?

Yes it is permissible

I paid khums on 25th of November which is also the day I receive my salary.
I combined the total amount in both my regular account and my savings account, and paid 20% of that amount
I noted down how much I had left and how much I paid in Khums
In this case I had about 1200£ left after I've paid my khums

Now next year, do I just do the same thing by gathering the total amount, but instead minus the 1200£ and then 20% off the total amount?
Even if I used much of the 1200£ during the December month (expenses etc), I can still deduct 1200£ next year correct?

Yes so next year if you have £1400 in total (after doing all calculations and deducing deductible expenditure), you only pay khums on £200 which is £40

1. If grass becomes najis with urine or some other najasat how do we make it tahir considering that according to Ayatullah Sistani sun cannot make the grass tahir?
2. Just to confirm if a person does not have a turbah they can prostrate on stone such as aqiq right? Is it fine if the stone is in a ring?

1. You can wash it with water
2. Yes it can be used, provided there is stability during sajda

If a fixed carpet has become najis, to make it pak after removing the najasat we pour some water in that area and suck the water with a clean cloth. Instead of a cloth, can we use a vacuum cleaner which sucks water?

Yes

My husband runs a small mobile food stall. The raw food we buy which we eventually cook and sell, we claim it on taxes. According to the state government the food left at the end of the day we are suppose to throw it as it exceeds the food safety limit. However, that would be israf and hence, we don’t throw it and instead we use it at home. My question is, is it necessary for us to show it and cut it from taxes or is it fine if we claim all of it on taxes?

As per our marajie instructions to follow law of the land, you need to in this case to show what you do in the tax calculations accordingly. Alternatively you can give the food left over to the needy, or to family and friends (and may be able to then ask for some back). It depends if the government allows you to keep it. Perhaps a permission is needed from them.

My relatives keep majalis at their place. However, the speaker they appoint to give a lecture is not at all qualified. That person does not even know to read Arabic properly. She reads from a book and listens to a few other lecturers and gives a lecture. What should I do? Should I attend such a majlis? Everyone attends for sawaab. However, I don’t really gain anything from those majalis. I don’t really know what to do.

You should advise them. It’s important that majalis are recited by qualified people
If the content is not anti Islamic, then attendance is worthy because of reward of remembering Ahlulbayt (a) and mourning them

If I live in a rented house, does Hajj become wajib on me?

The accommodation does not have any bearing on this. It depends if you have sufficient funds for hajj and after you come back.

I wanted to ask, if someone has got an implanon implant (birth control) and is spotting on odd days, is one allowed to fast on such days?
This implies for qadha fasts, sunnah fasts and also wajib fasts

As long as the blood is not flowing continuously for days then fasting is ok for all the purposes mentioned

What is the rulling of two men having sex together?

This is not allowed in Islam

I wanted to know whether it is haram to avoid tax by a self-employed individual registering people as employees that do not actually work for them but receive income from them every month? I don’t think this is illegal but I wanted to know if this is haram or permissible? And if haram, on which parties is it haram and what would you have to do with the money received?

If it is breaking the law of the land, such that those caught will be prosecuted, it becomes haram

If marhooma didn't have much wealth in inheritence and with all her money the qaza fasts and namaz couldn't be completed. Then is it necessary for her child to pay from their pocket and get the remaining qaza namaz completed? What if only child is a daughter and doesn't earn money and is living on her son's and husband's income plus pocket money?

If the daughter is unable to pay, there is no obligation. She should try herself to do the qadha. If not maybe she can get help from her marjie from khums to pay someone to do it as she is poor

I'm aware that there is a significantly higher reward for praying in a Mosque as compared to home. However I was wondering, is the reward higher for praying in a Hussainiya as well?

If it’s in congregation definitely
By one’s self, if it’s an area where Allah is worshipped regularly, it may be the case, and Allah knows best. One can perform prayers there and hope for more reward inshallah

Why does one gets executed if he leaves Islam? Is this authentic?

This exists in Islamic narrations
It does not apply in a non Muslim state
Also it is being reviewed by scholars on whether it applies today, since it was the case when those leaving Islam became direct enemies

Wondering if buying and selling cryptocurrencies like bitcoin is halal. I heard it is prohibited by obligatory precaution(Sayed sistani). If so which marjas says that it is fine?

This summarises it

http://ijtihadnet.com/bitcoin-perspective-shiite-clerics-fatwas/

I have two questions regarding this

1- I am unable to recite Dua e abo Hamza Thumali in one go, can i recite it in breaks? For example i divide the dua in parts and recite parts of it each night.

2- Is it okay to recite the translation of dua ( the english part, because that way i can connect more with the dua as compared to arabic) or is it necessary to recite it in Arabic?

1. Yes that is fine and good practice

2. Definitely, as it’s important you understand what you’re reciting

I'm currently becoming a fitness professional and looking to open a gym in near future and in every gym there is music and people expect a gym with music system. Although my aim is to open a gym but will playing music in it will be haram for me? And earning through that gym also will be haram?
Please suggest what you think is right

Yes playing music which is haram is forbidden. Maybe you can play music which is not usually used in gatherings of haram, eg nasheed perhaps.

Is it permissible to read salah with your eyes closed as it helps me focus. Also what are some tips to improve your salah? What can I visualize when reading salah to help me focus. I heard Ayatollah Khomeini said to visualize a bird and concentrate on keeping it on the tree and prevent it from wandering off. Would you recommend this?

Yes it’s permissible
You will need to do many things to gain that focus
This books helps:

101 Ways to Concentrate in Prayer https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/190811021X/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_fabc_EYX07B3E4XQB5BR5RKEK

Can you recommend me some books to read. I think I know the basics pretty well and want something a bit more advance. Do you know of any books that are informative and get let me get a more in-depth understanding of islam. Also what field of Islam should I study on. Do you mind recommending me informative lectures?

You should study theology, our Aqeeda and beliefs

Here are some books:

https://www.al-islam.org/tags/beliefs

I am a 19 yo student but I feel the need for marriage. However in our culture, early marriage is something that is looked down upon. I have tried a lot to manage it but I think it’s beneficial for me to get married earlier than what my parents would want. How do I approach them even as approaching them would be considered bad in our culture? What can I do?

Yes I encourage you to seek marriage
You need to find people your parents respect. If you can’t influence your parents maybe scholars or other family members can. Also don’t forget to pray to Allah and ask intercession of Ahlulbayt (a). Be honest with your parents why you need to get married but also you must show responsibility and ability to lead a family through your own actions.

I have friends who say this ruling

Ruling 2452. With regard to a mubtadhilah(1) woman who does not take heed if someone enjoins her to observe hijab, there is no problem in looking at her on condition that it is not with lust and there is no fear of committing a sin. In this rule, there is no difference between disbelieving women and other women. Likewise, there is no difference between looking at their hands and face and other areas of their body which they usually do not cover.


The claim of my friend is that:
It’s allowed to look at the nakedness of disbelieving females. Even further more that if one views these things a lot they will fall in sin. Like if you know Tiktok there are dancing females who do such stuff such as twerking and stuff and they are non-Muslims but the claim is that it’s permissible to view these things. So if one stares at someone (a female who is almost naked but have their private parts covered) but without lust is it still haram? Also is the ruling to be interpreted that it’s accidental or if one clearly stares out of lust and no fear of falling into sin? Please explain to me regarding this whole issue!

Looking at such images even without lust should not happen because it’s very hard to look at them without lust for a male. Many of the marajie say even without lust it is haram. If they think looking at those videos etc of women without lust is possible they are being deceived by Shaitan

I know that men work and get money for themselves and they pay Khums from the money the earn but the important question is what about a woman? How does she have to pay Khums ? She doesn’t work. What is the ruling on her?

Khums is on any profit gained that is surplus to need. So for example, if a woman gets a gift which she does not use and date of khums arrives etc

Is it mustahab to have an hair cut or make your hair short? Is this a sunnah did the prophet or the imams do this?

It is important to be clean and maintain hygiene and cleanliness

I have a question regarding Khums.

1. If I am in a state of fear (regarding the economy and housing prices and assuming this is a legitimate fear) and I have decided to sell my house, would I have to pay khums on the money I received from selling the house after a year with the ONLY reason for selling is the fear ifself.

2. If I have to pay khums on the money, does it have to be in my possession for one year? My khums end year is June 30. Would I have to pay khums for that money on June 30 or exactly a year later from the time I received the money.

3. Is there any way I don't have to pay khums since I'm in a state of fear and have the intention to purchase a house with that money after some time when I am no longer in fear.

1. Fear is not a factor in khums. If you sell the house a day before your khums date, it’s wajib go pay khums on the date.

2. On the day where khums is due.

3. You would need to seek permission from your marjie’s office and explain the situation as much as possible.

How do you distinguish between backbiting against warning a person of someone's bad character? For eg:
1. We entrusted someone with money and that person misappropriated it. Do we not tell other people of this so that they would be spared of the same by this person? Do we tell of this behavior to the general public or on an individual basis?
2. Another example would be if we know a person to be of unsound character (bad tempered, disrespectful, violent etc), is it not our duty to tell if someone wants to choose him/her as their life partner?

Only in situations were you’re asked about this person for marriage or business for eg you’re allowed to tell them these issues. Otherwise exception is if you have been wronged clearly and oppressed and it has not been solved then you can raise the issue with people

In ziarat of Lady Fatimah, we read that she underwent a trial before she came into this world. Does this points to our existence too as spirits before we are brought into the wombs of our mothers?

Yes everyone was tested before this world, and those who succeeded were chosen to be God’s representatives

I have always thought that our Prophet pbuh &hf had only one daughter. But I heard on an online lecture that our Prophet pbuh & hf had 3 other biological daughters Zainab, umm Kulthum and Ruqqayah

There is a disagreement historically

Many Shi’a ulema believe the Prophet had one biological daughter only and the rest were adopted daughters from Khadija’s sister

However some (minority) have argued otherwise

After some research I agree with opinion that states only one daughter

How does one do the Qunut in Salatul witr doing the counting of 300 Al – Afuw. Can both hands be raised with one hand holding the tasbih or counter?

Yes one hand can count, there is no problem

In the olden days, girls are said to marry at a young age as young as 9. So was Lady Khadijah marrying at the age of 25 or so not the norm during that time?

Yes although some did marry at 9 onwards, it was possible that others delayed the marriage for some reasons. Hence many Shi’a scholars believe she was not 40 but about 28 when she married the holy Prophet (s)

1. How long is the reign of our Imam Mehdi as?
2. Is prophet Isa also helping our Imam Mahdi during this time?
3. What will happen to Prophet Isa? Will he pass away first before our Imam?
4. Will most people in the world become believers during our Imam's reign?
5. Will the people go astray again after our Imam's reign?
6. Will the world end soon after our Imam's reign? Will this be immediately as the world must have Allah's hujjah always?

1. Only Allah knows
2. It’s not clear. It’s possible but difference of opinion exists
3. Yes narrations point to that
4. Yes they will
5. Not the majority but Allah knows best
6. The time is in the hands of Allah

Normally when we pray or donate in the name of our beloved deceased, we want to pass the good deed of our acts of worship to the deceased to benefit them. With regards of our beloved present Imam a.s. (my God hasten his appearance) ,
1. How do our prayers benefit thawab to him, as he is the ma'sum, and doesn't need it? Or when we offer our prayer, should we have the intention of a gift to him instead of thawab for him?
2. I have heard that we should make a habit to put aside a donation everyday for our Imam's protection. We know that God has assured victory for our Imam a.s. Our Imam a.s. is protecting us all the time and looking after our affairs. So could you please elaborate on this action on donation in our Imam's name. It will be a good habit for the children to show our love for our Imam, but how do we explain it to our children that our Imam is in need of protection still although Allah has kept him safe.

1. It raises his status, give him more protection and gets us closer to him
2. Yes Allah will protect him but also our donations will help the poor and needy so it is helping the followers of Imam mainly and making us think about others

I’m a victim of extreme waswas that makes me spend hours at the bathroom cleaning myself to the point that my skin is so dry that it bleeds. If I don’t spend that long in the bathroom I keep thinking that I’m najis. Should I ignore my doubt even if I’m certain?

OCD is probably what you have. You must get treatment for it. You must ignore the whispers. It’s Shaitan getting to you. Certainty is not same as doubt. But you might have condition which makes you feel it’s certain but in reality it’s not. It’s very important you seek medical help

I wanted to inquire about the consumption of beef gelatine in two aspects. I have various conditions where I lack majority of the major vitamins. As a result I am on medication. I have a bad experience with medicine hence why I avoid taking them. However, there are gummies that are known to be useful although they do contain gelatine from beef. Am I still allowed to take them considering it’s for my health?

Yes no problem.
In my research gelatine goes through complete transformation and hence it’s permissible to consume when in products like vitamins or sweets etc

Can a child born out of a wedlock have love for Ahlelbait?

Yes

During the days of mourning (2 months and 8 days as culturally commemorated in Pakistan) or ayyam al Fatimiyah (20 days), my wife believes that she should not wear good clothes or do any make up even for the sake of her husband. As a result she remains unattractive towards her husband who feels offended by her appearance. I think expressing signs of grief during 10 days of muharram and only on shahadat days are appreciated as we are followers of Ahlul Bayt a.s, but not wearing good clothes for longer periods does not seem logical. Can you please shed some light on this issue so that I can guide my wife?

Yes you’re correct. There is nothing in Islamic teachings or practice of Ahlulbayt that says for two months one should be in this state.

It is highly advisable for the wife to be attractive to her husband and clean at all times, but not on specific days of Shahadat of Ahlulbayt (eg actual day of martyrdom only)

Is it permissible to get a keratin hair treatment? (As in would it be considered a layer hence a barrier for ghusl)

If it’s planted into skin and becomes part of body then it’s fine

I heard some sunni molana speech where he was saying 'Imam Ali (a) had desire to marry abu jehal’s daughter'

Please read this
https://www.al-islam.org/fatima-the-gracious-abu-muhammad-ordoni/historical-distortions-regarding-alis-right


I recently came across a documentary by AhlulbaytTV where they discussed that Sheikh Suduq had a hadith which indicated that the Prophet (PBUH) accidentally lost attention in his prayers/made a mistake in his prayers (Astaghfurallah), and the Sheikh Suduq insisted this hadith was authentic. The clip was in minute 25:15 of this documentary (which can be accessed here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5bl00E-Zhi8&t=1560s). The documentary goes on to state that Sheikh Al-Mufid went on to reject this tradition based off of logical rationality. However because the documentary was so vague, I am not satisfied with this response and it has made me worried—as I am a firm follower of our Imams but did not know that such contradictory hadiths existed and that a scholar like Sheikh Suduq would even accept such a hadith. I would like the Sayed (or any one of his scholarly team) to comment on what basis Sheikh Al-Mufid rejected this tradition, and what the classification of such a hadith is (whether it is considered as weak or strong). I am sure none of our Imams(AS) would say such a thing. As a young Shia Muslim male, and I want to be firm on the path of the Quran and AhlulBayt, so I would like to know if I should also cross-check such hadiths with the Quran, so that if they contradict—to leave them. But please if you can also give me the basis for how Sheikh Al-Mufid rejected it, and what the consensus of the marja is on such a hadith by Sheikh Suduq.

Please watch this lecture that discusses the subject of Isma of the Prophet in details

https://youtu.be/dlci01DWLaE

My daughter was praying salaat layl and she says she heard a whisper near her ear while she was making dua and is confused what that was and is scared now to pray alone. What could that be?

She should ignore this and do istiadha from Shaitan. It could be internal thoughts. Prayer is powerful and nothing should stop us from doing it alone. She should give sadaqa and ask Allah for strength and protection and she will be ok Insha’Allah

1) Surah At Taubah verse 36, regarding the 4 sacred month and dont be unjust to ourselves during that month.
If let say we doing something unjust to ourselves and realized about this how to repent? Any extra thing we need to perform instead solat and dua?
2) Surah At Taubah verse 34-35, about gold. As I have heard before, some say we can save gold and some say cannot for safety measure. We should do saving something can be use by others example land, house etc. My question is if let say I plan to buy house later, instead of saving money in bank I deposit money in bank as a price of gold. Later if i want we can withdraw the deposit base on price of gold. Is it permitted?

1. By doing istighfar. Giving sadaqa
2. Yes that is fine

I've heard from someone Al Quran divided by 30 juz is not done by Rasulullah. We have to read by chapter not juz. Is it correct?

Both are fine, to read by juz or chapter

A few weeks ago my grandmother passed away because of Corona. Whenever my mother, aunt, uncle etc cry something bad happens. Once they cried much and then my uncle got corona, he’s in the ICU now. One time my aunt cried and then a few minutes later her son burned his hand. Why does something bad happen every time we cry about her? And how should we deal with it? It feels like it isn’t permissible to cry

I don’t think it’s related to crying. Everyone cries. It’s a series of tests God is putting your family through. You are somehow linking it to crying. It’s very unlikely. You must stay strong, patient and give lots of sadaqa and do good deeds for protection.

Too much crying over a dead person is also not recommended and should not happen. Yes we can cry but excessive crying becomes questioning God

I have alot of waswasas even about Allah and Prophet SAW. I was not religious and did not perform and follow teachings of Islam seriously. But I have been practicing Islam alot from last 6-7 months Allahumdulillah. After I started practicing Islam I have started to have a lot of evil and bad waswasas.

This is the Shaitan. You must seek refuge in God and ignore these thoughts and ideas. Don’t give up your hard work. Shaitan doesn’t want you to succeed. He will try everything. Surround yourself with positive people. Read about paradise. Stay away from haram as that enhances satanic thoughts

1) It is said that although Imam Mahdi(pbuh) is in occultation he still saves us from troubles. Is this true? If yes , then how exactly as we can see his lovers are in poor state and dying while his enemies are shining stronger.

2) Do we have any signs for Imam that his presence is making calamities stay away from us especially in this time where we can see that those who love him and have expectations from him for his help are suffering and are helpless and those who walk away from him are in better place?
What are the signs of Imam Mahdi's love for us that he also feels something when we are sad and alone and are suffering by the hands of the people of this world ?

1) Yes it is true. What may happen without his intercession is much worse than what we have today. He is like sun behind the cloud. We don’t see his impact but he definitely has much role

2) These are found in reliable narrations. We don’t need signs as such. The belief is key

There is a scarcity of good zakiras in our area…
Among these zakiras, only 1 or 2 have degree from Qom or from any madressa, rest are simply speakers. My mother has also forced me for several years to recite majlis but I had always resisted. But this year, due to covid we had more scarcity of zakiras I decided to recite the majlis on my own. Now people are saying to not to stop here and recite more majlis. But again I have a guilt feeling that I am not worthy of reciting a majlis because I am not an aalim. What should I do ? Should I recite more majlis and if someone asks me to recite a majlis at their place. Should I accept or should I decline saying I'm not an aalim?

Yes it’s dangerous for people to recite majalis without hawza training. Because we might say things which are wrong and it’s a big responsibility. I would caution that you keep going. What you can do is prepare a Majlis and get it checked by a scholar or alima. Then you can give that majlis. Do not do Q&A

Someone has given me a star ring and said its hirze jawad. However its a star on the ring and they said dua is written under the star. Can you please let me know whether it can be worn or not?

Yes I had one of them and it’s fine

In past I had some obsession with taharah but I noticed one thing during my problem. I was obsessed with purifying my body but not obsessed with purifying my soul. Why is it that people (including me) become so careful for physical taharah but are not so careful about taharah of the soul (i.e. staying away from sins)? I understand that shaytaan(LA) is the driving force behind the obsession with physical taharah. But is there any psychological aspect to it as well?

Yes it could be related to OCD. This requires treatment some times

What is the prescribed punishment for one who commits rape.

In terms of Islamic legal punishment, in an Islamic country the judge issues a decree (tazeer)

In terms of Gods punishment, it’s severe if they don’t seek repentance

I wanted to ask a question about manqabats and nohas. Is it okay to listen to such things as most reciters now have musical instruments in the background so therefore they sound more like songs?

According to Ayatollah Sistani, music that is haram is one that is suitable for events of indecency and evil. If it’s suited to be played on those events, it becomes Haram

The age of my grandma is around 94 years (she is very old). The doctors asked the following two important questions.
(1) CPR (cardiopulmonary resuscitation). The doctors doesn’t advise CPR considering Mum age. They explained that the CPR process may break her bones. She may temporarily survive but then she will be in a painful situation.

(2) Life savings machines (Ventilator). There are possibilities that Doctors may use ventilator to revive her Example: In case of cardiac arrest.

You must do everything to save her life, even if it causes pain or breaking bones

I just went to an islamic market and bought some packaged grains (beans, peas). I did not notice there but when I got home the brand on those packages are a hindu gods name and picture (laxmi) and it says product of india and Australia. Does the brand name make it haram? Should I throw it away as I can not return it? What’s the ruling on buying such products?

As long as the product is halal you should not worry about manufacturer, only if they are clear enemies of Islam

Recently, I was asked a question and didn’t know how to answer it from our sunni brothers/sisters. The Quran we have today the isnad contains personalities that don’t agree with the wilyat of imam Ali. So how do we shia deem this Quran to be reliable and take from it?

This is not only chain of narrations. We have various different ways. These are some who collected the Quran. You can read more here:

https://www.al-islam.org/collection-and-preservation-quran-sayyid-abu-al-qasim-al-khoei

https://www.al-islam.org/prophethood-and-prophet-islam-ayatullah-ibrahim-amini/revelation-and-preservation-quran

Would you know what is the ruling of eating HFA meat which is ‘Halal’ although it is stunned, and there is no confirmation as to whether the animal was killed by the stunning or not.

Do you know what the rule is for followers of Ayatullah Sistani and Khameini?

Both scholars allow stunning of meat.

Can tayammum be done on tiles or stone slab which are installed in the ground where it is meant to walk or on cement road? I'm not sure if it is najis but it is dry. Also, the surrounding mud/dust is still little moist and cold even after the rain has gone, is it allowed to do tayammum?

It should be done on dust and soil. Yes they ones from outside whilst wet is ok

What are the ruling for praying namaz at a safari park that privately owned, however open for public at a fixed entrance fee. Is praying namaz valid inside the park and do we need permission to pray inside the park?

If you don’t know of any objections, which is usually the case like many other parks, then it’s ok since it’s open public space and you have paid to enter.

How can I cleanse myself if water scares me? Due to past trauma

You would need to get some therapy to defeat this fear as water is source of purity

I am concerned that my spouse has been moving away from Allah.

1. Lead by example and do your wajib acts
2. Pray to Allah in desperation for the best
3. Keep advising them and don’t give up
4. Help them to read about why trials happens
5. Seek family who are close to them to support too

What is the correct etiquette for reciting ziyarat from home? As in should we read it standing or sitting?
I see some people raise their hands to the sky (like in Dua), while others recite with their hands on their chest, and others still just point towards Karbala with their pointing finger. Which should I do?

All are fine. It’s best to stand. You can place hand on chest or down on side of body

Regarding ziyarat ashura, do you think it’s a good idea if I do the 100 salams & Lanats on the way to work (as I don’t have anything meaningful to do during that time) and can therefore use the extra free time at home for other good deeds? Or would there be more reward in just doing everything in one sitting?

Yes sure you can do that, or listen to lectures, Quran or Duas also beneficial

In the dua for parents in Sahifa Sajjadiyah, in the 7th line, it says “teach me through inspiration knowledge of everything incumbent on me towards them”
My question is who is “them” in this context? Is it our parents or the Prophet (s) and his household ?

It is parents

There have been many proposals that have come for me, but none have gone through for their own separate reasons. Are there any duas specifically for marriage, one that can help with the process of looking for a spouse? Are there also any duas to help with mental health, as I fear that my mental health will continue to deteriorate throughout this process of looking.
JazakAllah

1. Recite this verse many times a day (25:74)

2. Do this prayer if you can and ask you hajaat
3. Seek professional help for mental wellbeing. There is nothing wrong with that and it will help you a lot, such as CBT.
4. Write down why the proposals are failing and work out a plan with the family

https://youtu.be/alDZrXTvP80

My mom was hospitalized and during Muharram she has been discharged. Can I give nazar during Muharram with the attention to thank Allah as she has been discharged?

Yes you can and there is no problem in it

Are we allowed to perform Mustaab / daily nafal prayers( Namaz e Shab, Daily prayers nafals etc) sitting down with or without any valid excuse. Would we get half the reward? As I heard that nafal or Mustahab prayers can be performed even when you are walking. Could you kindly advise me according to Shareya and my Maraja's Touzeeh. I follow Ayatullah Khamanie.

Yes we can and it’s fine even without an excuse. This is not the case for wajib salah though. Allah knows best about the reward. Ofcourse it’s best to do the prayer standing.

Request for clarification on something trivial, however has become something of a disagreement within my circle.

1. Were any of our Holy Imam (as) dark skinned/complexion ?
If yes,

1.1. Please share Their (as) names as well.

1.2. Did They (as) face discrimination & how did They (as) address it?

2. Also, did our Imams (as) marry women of dark skin who were slaves previously ?

Salaam alaikum
1. Yes, Imam Redha, Imam a Jawad and Imam Hadi were dark skinned according to Hadith.
2. They were rebuked for it

Please read following article for detailed answers

https://www.academia.edu/10349890/Racial_Othering_in_Shi_i_Sacred_History_Jawn_ibn_Huwayy_the_African_Slave_and_the_Ethnicities_of_the_Twelve_Imams

I have a question if a young unmarried women has committed zina and aborted a child resulting from that zina and have remorsefully repented and deeply regrets what happened, will Allah forgive this and also is there anything she has to do like pay a Diyah or pay sadaqa or any rules to the sin committed.

Yes Allah is most forgiving but tawba must be genuine and sincere

This is the answer from Sistani.org

5 Question: What is the kaffara of abortion?
Answer: In case the mother aborts the child, she must give the indemnity (blood money) to the father or other heirs. And if the father carries out the abortion, the indemnity is obligatory on him and he must give it to the mother. If it is the doctor who carries out the abortion, it is obligatory on him to give the blood money to the mother and father, even if he may abort the fetus on the parents’ request. He must give the blood money except if the heirs (i.e. the mother and father)exempt him.
It would suffice for the blood money of the fetus into which soul has entered to give 5250 mithqals of silver. That is when the fetus is male and if it is female, half of that amount should be paid.
If the fetus is lifeless and it is in the form of a fertilized ovum (zygote), 105 mithqals of silver would suffice for the blood money. In case it is in the form of a leech-like substance, the indemnity is 210 mithqals. If it develops into a chewed-like substance, the indemnity is 315 mithqals. If the fetus has bones, 420 mithqals of silver would suffice. If it has developed into a complete human body with grown up limbs and organs, the indemnity is 525 mithqals of silver. If the fetus is soulless, there is no difference between a male fetus and a female one as an obligatory precaution. The Soul enters the body at the fourth month of pregnancy except for when it is proved otherwise through modern technology.
If the fetus is alive and it is aborted, the indemnity is 5250 mithqal of silver for a male child and 2625 mithqal for a female child.
*Every mithqal of silver is equivalent to 4.64 g of Silver.*

Are items that are used in that state of haydh considered najis? (such as towels or clothes, that are otherwise Tahir except for the fact that they made contact with the body with wetness)

No they’re not najis, except if they come in contact with blood for eg. Otherwise it’s Tahir

Is there any hadith from Ahleibayt which in clear words rejects – slavery in Islam?

Slavery was slowly eradicated by Islam throughout life of Ahlulbayt as society very much depended on it that time

My question is why would a 20-30000 army give a whole day to every healthy male individual of the army of Aba Abdullah why would not that army attacked the tents of Ahlulbayt with thousands of arrows and if any how they would have survived that attack why wouldn’t the army of Yazid attacked with full gallop and finished the battle once

There are etiquette of warfare. We cannot dictate history. Not everything happens the way we expect either. Arab warfare rules say best to do dual and respect women as well. Also imam Hussain dug a trench with fire to stop attack from behind

What is the hadith in arabic whose tarjuma is If you fear Allah(swt),he will remove the fear of other things(shay) and if u don't fear allah(swt) ,he will induce a fear of all other things(shay).

Found in Alkafi

من خاف الله أخاف الله منه كل شيء ، ومن لم يخف الله أخافه الله من كل شيء

I don't remember quite yet but since the past 3 years I been committing a sin that is very bad. After 2 and a half year I find out that it was a great sin and haraam so I pushed myself and stopped doing it and started doing repentance. Now things have gotten dark I can't control myself as I could before. I am trying my best not to commit this sin but I am failing I have tried everything taken every advice but nothing is helping me I want to develop myself but I am failing. What should I do now, how should I control myself to not to commit this and because of this sin I have fallen bad into my studies. I also attented majalis of Aba Abdillah (a.s) and prayed to Allah to help me get rid of this sin but I think help is too far away. I haven't losen my hope in him as losing hope in Allah is a greater sin. The sin that I am committing is masturbation and watchin pornography.

Firstly it’s very good that you feel you have wronged and you want to stop.

Allah is all merciful. He will forgive you. You must believe this. But this act is damaging you badly. It’s worse than poison. Your future will be very negatively affected because of it.

Please watch this clip I did. Also another clip on pornography. You need to do what is recommended. Practice it and reward yourself with halal if you don’t do the haram. You must busy yourself as boredom makes you think of haram. Ultimately maybe marry temporary or permanent to save yourself and your religion. But don’t give up as Shaitan wants you to give up

https://youtu.be/y8pypvuw2u8

https://youtu.be/4ErJBv70VHU

Present scholars our great grand scholar ayatollah sistani said “In one of the recent meetings of Grand Ayatollah with a crowd of Popular Mobilization ‎Forces, one member said we have peaceful coexistence with our Sunni brothers. In reply, ‎Ayatollah al-Sistani underlined that do use the term Sunni brothers but say they are ourselves because ‎we are from the same origin and there is no difference between us and them.” Ayatollah Khamenei also preaches shia sunni unity, can you tell me what we should do? There is another issue of ayatollah Sadiq shirazi. I am really really confused can you tell me what to do and what is right?

Best way is to follow your current marjie and don’t worry about rest. The marjie knows challenges of modern era so it’s best to listen to him

I have got a question in regards to Surah 69:17, it states that “eight of them” shall hold the throne, in some Shi’a traditions some say it is the four prophets from the past that will hold it -Noah, Abraham,Moses and Jesus. And the later generations- Prophet Muhammed, Imam Ali and his sons Hasan and Hussain. However I’m not convinced enough or certain enough for this to be true as the Quran says it’s specifically directing towards the angels. So how can I truly understand this verse and what is correct interpretation of this verse?

Yes as you mentioned some narrations exist as such
In any case if it’s angels it doesn’t take away status of Ahlulbayt at all nor change anything. Sometimes we go by narrations as there is no other way to be sure

A Christian claimed that the Prophet (S.A.W.) received his first revelation while he was sleeping, is this true? And if not, how do we Shias address this claim and provide evidence that this isn’t the case.

We have strong evidence in Islamic traditions on how and when the Prophet received revelation. A person from another faith cannot tell us from their own sources. There is no Muslim scholar in history who has claimed the Prophet received revelation whilst asleep. All the biographies of the Prophet by Muslims established that he got it when he was in Cave of Harra fully awake

I’ve got a question in regards to the 12 Holy Imams. Are they divine? Or they are just Divinely Guided? Which is the difference between both? I’ve got a friend who is a Christian who says Jesus is Divine, what does Islam say about this?

They are human beings chosen by God. They are not divine, as only God is the Divine. They are humans who have been selected by God to guide mankind

I’m finding it hard to understand the difference between Aqa’id and fiqh. I know we must do taqlid for fiqh but not for Aqa’id, but what does Aqa’id mean?

It means beliefs. It’s the doctrines. It’s the theology.

Will I have to pray namaz ayat if a solar and lunar eclipse cannot be seen in the area I live in?

No it’s not obligatory on you

I wanted to know how can sadqah be given in the form of deeds and actions, can you please elaborate on this topic

Perform good deeds and dedicate the niyyah or intention for someone

When people post something on social media platforms, such as whatsapp, facebook, can we take a sanpshot and share it? Or do we need to seek permission to do so? eg; someone posts whatsapp status or whatsapp display picture of a doa or quote, can we save and send it to people? Or can we ourselfves use it for our benefit since it's kind of public? Or do we need to ask permission every single time?

If it’s a private group, and generally the people in that group do not want anything shared, then you should not share. It depends on the setting, some Facebook accounts are set as public so it’s ok to share etc. If people have placed setting as public then it’s ok to share. Otherwise we should ask permission as much as possible

Is it necessary to recite surah falaq with surah naas after surah al hamd in wajib prayers?

No it’s not necessary

I wanted to know what is the best way to dedicate a read quran to one of our marhooms I dont see any answers online from a shia perspective is this permissible and what should be the Niyat if you could shed some light on this.

Say I dedicate the thawab of this Quran recitation to soul of xx for the sake of Allah

Is there a good month in which the couples should try to conceive? Also, what if a female is pregnant during the month of Ramadhan? Should she be fasting? Also, can you please share any tips or books related to conceiving, pregnancy and child birth.

This book is very good and will answer many of your questions

https://www.al-islam.org/marriage-parenthood-heavenly-path

If the mother is in stages pregnancy and it’s Ramadan, and there is likely to be harm on her or the baby, she can break fast and re-do later.

There are enemies of Islam who also bring these hadiths Imam Muhammad Baqir said fasting in ashura eliminates the sin of an entire year (tahdihib al ahkam graded sahih by al khoei)

Imam Musa Kazim said Messenger of Allah would fast on the day of ashura (tahdihib al ahkam graded reliable by al majlisi)

How do we reply to them

Yes these narrations do exist. However position of many of our ulema today after studying the two sets of Hadith is that it’s not recommended to fast and should be avoided

My father has a skin condition that is very painful. He has trouble praying with a shirt on because of blisters on his abdomen. Is it okay if he prays namaz without a shirt?

Yes it’s fine, as long as the private area is covered

My father has advised he would not like me to be friends with another Shia brother as he thought he was disrespected by him once a few years ago. Do I have to break my friendship with this brother because of what my father says?

You’re not obliged to follow your father in this case. However be respectful to him and politely disagree if you wanted to do so

My question is was hazrat qasim(a.s) married? What was his age? With whom was he married?
We connect him with Bibi Fatima Kubra (s.a) but heard that she's much elder than him and was already married, what's the truth?
If she was already married who's her husband? Why do people all over the world celebrate hazrat qasim (a.s) mehendi?

Please read this

https://en.wikishia.net/view/Al-Qasim_b._al-Imam_al-Hasan_(a)

During my second trip to Lebanon to visit the shrine of Syeda Khawla bint Imam Hussain ع I was also blessed to visit another nearby shrine of another daughter of Imam Hussain ع. I was told this was the shrine of Syeda Safiya bint Imam Hussain however there was no one that spoke English who could give any information about this daughter. Recently I have been told that her name was Fatima Wusta and that she is mentioned in many narrations about Ashura and the events after however I have not been able to find anything in Fatima Wusta (except another member of Ahlulbayt buried in Iran) or Syeda Safiya.
Do you have any information on the personality buried within this shrine? What was her real name and what is written of her in narrations?
If you could provide any information that you know in brief or direct me towards a source in English then I would be very grateful.

I have not come across this. It is fairly known that Imam did not have a daughter by name of Saffiya. It is perhaps a great descendent of Imam who had a father by name of Hussain and people mistook it

1- I am unable to recite Dua e abo Hamza Thumali in one go, can I recite it in breaks? For example I divide the dua in parts and recite parts of it each night.

2- Is it okay to recite the translation of dua ( the english part, because that way I can connect more with the dua as compared to arabic) or is it necessary to recite it in Arabic?

1. Yes that is fine and good practice

2. Definitely, as it’s important you understand what you’re reciting

Does scholars of ahlulbayt have a different opinion when it cames to aqaid and other subject?

Yes as human being differ and there are some disagreements on some concepts but not on fundamental beliefs

Are there any situations were taqyyiah is haram?

In cases where in doing so you will harm others or their lives will be in danger against their wishes.

I came across a Hadith from Imam Ali (as) from Al-Kafi and I have been pondering about this hadith for quite a while. It says that Imam Ali have said the one should not marry black people because they are creatures of deformity. As a muslim I know that racism in Islam is totally forbidden, and treating people differently based on the color of their skin is a major sin. One example of this is the famous hadith from our beloved Prophet saying that a white person has no superiority over a black man and vice versa. I am now questioning this hadith from Imam Ali (as). Is the hadith really true? If it is, could it then have an underlying explanation? I would really like to know how one of Allah best creation could have said something like this, especially as a muslim. Also considering Al-Kafi being one of the shias most authentic and reliable hadith collections. I am attaching the hadith: علي بن إبراهيم، عن هارون بن مسلم، عن مسعدة بن زياد، عن أبي عبد الله (عليه السلام) قال: قال أمير المؤمنين (عليه السلام): إياكم ونكاح الزنج فإنه خلق مشوه

1. Not every Hadith in Kafi is authentic and quite a few are weak
2. If we were to accept this, the Imam is referring to a particular tribe at that time and not anyone generally with black complexion as the Imams married fairly darker ladies and had black companions

Yesterday I found pornography on my 14 year old daughters phone. How should I go about handling this issue? At her age, I never would have thought to look at such images

I understand this must be difficult for you as a parent.

You must explain calmly the massive problems of this and the devastating impact of it on heath and wellbeing. Watch TEd talks and Islamic talks on this together. Take her to a cemetery and explain to her death and afterlife. She needs to understand how negative it is. Be patient and don’t lose hope. You can watch this clip too

https://youtu.be/4ErJBv70VHU

I have a friend who has recently converted to Islam. She would like to read books on the Prophet (pbuh), there is lots of material on the Internet but she would like a book. Please could you recommend a few titles.

The book The Message by Ayatollah Subhani as well as the following book

https://www.al-islam.org/library/prophet-muhammad

Can women say bismillah in whisper for the fajr, maghrib and isha prayers before reciting of surahs alhamdulillah and one other surah?

Yes she can.

1. Was Imam Ali a.s. praying his nafilah prayer when he was struck or the fard prayer?
2. Where were Imam Hasan and Imam Husein and Hazrat Abbas present in the mosque during that time when Imam Ali was struck?

It’s very likely that Imam was praying his nafila, although it’s difficult to be sure as reports vary.
Imam Hasan was there but it’s likely that Imam Hussain was outside kufa for a task. We are not told whether Abbas was there or not in historical accounts

I’ve found on wikipedia that we had a number of our scholars who believed in the distortion of the quran like, al kulayni, al shaykh al mufid, qomi, al ayyashi, al sayyari, al tabbarsi and so on. Do we shias believe in any kind of distortion?

This is a good summary of our beliefs in this issue:

http://en.mobile.wikishia.net/view/Integrity_of_the_Qur%27an

I would like to ask if you can advice me any amal regarding barkat for family and house? Because there is always fight at home, communication is impossible.
We want to be a house that respect Ahlul Bayt (as)

Please continue to pray and don’t give up. It’s a test and you need to be patient. Do this amaal as well. Give as much sadaqa as you can and help others

https://youtu.be/alDZrXTvP80

I have a question regarding the following ruling:

“The fluid which a woman feels during foreplay or lustful thinking but it is not much to spread to other parts, is clean. Ghusl does not become obligatory in this case and it does not make wudhu void either but if there is much fluid and is called ejaculation and the fluid spreads to the underwear and this normally takes place during orgasm and full satisfaction, the fluid is najis (impure) and in this case ghusl becomes obligatory. In fact, if emission takes place without orgasm, the necessary precaution is that it is najis and it causes janabah.
Hence, if a woman enters the state of janabah intentionally with the details mentioned above, both Qadha and kaffara become obligatory on her. The obligatory precaution is that she should restrain from eating and drinking for the rest of the day”

I find it very difficult to perform ghusl everytime fluid discharged (due to lustful thoughts) reaches the underwear, as even if it is a very small amount it eventually reaches the underwear. This means I have to perform ghusl around 3 times everyday.

From some other sources I have read that ghusl is only required when an orgasm occurs, however this is different to what is stated on Sistani.org (shown above).

Please could you provide some clarification to the circumstances in which female ghusl is required, as this is very confusing and difficult to manage.

If you find that there is common discharge due to excitement but without signs of orgasm then you can follow another marjie on this issue and you would not need to do ghusl, except if it’s actual ejaculation with signs of orgasm.

I saw a video clip by where you mention that it is permitted to do sajdah on the back of your hand. Is it applicable only if the sajdagah/mohr breaks or at other times when it is not available?

It’s only permissible when you don’t have anything to pray on that is allowed during salah, for eg when Turbah is removed or you lose it during salah.

Under normal circumstances you’re not permitted to use back of hand

There are many tafsirs of the Quran but I am struggling to find a reliable shi’a tafsir. I have limited Arabic knowledge so is there any English Shi’a tafsir you can recommend?

Unfortunately we don’t have many.
Only one is the englightening commentary of the Quran found in al-Islam.org but it’s not very comprehensive.

I just wanted to ask whether there's any objection in pursuing the art of Islamic Geometry, I know it seems obvious as they're used to decorate mosques and ziyarah but I wanted to check whether it's acceptable to print on clothing? For example an Islamic Geometry print on garments

There is no problem in this.

I know it is haraam to show your face in makeup in front of non mahram but we know in Indian weddings a bride has to do makeup and they bring her in front of her non mahram inlaws. Its not only about the wedding day a newlywed girl has to wear makeup even after her wedding also and non mahram in laws are present . What should I do?

It’s not allowed to wear make up in front of non Mahrem. Don’t displease God to please His creation. Stay patient and He will help you. Maybe if you have to wear make up ask for your face to be covered by white veil when non Mahrem enter. This is what happens in Iraq weddings.

If Islam doesn't discriminate people on the basis of gender then why does a husband has more status than wife such that to a wife her husband is next to God(majazi-e-Khuda) and if God would have allowed anyone to do sajdah for anyone other than him then it would have been the husband? I have read this in Islamic books and have heard from elders also that for a wife the husband is next to God, such that if god would have allowed sajdah for anyone it would have been for the husband . I want to know if this is true or not because in India husbands generally quote this that they are majazi-e-khuda and they have more status than the wife and also they quote the verse 4:34 where it is written that men are superior to women. The book where I read this is known as "Tohfatul Awaam ". It is in urdu. It is generally used for matters related to Islamic jurisprudence. Under the section of rights of husband and wife, there is a hadith mentioned which is attributed to Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) that if god would have allowed sajdah for anyone apart from him than I would have ordered women to do sajdah to their husband.
Is this hadith authentic?

This is an exaggeration. In the eyes of Allah both are equal. In Islamic law the wife has more rights than the husband. We must not let the western ideology influence us wrongly, but rather study Islam properly from our ulema.

Yes the Hadith is there but it’s being used out of context. We have to see what the Quran says first. (4:34) does not say men are superior. It says they are maintainers of women.
Please watch this documentary for more info:

https://youtu.be/jYqOtIOZAgA

My sister is suffering from what the doctors seem to have diagnosed as depression. Alongside professional help we eagerly are praying but we don't know where to turn now and which prayers we can do with swift reply.

It’s very important to get professional help

Perform this salah if you can, it comes highly recommended

https://youtu.be/alDZrXTvP80

Is there anything wrong with wearing green on feet? Or black?

No, there is no issue

What are the ways scholars use to remember loads of information from the chain of narrators to a hadith, to the risele Ameliyye, to everything else?

It is mainly light placed in their hearts from Allah (swt). To have strong memory is possible and a number of recommendations exist.

Please check this link


https://www.al-islam.org/pursuing-excellence-guide-memorising-holy-quran-sl-al-hakim/part-2-how-memorise-holy-quran

1.Did the prophet of Islam forgave his uncles (Hazret Hamze) enemy?

2. Did the killer of his uncle became Muslim ?

1. It is not known whether habashi was forgiven, since the Prophet told him that he doesn’t want to see him.
2. Yes he became Muslim, but so did others like Abu Sufyan. The real intention and motive is only known by Allah

I’ve been having trouble understanding what are the most recommended Surahs to read in the wajib prayers and Salatul Layl. Regarding the wajib prayers, I read that according to Sayed Sistani it’s best to recite Qadr in the first rakat and Tawheed in the second. I’ve seen others say the same (e.g. Khomeini), but then they also say for examples it’s best to read surahs like Qiyamah, Qashiyah, Naba, Insan for Fajr or for example Takathur, Nasr for Asr. So I’m confused out of all these recommendations, which choice is the most recommended? I’ve seen different recommendations for Salatul Layl. For example Allamah Tabatabai says to read the azaim surahs (I’m guessing he means Sajdah, Fussilat, Najm, Alaq) and then Allamah Majlisi says for example surahs like Muzzamil, Naba, Yaseen, Dhukan, Mulk, Insan. I’ve read Sadiq Shirazi recommends longer surahs – he mentions Anam, Khaf, Anbiya. So again I’m confused as to which is the most recommended?

Yes there are various narrations.
It’s best to have a list and recite as many as possible in different salah. In that way you won’t miss out and cover all possibilities.

I run a restaurant and I have fish served. The fish served is Basa which I believe is not allowed for us to consume therefore do I need to inform every momin that comes in you cant have fish or leave it as choice for them to decide ?

According to Ayatollah Sistani, any fish without scales cannot be served to anyone, Muslim or non Muslim. All fish that you serve on your restaurant must have scales.

In Surah 4:157, Allah mentions that Jesus Crucifixion was made to appear to the Jews, however, I have been researching online in regards to this verse and who was that Allah made to appear to the Jews in resemblance of Jesus, and I came across three situations or opinions as to what happened:

A. Some say that it was Judas.
B. Others say it was one of Jesus’ disciples.
C. Still others say that it was a Roman soldier named Titawus."

I’m completely confused on which one I should believe, and I was hoping that you could help me find the right answer, because my Christian friend is trying to prove to me the crucifixion and I brought this argument up is that it was Judas Iscariot was on the cross, but he replied as to saying that Judas hanged himself due to the guilt of betraying Jesus and therefore committed suicide whereas in a Shia Movie of Jesus made by Iranian producers it shows that Judas was the one crucified, I hope you can answer my question so that I can bring my Christian friend to the path of Islam, the path of Ahlulbayt.

Yes it’s most likely Judas
You can read more about this in al-Islam.org

I’ve got an issue with regarding to my prayer, as we know, prayer should be in a moderate speed, not rushing, however when I’m working I find it difficult to pray at that speed, and I have to shorten my prayer. But the problem is, how do I shorten my prayer but at the same time be accepted in front of Allah(S.W.T). Can you please tell another alternative of prayer that I can quickly fit in during my working hours?

You should not shorten prayers and do it as an acceptable speed. It could be Shaitan who is encouraging you to speed.
Say the istiadha and seek protection from Shaitan.

My question is regarding the rule of namaz ayat. I know that I have to pray namaz ayat when there is a solar and lunar eclipse but I was wondering what is the rule for thunder and lightning. Is it obligatory to pray this namaz when there is thunder and lightning.

If it is to extent that causes you fear then yes you should pray.

What is the ruling on someone who makes an intention to fast and sleeps and wakes up in the morning having realised he has had a wet dream. This person unfortunately had a wet dream before the time of fajr prayer and didn't get up to do ghusul and also didn't pray fajr.

Considering this is a recommendated fast, will his fast be valid or invalid.

Yes the fast is valid.

Wondering if we were allowed to keep socks during prayers?
Also during those sad times, do you know if it exists some websites where sheikh lead the jumuaa prayers online ? And if yes is it allowed to follow jumuaa online from home ?

There is no problem in keeping socks on in salah (not allowed in Wudhu though)
Salah cannot be performed online under Shi’a fiqh whatsoever. This applies to congregational prayer too.

I can’t find in Europe any way to buy Fayrouza and aqiq rings coming from the holy shrines.
If I find rings with those stones but not coming from the holy sites, do they have the same spiritual value please ?
Otherwise do you know any reliable websites selling those stoned rings in Europe ?

If it’s a genuine stone ring then it doesn’t matter where you purchase it from

A website I came across but not used or know much about is this


https://www.shiarings.co.uk

What constitutes an enemy of Islam/Allah, or a non believer. I always imagine our Prophets and Imams, our role models, being soft hearted, patient people. Yet we are instructed not to be apparenty? If you can shed light on this issue i'd greatly appreciate it.

It depends on the situation and environment
Sometimes Taqiyya needs to be practised to save life
Sometimes in a battlefield we need to fight
Other times we might need to use intellect wisely and act accordingly under advice of ulema.

During the lockdown, the government has advised citizens not to visit friends and family if they do not live with us as part of social distancing measures enforced. However, I am concerned about my mother who does not reside with me and my father has passed away. I feel she is in a vulnerable group and may get anxiety from time to time. Every once in a while, she would like me to visit her. Is it permissible to travel to visit her? I am not too concerned with the other people that live with her such as my siblings. If I can visit, how much precaution should I take. Can I take other members of my household to visit her such as my children, wife etc.

You should try to keep in touch remotely and not visit since it may endanger her life. This decision is difficult but ulema have instructed us to abide by law of the land as much as possible. If she is in real need and you must see her to save her life for eg then there maybe an exception
Ofcourse if you live in that house too with her it’s ok according to the law.

I am wondering if the husband is allowed to impose the likes and dislikes of his parents on his wife and claiming that it makes him happy if she follows it. If the wife decides not to adhere to that decision knowing that he is asking her to please his parents, is it okay for her to refuse the request/decision? or religiously she has to do adhere to it?

Such imposing is not correct however there has to be an understanding between the couple and compromise so that the relationship flourishes and strengthens. Each has needs and so both need to sacrifice and compromise for the other, on issues that are not core or fundamental such as faith.

My question is regarding financial investments. Are we in the west allowed to buy shares in banks? Would the fact that we become part owners for the bank constitute any income as haram given these banks charge interest to customers?

https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01227/

Is CBD oil allowed as treatment for depression?

If there is no alternative then yes.

Is it required for the eldest son to live with his parents his whole life? Is he allowed to move out while still providing his parents with money in their old age?

It is not wajib per se but the children should not neglect their parents and help each other in looking after their parents.

Can I wear pajama to pray in? It’s like a one piece pajama cover all not a dress. Is that ok?

It must be like hijab, ie loose and not see through and covers all body.

Can we dye our hair during the days of hayz?

There is no problem in doing so.

Someone sent me a pdf that says Sayyidah Fatimah passed away at the age of 28 years. We have always heard 18 years. Would appreciate if you can please shed some light on above as am a little confused.

Yes there are some narrations pointing to this but generally the narrations are Sunni based. Shii scholars tend to lean towards 18 as her age of passing away.

I have a question regarding where it's best to buy ones shroud, and if there's a specific one to buy

You can get one with various Duas or verses but it’s is better that it’s not used as the main shroud but placed on top of the white shroud.
For eg in Iraq you can purchase one with Ziyarah Ashura, or Ayat Kursi.

Ever since I was young I've been hearing that not praying = hell. I'm a youth living in the west, I try my best to be a really good person in all aspects but I'm having extremely difficulty praying. I don't understand how non Muslims can be at a good standing if they are good human beings but as a Muslim being a good person is not sufficient because by not praying I'm not able to accumulate any thawaab. I'm very confused and this often pushes me away from religion. Please help me out.

Prayers had benefits in this world and next. It’s the foundation of faith. The fact that people who don’t pray are seemingly successful doesn’t mean they are truly happy or enjoy success in the eyes of God since it’s about both worlds.

Try to understand why we pray. Read books about it and enjoy speaking to Allah. It’s a way of saying thanks to Him for all the blessings. It’s also a protection against vice according to Quran. It’s spiritually uplifting and recharging. If it wasn’t good for us God would not have made it wajib. Hence there is real benefit. By not praying we miss out greatly, and ofcourse as Muslims we must obey God to attain success.

But I'm just very confused as why we have to pray so strictly and not others.

It's not their fault that they're not Muslims and don't have to pray. But from my understanding that wouldn't mean they won't go to heaven right? I just don't understand how this whole thing works. ~Are there any sources I can look through to understand this better?

It’s an act of mercy for us from God and an opportunity to get to Paradise. Yes it’s Allah who decides but we can help our case by performing our prayers correctly and understanding what we’re saying. It’s an honour to pray. We should not look at it as a burden. In fact salah helps our spiritual growth. Quran tells us it protects us from vice and evil. It’s a positive act not a bad one. Hence we should embrace it fully.

I want to ask about making Islamic post in which the name of khalifa of so and so are mentioned for example that fadak was usurped by so and so. And mentioning hadith with reference. So can i make that post?

As long is its actual fact, with no emotion or personal attacks, then it’s fine.

What is the correct order or reading a tasbeeh? is it Subhanallah-Alhamdulillah-Allahu Akbar or the other way round?

Allah Akbar
Alhamdulillah
Subhanallah

Who did the children of Adam marry?

It’s likely that Allah created females for them to marry.

I wanted to ask about the rituals in marriage. I have been told by some people that on the wedding night the groom has to wash the wifes feet and sprinkle the water in the room but there seem to mix views regarding this. Is this something that needs to be done?

Some are recommended and others cultural but none of what you mentioned is wajib.

I wanted to know how long should a woman stay in idda after the end of the muttah ?

2 monthly cycles (periods)

Does Islam allows married partners to have as much children as they want e.g 4-5 and then use a permanent birth control. Permanent birth control methods could be a surgery or any thing else so does Islam allow this with the consent of both the spouses or not

Surgery in this case is only allowed if it’s reversible

I just wanted to ask about interest and the conditions that it is allowed in. I want to buy a car on finance as I can’t afford one for full price. Is it possible to engage in the interest.

You are allowed but have intention that you’re paying the company a gift and not interest

Is there anything wrong with wearing green on feet? Or black?

No, there is no issue

I wanted to know if it is haram to have intercourse during first 10 days of Muharram? In Indian community, it is strictly prohibited but I wanted to know if it is islamically prohibited.

It is permissible

I wanted to ask the rulings of smoking marijuana; does it invalidate prayer, and if so – for how long? Furthermore, if one wants to use it for relief from mental health issues (such as suicidal ideation in depression) can this be done?

Just by smoking it, although haram, it does not invalidate prayer

As for medicinal use, the cbd oil of it can be used

Is trading in the Stock Exchange Halal?.

In principal yes, but not in comparing selling alcohol, or promoting usury or supporting openly and widely countries that are enemies of Islam

I wanted to know is there any dua to control the anger of a person. I have a friend who loses his temper on petty issues and regret for it later. I want to help him. Please suggest me what can be done to make him control his anger?

It’s not only dua that is needed, but following some recommendations such as having wudhu at all times, sitting down when angry if standing up or vice versa, go to anger management classes or to be equipped with knowledge of dealing with it

As far as dua, there is a few, but for example this one from Sahiffa Sajadiya is good:


http://www.duas.org/safeguard.htm

I have a question in regards to family planning. We have Alhamdulillah two boys. My husband and me are not planning to have any further children. Is there any permanent way of not getting pregnant? Is that permissible in Islam?

Any method needs to be reversible for it to be permissible

Is there are rule in islam that it is compulsory to make a partition in the hair style ?

As long as it’s fully covered for the female in presence on non mahrems then that is hijab

I'm studying a medical degree so in my skills class where we have to medically examine each other (not intimately just like hands and arms and face and legs from knee downwards) there’s 2 Muslim boys, 1 white girl and 2 Hindu/Sikh girls.
Last week I worked with the white girl and a Sikh girl and because of the hand gel we use and touch each other while our hands are still wet plus natural human sweat, I got completely najis and so did my stethoscope. There was a stethoscope we had to share and I was unsure of which one to put in my ear because I wasn’t sure which side the Sikh girl had used so I gave myself the benefit of the doubt.
Basically it was manic trying to stay paak.

And this week because I was examining a patient towards the end, the two Sikhs and the white girl paired up so I began examining the Muslim guys and they examined me (hands, arms and face).

So what is it better to do? Get examined by a girl and get Najis or get examined by a guy who’s not your mahram?

It is not permissible to be examined by a non mahrem for learning purposes usually. Therefore you should avoid this as much as possible, unless it causes you unbearable difficulty
As for the other situation, try your best to clean whatever has become najis as much as you can, but don’t be pedantic about it, and if you don’t know if something has come in touch with wet hands for eg assume it’s Tahir.

Our Khums date used to be the 11th of Dhul Qadah but then because the Islamic dates kept changing around we decided to follow the Gregorian calendar and set our Khums date as the 15th of August. So do we have to start counting all the income we have left over from maghrib time on the 14th or do we start counting what we have left from 00.01am on 15th August?
It’s just that we wanted to buy a wardrobe today (14th August) before maghrib but now it’s maghrib already so we were just wondering that the money we use to buy the wardrobe after maghrib, is Khums wajib on that money?


It would be from 12am 15th August

Saalam, I have 3 questions: Ïnshallah I hope you will answer them .

1) After the Battle of Kerbala, some say that the wife of Imam Hossein (s) went to Iran were she hidden herself in a cave. From there on no one every so her. So my question is : If this narration is authentic, then why did she do that? and so she died there as well?

2) There are some shrines of the daughters of Imam Ali (s) and other Imams (s) , but the problem is some say for example that Rukhayya his (Imam Ali (s) ) daughter’s grave is in Pakistan while others say that 7th Imams daughters grave is also in Pakistan? And yes one more, the wife of Muslim bin Aqeel’s grave is also in Pakistan. If this is true, how on earth did the land in Pakistan? If not, where is the real graves of the daughters the Imams (s)?

3) What was the philosophy behind 10th Imam’s choice for naming her daughter Ai’sha?


1. I have not come across this, and I have studied lives of the wives of Imam Hussain in detail. I would like to see evidence of this claim

2. Again it is not something established. These maybe descendants of Imams several generations

3. It is not proven that Imam Hadi named his daughter as such

I have seen that many people use images from google, other websites, etc in order to make majlis invites, etc. These images available online have copyrights on them. However, is it permissible to use them, without taking permission from the owner, if we are using them to make majlis invites, i.e, personal use of them

Regarding your question specifically, and as the internet is usually common usage for people, there is no problem in using the image for general material, but perhaps seeking permission is better out of precaution, and Allah knows best

Is killing insects particularly spiders forbidden /makruh ?

Yes it’s allowed especially if they will be harmful

I’ve often heard the phrase “Halal and Haram music” .. which means there is a type of Halal music that we can listen to. Can you please explain how to differentiate between Halal and Haram music

Music that is permissible is the music that does not entail entertainment in gatherings held for that purpose. Forbidden music is the music that is suitable for entertainment and amusement gatherings.

https://www.sistani.org/english/book/46/2071/

There is a person I know, he is Shia, follows the everything just the way we do including wilaayah, believing in 12 imams, practicing Muharram and etc. There is no difference whatsoever just apart from the fact that they dont do “Taqleed” of a particular marj’ah.
Their community does have a leader however, who is a direct descendant of Imam Jaffar as Sadiq (a.s), who guides them just the way a marj’ah guides us. The way we call ourselves Ithnaasheri their title is Mashayakhi. It's nothing like the Ismaeelis or Bohras. The only difference is they dont do taqleed.
However I read from the app iSistani regarding taqleed of a mujtahed. It said that Taqleed means to follow and Mujtahed is a knowledgeable leader that a community or person can follow and ask advice from regarding Islam and its practices.
What are your views on this? Is it right? And would it be permissible to marry in this community? And after marriage what should be the conditions for the children? As the child gets the title of his Father.

I understand that such groups exist.

With respect, we believe taqlid of the most knowledgeable mujtahid is necessary and a must. This is the teachings of our ulema. Although we respect others who don’t follow this, we disagree with them. Marrying into such community is permissible

Since becoming Shia I have had a bit of difficulty eating zabihah meat. I am college student, and my parents do not eat zabihah so our meals are not made of zabihah food. I try to avoid eating the meat as much as I can, but I do not want to displease my parents by not eating with them. How should I deal with such a matter as eating zabihah is something which we must do?

If they know you’re Muslim, try to explain the rules and that it’s strictly forbidden for you to eat meat which is not zabiha

If they don’t know your Muslim and you need to conceal it for a reason, perhaps consider not eating meat at all or becoming vegetarian as eating non-zabiha regularly is a sin and has negative impacts on your soul and manners

I attended a majlis one of the nights of Ashurah, and I was deeply touched by the story and what I had heard. I am a bit familiar with the basic Shia aqaid, and Alhamdulilah I did recently take the step to become Shia as I was originally a Sunni. My question is should we view the tragedy of Karbala moreso as a praise of the Ahlul Bayt or should we view it in terms of its broader messages (such as justice and imaan and oppression) without so much focus on the Ahlul Bayt? My understanding of Karbala was not with a focus on the ahlul bayt, but of the universal ideas of divine justice and truth. Also how much should we use the wasila of the Ahlul Bayt in dua?

May Allah (swt) bless you for discovering and following the truth
We should remember Ashura both in terms of the values and universal lessons but also because God commands us to love and follow Ahlulbayt in the Quran. Both are important

As for seeking intercession, again the Quran instructs this (5:35) so it is totally fine and islamically encouraged so use it as much as you can

I am seeking a clarification. According to fiqh, it is essential to ensure that during ablution water reaches the skin. Can you please confirm what this means?
Usually after washing face with soap, after sometime, there forms a layer of oil on skin. Should this oil be considered a barrier in water reaching skin or is it ok to consider this oil as part of skin thus water can be poured and spread over face or hand to meet conditions of ablution.

Please confirm

The oil you described after washing with soap is fine and will not sop water getting to the skin

I want to know what is the status of palmistry, horoscope and astrology in Shia Islam. What have the holy Imams said about this subject? Can you send me a book or article which explains with sayings of Imam, what is the ruling behind palmistry and horoscope and astrology? Please send me link if you know any.

https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01285/

My aunty, my uncle's wife is so ill. Both her kidneys have been damaged and she is admitted to the hospital. We do live with each other and so I have to do a lot of work like to cook meals of all the times and to go to the hospital to spend nights with her. There are other people as well in the house but I don't know how all the works are put on me. I have to give a competitive exam in december and I dont have time to study and this is my last oppotunity to pass the exam otherwise I have to leave that field and all money of my parents will be wasted, but in this situatin where I have to do a lot of house hold work, I am unable to study. Shaykh please suggest me some ways to come out of this situation. I have just 2 months left for my preparation for exams.

In addition to Duas, you should be clear and have an open conversation with your aunt and other family members. They need to understand the importance of your exam and your future
Have reliance on Allah and be positive and patient. Life is full of challenges and opportunities and this is one of yours

I cheated on my husband. I regret it so much. I have been crying for (removed) days about it I just feel the guilt so much within me. I did pray to Allah for forgiveness but I still feel this extreme huge guilt and I feel like an extreme bad person

What you have done is a major sin and you must seek genuine repentance from Allah (swt). If you are sincere in being remorseful and you make a commitment not to do it again He will forgive you.
Don’t despair from His mercy. He forgives all sins. We all do mistakes but as long as we acknowledge we have and we want to correct it then He will help us. Give charity as much as you can and do good deeds. Make sure you keep pushing Satan away since he will be back to tempt you again

I don’t know exactly what I have to say while doing my wudu before prayers (i’m not an arabic speaker yet). Is my wudu still valid if I don’t say nothing while doing it ?
Also do you have a book or websites where I could learn it to properly to it?

You don’t need to say anything whilst doing Wudu. It’s not obligatory to say anything. It’s recommended to remember Allah and recite Duas

This video shows you how to perform Wudu


https://youtu.be/hYfI3g_OD4A

If verses of the Quran can be abrogated in meaning/ruling, then of what use are the abrogated verses? What meaning do those verses have if their rulings were overruled? I ask this especially because the Quran is meant to be a universal Book for all of mankind, and all of its verses possess some wisdom, and if the verses were overruled then they may lose meaning. Is this a correct understanding?

Very few verses were actually abrogated
The reason is contextual, some events during the 23 years went through a change and hence needed new ruling. For eg, Allah commanded the Muslims to give sadaqa when they came to ask the Prophet private questions. Only Imam Ali did, and hence the verse was abrogated to allow them to ask without Sadaqa

The Quran has many levels of understanding and complexities as it’s the word of God, and His wisdom entails that a very few is abrogated. Also it highlights the need of the Prophet and Ahlulbayt to actually tell us which verses were abrogated, since amongst different schools disagreement exists in this regard

Given your background in pharmacy I thought you may be well placed to answer the question about whether the nasal flu vaccine is suitable for Muslims. As a practicing Nurse I always get asked from various perspectives and I feel there is confusion in our community with regards to the following:
a) We are not "eating" it and the vaccine replicates in the nose
b) hHow can we form herd immunity and protect those that can't have it
c) Does the gelatine go through chemical changes making it pure no longer najis

I have a 5 year old who has never had the vaccine and I never felt that he was a risk to others because I always felt that I didn't want to put something najis into his body despite being a nurse and knowing the benefits of the flu vaccine and Alhamdulillah we have managed to stay well over the winter months without it. But I do get asked a lot and I wish I had a better answer!

Yes I’m aware of this re ruling. Scholars like Ayatullah Sistani leave it to the people themselves to make decision on whether complete transformations as taken place of the gelatine

I have done my research personally on this and I’m satisfied that indeed transformation does take place. But it’s a personal decision.

I am a business partner in a franchise here in the United States. It is a fast food restaurant. Part of the menu contains pork items which I know is haraam to sell. However, as a whole all partners have decided that we will not touch any of the money that we make from the pork sales. Is my rozi considered halal if I am not taking any money from the pork sales? As a part of a franchise it is mandatory to include pork items or else I would take them off the menu. Your help is much appreciated.

Selling pork to anyone is not permissible and haram. This is not affected if the money is separated or not. However if there is no other way, then permission can be sought from your marjie or representative to look at your case individually.

I had a question in regards to tamam and qasr prayer.

I have a house that I own in Atlanta, GA but I barely reside there as I had moved to Alabama for schooling and after schooling was over I moved to another town known as Augusta, GA. Now Augusta is my permenant residence hence my hometown. However I visit Atlanta every once in a while since my parents live there. That house in Atlanta is under my name. So when I go to Atlanta do I pray qasr Namaaz or tamam? Would that house in Atlanta be considered my second home? I only go to the other house once a month or once every two months. Is it still considered my home then?

Also, I was born in India so that is my birthplace.

Based on what you have mentioned, it is not considered your home, and you should pray qasr there

Which is more reccomended, supplicationing directly towards Allah or supplicating to Allah through a Waseel? Which method of supplicating is more appropriate in certain situations? Which method is reccomended in all situations?

Both are needed and are recommended in the Quran

How can I stop watching pornography and masturbating when I am so deep into it so. Can you give me some advice on how to stop this gunnah and be a proper muslim

Please watch this lecture

https://youtu.be/tckb_PK2CbU
https://youtu.be/pwkci_Tg5SM

Both are connected

I remember weakly that you had shared a Facebook post regarding the number of turbah one can use. I think it was mentioned that one cannot use more than one turbah from the masjid at a time.

I’m unable to find that post. Can you kindly help me with the issue here and maybe point me to any reference book that has spoken about it?

Essentially if you don’t have permission you should use one turba in the mosque. The waqf on it is usually for Sajda not for support of sajda. Best to bring your own from home

This is in Sistani.org Arabic

Is it permissible to eat meat from a Halal animal which has been stunned before being slaughtered.

Yes it’s permissible

I'm a revert to Shia faith and my husband is a Sunni. However , my family and my husband don't know about my faith since it'll cause them to break ties with me. Now, I'm married to my husband for 4 months and he's being really toxic towards me. He doesn't respect me or care for me like a husband does and gets mad if I try to approach. We are at the moment in a long distance relationship and won't be meeting until 2021. I'm trying my best to cope with this situation. And I can't tell anything to my parents since he's my cousin and my parents will take his side. Could you advice me Sheikh on what strategies I should follow in order to help this relationship grow. I don't want my husband to leave me God forbid.

It is important that you don’t dismiss these concerns at this stage.

Marriage is a journey, which has ups and downs, but you learn about each other

Suffering in silence is not way forward. Husband and wife need to develop communication skills, love, respect, appreciation and trust for each other. Sometimes books and courses need to be referred to. Your husband needs to understand his roles and duties going forward.

Long distance is not good and especially for a few years. The first few years of marriage are key and you should be together. It does not spell well for future if it’s a lengthy years away from each other.

In tarikh tabari they say that from Karbala to Sham the enemies of Allah pulled Sayyida Zaynab and the ladies hijab. Some say they only pulled their maqnah they had underneath a chador. While others say they pulled the entire hijaab so that her hair was showing. Do you know whether it’s the first or the latter which is the case.

In my research, it was both but for different people. For some it was the outer hijab or face covering, whilst for others it was the hair covering. For eg, Sukayna daughter of Imam Hussain has her earrings snatched. This can only happen if the hijab was removed

I am facing grave problem because of my excessive and uncontrollable anger and foul-mouth. I am trying a lot,making dua but I cannot control myself. Even I lost my control and beat my loved one(wife). I want to get rid of this calamitity of my life. Please provide me with advices.

You must seek professional help by seeing specialist and doing courses. This is fine and in fact in your case very necessary. It’s like any other condition which requires attention.

You can also watch this lecture on marriage and anger

https://youtu.be/EK301cVSO4U

What does Islam say on people who use Jinn to predict and spy on people? Can you please give me verses from Quran, and hadiths? I need it badly.

Please see this answer by Ayatollah Sistani

https://www.sistani.org/english/qa/01224/

Teens these days use the Ahlulbayt in their jokes or so called "memes". Is it prohibited to do so? Often, its pretty disrespectful as well, but they justify it by saying that "its a joke". Can you clear this for me?

Such memes are not permissible and should not be spread as well
Any form of disrespect towards Allah, the Prophets and Ahlulbayt is not allowed in Islam

If Prophet Muhammad (saws) was already present when Adam (as) was created, why did he (saws) come in the last? What message was it that he (saws) had to deliver that he (saws) waited for thousands of years and thousands of messengers from Allah to pass by?

His light was created first, not his physical body.

Is there any issue with getting a haircut or cutting your nails on certain days like Tuesday?
I’ve often heard people in my community say that an Imam from the Ahlulbayt (as) forbade people from cutting hair and nails on Tuesday but without any proof. This has often led to arguments within our family aswell. Would be very grateful if you could please clear away any doubts.

No there is no prohibition at all during days and times of the week (except in hajj).
Yes there are times when it is makrooh (discouraged) but not haram.

I wanted to know a book which could be easily available which has all issues of number two just like what was done in Sulah hudaybiah and raziyat yaum al Khamis. I need to know where I can find all atrocities done by him and others claiming near and dear ones

See this book
https://www.al-islam.org/restatement-history-islam-and-muslims-sayyid-ali-asghar-razwy

Is it haram to cheat and if so what is the punishment?
If there was a condition in the Muttah contract that the male cannot take another partner and he breaks the contract and does, what’s the ruling/punishment?
As well if he forced the girl to change her mahr and kept prolonging giving her it?

Yes cheating is not permissible and it’s a sin.
If the contract is broken then the wife has the right to annul the contact. Forcing change of mehr is not permissible

To whom we say السَّلاَمُ عَلَيْكُمْ وَرَحْمَةُ اللهِ وَبَرَكَاتُهُ in prayer.

It is a salaam to all angels, Prophets, believers etc as the previous statements point to

1) If i am filling a bucket from a tap which is connect to a tank of 1200 liters, can i consider that bucket water as qur water and all the laws of qur water applies on that as well.
2) If I came to know that I was in state of janabat after one day, do I need to repray all my namaz or its ok?

The water in the bucket would not be kur just because of where you got it from, but rather the size of the bucket is the determining factor
Second, yes if you discover on second day and u know for sure it was from day before then you would need to repeat the prayers

Why muslims do not compromise how the great prophet has been murdered and why they do not have that courage to say it?

There are different opinions amongst the scholars on this matter. At the same time there are scholars who believe such a discussion brings about Muslim disunity hence they avoid it
Allah knows best

I work as a kitchen hand in a restaurant that serves bacon. Is it Haram to work here?

Serving pork products is not permissible

Can I eat In N Out burgers? My shia friends eat it and when asked they say that Allah says in Quran that you can eat from the people of the book and this is a wholesome christian establishment. Therefore it’s halal.

According to Shia Islamic law you can only eat meat that which has been slaughtered according to Islamic guidelines. Just saying name of Allah on it does not make it halal at all, and consuming it would then be haram

I am really interested in further studying Shia Islamic studies but don’t know the most efficient way. I have plenty of great books I got from Najaf and Karbala and l am currently reading them carefully. l would like to know a better way to study the books so l will get more knowledge and ask the right questions. I don’t know where to seek a hawza in my area and l'm still studying full time at uni. Where do you recommend l begin? I will also watch lectures please guide me to good maulana speeches.

Keep this enthusiasm for learning as it’s a good sign. Try ehawza.com as it has a good Hawza course. Also identify gaps in your knowledge and then find books on the subject

My toddler is due for her yearly flu vaccine which is a nasal spray. I have learnt that it contains pork gelatin. Is it permissible for her in islam to get the vaccine containing pork gelatin?

According to Sayid Sistani, if you are fairly certain that in the manufacturing of the spray (or anything else that contains animal gelatine) transformation استحالة takes place, then it is permissible to use. This is the case even if it’s pork gelatine. Ayatullah Khoei believed it that it does go through transformation and so it’s ok (confirmed to me by Sayid Milani).

So it comes to personal conviction. My personal opinion, and ofcourse non binding on anyone, and after speaking to my father as a chemist and Sh Usama Attar who has a PhD in chemistry and he asked his professor in Canada too, and they both confirmed transformation does take place

My 80 year old uncle and his wife are going to umra for the first time without a Maulana or group. I had one question. If they complete the umra, finish the taqseer, MUST they do the tawaf un nissa the same day? It might be to taxing for him. Also, the last umra I did was 2017 April… are their any changes to the haram like levels for saee that I can give them a heads up on. Just in case you are wondering, I am assisting with umra procedure bc they aren’t too well versed on fiqh matters.

It is fine to do tawaf al-nisa next day or day after, but before they return and leave Mekka it must be done. The only thing they can’t do before tawaf al-nisa and afternoon taqseer is the relationship between husband and wife

Rules regarding tawaf and saee are the same as 2017 as far as I’m aware

I converted (reverted) to islam when I was 30 by myself no witnesses alone. I do not know if I converted properly for one this always makes me question is it valid and also how many prayers and fasts should I make up for now am 42 have prayed many and fasted many but I feel I should just make up for last 12 years to have a topped account of my obligations and do I include the mentsral days as well ? Do I make up since 12/13 years old to make sure I have no debts in those and leave upon my death on others for these when I can do my best to do these myself as these are my responsibilities. Or since I converted to Islam at age 30 so do I make up from 30 or since first menstral? Also for missed prayers to do is the qunoot wajib to do it or mustahab since I have many many to make up for? Please tell me so I can work on these things and if I am not been able to complete by my time to go can any charities feeding homeless or anything can help on these to help me ? Please help answer these

Please let me know how u converted

You don’t need witnesses, just to state the shahadah

I took shower and stated the shahadah. I studied and research a lot before I converted and still always read and study always educate myself. My concern is above inquires. As I hope to complete with additional before my time is finished here! May Allah (swt) allow it

You don’t need to worry and may Allah accept your deeds

How to guide your children from the shaytan ages 14,boy 15 girl from influential friends that they make? A lot of parents are so busy with work to make money and don’t pay attention to their children and what they do. As I do not work, I see many things that is not good for their hereafter. I cannot guide these many children but the influence is really overwhelming. I want to move from my city to make another move eventually out of western world to not lose them to shaytan for I do not have family that follow. As for my husband he has but always busy same thing work both leave kids. Please help

Tarbiyya begins in the beginning of childhood .Parents are role models and you have to start with yourself. They will learn from you through actions.
Also friends are important. Creating spiritual love in the house helps too.
Please recite Quran 25:74 as many times to help

There is a YouTube by the name of (removed). They regularly make a hoard of academic videos to refute the Shia ideology. My question is esteemed sheikh, has any scholar recognized the existence of such a channel? Are they working to refute their academic arguments? They even have a website called twelvershia.net, and they post their so called refutations there too. It would be extremely helpful for laymen's such as myself to have an answer to most of the things that they say.

Such sites and channels promote sectarianism and have no basis. All of their points have been answered strongly and refuted by our ulema in thousands of books.
The best way is academic calm discussion based on evidence. Giving attention to these sites only supplies them with the oxygen they’re desperate to get for publicity. Channels and sites are many which attach shiasm. We have to provide alternative sites where the beautiful message of Ahlulbayt is presented with wisdom and intellect

I have a question regarding la3n.

Firstly is la3n halal?
Secondly when am i allowed to send la3n on someone?
Thirdly, if someone claims to be shia but openly says things such as hadeeth al kisa is bid3a, the walk of arbaeen is an innovation etc and this persons idea is causing disunity in a community am I allowed to send lanat on then person?

La’an is a dua which is requesting Allah to withdraw His mercy from someone. It is mentioned many times in the Quran. It should be sent on enemies of Allah and the Ahlulbayt
You should not say it against someone you disagree with only even if they’re wrong. The only way they’re to be included in la’na is if they’re clear enemies of God and Islam.

I have heard that once you finish intercourse with your partner and you wipe yourselves with tissues, you should not both put your tissues in the same bin as it causes animosity between the couple. Is this true or just a false tale?

This is not based on Islamic teachings and perhaps maybe cultural practices

My child is enrolled in a daycare. He is learning many things over there. But he has also started to dance on music. I guess they make him dance on rhymes. I had seen the previous daycare too, making kids dance.

I had mentioned this specifically while enrolling in this daycare, that I don't want him to be made to listen to musical rhymes or dance. But they seem to have not paid attention to that. And usually they can't stop one child from a musical activity, while all others are doing it, because child cannot understand and forced.

I'm thinking of many alternatives, but it's not working out for me currently. I wanted to know if it is obligatory to avoid musical rhymes from kids. Or it's acceptable?
These days, every toy is musical. And my kid has also started to ask to play rhymes on ipad /mobile. So should I avoid that too? What's the ruling? How to solve this issue?

You should be careful as it may develop into a habit and liking as the child grows up
It depends on age but you must not take this lightly and tried to avoid it as much as possible, esp when child becomes older such as 7 onwards

Should we avoid participation in such Mock Arbaeen walks that are organised in Non-Muslim countries by Shias?

Such processions are usually done on good faith to uphold name and values of Imam Hussain (a) and Ashura, therefore as long as they serve this purpose and are in line with Sharia they should be attended and supported

I’m a revert to shiaism alhamudlilah but unfortunately my parents come from a strict salafi background and claim Shi’as are kufar and they are unaware of my transition. Recently I have met a Shia man who I am willing to get married to but I don’t know how to approach my parents as I’m afraid they will disown me or become greatly upset with me. I will be very grateful for any advice you can provide in terms of dealing with this.

Perhaps you’ll need to approach a member of family who is sympathetic and can speak to your parents on your behalf. Ultimately you have to be positive but expect the worse as well. Pray on these holy nights sincerely and seek intercession of Ahlulbayt (a)
I pray for your success



شو رأيك بالموضوع النصيب؟

كام ناس بيقول ما في شي اسمو هيك بالحياة وكام ناس بيقول عنجد في



الله يبسط الرزق لمن يشاء و يقدر

من احد مصاديق الرزق الزواج، فلذلك نؤمن بأن الله تعالى يعطي و يمنع لمصلحة يعلمها هو، و ما علينا الا ان ندعوا و نسعي و نتوكل علية سبحانه

My question revolves around the car business. If some of my income is derived from collecting interest, is this considered haram income? Let me give you details: customer comes to the car dealership to buy a car, requires financing, we contact the bank and the bank gives us an approval interest rate, the dealership in turn marks up that approval rate and profits the difference. My paycheck is derived from getting a percentage of that difference. Is this haram income because the source is from interest?

If you are in charge and set the interest yourself or the interest gaining scheme and you can change it, then it’s not permissible

However if it’s out of your hands and you’re an employee then there is no problem

A fellow Christian friend has asked me a few questions in regards to these Qur’anic verses;

“And of His signs is that He created you from dust; then, suddenly you were human beings dispersing [throughout the earth].”-30-20

“Allah has created every [living] creature from water”. -24:45.

His question is, if man is created from dust, that which is dry, then how can we are created by something which is wet, that is- Water?

The process of creation is complex. It’s a sign of Allah’s Greatness. Adam was created from soil mixed with water. Our creation involves much fluids, origin of it is water. Much of our bodies is water based etc

Being a student in a european country, I sometimes pray with our sunni brothers in their mosques since I do not find mosques of the followers of Ahl al Bayt (as) here.
Sunni point their index fingers of the right hand while they are doing the qad’ah and the greetings (in the sujud).
I would like to know if this act is obligatory, haram or if their is any recommandation about doing this since I never learnt about this with shia.

This is not something that should be done in Salah according to the school of Ahlulbayt since they and the Prophet did not practice this

To contextualize my question, I'm going to tell you what I'm not asking: Im not asking for proof of Ismah as a doctrine, but rather why Prophets have been given ismah in the context of predestination and free will. Moreover, I am not asking for proof of free will either.

My question is in multiple parts and I've done my best to break it down into yes/no type questions.

Were Prophets chosen from the start or were they chosen conditional to whether someone in a society was capable of accepting Prophethood (by their own merit)?

If the former, then can't the objection be brought up that those prophets were essentially predestined heaven (and therefore making Allah unjust in some way)?

If the latter, then is it possible for ordinary people to reach the level of prophets?

If this is not possible and if what makes prophets better than ordinary humans the fact that Allah has granted them wahy and knowledge, then is it fair ask why ordinary people don't also receive that same treatment as mentioned by 12:24 which would thereby guarantee them heaven and protection from sin?

If the granting of wahy and knowledge is conditional upon someone having intelligence and purity, then is it a reasonable objection to say that intelligence is not a controllable factor?

If intelligence is not a controllable thing, then can the same objection be brought up that most intelligent people who are granted prophethood are guaranteed heaven (thus making Allah unjust again) because their uncontrollable faculty of reasoning was why they were granted wahy which prevents them from sin? (That is, someone's uncontrollable circumstances has led them to have a higher capacity, and therefore they have a greater opportunity to reach a higher level of heaven than ordinary people)

Please forgive the scatterbrained question, I had to think about how I was going to ask this. I'm not sure if you can ask for clarification on this app, so forgive any confusing wording.

Yes I understand how this question can go round in loops

With Allah there is no time. He created time. In His infinite knowledge He knew that these people (Prophets and Ahlulbayt) would be suitable to attain ismah. He does not need to create them to then see they’re good and grant them Ismah. He knew before creation.

Is this predetermination? Not really, since they have a choice and can sin if they wanted. In Quran a number of verses confirm this.

Therefore they’re the best people to receive this

Could we also have been those people? Possibly, but the choice was made for them. Why we don’t know. Some had to be chosen. Could we reach their ismah? Not their level but some level is possible.

The other thing to consider is some areas might confuse us more when we keep thinking about them, for eg what happened before creation of the universe, time etc..our intellect has not been created to take this information. Allah knows best

I had a somewhat related follow-up.

In looking into this question, I came across A'raf 172. How does that fit into this discussion? Was this a time where we were tested before we were born and then given distinctions? I read into Allamah Tabatabai's 'Mizan' on this verse and it ended up confirming that Imamate and Prophethood were chosen in that world as part of our covenant. Can you explain this verse further please?

Yes this is known as Aalam Aldhar.
We were tested before this world.
Narrations tell us the Prophets and Imams responded before us acknowledging God’s oneness etc.

My emotions about to be a Shi'â, want to know what should I do about it?
And if Majlumiyat a Niyamat from Allah then in which way to talk about life will be a Haqque or Itaât?

You should research from authentic sources and ask any questions you may have from reputable scholars.

The path of Shiasm we believe is the true path of Islam, with the teachings from the Holy Prophet and his family, who according to the Quran are the best.

Is it recommended to marry four wives?

It is permissible in Islam, under certain conditions

If for example during my salah , I think about something bad , without do it intentionally makes my salah baatil?

For example, I prayed, and one music just come to my mind and I tried to directly ignore it and change my mind to be more concentrated and continued my prayer.
Is it ok? Or I have to repeat my namaz again?

Thoughts in the min do not invalidate the prayers

If I make mistake in the makhraj of the zikr of the namaz, my salat is still ok? Or its invalid?
Do I have to re do it again?

It depends on which act of salah and whether it was intentional or not.
For eg any mistake in the Takbeer renders the salah batil.

I am muslim but I got a lot of questions about raising children with a woman or a man who doesn’t follow or who doesn’t have the same faith? For example a shia muslim who married a sunni woman, having children a shia man want to bring the chidren to his side, but she doesn’t want. What is going to happen in that case?

Such marriages are challenging as both husband and wife need to be understanding and have mutual respect before marriage regarding these sensitive issues.
Otherwise problems will arise.
If these conflicts do arise, there has to be an agreement with negotiation on exactly how to proceed.
This will involve some degree of compromise.

I have three questions pertaining to Ehram.
First: Are we allowed to use unscented halal deodorant while in Ehram? Can we use baking soda/corn starch on our body to stay dry.
Second: Can we use mint flavored toothpaste while in Ehram?
Third: Is it true that while in Ehram we are not permitted to use any clothing like sheets, towels etc that are yellow in color?
Also, Alhamdulillah we are going for Hajj this year. We have been taking out Khums every year for the past several years. However in early stages of his career my husband did not bring Khums out for various reasons one of them being that he was not fully aware about it and now looking back since he was not earning enough and had family responsibilities and loans he was mostly short of cash. That was for 6-8 years. Now how do we figure out how much khums he would have had to take out during those years. We have taken an estimated number but are not sure if it is ok. Will you please help us with this.
InshaAllah I will be praying for your son at Hajj. May Allah, for the sake of His Holy Masumeen, grant him a quick and complete recovery and bless him with a happy and healthy long life. Ameen!


1) Any deodorant is not permissible whilst in ehram unless it’s for medical reasons (one that is needed to avoid excessive harm)
2) Mint toothpaste is allowed but you should avoid smelling it as much as possible
3) Yellow sheets etc in ehram is ok

For khums, try to go back to bank statements on those years and estimate to the best of your ability, asking Allah for help and forgiveness

Is it wajib to save your own life? Even if saving your own life means taking away someone elses

You should seek to save your life and the ones of others as well

Can a female lead jama’a prayers for females?

Yes

I was thinking of starting a youtube vlogging channel along with my wife. I want to know whether that is permissible in Islam.

As long as hijab is observed and content is not haram there is no problem

Is diyah money required when the child died unintentionally because of mother being ill and the cause of death was due to medicines.

More information is required.

Did the mother’s illness lead to the death? How were the medicines involved?

Is it allowed for me to have a preferred surname to go by? I'm aware it's haram for me to change my surname to that of my (step) father from that of my biological father but was wondering, while officially in places like uni and work my biological name would be used, could I request for my preferred name to be used casually?

As long as this preferred surname does not bring you degradation or is that related to enemies of Islam there is no problem

I had a question on something I’ve been curious about. I know in Islamic jurisprudence, fathers are responsible for providing for children. What happens if there is a divorce? Does the woman have any rights to her kids? I’m just curious as I’ve never heard it talked about (and in reality most children end up with the mom). Part of my curiosity is because the Quran so beautifully talks about reuniting Moses (pbuh) with his mother to cool her grief.


In Islamic law, after divorce the mother has the right to look after the children until they’re seven years of age. In these years the father has to provide for the needs of the children. After seven, he has the right of the children. There are some exceptions stipulated in opinions of scholars.

How to guide your children from the shaytan ages 14,boy 15 girl from influential friends that they make? A lot of parents are so busy with work to make money and don’t pay attention to their children and what they do. As I do not work I see many things that is not good for their hereafter, I cannot guide these many children but the influence is really overwhelming. I want to move from my city to make another move eventually out of western world to not lose them to shaytan for I do not have family that follow. As for my husband he has but always busy. Same thing- work both leave kids. Please help.


Tarbiyya begins in the beginning of childhood.
Parents are role models and you have to start with yourself.
They will learn from you through actions.
Also friends are important.
Creating spiritual love in the house helps too.
Please recite Quran 25:74 as many times to help.

I have been doing a horrible sin for multiple years (masturbation). I do so frequently. I am studing in Uni and I have been trying to get married for two years so I can stop sinning, but have found no spouse. I have made numerous attempts to stop sinning by seeing a psychologist, fasting for 40 days, increasing istighfar, and more. I don't know what else to do and I think my heart is diseased. I need a solution. I am in great distress.

You must do whatever it takes to stop sinning. One option is temporary marriage. Other is to widen your search for permanent wife. You must not let the Shaitan win and should work hard to satisfy your needs in an Islamic acceptable way.
You need to make yourself busy and don’t go through boredom. Don’t watch or think of indecent things and try to busy yourself with halal means and recommended deeds

I used to go to the gym, but stopped because seeing women there had a negative effect on my faith. Now I exercise at home instead with the intention to maintain health because I feel it helps my iman, but now I receive negative comments about how scrawny I look. I want to exercise to get big muscles instead so I can feel good about how I look. My question is, is this a halaal intention in Islam? Is it ok for me to exercise with this intention or should I just forget about exercising to build muscles and look good? What do you suggest in my situation?

There is no problem in exercising to become healthier, but be wary of building muscles or doing it to show others, as this is frowned upon in Islamic teachings.

Allah loves stronger human beings. There is no problem is this is done for His sake. Strength should be physical as well as spiritual

My question is that what is the meaning of Ta'a kibat?

It means ‘afterwards’ or ‘what is to follow’

This is in reference to the dikhr and duas recited after obligatory prayers

I am angry with my parents since a month, and at the same time,they are also angry with me. I dont want this situation but every time , the things happen unintentionally , a week passes in this state and after that no one talks to each other because of ego. I am afraid that I am being cursed by Allah, Imam and angels in this state.
My question is, is it true that a person in this situation is cursed and the prayers and ibadat of such person is not accepted? Even due to such thoughts I often dont offer prayers or in other words i am being deprived from namaz and divine guidance. If I feel sorry for my act but dont appologize to them, am I forgiven by Allah?

As you know Islam emphasises strong respect to Parents
It’s essential they are not hurt or annoyed if possible, unless it’s because of obedience to Allah.
Qur’an says we should not say ‘uff’ at the very least.
So you should seek forgiveness from them and try your best, even if they’re wrong
But you should never stop prayers etc
You perform Salah and try your best not to have fights with your parents and please them. This will please Allah (swt)

Is it sami allah hu leman hameda or hamedah with a slight h? Because I said the former instead of the latter then I wasn’t sure which one was correct so I carried on with my Salah. Is my salah valid?

This is mustahab anyway and so your Salah is valid

Is it backbiting if I speak about something done to me without the other person knowing who it is I'm referring to. So for example I say my neighbor did so and so to upset me, given that the person I'm talking to doesn't know who my neighbor is, would that still count as gheeba?

The neighbour can be identified later and is being specifically identified so you should not say anything about them that is hidden from people and they don’t like

My question is, is it allowed to give a wine bottle as a gift to a Christian/ non Muslim colleague at work place ?
How about if someone else buys the wine and gives as a gift to the coworker on behalf of me, would it be permissible then? And I give the coworker who bought wine, another gift evaluating to amount he initially spent on the wine bottle?

Any interaction or delivery or passing on alcohol to anyone is not permissible and haram. This is irrespective if the recipient is Muslim or not.

1: Is it allowed to swim during the mustahab fasting?
2: Can we break the fast if someone is offering you food even though the person knows I am fasting?
3: Is there a time limit to break the mustahab fast or it can be at anytime if anyone offers food that we can consume it?

1. According to Ayatollah Sistani it is allowed but strongly discouraged
2. If it is recommended fast and not obligatory, yes you can break fast
3. It can be anytime

My daughter lives in Cairo and there are no official Shia nikah authority that perform official Shia nikahs. Therefore we shall do the official nikkah the Sunni way, and we will recite the Shia nikkah ourselves at home. Is this ok according to Islamic Laws?
Secondly my daughter will travel to India for the wedding after a few months and we want to do the official Shia nikkah in India. Is there an issue/problem in reciting a nikkah more than once?

Both are fine

There is a widow lady she lost her husband 10 years back and she is in menopause stage and she has no issue recently. She heard about IVF method that with the help of IVF a lady with Menopouse get pregnant and she want to get pregnant with this method. But she would like to know if the child she births will be jaiz or not.

There is no problem in it per se, however, since the process may involve masturbation, and implanting involves touching and seeing the private part, insemination would only be allowed when the parties involved may face difficulty in their life which is not normally bearable.
Also, regards to the matters of inheritance and Mahramiyat the parties involved need to refer to the specific Islamic Law rulings.

We know there are 4 living prophets. I only know Isa is in the heavens and Khizr on the land. The two remaining, Idris and Ilyas, where are they? Any evidence from Quran or ahadith on these 4 living prophets? Will all 4 re-appear when 12th Imam (a) reappears?

Re Prophet Idris: check surah Mariam verse 57
Re Prophet Ilyas: historic narrations such as in Tabari point to Allah raising him to heavens

Yes they will all return with the holy 12th Imam, the awaited saviour, Inshallah

What is the ruling of agha seestani for the leather products made in China, India, Italy, Portugal, Brazil and these products purchased from UAE. Can we give probability of tazkia and considered it as tahir and use those products or those products are najis.

If you’re sure they are from the countries mentioned, it’s likely to be Najis, since his ruling is whether there is a chance they are made from dhabeeha which is halal. It is unlikely that this is the case in those countries, since they’re not majority Muslim countries, unless you have information that dhabeeha was used

I have not paid Khums in my life. I wanted to do it now…Can you please let me know how to compute the Khums for the first time?

You need to estimate as far back as possible, as well as deduct the loan from the khums. Please read this book and if you have any questions please ask:

https://www.al-islam.org/khums-islamic-tax-sayyid-muhammad-rizvi

Recently I have come across a difference in understanding of the translation/tafseer of Surah 7, Verse 46. This verse speaks about the individuals who are on top of Al-A’raf (the elevated wall) and are able to recognize people based on their marks.

‎وَبَيْنَهُمَا حِجَابٌ ۚ وَعَلَى الْأَعْرَافِ رِجَالٌ يَعْرِفُونَ كُلًّا بِسِيمَاهُمْ ۚ وَنَادَوْا أَصْحَابَ الْجَنَّةِ أَنْ سَلَامٌ عَلَيْكُمْ ۚ لَمْ يَدْخُلُوهَا وَهُمْ يَطْمَعُونَ

[46] A barrier divides the two groups with men on its heights recognizing each group by their marks: they will call out to the people of the Garden, ‘Peace be with you!’- they will not have entered, but they will be hoping,

The meaning according to the Sunni school of thought suggest that this is in regards to people whose good deeds equal their bad deeds.

From my understanding, the Shia perspective is that these individuals are in fact the Ahlulbayt (and/or the Prophets). What is the basis behind this? Are there authenticated narrations that indicate this?

Ash-Shaykh al-Mufid comments that: "It has been said that al-A‘raf is a mountain midway between Paradise and the Fire. Also, that it is a dividing wall between Paradise and Hell. It is generally considered a (particular) place belonging neither to Paradise nor to Hell."These interpretations are confirmed by traditions, which furthermore, state that on the Day of Resurrection there will be found upon it the Messenger of Allah, the Commander of the Believers and the Imams from his progeny – may the blessing of Allah be upon him and his family.
Those are they whom Allah, the Exalted, and means by His saying:
And on the ramparts do men know each by their mark, who shall call to the inhabitants of Paradise: "Peace be upon you! They have not entered it, for all their eagerness" [7:46],
that is, because Allah, the Almighty, will enable them to discriminate between the inhabitants of Paradise and those of Hell by signs resembling marks.
This He illustrates further in His saying:
"They know each by their mark". And also: The sinners shall be known by their marks [55:41].
He the Almighty, also says:
Surely in that are signs for such as mark; surely they are on a way still un- effaced [15:75-76].
Thus, He tells that amongst His creatures there is a group which scrutinizes men and knows them by the marks they bear. It has been related from the Commander of the Believers, peace be upon him, that he has said in some of his narrations, "I am the holder of the baton and the clear-sighted", which means that he knows the state of him whom he scrutinizes carefully.
It has been related from Abu Ja‘far Muhammad al- Baqir, peace be upon him, that he was questioned on the meaning of the speech of Allah: "Surely in that are signs for such as mark1 , he said, "That it refers to us, the People of the House (i.e., the Imams, peace be upon them)." It is also mentioned in the traditions that Allah, the Almighty will place therein, that is, al-A‘raf, a group of men who have failed to merit Paradise by their good acts and have not deserved punishment, yet they do not merit an eternal abode in Hell; among these are they who wait for the decision of Allah and entertain hope of intercession; they will abide there till they are permitted to enter Paradise through the intercession of the Prophet, peace be upon him and his progeny, and the Commander of the Believers and the Imams, peace be upon them.
It has been mentioned also that it is an abode of those who were not subject to any relig- ious obligation in their lifetime, thus they do not deserve either Paradise or Hell; therefore Allah will place them therein and recompense them with a certain grace which is far below that of those who merited it by the virtue of their acts. Hence, all that is mentioned above (concerning al-A‘raf) is tenable by reason and confirmed by traditions, and yet Allah best knows the truth. What is generally accepted regarding al-A‘raf is that it is a place midway between Paradise and Hell; there will stand those whom we call the Proofs of Allah to His creatures (Hujaj Allah, that is, the Prophet and the Imams); there, also, will be those whose final judgment has been deferred. Beyond this Allah knows best what will be.
* 1. See al-Kulayni, al-Kafi, vol.l, p.218, Tradition nos.l & 2. Also, al-Mufid,al-Ikhtisas, p.303.

https://www.al-islam.org/emendation-shiite-creed-shaykh-al-mufid/24-chapter-al-araf

My brother in law works as a crew in airlines and travel abroad very frequently. Today he has a flight at 4:30 pm and he will reach switzerland at 12 midnight. What is the ruling for breaking fast. He should break the fast on time in flight or after reaching? The flight time is 7-8 hrs

He can break the fast in the plane when he sees that it’s dark outside (ie sun has completely set)

How does one attend family house when one does not feel comfortable? Therefore one has stopped going. They have said that when we invite you never come. One has to make excuses not to attend. The environment is about gossiping, getting too involved in others lives, listening to music etc.

Perhaps attending for a short while or explaining the reason is the best way forward

I have read and heard in the past : to the Eyes of Allah swt fasting is even greater than praying because a female that is in her period does not need to repay her Salaah but has to repay her fast. Was this a hadith or an incident ? I cant remember more details about this

No this is not the case. One is not able to derive this based on the ruling, as this would be conjecture (qiyas) which is not permissible. Both prayers and fasting are obligatory and beloved to Allah (swt)

The english translation of ruling 1750 says that “it is haraam for the children to observe a Mustahab fast if it causes emotional suffering to their parents.”
Does “children” here mean small children or sons and daughters regardless of age?

This is for any children that are still being looked after by their parents, ie dependents

Please elaborate on the Rules/steps that need to be followed for a couple who are on mutah/engagement and want to make changes:

1. how can a condition that was part of the mutah be changed/added/removed?

2. how can the remaining period can be forgiven?

To end it, the husband says: I forsake the remaining time remaining.

Then it’s best to do another contract with the new conditions agreed by both

Follow up question:
Would it be correct if the husband says that from this future date and time i forgive the remaining period?

No, it should be said whenever he wishes to terminate

My question is regarding the precautionary ‘imsaak’ period before fajr.
Is it compulsory to observe this and start the fast at the time of imsaak and is the fast void if you eat during the time of imsaak? And what are the references for this.

It is advisory and not obligatory, due to the difficulty of determining exact fajr or subh sadiq time in some places

I have been struggling with spirituality for a prolonged period of time. It has exhausted me, especially since i haven’t experienced a spiritual low like this in so long.
I long to regain high spirituality, but even though I still perform prayer & read the Quran, I can’t seem to feel a connection with God. Any advice would be appreciated, for I am incredibly lost at the moment.

The very fact you’re looking for connection is good
You need to to stick to what is wajib and avoid haram acts. Then as much as possible recite Quran, the Dua that you can connect with and understand, help others (which increases spirituality) and speak to Allah privately. Don’t give up and sometimes going to holy places or mosques etc helps
Have a programme of seeking knowledge and reflect on Qur’an and Hadith as much as possible
Lots of reflection on the greatness of Allah and His creation would help as well
Try to find a scholar who can give u personalised advice based on your own situation in your area. Sometimes what works for some may not work for others .

Since I've been baligh, I've prayed and fasted on and off and I have no idea how many prayers/fasts I've missed.
I'm pretty sure some years I haven't missed anything, and other years I've missed the majority. How do I determine how many prayers/fasts I have to make up? Also, some of the fasts missed were intentionally broken while some weren't, so how do i determine how many i have to do kaffarah for?

You have to first estimate to the best of your ability. It’s between you and Allah. Those that you know for sure u broke intentionally you must pay kaffara for.

After this, I recommend you do prayers and fast ‘ihtiyat’ just in case, to cover what was possibly missed.

What amaal can i do to meet Imam Mahdi aj.Either in my dreams or in person.

Imam (a) meets people who are pure in their heart, sincere in devotion and are humble in the path of Allah (swt). It does not necessarily involve Amaal or to be a scholar etc

But it is highly recommended to keep praying to Allah for the blessed meeting and not to give up. Sometimes we meet him in person or In dream but we don’t recognise him.

Dua Ahad every morning for at least 40 morning
2 Rokah after fajr and gift it to Imam (as)
Give Sadaqa on behalf of Imam
Improve Akhlaq and relationship with Allah

Could you recommend an amaal I can do at home to meet Imam Mahdi either in person or in my dreams?

There is no authentic Amal for that.

Can you recommend an amaal to recite to help meet Imam Mahdi aj?

You may read dua e Ahad for 40 days after namaz e Fajr In’Sha’Allah you will meet Imam Zamana as Imam Jafar Sadiq A’s has promised.

And what about the days in which I may miss fajr due to menstruation?

Continue after the taharat.

Recently I have given up wearing makeup as I now know that it is not allowed.
I have a lot of makeup I wish to remove from my home.
Is it okay to give this away to family members that wear makeup?

Yes that is fine, since your intention should be that they use it for halal purposes (ie when they are with mahrems only)

Recently I have given up wearing makeup as I now know that it is not allowed.
I have a lot of makeup I wish to remove from my home.
Is it okay to give this away to Muslim family members that wear makeup?

Makeup to be worn infront of Na mahram is forbidden and attracting them would be counted as a sin. You can keep it and use it appropriately for your spouse or other gatherings where women usually attend, there is no harm in that, rather, it can be an act of virtue if done for the sake of Allah's pleasure.
If you still want to distribute it, do so to people whom you know would not use it in the wrong way as I've mentioned, ie, attracting Na mahram.

I’ve met someone online and he’s wanting to come visit me and I’m not sure how I’d tell my parents or anything. I want to do mutah with him just so I can go out with him and talk to him and get to know him but I’m not sure how I’d approach my parents because they’re really close minded and the subject of mutah is often looked down on but I’m doing it just to get to know the guy because he is in a different country and traveling a long way to see me is such a hassle and I want to make the most of it and I don’t want to do it behind my parents backs because I value both relationships

You should seek parents approval and it’s not a good idea to do it behind their back
Have Tawakkul on Allah and place trust in Him
Maybe if the say no ask a relative or a local scholar to speak to them
Try to be calm but rational. Explain the circumstances to your parents. Give sadaqa and do much Dua

I wanted to ask about the nawfil salah after salatul isha, if it’s performed standing or sitting, and if it is sitting what is the reason behind it. Also can salatul witr be prayed directly after isha.

It should be done whilst sitting.

Yes witr can be performed directly after isha, in accordance with Ayatollah Sistani

I’ve recently heard that delaying isha salah has been advised by the prophet Mohammed (saw), just want to clarify the authenticity of this.
Furthermore, I’m a revert into the school of ahlul bayt and my family don’t know and they come from a very strict Sunni background. I know in terms of salah I can perform it under taqiyah but conscious about fasting because I end up breaking it at their Maghreb timings. Also I’ve met a shia man and I really want to make it halal between us but don’t know how to go about this because I’m still living with my parents I.e. I’m not independent and I’m still a virgin- these are the conditions I’ve seen where I don’t need the permission of my wali; and my family will never accept a shia man.

1. Delaying isha salah is ok if it’s within time frame of its recommendation, as the Prophet used to combine and separate prayers in different occasions

2. Yes you can break fast with your Sunni family by taqiyya (some Shi’a marajie allow it)

3. Ayatullah Hakim allows temporary marriage without sexual intercourse without need to take permission of father. You can follow him in this ruling. Please be advised on the strict condition as above

If someone is bald or suffers from alopecia such that he wears a hair system/piece/wig that is stuck on to his head, can Ghusl and Wudu be performed over such hair systems – whether temporary or permanent? Or must they be removed first, no matter how difficult that may be? The same question also for women with hair extensions/pieces.

They should be removed, as they’ll be a barrier to water getting to scalp (unless water can get to scalp somehow with required amount)
If it’s too difficult then tayamum must take place instead of wudhu

What is the ruling regarding nauha/marsiya with background music?

Specially in nauhas of iran and Iraq.

Example link :https://youtu.be/P81wdwSj0YA

The music must not be suitable for gatherings of vice and wrongdoings

How to distinguish music suitable for gatherings of wrongdoings and vice.

If it can be played or used in those gatherings then it’s suitable

I am getting to know someone for marriage and I have discovered the mans father drinks. Also, Alcohol enters his families house but the man I want to marry does not drink only his father. Does this affect my choice in marrying him or have any sort of affect on me or my family or my future ?

Yes for sure it is a concern that you have to keep into consideration. You need to look at it along other factors, weigh pros and cons and decide

We are couple with (removed) toddlers things are not getting right even our intentions were right. We never harm or duped anyone always look ways to support parents and brothers and sisters in our best possible way. We both work hard to meet ours and family’s end meet. But Since last couple of months things are not going right for us. We incurring huge monetary losses bearing stressful relationship between us, always complaining, unintentional wastage of food or resources. Health wise all (removed) of us are suffering. The barakah is no more in our life’s. We both can’t stand each other. People whom we always being nice either uses us or become enemies with us.
We strongly feel there is some wrong doing or something bad is coming on our way.
Please Maula help us understand this situation and so we can act before our home breakup.

Not single moment passing without we being worried about Finances, losses, health, future, relationships kids etc.

This could be a test from Allah (swt) for you and Family. Allah tests us all in different ways. It’s very important to stay strong, patient and thankful to Allah. Staying positive is key, as is helping each other to get through this rough period.

It could be the evil eye as well, but we cannot be sure. In any case please pay sadaqa regularly, recite Ayat Kursi, the two ‘quls’, salawat as well as verse (68:51).

If u can listen to this lecture:

https://youtu.be/ezQRSIT_dz0

On Tuesday night we put our cat to sleep. She was struggling to breathe from Sunday and the vet said she had water outside her lungs which would have to be drained. They said even if we got it drained it would come back in a few days and even if we kept getting it drained our cat would only live for a few weeks with poor quality of life. In hindsight we think of the possibilities we could’ve explored but at that point in time none of us could think straight. I asked a Sheikh to do istikhara whether we should put her down and he said it came as ‘it’s up to you’. When I asked his opinion he said don’t do it, there may be a solution. By Tuesday night our cat was panting which is really bad for cats. And looking back I feel like the vet was talking in code and if we had pushed harder maybe we could’ve saved our cat even if she had a poor quality of life. But we were so upset and panicked none of us could think straight, we believed the vet and we put our cat to sleep. The pain I can get over but the guilt is eating me away that we killed a creation of God.

Do you think we did the right thing?

Don’t worry. You have not done anything wrong

I had another question as well . If someone makes a promise to Allah (swt) and this promise is not a nazr (eg- I will do so and so , if so and so work of mine is done) ; just a general promise , eg- of reciting a particular day every day – ie, the person promised Allah (swt) that they will recite a particular dua everyday , but he doesn’t end up keeping the promise – he does not recite the dua- then is there any sort of Kaffara to be paid for this , and is the person liable for any punishment because he has not kept the promise ? If he continues not to keep the promise , is this a sin?

They should seek istighfar and make sure they don’t repeat it again

Someone asked me these questions: Suppose a woman is in her house and there are construction happening in her house. She doesnt know that workers come in and go, and unintentionally a man sees her without her veil. Is she entitled to the same gunah? For instance a student of mine told me she was sleeping and when she woke up, she saw her brother in law in front of her, she wasnt wearing her hijab.
She clearly didnt do that intentionally, sure she will do isteghfaar but whats the ruling on this?

A female should be careful to ensure she is covered in the presence of non mahrems
If such a situation happens as described, she should ask for forgiveness as it was unintentional

My wife asked me to upload her audio nauha's on YouTube. Only audio with some photos of the Tomb of Aimmah(as) and azadari pics.

What is the ruling on this?

It should be avoided, especially if name or image is being uploaded

We currently have a guest living with us for a few weeks. The issue is this person has a habit of speaking bad about others even when the issue we're talking about has no relevance to the person. My husband spoke to the guest and I as well explained the evils of backbiting twice and once kindly told the guest I don't want to know the bad about their family members. While the guest reduced speaking bad about their family, instead started on backbiting about others who are not family!
What is my role here now? And how do I avoid the spiritual effects of this as I'm afraid I will become immune and be able to accept backbiting if this goes on any further.

Yes the impact of gheeba upon those who listen to it is harmful as well

You need to continue to object to the wrong as this is your duty. Speak gently to the person but firmly that you don’t want such statements or words in your house. You should not remain silent about it. Allah knows how hard it is for you especially as he’s a guest but He will help you and reward you. Keep reminding the person that they’re eating flesh of their brother and sister. That image should be on their minds when they’re about to backbite

I want to know if investing in crypto currencies is allowed in Islam. Please advice me on what the rulings of ayatollah Ali sistani and ayatollah sayed ali khamenie are regarding investing and dealing with crypto currency.

Many of our scholars have prohibited it, whilst some have said we should avoid trading in it. This is the best way

Here is an article with more details

http://ijtihadnet.com/bitcoin-perspective-shiite-clerics-fatwas/

The namaz timing of Zuhr as per many calculation we receive online says it is 12:15 in bangalore India. Therefore can we pray right after that zuhr & Asr or wait for azan which happens in the mosque at 1pm. Mosque is far away I won't be able to pray jamat. So what's the condition can I finish prayers at prime time 12:15 or wait for masjid azan and then read?

Yes you can perform your prayer straight after it’s actual timing, as you don’t need to wait till it’s performed in the Mosque

Please can you tell me that Khake Shifa can be eaten for the purpose of gaining Shifa

Just a small tiny amount mixed with water can be taken for the purposes of healing an illness (not as preventative) and by asking Allah for healing using intercession of Imam Hussain (a)

My question is can we use deodorants and perfume which have alcohol content in it, on the clothes we use to pray namaz and even otherwise.

Yes that is fine

I have recently started praying salat al leyl, and alhamdollelah this has sparked my interest in reading the other nafilah prayers as well. I’ve searched about it on the internet and found a bit of info. But i don’t feel like i am completely sure on how to do it. Could you explain the way to do nafilah for all of the obligatory prayers. And what to recite etc. God bless you.

There are many Mustahab prayers which are generally called Nafilah, but more stress has been laid on the daily Mustahab prayers. The number of the Rak'ats everyday excluding Friday, is 34. It is an follows:

8 Rak'ats Nafilah for Zuhr
8 Rak'ats Nafilah for Asr
4 Rak'ats Nafilah for Maghrib
2 Rak'ats Nafilah for Isha
11 Rak'ats Nafilah for Tahajjud (Namaz-e-Shab)
2 Rak'ats Nafilah for Fajr

776. The Zuhr Nafilah is offered before Zuhr prayers. Its time is from the commencement of the time of Zuhr, up to the time when the shadow of indicator equals 2/7th of its length. For example, if an indicator is 7 yards long, and the shadow appearing after Zuhr reaches 2 yards, the Nafilah time would end. He should now offer Zuhr prayers.

777. The Asr Nafilah are offered before Asr prayers, and its time is till the moment when the shadow of an indicator appearing after Zuhr, reaches of 4/7th of its length.
In case a person wishes to offer Zuhr and Asr Nafilah after their recommended time, he can offer the Zuhr Nafilah after Zuhr prayers, and the Asr Nafilah after Asr prayers, but as a precaution, he will not make niyyat of Ada or Qadha.

778. The Maghrib Nafilah should be offered after Maghrib prayers, and one should make an effort to offer it in time after Maghrib. However, if one delays offering Maghrib Nafilah till redness in the western sky disappears, then it would be better to offer Isha prayers at that moment.

779. The time for Isha Nafilah is from the completion of Isha prayers till midnight. It is better to offer it immediately, after Isha prayers.

780. The Fajr Nafilah is offered before the Fajr prayers, and its time commences when Namaz-e-Shab has been completed, till the time of Namaz-e-Fajr draws near. But if someone delays it till redness is seen in the eastern sky, then it is better to pray namaz of Fajr.

Imam Ali (as) in sermon 80 of nahjul balagha is reported to have said "Women are deficient in Faith, deficient in shares and deficient in intelligence." What is the meaning of this statement and is deficient a correct translation here?

1. It is likely in reference to a particular woman, eg one of the wives of prophet
2. Imam Ali (and all Ahlulbayt) have great respect and praised women in numerous traditions
3. It could refer to certain times of the month and not translated as such

This needs more extensive answer and there are good books and lectures on this

I am a newly wed and my husband has a habit of brushing his teeth in our kitchen sink and it bothers me because the sink is only for dishes and cooking not for spitting after brushing your teeth. I believe cleanliness and following ur wifes house rules is important, what is the ruling on this?

Marital life is about correct communication, trust and Love between each other. There should be understanding and compromises. At the beginning of the marriage you both will learn things about each other, and it’s important to be flexible and adapt as much as possible. Both sides need to sacrifice.

You need to discuss this with your husband calmly and carefully, not necessarily using anger or words etc

Be patient with him as he tries to change slowly but don’t give up and at same time you need to make sure you’re flexible too in other matters (other than practicing faith)

How can one tell a sibling that they will not attend their wedding? There will be music in that function, it will be a mixed gathering and I don’t think hijab will be observed as they are not religious. I will not feel comfortable. It will probably cost a lot of money to attend. I have nothing against the sibling, but I feel that I will be emotionally blackmailed to attend the wedding by the parent. How can one overcome this?

It can be done with respect and relying on Allah (swt). It will be difficult but if you place Him first He will look after you and reward you. Try to explain it politely and later visit them to congratulate the couple at home.

– One has been married for 7 years and I come from a Sunni family and within
2015 I have been blessed by Allah swt to follow the path of the Ahlulbayt (as). My spouse is from a Shia family, he has not told his family that my family are Sunni. I have not meet his parents as they live in India. He has visited many times and still goes but I have not gone with him. This causes and issue between us at times when we have argued in the past I felt that he does not respect my family because they are Sunni. When one asks him let’s visit my family he does not want to go and makes excuses. This leads to an argument. How does one overcome this issue? My family always ask why he does not come with me and I have to keep saying he is working even when he is not.
I understand that telling his parents maybe an sensitive issue as living in (removed) is so different to India the different cultures. My spouse is a (removed)’s boy and he still acts like a stubborn child at times. How can one overcome this?

My spouse is providing for us financially, I am really grateful for that. I would like to ask does my spouse have to financially support his (removed) that is married and has a child because her spouse does not work?

– My spouse has some habits since he was a child, I do not like them and don’t want to do them. When I say that, he gets into a mood about it and says that I don’t love him and only his family does. There are several things I don’t like what he says or does but I do it so we don’t argue. How can one overcome this?

1. Re habits, you need to communicate this clearly and calmly over time and be flexible. Marriage is about adapting to situations that ppl are not comfortable with. He will also have comments about your habits. It’s about supporting each other. It should not be said in any way which is hurtful or abusive, but with respect.

2. He does not have to support his sister but it’s recommended as Islam says charity starts with Family. However it should not be at the expense of his immediate family

3. Meeting Family is important and part of marriage. One can not exclude Family in this partnership. This will only be resolved by clear and honest communication which happens not at times where he or you are stressed or angry, but at good times.
Don’t forget to ask Allah to help because it is only He who changes hearts

How does one help their marriage? When their spouse does not like spending any time with them. They would rather spend all day at work or with work colleagues.You feel alone in your marriage. One has spoken to spouse but they don’t seem to understand and all you do is such repeat the same things all the time. They don’t seem to understand you. One has been married (removed) years and it’s going down the hill for sometime now.

There has to be external help from a qualified scholar and therapist. Such a marriage will not necessarily last and needs help. It’s not something negative but rather key to it’s survival.

How can one help spouse attend lectures? They are not interested in religion. When one talks to them about religion, they say I am boring.

Don’t force them but rather have discussion about great benefits and rewards
Discuss why they find it boring and how you can remedy this
Also if you do some of the activities they enjoy they’ll accompany you in majalis as well

There is a app available now called "instacart" where you can work as someone who buys people groceries. Now there are many things in the store which are not halal for a muslim to eat but is delivering it an issue? My main concern would be pork. Is this job halal for a muslim and which things should he watch out for?

If the delivery includes alcohol or such products, then it’s not permissible to undertake
Otherwise there is no problem in taking this role

When praying behind a sunni sheikh, should I recite me 2 surahs of quran in a low or high voice for maghreb prayer?

Low voice

I have a question regarding najasah. if i eat at a restaurant with a kafir friend or family member, am i allowed to go back to that restaurant because now i know that a plate has become najis and spoon. or Does it become tahir?

If the plate is washed then there is no problem
Also many marajie today consider Ahlul Kitab as tahir

So we can be certain that the plate has become tahir by their washing correct? Even by non muslims?

Usually plates are washed by machines in Restaurants, hence it should be tahir

Was wondering what is the most rewarding act in islam?

To perform obligations and to stay away from prohibitions is essential. To serve others for the sake of Allah and to be the best we can be is what the Almighty wants from us

I would like to know how we should we pray wajib namaz in masjid e kufa masjid sehla and imam e Hussain (a.s) shrine?
Do we pray qasar or full namaz?

You have a choice between full or qasr. Full is better.
As for Imam Hussain shrine, you only have a choice if it’s 5 arms length from the actual grave. Otherwise it’s qasr

I’m a university student and I had a question regarding my prayer.
I’m currently living at home and commute to university 5 days a week by car. However, my university is 27 miles away (one way) from my home. And I leave my house everyday before dhuhr (~8-10am) and return from university ~6pm on most days. This means I end up spending more time at university than I do at home.

Since I have to perform my dhuhr and Asr prayer at university, could you please let me know what the ruling is regarding my prayers. Would I have to shorten my Dhuhr and Asr prayer every day? Or would I perform them normally?
Additionally, I would also be travelling every day during Ramadan. Would I be able to fast normally?

If you will be going to university for at least 6 months in a year then you should observe full prayers whilst you’re there, and you can fast whilst traveling there as well

Which Quranic Surah is highly recommended to recite as a Dua to hasten Hajj?

2:158 plus Surat alhajj is recommended

A key set of rituals is amaal in month of Ramadan especially on nights of Qadr. Many Duas on that holy month have reference to hajj, eg Dua abu Hamza and Dua iftitah

I have been praying for improvement of a situation in my family for a decade. I have offered so many prayers for hajat that i have lost count now. I have been asking Imam (AJTF) of our time for help but all my prayers have gone unanswered. What should i do? What is the proper way of asking our Imam for help?

It may not be for your benefit
Don’t give up and keep asking
You can watch this lecture

https://youtu.be/ezQRSIT_dz0

Is it permissible to use hypnosis (from a professional counsellor) to help alleviate depression?

If it does not cause harm then it is permissible

Is it allowed to use duplicates of branded clothing Like Burberry, Gucci, etc., How to deal with such gifts given to you by friends and family?

Are you referring to fake remakes of branded clothing?

Yes exactly those.

Yes there is no problem of using them or receiving them as gifts

Sometimes when I feel like speaking to Imam E Zamana and discuss my problems with him, I write my feelings on a paper. Everytime it is not possible for me to put the letter in the river as it is recommended for an Ariza. so can I just keep the letters to myself instead of letting them in water? Will my problems reach Imam E Zamana if I keep the letters with myself?

Yes inshallah. If Allah wills he will read them

My question is on latmiya. I find it difficult to understand why beating ones chest or body is permissible if our imams ع who came after Imām Hussain ع never did. To the best of my knowledge, none of our imams have been narrated to be involved in latim or tatbir. So I struggle to see why it’s a common practice considering it is a risky practise as it can be considered self harm.

There is no evidence at all that it’s not permissible. In Islamic law, everything is permissible unless we have clear instruction otherwise. Also some quran verses point to this taking place,eg wife of Ibrahim slapping her cheeks. In addition, it’s a form of expressing grief and sorrow. If it causes excessive harm then it becomes prohibited

My question is whether we as Shi’a believe Buddha was a prophet of Islam? I have heard that it is possible Buddha is one of 124,000 however have not been able to find a good answer.

This is possible but cannot be confirmed. Many of the Prophets we don’t have their names (perhaps about 100 or so).

From my understanding, although it is permissible to combine dhuhr & asr as well as maghrib & Isha into 3 daily prayer times, it is recommended to separate them into 5 daily times as our imams ع did. Is this correct? Should I aim to separate them and if so, why do all masjids (in London) combine them in congregational prayers? Should we not aim to follow in the footsteps of the ahlul bayt ع?

Also what is the importance of the 2 rakat tahiyat al-masjid when entering a masjid (in terms of its reward and if it’s mustahab, is it makrooh to not pray these rakat? And what is the meaning of it? Is it to literally greet the mosque or I have also been told it is a way of sending blessings upon the people who maintain the masjid itself?

Yes it is sometimes recommended to separate if you can, however also to combine is good, since it’s a sign of the practice of the Shi’a and needs to be preserved.

The centres do so due to practicality

Re the2 unit prayer for mosques, it’s recommended for every mosque, to honour that place and signify its importance. The mosque will testify that you prayed there on qiyama day.

Can you please tell me the difference between Marja, Ayatollah, Mujtahideen and Ulama

Marjie: A mujtahid who publishes his Manuel of Islamic laws and declares he can be followed

Ayatollah: Sign of Allah. A person who has reached ijtihad

Mujtahid: a scholar who reaches ijtihad, meaning they can extrapolate islamic law from Quran and Hadith etc (after studying for many years)

Ulema: comes from Arabic alim, ie knowledgeable person

I don't know why I have this certain doubts about Allah.
Even though I know that I shouldn't have this doubts as a shia or as a muslim. It is really I thought for me or is it only from shetan what should I do when I have this doubts. How to prevent my self from falling into doubting allah swt.
I know there is no god except Allah. I have all dalil ( proof) scientific , philosophic etc but my heart is not accepting Allah existence.
I’m so confused. I don't fill the test ( khushu khuzu ) of my salat. When I try to pray it feel that No one listening to me. It like I’m speaking alone.

You need to increase your knowledge by reading books, listening to lectures and visiting cemeteries
Think about your beginning and end. Dedicate time to reflection and pondering
Associate with scholars and the learned
Have a positive atmosphere around you that reminds you of Allah
Increase spirituality by visiting shrines of holy individuals such as the Prophet and his family
Keep praying to Allah for guidance and conviction
This certainty in the heart is not a process that comes through intellectual reasoning but rather a private journey

اعيش في دولة اجنبية مع عائلتي.. قمنا مؤخرا بتعبئة طلب من اجل الحصول على معونات مادية لوالدتي بسبب كبر عمرها وحالتها الصحية. قامو بسؤالنا ما اذا كان لديها راتب تقاعدي من البلد الام ام لا. هي لديها راتب بسيط جدا وانا انوي ان اذكره عند تعبئة الطلب. لكن عائلتي لا ترضى بان اذكره لسببين. اولا لانه من المحتمل جدا ان لا تحصل والدتي على الاعانة المادية في الدولة الاجنبية وثانيا لانه في نظرهم انه من حقنا ومن العدل ان نحصل على المعونة بحكم ان فردين من العائلة يشتغلون ويدفعون الكثير من الضرائب للدولة ويستفاد منها الكثير من الشباب المتكاسل والعاطل عن العمل. وانا في حيرة من امري
١- هل من الحرام عدم ذكر راتبها التقاعدي؟
٢- لو لم اذكره وحصلت على المعونة.. فهل هذا يعتبر من الكسب الحرام؟
نرجو الافادة وشكرا جزيلا مقدما

١. نعم على رأي سماحة السيد يجب الصدق و عدم الكذب أو التدليس في هذه الأمور
٢. على فرض عدم الصراحة، ينبغي منكم الاتصال بمكتب المرجع للحصول على اجازة من الحاكم الشرعي
و دمتم بخير

A few days ago a friend was speaking about the Adam and Eve story and how it is a flawed story and evolution proves that. What would be your answer to this.

As Muslims we believe in the Quran to be the word of God and absolute truth. The story of Adam and his creation is clear in the holy book. Scientific theories are theories. Quran is fact

Lately here in the west, as I presume you've heard, there is a bit of controversy within the Sunni community regarding individuals who deny the Nuzul of Isa (AS). That being said, as I know a fellow Shia who was roped into this belief, what is the Shia view on an individual who rejects the Nuzul of Isa (AS)? I have seen many opinions from amongst the sunnis that such a person is anything from a kafir to a man of knowledge! However I would like some clarity on our belief regarding such a person.

Such a person with such a belief is wrong. If they insist and spread this they are committing sin and should be intellectually and evidently challenged with proof

Will we be questioned on the day of Judgment for our thoughts and whispers or solely just our actions?

Our deeds will be subject to accountability
If our intentions are good we may also be rewarded for it (without actions if we couldn’t do it for eg)
However our thoughts will impact us in this world negatively

I am residing in Dubai and have been buying Indian/Pakistani mutton/beef but now as it’s not available near by so can I buy Australian/Brazilian mutton/beef/lamb?

Everything is written Halal meat but I was comfortable with Indian/Pakistani meat.

If you are confident that it is zabeeha and that there is not reliable information saying otherwise then you can buy the meat

Is khums payable on cash gifts received by a couple at their wedding? The social norm is to give a card with money inside per family that attends. Is khums obligatory on this wealth ? (just received a couple of months before khums date)

Yes, it should be added to income and included in khums calculations when the khums time is reached

Despite the differences between sunni and shias I see mostly shia scholars are never against a sunni shia marriage and sunni scholars are always strictly against it. Why is that so?

Jurisprudentially there is no problem with it unless the person marrying a Shia is a Nasibi. However ethically a number of factors need to be kept in consideration and assurances taken etc
Re other Muslim scholars, they would need to be asked themselves. Shia Scholars have also by far been the most advocates of unity for over 1300 years.

I have a question about the following verses in the Quran:

يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا لَا تَسْأَلُوا عَنْ أَشْيَاءَ إِنْ تُبْدَ لَكُمْ تَسُؤْكُمْ وَإِنْ تَسْأَلُوا عَنْهَا حِينَ يُنَزَّلُ الْقُرْآنُ تُبْدَ لَكُمْ عَفَا اللَّهُ عَنْهَا ۗ وَاللَّهُ غَفُورٌ حَلِيمٌ

(Sahih International)
O you who have believed, do not ask about things which, if they are shown to you, will distress you. But if you ask about them while the Qur'an is being revealed, they will be shown to you. Allah has pardoned that which is past; and Allah is Forgiving and Forbearing.

Sura Al-Ma'idah, Ayah 101

قَدْ سَأَلَهَا قَوْمٌ مِنْ قَبْلِكُمْ ثُمَّ أَصْبَحُوا بِهَا كَافِرِينَ

(Sahih International)
A people asked such [questions] before you; then they became thereby disbelievers.

-Sura Al-Ma'idah, Ayah 102

My question is, what sort of questions are these verses telling us not to ask and how would one become a disbelievers as a result?

Some of the questions are related to issues beyond human capability to understand, such as before creation where was God, how long etc

Also questions that are not sincere or ones that create corruption

I am little confused. Regarding what type of niyaz to serve azaadars. Its true we should give what we can for Maula

But when someone from our community passes away we keep simple food And when its majlis of Imam (as) can we keep good tasty non veg fried foods etc or variety of foods or should it be simple?

Salaam alaikum

Other than day of Ashura, it’s a good thing to serve the lovers of Imam Hussain respectful and nice food

Are university loans permissible to take if you have to pay them back with interest.

Yes

If you accidentally recite Surah Qadr as well after Surah Fatiha in the 3rd rakat does that make your salah void?

If it was not intentional and you did not believe it’s part of salah then you prayers are valid

Recently, a brother in faith did this. I wanted to know if he did the correct thing and if this is allowed in Islam :
The brother recently opened a new catering business. However, in order to get good cooks for his business , he told 2 cooks who were currently working in other restaurants , that he would pay them a higher salary if they worked for him. In this way, he got them to leave those restaurants and work for him. Is this allowed?

As long as he was truthful and honest, there is no problem in this

I was wondering if it is permissible for a woman to change her last name to that of her husband's. If not, can the husband's last name be added at the end with a hyphen

Yes there is no problem in doing so

Nowadays we do have an options where the mother can stop having children when she wants to by following few medical producers. after this she cannot conceive and that's her choice.

is it permissable to do this, part of family planning

If it is irreversible procedure, it is not allowed

Does these dreams have any meaning. I have seen couple times dreams of Imaam Ali and Imaam Al-Ridha.

The reality of dreams is commonly sought amongst human beings since it’s an experience most people go through sometime during their lives. What we understand is that in terms of interpretations, two types are commonly presented: the materialistic and spiritual.

The materialistic interpretation are commonly associated with the daily actions of human beings, i.e. whatever we may have experienced over the past few days becomes somehow embedded in our dreams. This is especially the case if before sleeping the mind is in reflection about activities that the body had undertaken during the day. Sometimes it’s also unfulfilled desires or even fears that influence dreams and their nature. Therefore many of such dreams are related to the past.

Those subscribing to the spiritual interpretation of dreams view them a result of possible delusions, inclinations, desires and imaginations. Such dreams relate to the future and people often seek interpretations. Not all such dreams have meaningful interpretations, as some are called (athgath ahlam or distressing dreams).

We know from the holy Quran that one way in which Prophets of Allah received revelation is through dreams (e.g. Prophet Ibrahim as). Indeed Prophet Yusuf (as) was given the ability by Allah (swt) to interpret the dreams. Therefore we don’t reject all dreams and dismiss them. From history books and narrations, we find that some dreams do have meaningful interpretations whilst others don’t. Another Quranic fact is that the soul departs from the body during sleep, thus some dreams are associated with the idea that the soul is not limited to time and space, as well as it belonging to the realm of malakoot (i.e. unseen realm).

The difficulty in interpreting dreams is that people often do so themselves, without seeking help of experienced and knowledgeable scholars. We know that some dreams refer to aspects in this world, for e.g. I was told by an alim that if a believer witnesses a dream of being given water to drink, it eludes to the idea that Allah ta’la is bestowing them with knowledge.

This year we have with the blessings of Allah successfully organised provision for another imambargah in our city. This is the first meaningful Muharram my children have observed in 12 years by the blessings invoked by our Holy Masomeen.
The other group however have spread falsehood and fatwas of sort than anyone who attends anything we do as an anjuman, will not be accepted as ibadah. We are not in competition with them but they think we are.
I am having trouble dealing with intense hatred towards them which I didn’t before. I feel like sending lanat on these people but i am holding back. What should I do?

I recommend you exercise patience and continue serving Allah without worrying what people says. Disagreements and sometimes attacks are part of human nature sadly but the believers are those who focus on the bigger picture and want the reward from Allah (swt).

You should not say Lana on these people but rather pray for their guidance and forgiveness

What is the earliest I can make ghusl and have it count as a Jumma Ghusl. Can I make it Thursday afternoon and not have to repeat the ghusl Friday morning for Jumma. I’m just using Jumma as an example.

Anytime after fajr in Friday

Is there any hadith in regards to the color of wedding dress Hazart Fatima SA or any ahlulbayt wore for their nikkah? Is it sunnah to wear white for wedding dress?

I have not come across any, however many narrations from Ahlulbayt emphasise white clothing as colour of choice and they wore such colours too, eg Imam Ali (a)

Could you please refer me to one such narration?

“White is the best color to wear; the next best color is yellow and then comes green. After that are pale red, purple, and brown. Dark red is considered an abominable (makruh), especially during prayer. One must avoid wearing it [dark red], and wearing black is loathsome for everything except for the turban, aba (inner robe), and high boots. However, if the turban and aba are not [emphasis mine] black, it is better.”

Allama Majlisi
Hilyat Almutaqin
P.5-6

I wanted to know what’s the ruling on marrying someone outside where you’re from like an iraqi marrying a lebanese and how to go about that if the family isn’t allowing of it

Yes it’s permissible provided conditions (eg they’re Muslim etc) are found. It will have challenges but one way is to seek help of Ulema and Family relatives who can influence parents perhaps.

It’s important to note that invariably there might be cultural conflicts and both the husband and wife need to be patient and know what kind of issues may face them

Is it Haram to work as a security guard at a place that involved the selling and consumption of Alcohol (Note: your job doesn’t involve selling or serving the Alcohol yourself, rather it’s dealing with the safety of the people.

If it’s a place solely for the sake of alcohol then it’s not permissible since you will be facilitating the sale

If it’s a grocery store that sells other stuff for eg then it is permissible

I had a question regarding my job. I'm still a student but for the last year I have been working as a Loss Prevention Officer. Sometimes I have to arrest or detain people who I find stealing or damaging the property in some manner. This usually involves some level of force but only to the extent that's necessary to get them to comply.
As an example, earlier this month a man tried to run past me with stolen items in his hands. Instead of trying to fight him I just tripped him and held him on the ground until the police arrived.

While I know that using force like in that example is permissible by the laws in Canada I was wondering if I am in any way crossing any Islamic laws?

There is no problem with what you are doing if it’s part of the law and it’s needed to uphold law and order. You must be careful not to use extra force than what is necessary

I am one of the only Chinese people in a mainly urdu-speaking community of brothers and sisters from India, Pakistan, and Iran. Is it obligatory upon me to gain knowledge at the hawza? And if so, how should I proceed given that I am the only child of my recently-widowed Christian mother and that I am planning on getting married in January 2019?

You can study islam online or where you are
For eg ehawza.com will send you hundreds of lectures.
You need to look after your mother and must not neglect her and must attend to her needs. This is important

My question is if eating pork is forbidden in Islam unlike beef then why Allah created it at first place?

We cannot explain why Allah created certain things or animals. It could be as a test for us. Everything from Him has a purpose and nothing is in vain.

Is homosexuality is biological or psychological illness? I have some friends who claims that they sexually attracted towards same gender since their adolescent age even they don't want. If homosexuality is biological illness then why Allah in Quran forbid this?

This practice is forbidden in Islam, regardless of its background or classification. Morally it is unacceptable

How one should control his feelings when he don't want to have such feelings for same gender? It feels like as natural as someone feel about opposite gender. It is very disturbing. I want to get married with a woman but I am afraid as I don't have feelings for any woman.

Allah has created us with desires. We must control them. To give in is to transgress. Allah has created humans with desire for opposite gender. Any deviation is man made. You must exercise patience and realise the severity of acting on your desires. To do so is a great sin in islam

As you have said any deviation is Man made but how can a child before going into puberty can deviate or choose his sexual orientation when he has no idea of what this homosexuality is? I will definitely now control my feelings and try to act on patience but it does really hurt, its like you have to act totally against your soul feelings and desires.. I want to kill that negative feelings.

Sometimes help is needed from experts
Children can be influenced by external factors too

My question is regarding the extent of right of a husband over his wife.
Firstly does a husband have the right to forbid his wife from visiting her parents (and relatives) possibly due to ego issues ( between him and his in-laws).
Moreover, some people believe husbands to be controllers of their wife in every aspect of her life and quote various Hadeeth from the 14 infallibles. To what extent is this correct in the religion of Islam.

It is not right for the husband to prevent his wife from seeing her family. This is not part of islamic teachings nor from the recommendations of Ahlulbayt. Marriage about helping each other and supporting one another. A good relationship with parents is important for both husband and wife.
According to Quran 4:34 husbands are protectors of their wives. They should not be dictators. According to islam they should treat each other with love and respect. Hadith can’t be interpreted by people to suit their own whims

Many people present the point that permission of husband is needed for a wife in "every aspect of her life" for example in leaving the house to perform any task and if she doesn't adhere to it then she will be punished in the hell fire (as what people have personally told me).
I understand that husbands are the head of the house but to what extent is the say of a husband lawful and in what all aspects of the couples life.

The husband must not be a dictator at home. As much as possible there should be joint decisions based on love and mutual respect. Yes in some occasions he will have final say, but if he is controlling his wife completely and does not listen to her then this marriage is not in line with Islamic ethics nor will it succeed

Who was older between Hazrat Ali-Akbar A.S. And 4th Imam A.S. And their age at the battle of Karbala?

There is a historic discussion amongst scholars

Some believe Ali Akbar is older, he was 27 when he was martyred and Imam Sajjad was 24

Others say the opposite

As a student of Islam I believe the first opinion to be more likely as Akbar means the oldest

Allah knows best


There is a one day activity at my daughters school where kids will interact with dogs like reading a book to them
The mission of ‘Reading to Dogs’ is to enhance the experience of learning, to bring comfort to children, to promote a lasting love for reading and to enrich lives of our canine volunteers
Is it allowed as per Islamic laws to play/touch dogs? Don’t intend to take a dog as a pet though, It’s just one of schools programme

There is no problem as such, provided you make the child understand that the dog is najis (impure), and so touching it with wet hands means Najasa is transferred. Similarly there are stricter rules re the saliva of the dog

Insha’Allah I shall be going on Hajj next year however I graduate from university just before Hajj and therefore have the debt of Student Finance. Will I be in debt and therefore unable to go on Hajj, or am I exempted since I don’t work and I’m a full-time student?

If you don’t have means to go then it is not wajib for you

What is the authenticity of Dua Tawassul and the version of Hadith Kisa found in mafatih al Jinan? Are they from an imam?

Despite discussions on the chain of narrators of the mentioned Duas and hadith, shia Ulema generally accept them and recite them, based on a principle known as قاعدة التسامح في ادلة السنن which means we seek God’s pleasure and hope that it’s accepted

Due to the scholars reciting them for hundreds of years, it’s is very important that we keep reciting them, since the meanings contained are in line with Quran and authentic narrations

In the UK I recently received news that a girl who is 10 years old recorded a nawha and released it to the general public. Would such an act be haram as her voice will be heard by those who are not mahram to her?

An answer from the marjie office is needed here as it depends on repercussions of this and whether it’s considered awra (that which needs to be protected by the female)

1) Before some days i lost my tawiz which was contains quranic verses and some duas. It fell somewhere on road I tried to find out but didn’t get it. What is the ruling regarding it?

2) As it is recommended to shave newborn child’s head and have to give silver equal to the weight of that
I had given equal amount(money) which is wrong which i come to know now. Now shall i give silver to correct?

1. At this stage you don’t need to do anything as what happened was out of your control
2. Yes you can do that

People say we shia do shirk!
coz we give the attributes of Allah swt to Ahlulbayt a.s like they come on every farshe Aza so they are Omni present and like they listen our prayers and they see us so they r all seeing and hearing…
plz explain me this point

Our teachings clearly mention that the Ahlulbayt are humans and are dependent on Allah (swt). However they have been given attributes from Allah (wilayah takweeniya) which enables them to perform certain blessed acts. This is not unusual. Isa (a) in the Quran says ‘I create’ but with permission from Allah.

Having said that we have to be careful that we don’t describe them in a way that they didn’t describe themselves and create confusion. Our direction is from our Ulema

But the attributes or Position which Ahlulbayt holds is different from the ordinary person they cannot do the same right?
And please answer aren't they all seeing and hearing? and they're everywhere right? but by the permission of Allah right?

They are given special knowledge by Allah. But our aqeeda is that they are not everywhere and they cannot see everything. This is only for Allah (swt).

My question is how to avoid handshakes with namahram and what to say when they offer handshakes with us.
Reply should not hurt the person nor should she feel ashamed

You can use gloves or a barrier cloth to avoid skin contact

If it’s very difficult to avoid which causes you unbearable distress, you can shake their hands. Please explain to them that you can’t because it’s part of your faith where you cannot touch non related women

Please watch this lecture of mine which is on this topic:

https://youtu.be/sVxD5fmbvKE

My question is regarding the month of Muharram. Is it haram to play games or watch movies in this month.

It is not haram per se but out of respect for the sanctity and sacredness of this holy month and especially Ashura one should minimise such mentioned activities

If the games etc are done deliberately to violate the sanctity of this month then it’s not permissible

I currently work in an administrative role at a bank, owned by Non Muslims, in a non-muslim country. My job involves dealing with peoples investment and pension accounts, action requests and closures, and at times- applying interest or moving interest into the account for the clients. Is there any problems in working in such a role, considering the bank is owned by Non Muslims

Working in such a position requires you to obtain permission from your marjie or his office

Is dressing up as a lion to reflect Shehr e Fizza and illustrate Karbala in the same way that people dress up as the Imams and the Ahlulbayt allowed?

In principal there is no problem

I am currently studying pharmacy assistant, Hospital pharmacy assistant and regular pharmacy assistant. I think I like hospital pharmacy the most
But there is one problem I should expose my throat (wearing hijab but everyone can see my throat) and wearing short sleeves ( hospital pharmacy uniform) the reasons of exposing is because if you are busy preparing medicines, everything should be really hygienic and really clean)
My question is: is it haram to specialize myself to hospital pharmacy and expose my throat and arms

You should try your best not to compromise your hijab because this is more important

If this would be your only means of living and without it you are in unbearable difficulty then you can work there, otherwise if you know for sure that your hijab will be compromised regularly and it’s a requirement you should look for another job